When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Products or services may be offered by an affiliated entity. Learn more.

Headshot of author Lauren Fountain
By Lauren Fountain
Why Trust Sleep Foundation

When you spend money on a new mattress, it’s natural to expect many years of sound sleep in return for your investment. Luckily, there are many reasonably priced models that guarantee a long lifespan as long as users properly care for them. Knowing what to look for can help you discern between good-quality builds versus mattresses made with cheap materials that might break down sooner.

We’ll discuss how to choose a durable mattress and share recommendations for the best mattresses that won’t sag.

The Best Mattress Deals of the Week

In-Depth Reviews

The Helix Midnight is a big favorite among the testers in our lab. Gentle cushioning, responsive coils, and reinforced edges all make for a well-rounded bed.

  • Pros

    1. Medium firm hybrid design delivers strong support and noticeable cushioning

    2. Thick coils reinforce the edges to reduce sinkage

    3. Below-average pricing for a hybrid

  • Cons

    1. Foam layers may retain some heat

    2. Some off-gassing might occur at first

Mattress Type

Hybrid

Firmness Options

Medium Firm (6)

Price Range

$749 – $1,399

Trial Period

100 nights (30-night requirement)

Product Details

The Helix Midnight is one of the most balanced and affordable hybrid models we’ve tested in our lab. Although the mattress is specifically designed for side sleepers between 130 and 230 pounds, our tests also reveal sufficient support for back and stomach sleepers who weigh under 130 pounds. Breathable construction, sturdy edges, and comfortable bounce add to the Midnight’s appealing design.

What It’s Made of

The Midnight begins with a top layer of memory foam, followed by two polyfoam layers. These materials provide some cushioning, but they are dense and responsive enough to keep your body aloft. Pocketed coils and dense base foam make up the base layers. The long sides are lined with thicker coils to push back against your weight, so you shouldn’t notice any sinkage when lying along the edges or getting in and out of bed. A breathable cover encases the mattress. You can swap in a GlacioTex cover with heat-dissipating phase change material (PCM) for an extra fee.

We’ve rated the Midnight as medium firm, or a 6 on our 10-point firmness scale. The mattress measures 11.5 inches thick. Helix also offers an upgraded version of the mattress known as the Midnight Luxe, which builds on the initial design with an extra foam layer encased in a Euro-top cover, zoned coils that provide enhanced support to the midsection, and a cover made of moisture-wicking Tencel fabric.

How It Performed

Foam hybrids have a tendency to sleep hot, but the Midnight resists heat buildup thanks to its medium firm feel. You’re less likely to sink into the mattress and lose surface airflow, and the coils generate enough airflow to maintain a comfortable core temperature. If you’re a hot sleeper, we recommend upgrading to the GlacioTex cover — the PCM makes a noticeable difference in how cool the surface feels.

Ease of movement was another highlight during our tests. Most of our testers encountered little resistance when moving across the surface, and the reinforced edges should help you get on and off the mattress with relative ease.

In addition to a below-average sticker price, the Midnight comes with two free pillows and ground delivery is free to all 50 states. Your purchase includes a sleep trial that runs for 100 nights. If you decide to keep the mattress after the trial ends, you’ll also receive a 10-year warranty against premature sagging and other structural defects.

The Brooklyn Bedding Essential performs as well as many other hybrids we’ve tested — at a much lower price-point. Robust coils and dense foam on the surface keep the edges nicely supported.

  • Pros

    1. Dense foam over sturdy coils ensures excellent overall support

    2. Adaptive comfort layer cushions the spine and reduces pressure

    3. Below-average pricing for a hybrid model

  • Cons

    1. $99 fee for mattress returns

    2. Sleepers may notice an off-gassing odor initially

Mattress Type

Hybrid

Firmness Options

Medium Firm (6)

Price Range

$532 – $1,132

Trial Period

120 nights (30-night requirement)

Product Details

Hybrids have quickly become one of the most popular mattress types, but the average model costs at least $1,200 in a queen size and price is a barrier to many shoppers. The Brooklyn Bedding Essential bucks this trend. The mattress features a minimalist yet high-quality design, and a medium firm (6) feel ensures both great support and wide appeal across different sleeper types, but it is more affordable than most competing hybrids on the market today.

What It’s Made Of

The Essential begins with comfort and transitional layers of high-density polyfoam. This material is somewhat adaptive, so you’ll notice some cushioning and contouring when you get into bed, but also supportive enough to keep your body on an even plane and help prevent uncomfortable sinkage. Robust coils and dense base foam provide additional stability. A breathable, quilted cotton-polyester cover encases the mattress.

How It Performed

Based on heat gun readings during our temperature control tests, the fabric effectively offsets heat retention from the foam layers. Another cooling component is the coil system, which promotes steady airflow throughout to maintain a comfortable interior temperature. Pressure relief was another testing highlight. Despite the limited contouring, the foam layers offer enough cradling to alleviate sore spots in the shoulders, hips, and other sensitive areas along the spine. The mattress earned high ratings from most of our testing team, with the most favorable feedback coming from side and back sleepers weighing up to 230 pounds.

In addition to its below-average pricing, the Essential qualifies for free ground shipping throughout the contiguous U.S. Brooklyn Bedding’s sleep trial runs for 120 nights, and you may return the mattress for a full refund after sleeping on it for at least 30 nights. Should you decide to keep the Essential, it’s further backed by a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty.

If you’re seeking a mattress with a luxurious feel and sturdy design, the Saatva HD won’t fail you. Responsive latex, a foam-quilted surface, and supportive coils give this bed a firm yet plush quality.

  • Pros

    1. Made with natural latex and organic cotton

    2. Spinal zone wire provides targeted support for the lower back

    3. Shipped with complimentary White Glove delivery and old mattress removal

  • Cons

    1. $99 fee incurred for mattress returns

    2. Price is on the higher end for a hybrid mattress

Mattress Type

Innerspring

Firmness Options

Firm (7)

Price Range

$1,895 – $4,190

Trial Period

365 Nights ($99 Return Fee)

Product Details

An innerspring mattress with a firm (7) feel, the 15.5-inch Saatva HD is designed with heavy-duty elements engineered to support sleepers up to 500 pounds without compromising  pressure relief. This is a strong option for shoppers who are willing to spend a little bit more money for a bed with superior support.

What It’s Made of

The Saatva HD has a breathable organic cotton cover certified by the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS). Quilted polyfoam adds extra padding with an integrated, hand-tufted Euro-top design. The comfort system also includes five-zone natural Talalay latex and memory foam. These layers contour to the sleeper and provide additional support to the lumbar area to help prevent pressure buildup.

The support core consists of a layer of thick 12.5-gauge innerspring coils. The coils feature a polyfoam encasement around the perimeter, allowing more usable surface area for sleepers. The layer also has a spinal zone wire for additional lumbar support.

How It Performed

The Saatva HD helps maintain spinal alignment for back and side sleepers over 130 pounds. It also supports stomach sleepers across all weight categories, and the combination of latex and springs helps facilitate movement.

This model stands out for its temperature neutrality. The latex is perforated with tiny holes to increase heat dissipation, and the innerspring support core allows air to flow freely.

The Saatva HD is available in the six standard mattress sizes as well as split king. Like Saatva’s other mattresses, the HD is delivered with complimentary White Glove delivery and old mattress removal. Saatva offers a lifetime warranty and a 365-night sleep trial, with a nominal $149 return fee to cover handling costs.

The Leesa Sapira Hybrid pairs adaptive foam with sturdy coils to produce a just-right balance of contouring and support that felt comfortable for many people on our team. Airflow through the coils and ventilated polyfoam also keep the surface at a nice, neutral temperature.

  • Pros

    1. Mixed-foam comfort system cushions the body without sacrificing support

    2. Perimeter reinforcement minimizes sinkage

    3. Top-to-bottom-airflow and a cooling cover ensure excellent temperature control

  • Cons

    1. Foam hinders some movement across the surface

    2. Stomach sleepers over 230 pounds may receive insufficient support

Mattress Type

Hybrid

Firmness Options

Medium Firm (6)

Price Range

$1,349 – $2,299

Trial Period

100 nights (30 night requirement)

Product Details

Finding a mattress that doesn’t sag too much and also feels comfortable can be challenging, since less sagging is often associated with a firmer, stiffer feel. The Leesa Sapira Hybrid successfully toes that line thanks in part to its deep foam layers near the surface.

What It’s Made of

The Leesa Sapira Hybrid is constructed with a mixed-foam comfort system. The top layer consists of polyfoam that feels both adaptive and responsive, creating a light bounce as the material molds to your body. The polyfoam is perforated with channels to promote ventilation. A second comfort layer of medium-density memory foam provides additional contouring. Although the mattress is medium firm (6), both of these foam layers are fairly plush.

The mattress also contains a transitional layer of high-density polyfoam, followed by a pocketed coil system and another high-density foam layer for base-level support. The coils deliver strong stability with extra reinforcement along the edges. A knit polyester cover encases the entire mattress.

How It Performed

Most of our testers experienced little to no pressure buildup and received adequate support from the coil and base layers. The hybrid was particularly popular among our side sleepers weighing at least 130 pounds, and back and stomach sleepers under 130 pounds. Temperature control is another area where the Leesa Sapira Hybrid excelled during our hands-on tests. The ventilated polyfoam layer pushes air near the surface to keep you comfortable, while the coils circulate additional air to cool off the mattress interior. The knit cover is also breathable. None of our testers felt excessively hot lying on the mattress.

The Leesa Sapira Hybrid is priced competitively and shipping is free of charge for customers in all 50 states. Each order comes with a 100-night trial period and a standard manufacturer’s warranty that covers structural defects for up to 10 years.

Strong support is a must-have if you’re looking for beds that minimize back pain. The WinkBed Plus is a perfect candidate, due to its exceptionally firm feel and sturdy coils. Even better, the coils are zoned to boost support to your lower back.

  • Pros

    1. Exceptionally supportive design intended for sleepers who weigh at least 230 pounds

    2. Zoned latex and coil layers provide enhanced support for heavier areas of the body

    3. Consistent cooling thanks to steady airflow and breathable Tencel cover

  • Cons

    1. Side sleepers under 230 pounds may not receive enough cushioning

    2. Limited motion isolation

Mattress Type

Latex Hybrid

Firmness Options

Firm (8)

Price Range

$1,349 – $2,199

Trial Period

120 nights (30 night requirement)

Product Details

The WinkBed is available in four firmness options, but the WinkBed Plus caters specifically to sleepers who need enhanced support. We found the sturdiness of this hybrid model also makes it a great option for sleepers who need extra support to reduce back pain during sleep.

What It’s Made of

As a mattress designed for people who weigh more than 230 pounds, the WinkBed Plus begins with a top layer of high-density polyfoam and a second layer of zoned latex. Both of these materials are highly responsive, adding extra bounce to the surface and reinforcing the firm (8) feel. A Euro-top surface adds some plushness for comfort without sacrificing the Plus’s supportive qualities.

The support core contains 7.5-inch pocketed coils in a zoned arrangement. Thicker coils lie beneath the midsection to provide push-back and prevent sagging around the sleeper’s heaviest areas. The coils are also bolstered along the perimeter to reduce sinkage when you lie near or sit along the edges. A cover made of breathable, moisture-wicking Tencel fabric encases the mattress.

How It Performed

The WinkBed Plus performed well across the board during our hands-on tests – no small feat for a mattress this firm. The testers who felt most comfortable were those weighing more than 230 pounds, but the Plus also fared better than expected with lighter sleepers. This was especially true of testers who primarily use the back and stomach positions.

The latex retains very little heat, air flows freely through the coils, and the Tencel cover is both breathable and absorbent. As a result, the Plus is a great choice for people who frequently sleep hot or sweat in bed. The zoned coils also provide excellent push-back to ensure little to no sinkage around the torso and hips, as well as superior perimeter protection.

WinkBeds offers free ground shipping throughout the contiguous U.S. Each order comes with a 120-night trial. If you find the Plus too firm, you may exchange the mattress for a model with a different firmness level at no extra charge. WinkBeds are backed by lifetime warranties.

Side sleepers need a mattress that cushions their shoulders and hips, making the Nolah Evolution 15 a perfect match. The bed’s thick foam cushioning cradles your joints deeply, but you’ll still get enough lumbar support from the supportive coils.

  • Pros

    1. Thick comfort system adapts evenly to improve alignment and reduce pressure

    2. Available in three firmness levels

    3. Excellent thermoregulation thanks to breathable foam layers and steady internal airflow

  • Cons

    1. Customers must pay a $99 fee for mattress returns

    2. Thick profile may require deep pocket sheets

Mattress Type

Hybrid

Firmness Options

Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)

Price Range

$1,004 – $2,143

Trial Period

120 nights (30-night requirement)

Product Details

When choosing a new mattress, we recommend taking your sleep position into account. Side sleepers generally need a softer mattress that provides extra cushioning for their downward-facing shoulder and hip. The Nolah Evolution 15 is a hybrid mattress available in three firmness levels, allowing you to choose a support system based on your body type. All three models offer plenty of padding for side sleepers, and members of our testing team who primarily use this position awarded very favorable ratings to the Evolution 15.

What It’s Made of

The Evolution 15’s comfort system features a Euro-top containing four individual foam layers. Each layer is progressively denser from top to bottom, so you’ll notice some plushness when you get into bed and a cradling feel as your body settles. All four foams have an open-cell composition, so bothersome heat retention shouldn’t be a major issue. A graphite gel infusion in the second layer delivers additional cooling.

The support core consists of pocketed coils in a zoned arrangement. Thicker coils push back against the extra weight in your chest, stomach, and hips, while thinner coils create a gentler feel for lighter areas of your body. Extra perimeter reinforcement also means the mattress won’t sag when you lie or sit along the edges. The Evolution 15’s cover is made of organic cotton woven with cooling ArcticTex fabric.

How It Performed

Our team tested each of the Evolution 15’s three firmness levels. The medium (5) feel was most comfortable for our side sleepers weighing up to 230 pounds, and back sleepers under 130 pounds. At the other end of the spectrum, the firm (8) model provided adequate support for our back and stomach sleepers weighing at least 130 pounds. If you’re looking for something in the middle, we recommend the medium firm (6) design.

Temperature control proved to be a major strength of the mattress during our tests. We detected little to no heat buildup on the medium firm and firm models. While the medium design absorbed slightly more heat, none of our team members felt uncomfortably warm. Our testers also found that the Evolution 15 isolates motion and alleviates pressure better than the average hybrid mattress. We attribute these qualities to the deep, multi-layer foam comfort system.

Nolah offers free ground shipping throughout the contiguous U.S. and you’ll receive a pair of pillows with your mattress order at no extra cost. The Evolution 15 comes with a 120-night sleep trial, but you can opt out of the trial and cut your up-front costs by as much as $150. The standard manufacturer’s warranty covers structural defects for as long as you retain original ownership. You may purchase additional coverage for stains and spills for 10 years.

The Titan Plus caters to heavy sleepers who require exceptional firmness. The foam layers provide just enough cushioning to lightly cradle sensitive joints, but otherwise this bed is all about the support.

  • Pros

    1. Ultra-firm hybrid design provides excellent support and resists sagging over time

    2. Optional cooling panel helps eliminate heat retention

    3. Below-average pricing for a hybrid

  • Cons

    1. Mattress returns incur a $99 fee

    2. Side sleepers under 230 pounds may experience uncomfortable pressure buildup due to firmness

Mattress Type

Hybrid

Firmness Options

Firm (8)

Price Range

$489 – $1,119

Trial Period

120 nights (30-night requirement)

Product Details

The Titan Plus is one of the firmest hybrid models we’ve tested firsthand. Rating as an 8 on our 10-point firmness scale, the mattress feels exceptionally supportive and maintains a flat, even surface for most people – even those weighing more than 230 pounds.

What It’s Made Of

The Titan Firm Hybrid is one of the firmest hybrid models we’ve tested firsthand. Rating as an 8 on our 10-point firmness scale, the mattress feels exceptionally supportive and maintains a flat, even surface for most people – even those weighing more than 230 pounds. A thin layer of memory foam is quilted into the cover, followed by 2 inches of dense polyfoam. These materials provide light cushioning. The support core consists of thick pocketed coils over a base layer of high-density polyfoam.

We found that the Titan Firm Hybrid sleeps reasonably cool. If you are a hot sleeper, you can opt to include a phase change material (PCM) panel sewn into the cover. PCM is engineered to capture and release body heat on contact, creating a surface that feels cool at all times. Measuring 11 inches thick, the Titan Firm Hybrid is considered a medium-profile mattress.

How It Performed

As a relatively firm mattress, the Titan Firm Hybrid performed well in areas where softer, more adaptive hybrids tend to struggle. These include temperature control, ease of movement, and edge support. Our tester encountered little resistance moving across the surface, and no one sank excessively when positioned near or along the perimeter. The cooling panel makes a noticeable difference to the surface temperature, but we also found the mattress comfortable without the panel.

During our hands-on tests, we found the Titan Firm Hybrid best suited to people over 230 pounds across the side, back, and stomach sleeping positions. The mattress offers plenty of support, which sleepers in this weight range often need. Back and stomach sleepers between 130 and 230 pounds also found the mattress comfortable.

The Titan Firm Hybrid is available in seven sizes, including a split king for couples who share adjustable beds. The price-point falls well below average for a hybrid and shipping is free throughout the contiguous U.S. Your purchase comes with a 120-night sleep trial, and you’ll also receive a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty if you decide to keep the mattress.

The Bear Elite Hybrid has memory foam and polyfoam layers that ensure cushioning for sleepers across all sleep positions and body types. One of the foam layers is also zoned to boost cushioning where it’s most needed.

  • Pros

    1. Available in three firmness levels and a dual-firmness option for split king

    2. Excellent cooling thanks to Celliant-blend cover and steady airflow through the coils

    3. Transitional layer is zoned to push back against heavier areas of your body

  • Cons

    1. Foam may emit a slight off-gassing smell after unboxing

    2. Coils produce some motion transfer

Mattress Type

Hybrid

Firmness Options

Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)

Price Range

$1,231 – $2,548

Trial Period

120 nights (30-night break-in period)

Product Details

If you’re shopping for a new mattress with a partner, you’ll need to take a few extra considerations into account. The Bear Elite Hybrid performed well in all testing categories associated with couples. Findings include consistent motion isolation, a sturdy perimeter, excellent temperature control, and good bounce for sex.

What It’s Made Of

The Elite Hybrid’s comfort system contains memory foam over transitional polyfoam. A cooling gel infusion in the top layer helps dissipate heat and keep you cool, while the transitional foam is divided into five firmness zones based on where most of your weight is concentrated. This helps ensure pushback for the torso and hips, and a gentler feel beneath lighter areas of your body such as the head and legs. The support core consists of pocketed coils and high-density base foam. Thicker coils around the perimeter help strengthen the edges, allowing you and your partner to use the entire surface for sleep and sex.

A cover made with Celliant fabric encases the mattress. Celliant is engineered to capture and release heat on contact, maintaining a cool-to-the-touch feel at all times. You can choose from medium (5), medium firm (6), and firm (8) feels for your Elite Hybrid. The mattress is also available in seven sizes, including a split king for couples who use king size adjustable beds. If you fall into that category, Bear allows you to choose a different firmness level for each side of the mattress.

How It Performed

We tested all three of the Elite Hybrid’s firmness levels. The medium feel earned favorable ratings from side and back sleepers up to 230 pounds, but this model may be too soft for some. Those seeking extra support should consider the firm design, which was popular among our side sleepers over 230 pounds, and our back and stomach sleepers of at least 130 pounds. The medium firm proved to be the most balanced option, and received positive ratings from side and back sleepers across all weight groups.

Cooling is a major strength of this mattress. The cooling cover, gel-infused foam layer, and air-circulating coils work together to regulate your temperature and keep you comfortable throughout the year. The medium and medium firm models performed well during our pressure relief and motion isolation tests, while the firm model earned higher marks for edge support and ease of movement.

The Elite Hybrid is competitively priced and ground delivery is free throughout the contiguous U.S. Each order includes two pillows at no extra cost. Bear’s sleep trial spans 120 nights in length, and includes free shipping on returns. Those who keep their mattress receive a lifetime warranty covering various defects as long as they retain original ownership. An accidental protection plan against stains and other types of physical damage is available for an additional fee.

The adaptive foam layers in the Emma Hybrid Comfort minimize motion transfer while sturdy edges ensure you can use the entire surface without rolling off — both excellent qualities for a mattress meant to be shared by couples.

  • Pros

    1. Foam layers contour closely for strong pressure relief

    2. Zoned coil layer delivers targeted support for the torso and hips

    3. All orders include a year-long sleep trial

  • Cons

    1. People who are sensitive to smells may notice some off-gassing at first

    2. Stomach sleepers over 230 pounds might find the bed too soft

Mattress Type

Hybrid

Firmness Options

Medium Firm (6)

Price Range

$739 – $1,499

Trial Period

365 nights (4-week try-out request)

Product Details

Important mattress qualities for couples include consistent motion isolation, sturdy edge support, and enough responsiveness for sex. The Emma Hybrid Comfort checks all of these boxes. The mattress is also fairly robust and resistant to sagging thanks to its medium firm (6) feel and sturdy coil core.

What It’s Made of

The Hybrid Comfort begins with an adaptive polyfoam layer followed by a memory foam layer that provides additional cushioning. Next is another polyfoam layer that further enhances contouring but has a slightly firmer feel. The support core is composed of a thick coil system that makes the mattress feel somewhat bouncy without generating excessive motion transfer. The coils are zoned to deliver extra pushback in areas like the midsection.

How It Performed

Our testing team awarded favorable ratings to the mattress across different body type and sleep position groups. Side sleepers over 130 pounds and back sleepers up to 230 pounds were particularly impressed, though we expect most stomach sleepers over 130 pounds to feel less supported. The mattress tested well across several performance categories. These include consistent motion isolation and strong pressure relief, which we’ve attributed to the thick foam layers, and above-average cooling thanks to the steady air circulation through the coil system.

Emma offers free ground shipping throughout the contiguous U.S. The company’s 365-night sleep trial is one of the longest in the online mattress industry, ensuring ample opportunity for you to test out the mattress. You’ll also receive a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty covering various structural and material defects.

The Birch Mattress checks off a lot of boxes for a bed with excellent cooling properties, from the breathable latex to the moisture-wicking wool layer. This is a great option for sleepers who routinely overheat at night.

  • Pros

    1. Latex hybrid design ensures excellent durability and a noticeable bounce

    2. Excellent cooling thanks to breathable, moisture-wicking materials

    3. Coils reinforced along the edges help prevent sinkage

  • Cons

    1. Not suitable for sleepers with a latex allergy

    2. Responsive surface may not appeal to sleepers who are sensitive to motion transfer

Mattress Type

Latex Hybrid

Firmness Options

Medium Firm (6)

Price Range

$1,099 – $1,799

Trial Period

100 nights (30-night requirement)

Product Details

Hot sleeping is all too common, and anyone who overheats in bed should consider a mattress with cooling components. The Birch Mattress is constructed top to bottom with temperature-regulating materials, and its medium firm (6) hybrid design also helps ensure above-average durability and little to no sagging over the course of its lifespan. Latex’s naturally springy feel is a great alternative if you want a mattress that cushions your body without the “hugging” sensation of sleeping on memory foam.

What It’s Made Of

The mattress begins with an organic cotton cover and wool fire barrier. Cotton is naturally breathable and the wool has moisture-wicking properties, allowing the Birch to maintain a cool, comfortable surface throughout the year — even on exceptionally hot or humid nights. The latex comfort layer gently contours to cradle your sore spots, but you’ll notice a significant bounce before your body settles. This bounciness helps you move across the surface without sinking.

Pocketed coils and a base layer of wool/rayon fiber batting make up the support core. The coils are thicker along the perimeter, so you should feel secure sleeping near the mattress’ edges and won’t sink too much when getting in and out of bed.

How It Performed

The Birch earned widespread praise from our testing team. Its most favorable ratings came from side sleepers weighing at least 130 pounds, and back and stomach sleepers weighing up to 230 pounds. We were particularly impressed with the Birch’s balance of surface-level cushioning, robust base support, and subtle bounce.

Our edge support tests confirm sufficient pushback along the perimeter. Temperature control was another testing highlight. Our thermal mapping technology revealed very little heat buildup, and none of our testers felt excessively warm lying on the mattress. The responsive latex also allowed us to move across the surface without sinking too much.

The Birch Mattress is competitively priced, shipping is free to customers in all 50 states, and you’ll receive two free pillows at no extra cost. Your order comes with a sleep trial running 100 nights in length. You may return the mattress free of charge during this time frame. If you’re satisfied with your purchase, a 25-year warranty against structural defects kicks in once the trial period ends.

Data-Driven Results You Can Trust

Finding a mattress that will stand the test of time can be a challenging task, especially since many newer manufacturers don’t yet have a proven track record. Our experts are well-versed in mattress construction, and our vast experience has helped us learn how to identify well-built designs with a long-expected lifespan.

We back our recommendations with an extensive testing process during which we analyze every facet of the mattress, including how it performs for people with different body types and preferred sleep positions. Because sleepers over 230 pounds exert more pressure on mattresses, our team incorporates sleepers in this weight range as well.

Dive Deeper – In-Depth Mattress Guides

If you’re still concerned about finding the perfect mattress for your needs, take a look at our guides broken down by mattresses that help address specific issues.

What Causes a Mattress to Sag?

Over time, foam breaks down and coils lose their ability to spring back to their original shape. Both of these issues can result in sagging. Most mattresses will sag eventually, but the quality of construction and materials can accelerate or delay the occurrence.

Premature Sagging vs. Normal Wear and Tear

There are two primary components to a mattress: the comfort system and the support core. Ultimately, every layer of the mattress affects its propensity to sag. The comfort system is more prone to localized body indentations, whereas the support core can cause broader structural problems.

Support Core: The support core is usually made of sturdy materials such as steel springs or high-density polyfoam, which are designed to withstand repeated use before they start breaking down.

Mattresses with low coil counts or low-quality steel are quicker to lose their elasticity, and they generally sag sooner than higher-quality builds. A hybrid mattress made with low-quality coils may only last 5 to 6 years, whereas a better-quality base may lengthen the expected lifespan up to 8 or 10 years.

Likewise, low-density polyfoam with thinner cell walls and more air pockets is more susceptible to sagging. Lower quality all-foam models can break down as soon as 2 or 3 years after purchasing, whereas better models may last up to 7 or 8 years.

Comfort System: The comfort system tends to include softer materials such as memory foam, which can break down sooner and develop permanent indentations. Additionally, mattresses with thicker comfort sections may be more vulnerable to forming body impressions. To a certain extent, this wear and tear is considered a normal part of mattress use. Sometimes, manufacturers add firmer transitional layers to reinforce the softer layers on top.

Most manufacturers don’t cover sagging and body indentations under warranty unless they reach a certain level, such as 1-inch indentations that are visible even when no pressure is applied. If your mattress has body impressions that are not covered by the warranty and you find they affect the mattress’ ability to provide pressure relief, you may be able to compensate by using a mattress topper.

Although the warranty length and terms do not always correspond to the quality of the mattress, these can be a good indication of how long the manufacturer expects the bed to last. Warranties that cover body impressions of at least 1 inch⁠ — as opposed to impressions of 1.5 or 2 inches ⁠— indicate that the construction will likely prevent premature sagging.

Similarly, longer warranties of 15 or 20 years imply that the mattress may last longer before needing to be replaced. These models are often more expensive up-front, but the price may be worthwhile if it saves you the cost of buying another new mattress within that time frame.

How to Choose a Durable Mattress

There are several indications that hint at when a mattress may start sagging, such as the price, the type of materials, and the firmness level. When purchasing a mattress, you should also consider factors that influence the overall comfort, such as temperature regulation and motion isolation, as well as whether the mattress design is appropriate for your body type and sleeping position.

What to Look For in a Mattress That Won’t Sag

Mattress shopping can be overwhelming, as every manufacturer has its own terms to describe proprietary materials. Understanding how the different mattress components contribute to its overall feel and performance can help you narrow down your choices and find a bed suitable for your needs.

Price
Mattress price is an easy way to weed out low-quality mattresses. While prices can vary according to brand, special features, or organic certifications, a cheap mattress will generally sag sooner. These beds may be suitable for guest rooms, but they likely aren’t designed to withstand regular use.

Sleeping Position
Proper spinal support is important no matter what sleeping position you prefer. However, a sagging mattress may be most uncomfortable for stomach sleepers if it allows the midsection to sink in too much. Back sleepers also require a reliable surface to support the lumbar spine.

Quality Materials
Mattresses built with natural materials such as latex and wool tend to outlast other materials. When assessing the quality of your mattress, note the coil count, the coil gauge or thickness, the foam density, and any vulnerable points that may be more susceptible to premature sagging, such as convoluted polyfoam. Look for manufacturers that are transparent with their specs.

Firmness Level
The right firmness level for you depends on your body weight and primary sleep position. Broadly speaking, firmer mattresses tend to be more resistant to body impressions, although there are many exceptions as this also depends on the materials used. Stomach sleepers and individuals who weigh more than 230 pounds may find that a firm (7) or extra firm (9) mattress offers longer-lasting support.

Pressure Relief
Pressure relief is a key factor for all sleepers, especially for side sleepers and those who weigh under 130 pounds. These sleepers can experience pressure points where the hips and shoulders make contact with the mattress, so they benefit from having cushioning materials in the comfort system. High-density memory foam, natural Talalay latex, and wool are examples of pressure-relieving materials with a long-expected lifespan.

Motion Isolation
For people who sleep with a partner, it’s important to find a mattress that doesn’t transfer motion across the bed. All-foam models and hybrids with individually wrapped coils tend to perform well at motion isolation.

Temperature Regulation
Temperature neutrality is especially relevant to hot sleepers and those who live in warm climates. Mattress manufacturers use many techniques to fight against heat retention. For example, mattresses can include moisture-wicking covers, and foams may be perforated or infused with gel beads designed to draw heat away from the bed’s surface. Innerspring cores also perform well at temperature neutrality, as their construction allows air to flow freely through the coils.

Edge Support
Whereas hybrid and innerspring models usually feature a reinforced perimeter, foam and latex models may compress significantly when weight is placed on the edges of the bed. Weak edge support can significantly limit the usable surface area, so it’s an important consideration for people who like to sit on the edges, partners who share a smaller bed, or those who have trouble getting in and out of bed. Foam mattresses may break down sooner, so if you value edge support, consider a bed with a firmer, thinner comfort system.

Contouring
Contouring refers to a material’s ability to mold itself to the sleeper. Mattresses that contour more closely tend to provide better pressure relief, but they may be more apt to develop body impressions over time. Ideally, the comfort system should provide a certain level of contouring, while the transition layers and support core help bolster spinal support and enhance durability.

Mattress Type
Mattresses are classified into different types according to the primary materials used in their construction. While every model is unique, the mattress type plays a significant role in its performance and durability. Latex and hybrid mattresses often outperform foam and innerspring models when it comes to durability.

Mattress Types

The primary mattress types include hybrid, innerspring, foam, latex, and airbed. Mattress type is mainly determined by the materials used in the support core. While a mattress type can describe general characteristics, there can also be variations from model to model depending on the design and the quality of the materials.

Hybrid

Hybrid mattresses combine a substantial comfort system with an innerspring core, which is typically made with pocketed coils to reduce noise and motion transfer. The comfort layers may incorporate polyfoam, memory foam, latex, wool, cotton batting, microcoils, or other pressure-relieving materials.

Hybrid mattresses offer better pressure relief than classic innerspring models, and they also tend to boast sturdy edge support and strong breathability due to the coil layer. This makes them ideal for hot sleepers and those who enjoy using the full surface of the bed.

When looking for a hybrid mattress that won’t sag, aim for a minimum of 1,000 coils in a queen size and dedicated reinforcement around the perimeter. In the comfort system, high-density foams or natural materials like wool or latex are usually the most durable.

Innerspring

Sleepers who favor bounce, edge support, and airflow may be interested in an innerspring model. This mattress type is made almost exclusively of tempered steel coils, with little to no comfort system. These features make innerspring mattresses suitable for stomach sleepers but less suitable for side and back sleepers.

The durability of an innerspring mattress can vary greatly depending on the type, the gauge, and the total number of coils. Thicker-gauge coils and designs such as offset coils can withstand more pressure without losing their resilience. By contrast, older designs such as Bonnell coils may start sinking sooner.

It’s good practice to ensure your mattress has an appropriate coil count for the type of coils used, though several other factors influence a mattress’ performance. Similarly, coils may have different functions depending on their gauge and placement in the mattress. Many manufacturers use thicker low-gauge coils to strengthen the edges and thinner high-gauge coils for the hips and shoulders.

Foam

Foam mattresses contain polyfoam, memory foam, latex, or textiles in the comfort system and sit above a polyfoam support core. Ideally, the support core uses durable high-density polyfoam with a density of at least 1.8 pounds per cubic foot (PCF).

Couples often prefer foam mattresses because the lack of springs allow less motion to transfer to the other side of the bed when one person moves. Models with memory foam in the comfort layers also offer unparalleled pressure relief for side sleepers and individuals under 130 pounds. Sleepers over 230 pounds, however, may find that foam mattresses lack sufficient support.

In addition to the foam density and quality of the materials used, the thickness of the comfort system can also affect a mattress’ lifespan. Thicker comfort systems are more likely to develop body impressions, especially if they are made with low-quality materials.

Latex

Natural latex is made from sap found in rubber trees, which is whipped into a froth and baked using either the Dunlop or the Talalay process. Dunlop latex tends to be denser on one side, whereas Talalay is more buoyant and uniform. Latex can also be made synthetically using petrochemicals.

Natural latex is considered one of the most durable mattress materials, making it highly resistant to sagging. It can be used in the comfort or support layers, and it is often aerated with pincore holes to improve breathability. Mattresses made with certified organic latex may be appealing to sustainably minded shoppers.

Airbed

Airbeds use air chambers as the support core, which can often be inflated or deflated by the user until they reach the desired firmness level. Provided there are no leaks in the air chambers, this system should be protective against sagging as more air can always be added to increase the firmness setting.

Sleepers who want adjustable firmness levels or couples with differing comfort preferences may be interested in an airbed, as each side of the bed generally includes its own customizable air chambers. Airbeds may have additional layers of polyfoam, memory foam, or other materials to supplement the air chambers as well.

Extending the Lifespan of Your Mattress

By adopting a few proactive habits, you can help keep your mattress in tip-top shape for a longer period of time and delay when you need to invest in a new one.

Use a Mattress Protector and Clean Regularly
A mattress protector is a thin, waterproof membrane designed to protect your mattress against spills and stains. Not only does this help prevent accidental damage to your mattress, it can also prevent you from inadvertently voiding your mattress warranty, as most manufacturers won’t cover mattresses with visible stains.

Rotate Your Mattress
Most mattresses sold today aren’t designed to be flipped. However, you can delay the onset of permanent body impressions by rotating the mattress head-to-foot every 3 to 6 months.

Use Proper Support Under The Mattress
A proper foundation is essential for keeping your mattress supported and preventing pressure points from improper spinal alignment. Consult the manufacturer’s website or the warranty terms to find out what type of base is recommended for your model. Generally, a solid or a slatted foundation will offer sufficient support. You may need to ensure the slats are close enough together to prevent sagging. A full mattress or larger may require additional support in the center of the bed.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the pros and cons of a gel mattress?

Gel mattresses aim to offer a cooler sleep experience, which can raise the price-point compared to regular foam mattresses. Gel foam is a good option for sleepers who like the pressure-relieving, motion-isolating feel of memory foam or polyfoam but don’t like sleeping hot.

Because gel must be added to either memory foam or polyfoam, gel mattresses may not be attractive to shoppers who prefer natural materials or those who are sensitive to off-gassing smells.

What kinds of gel mattresses are available?

As gel foam is meant to be used in the comfort layers, gel mattresses can come in either hybrid or all-foam models. All-foam models have a high-density polyfoam support base, whereas hybrid mattresses have an innerspring base that is often made with pocketed coils. More rarely, shoppers might see airbed models with gel foam comfort layers over an inflatable air chamber.

How much does a gel mattress cost?

The average price of a gel mattress runs from about $800 to $2,000, though there are plenty of models that fall outside of this range. Foam mattresses are among the cheapest options, while hybrids may be more expensive. Although gel foam is more expensive than regular memory foam or polyfoam, gel mattresses usually cost less than natural latex mattresses.

Pricing can change depending on the brand, the design of the mattress, the quality of the materials, and the shipping and return policies. If you want the feel of gel foam but not the investment in a new mattress, a gel foam mattress topper may also be an option.

How long does a gel mattress last?

On average, buyers can expect a foam or hybrid mattress to last 6 to 8 years if properly cared for.

With all mattresses, the comfort system generally starts to break down before the support core. As a comfort layer, gel foam is not the most durable material, especially in its plusher iterations. However, regularly rotating the mattress from head to foot can delay the onset of permanent body indentations. Using a mattress protector can also help extend the lifespan by shielding the material against accidents.

Still have questions?

Our product experts have extensive experience testing just about every sleep product on the market.

Send an email to [email protected] with your questions and we’ll help you find exactly what you’re looking for.

Learn more about our Editorial Team

Trouble sleeping?

Answer these 5 easy questions to discover your perfect mattress

Trouble sleeping?

Answer these 5 easy questions to discover your perfect mattress

What position do you sleep in?

Side icon

Side

Side icon
Back icon

Back

Back icon
Stomach icon

Stomach

Stomach icon

Do you experience any pain while sleeping?

Back and/or side pain icon

Back and/or side pain

Back and/or side pain icon
Neck and/or shoulder pain icon

Neck and/or shoulder pain

Neck and/or shoulder pain icon
Little to no pain icon

Little to no pain

Little to no pain icon

Do you have any material preferences?

Innerspring icon

Innerspring

Innerspring icon
Foam icon

Foam

Foam icon
No preference/ Other icon

No preference/ Other

Do you sleep hot?

Yes icon

Yes

Yes icon
No icon

No

No icon

Do you sleep with a partner?

Yes icon

Yes

Yes icon
No icon

No

No icon

Back