Nectar vs. Casper Mattress Comparison

Nectar and Casper are both popular direct-to-consumer mattress companies. Both companies produce all-foam models, and Casper also produces two hybrid models.

Nectar currently sells two models constructed entirely of foam: the Nectar and the Nectar Lush. The Nectar is the company’s flagship model. It is constructed of three layers of memory foam and a polyfoam core. The Nectar Lush is the company’s newest model. It uses a layer of memory foam and two layers of polyfoam.

Casper produces five models: the Casper, the Casper Hybrid, the Wave, the Wave Hybrid, and the Essential. The Casper is the company’s all-foam flagship model, while the Casper Hybrid uses a very similar design but replaces the polyfoam core with a layer of coils. The Wave is the company’s all-foam luxury model, while the Wave Hybrid is its hybrid equivalent. The Essential is an all-foam, budget-friendly model.

The mattresses from both brands fall between medium and medium firm, rating between 5 and 6 on the 10-point firmness scale. This firmness range is popular and can accommodate most sleepers.

Nectar and Casper mattresses share some similarities and some key differences. In this guide, we’ll examine both brands on important criteria, including performance, construction, sizing, shipping, and more.

Quick Look

---

Sizing and Weight Options

A mattress’s size, height, and weight can affect the sleep experience and what sort of sleepers the mattress can best accommodate.

A mattress’s size influences how much space it needs and what size foundation it requires. Smaller sizes may be a better fit for small spaces, but couples often prefer larger sizes so that they have more room to move around.

The mattress’s height can also influence what space it fits into. Low-profile models often fit better into areas without a lot of clearance, like bunk beds. High-profile models often have thicker comfort and support layers, which may give sleepers who weigh over 200 pounds more support. Different heights may also make it easier or harder for some individuals to get into and out of bed.

A mattress’s weight can play a role in how easy it is to move and how secure it feels. Lighter mattresses are often easier for owners to move and rotate. However, some heavier mattresses may feel more secure and shift position less.

 

Nectar

Casper

 

All of the Nectar and Casper models are available in the standard mattress sizes. Since Casper produces five models while Nectar has two, Casper has a slightly wider range of mattress heights and weights.

While both brands produce 11-inch and 12-inch models, Casper also produces 13-inch models. These high-profile mattresses may be well suited for individuals who weigh over 200 pounds or those who struggle to get into or out of lower beds.

The Nectar and the Casper Essential are the two lightest models by the brands, and they are very close in weight. These options may appeal to sleepers who are worried about moving heavier models. The Casper Hybrid, the Wave, and the Wave Hybrid are heavier than either of Nectar’s models, so they may be a good choice for people who are concerned about the possibility of a lighter mattress shifting position.

---

Construction and Materials Comparison

A mattress’s materials influence its durability, quality, feel, and performance. Mattresses can be constructed of several different materials, each with its own distinct benefits and drawbacks. While there is no one best material, some may be better suited for some sleepers.

Memory foam has exploded in popularity in recent years. This material responds to a sleeper’s heat and weight to conform to their body, relieving pressure points. Memory foam tends to trap heat, but some models use temperature-regulating features to fight this tendency.

Polyfoam also conforms to the sleeper’s body. Because it is less dense than memory foam, it usually traps less heat and regains its shape more quickly. However, it also tends to break down faster.

Latex contours to a sleeper’s body without much sinkage. The sleeper’s weight is dispersed over a wider area than most memory foam or polyfoam, creating more of a floating feeling. Latex tends to sleep cool and is usually exceptionally durable.

Coils give a mattress bounce and breathability. Depending on their quality, coils can be quite durable. However, they are also more likely to make noise than most other mattress materials, and they may contribute to motion transfer.

Nectar

Nectar

The Nectar Mattress is constructed of four layers of foam.

The comfort system consists of two layers of memory foam. The first layer is 1 inch of gel-infused memory foam quilted into the mattress cover. A second 3-inch layer of gel memory foam contours more deeply while pulling heat away from the sleeper’s body. This memory foam has a density of 3.5 pounds per cubic foot (PCF), which is considered low-density. Low-density memory foam tends to trap less body heat than higher-density foams.

A 1-inch transition layer of gel-infused memory foam provides support and prevents the sleeper from sinking into the core. The support layer uses 6 inches of 2.2 PCF polyfoam that acts as a stable base for the rest of the mattress.

The mattress is wrapped in a Tencel cover crafted for cooling.

Nectar Lush

The Nectar Lush is an all-foam model constructed of three layers of foam.

The comfort layer uses 3 inches of 3.5 PCF memory foam infused with phase-change material gel. The low-density of the memory foam coupled with the gel-infusion help disperse excessive heat to maintain a more even temperature. This material also contours to the sleeper’s body to relieve pressure points.

A 2-inch transition layer of 2.5 PCF polyfoam acts as a buffer between the softer comfort layer and the firm core while providing extra bounce, much like latex. The support layer uses 7 inches of polyfoam to provide an even base for the mattress.

The mattress cover is a blend of polyester, nylon, and spandex. This material is stretchy and soft to the touch. It is engineered to help maintain a cool sleep surface by wicking away heat and allowing air circulation.

 

Casper

The Casper 

The Casper uses a four-layer construction.

The comfort system starts with a 1.5-inch layer of open-cell polyfoam. Open-cell polyfoam allows more air circulation than most foam to help keep the surface of the mattress cooler. Next, a 1.5-inch layer of 4 PCF memory foam contours to the sleeper’s body. This is a medium-density memory foam, making it more breathable than most high-density foams but more contouring than most low-density foams.

A 1.5-inch transition layer of 3.5 PCF polyfoam acts as a barrier to prevent sleepers from sinking in against the firm base. This transition layer is also zoned with extra support under the sleeper’s hips to promote better spinal alignment. Finally, a 7.5-inch layer of polyfoam stabilizes the mattress surface.

The mattress cover is composed of two main components. The top panel uses polyester, while the bottom and border use a blend of polyester and spandex for a stretchier feel.

 

The Casper Hybrid

The Casper Hybrid uses most of the same materials as the Casper Original, including the polyester and spandex cover, the comfort system with 1.5 inches of polyfoam and 1.5 inches of memory foam, and the 1.5-inch zoned polyfoam transition layer.

The difference between these two very similar models lies in the support layer. Instead of polyfoam, the Casper Hybrid uses a 6-inch pocketed coil layer and a 1-inch polyfoam base. The coil layer gives the Casper Hybrid extra bounce, edge support, and breathability. Since the coils are pocketed, each coil can move independently with minimal motion transferred between coils, which can help reduce nighttime disturbances when one partner moves. The final layer of polyfoam reinforces the coil system.

 

The Wave

The Casper Wave is an all-foam luxury model constructed of five distinct layers.

The comfort system uses three layers of varying materials. The top layer of the mattress uses open-cell polyfoam, while the second layer uses open-cell latex. These two layers are soft while allowing cooling airflow. The third layer of the comfort system is memory foam for deeper contouring and pressure relief.

A transition layer of polyfoam with targeted gel pods is softer under the shoulders and firmer under the hips to promote proper spinal alignment. It also serves to prevent sleepers from sinking into the mattress core. A polyfoam support layer reinforces the layers above.

The mattress cover is constructed of polyester, wool, and rayon. The addition of wool helps wick moisture and heat away from the sleeper’s body to promote a cooler night’s sleep.

 

The Casper Wave Hybrid

The Wave Hybrid is the hybrid version of the Wave Mattress. Like the Wave, the Wave Hybrid has a cover made of polyester, wool, and rayon; a comfort system with layers of open-cell polyfoam, open-cell latex, and memory foam; and a transition layer of polyfoam with targeted gel pods.

The support system is the key difference between the Wave and the Wave Hybrid. While the Wave uses polyfoam, the Wave Hybrid uses pocketed coils and a thin layer of polyfoam. The pocketed coils can move independently for deeper contouring. The pocketing also limits motion transfer between coils. The coil layer adds to the mattress’s bounce, breathability, and edge support. A final layer of polyfoam serves as a base for the coil system.

 

The Casper Essential

The Casper Essential uses a streamlined design that helps make the mattress quite affordable compared to similarly constructed models. The all-foam model is constructed of three distinct layers.

The Essential’s comfort layer uses 2 inches of polyfoam. This layer conforms to the sleeper without as much hug as memory foam. It also allows airflow to help cool the sleep surface.

A 1.5-inch transition layer of memory foam offers more contouring while preventing the sleeper from sinking into the firm core. The support layer uses 7.5 inches of polyfoam to give an even plane for the sleep surface.

The Essential is encased in a knit polyester cover.

---

Average Customer Ratings

Reading customer reviews can give potential buyers insight into how a mattress performs for existing owners. Strong reviews may indicate that most owners are satisfied with their purchase, which may make it easier to buy the mattress with confidence.

When looking at customer reviews, shoppers should pay attention to the written text in addition to the numerical ratings. Comfort is subjective, and each sleeper may have different opinions on what makes a mattress comfortable. Reviewers often mention specific performance criteria, like temperature neutrality, motion isolation, and pressure relief. Understanding how different individuals experience a mattress may give potential buyers a better idea of how it will perform for them.

 

Nectar

 

Casper

In-Depth Ratings

The following key criteria affect a mattress’s overall performance. Which criteria matter the most depend largely on an individual’s sleep style and preferred position. Once you understand these factors in more depth, you may be able to determine what matters most to you and shop for a mattress that can fulfill these needs.

• Durability: A mattress’s durability affects its lifespan. Mattresses that are not durable may breakdown or sag, making them less comfortable. Durable mattresses can last for years to come, preventing sleepers from needing to replace their mattress as often. Durability may be particularly important to individuals who weigh more than 200 pounds. Since these sleepers exert more force on a mattress, the mattress may breakdown more quickly.
• Motion Isolation: Motion transfer occurs when vibrations from movement spread across the mattress surface. Mattresses that isolate motion well absorb this movement rather than transferring it. Strong motion isolation is most common in mattresses with substantial foam comfort layers. Motion isolation may be most important for couples who are easily awakened when one of the partners changes position or gets up during the night.
• Sex: Certain mattress characteristics may be conducive or detrimental to sex depending on the couple’s preferences. Latex mattresses and mattresses with coil layers often have more bounce, which many couples prefer. Mattresses with coil layers also usually have more edge support, which may allow couples to use more of the mattress surface. However, they may be more prone to producing noise, which may not be discreet enough for some couples. All-foam models usually have less bounce but more traction. Since all-foam models tend to be virtually silent, they can be very discreet.
• Temperature Neutrality: A mattress’s materials and construction can influence how much heat it retains. Memory foam mattresses have a reputation for trapping heat against the sleeper’s body. However, many models use special features and constructions to help dissipate heat. Latex, innerspring, and hybrid models tend to allow for more air circulation than all-foam models. People who tend to sleep hot may prefer a mattress that dissipates heat and allows airflow to promote a cooler, drier night’s sleep.
• Pressure Relief: When a mattress contours to a sleeper’s body, it usually spreads out their weight. This can relieve pressure from a sleeper’s wider, heavier body parts, like their hips and shoulders. People who suffer from aches and pains may prefer a mattress with strong pressure-relieving properties. Mattresses with thicker memory foam comfort layers tend to excel in this area.
• Off-gassing: Many mattresses produce a slight odor when first unboxed. This is particularly true of compressed mattresses since they do not have time to air out. Mattresses that contain synthetic foam are most prone to off-gassing odors since they tend to emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs). While these substances are not generally considered harmless for most people, those who are sensitive to smells, suffer from chemical allergies, or have respiratory issues may find them problematic. Giving your new mattress a couple of days to air out before you use it should allow most of these odors to dissipate.
• Ease of Movement: Sleepers who tend to change positions during the night may prefer a mattress that is easy to move on. Memory foam shapes to a sleeper’s body and tends to retain impressions longer, which may make it harder to change positions or move across the surface of the bed. While polyfoam usually regains its shape more quickly than memory foam, latex and innerspring models tend to be the most responsive.
• Edge Support: Mattresses without reinforced edges tend to sink when a person sits or sleeps near the perimeter. This might limit the usable surface of the mattress since a sleeper may avoid the edge due to the feeling of instability. Sleepers who want to use the full surface of the mattress or who like to sit on the edge of the bed may prefer a mattress with sturdy edge support. This may be particularly important for people with mobility issues that make it more challenging to get into or out of bed. All-foam mattresses frequently lack reinforced edges, while innerspring and hybrid models usually have a stronger perimeter.

 

Nectar

 

Casper

---

In-Depth Pricing

Mattress prices are determined primarily by the materials and construction. Advanced and high-quality materials often carry a higher price tag. Innovative materials engineered to improve the sleep experience tend to be pricier than materials that have been on the market longer. Similarly, high-quality materials usually cost more than lower-quality alternatives. However, since high-quality materials also tend to be more durable, a more expensive mattress could last longer and save you money in the long run.

The type of mattress influences the materials used, so it can also play a role in determining the mattress’s price. Innerspring and all-foam mattresses tend to have a lower average price point, while airbeds, hybrid mattresses, and latex models tend to run more expensive.

The size and thickness of the mattress determine how much material is needed to construct it. Therefore, larger, thicker mattresses are usually more expensive.

 

Nectar

 

Casper

 

Nectar’s flagship model comes in at a slightly lower price point than Casper’s flagship model. However, the price differences are not particularly significant, so either model may constitute a better value depending on the sleeper’s needs and preferences.

Since Casper produces five models while Nectar produces two, Casper’s mattresses cover a wider range of price points. Casper’s most budget-friendly model, the Essential, is less expensive than either of Nectar’s models. Casper’s luxury models, the Wave and the Wave Hybrid, cost significantly more than either Nectar model.

While the prices between models vary, any model by Nectar or Casper may be a good value for some sleepers. It boils down to personal preference. While the pricier models have some distinct advantages, these may not be worth the extra expense for some sleepers. Whether or not a more expensive mattress is worth the extra cost depends largely on the sleeper’s priorities and how much monetary value they place on them.

---

Trials, Warranty, and Delivery

Nectar Policies

Shipping - Nectar typically ships mattresses 2-3 business days after an order is placed. Delivery usually takes another 2-5 business days. Purchasers can expect to receive their new mattress 7-10 business days after they place their order.

Mattresses ship free in the contiguous United States via FedEx Ground and arrive compressed. The owner is responsible for unpacking and setting up the mattress. White Glove delivery is available at an extra charge.

Returns - Nectar has a 365-night sleep trial. There is a required 30-night adjustment period before the sleep trial begins. If customers choose to return their mattress during this window, they may be eligible for a full refund of the purchase price. To return a Nectar mattress, contact Nectar’s customer service team. Nectar will help arrange for the mattress to be donated or disposed of.

Warranty - Nectar provides a limited lifetime warranty for its mattresses. This warranty covers indentations greater than 1.5 inches, physical flaws that lead to cracking or degrading, and manufacturing defects in the mattress cover.

The warranty applies to the original owner when purchased through an authorized seller. The owner is responsible for using a proper foundation and providing a receipt as proof of purchase. Damage caused by misuse or abuse is not covered. Additional terms and conditions apply.

Casper Policies

Shipping - After the customer places their order, Casper mattresses generally ship within 1-2 business days and arrive within 2-5 business days. The Casper, the Casper Hybrid, and the Essential ship for free in the contiguous United States via FedEx. These mattresses arrive compressed in a box, and the owner is responsible for setup. An in-home setup option is available at an extra charge.

Free in-home setup is available for the Wave and the Wave Hybrid. Casper’s local delivery partner will contact customers receiving in-home setup to arrange a delivery date.

Returns - All Casper mattresses come with a 100-night trial period. Customers are eligible to return their mattress for a full refund of the purchase price during this timeframe. To do so, customers can contact Casper. Casper will arrange to remove and dispose of the mattress. The company aims to either donate or recycle returned mattresses.

Warranty - Casper mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty that covers indentations greater than an inch, flaws that lead to foam cracking, and manufacturing defects in the zipper.

To be eligible, the claimant must be the original purchaser and have bought it through an authorized seller. The owner is responsible for using a proper foundation and supplying required documentation, including a receipt. The warranty does not cover damage due to abuse or misuse. Additional terms and conditions apply.