Home / Product Research Methodology - How We Make Our Selections

Product Research Methodology – How We Make Our Selections

At, we take product testing seriously. Our hands-on tests for mattresses and other sleep products are the basis for the performance ratings found in this site’s reviews and guides, which in turn influence our product recommendations for readers.

We conduct all tests in our dedicated sleep lab using state-of-the-art equipment. In addition to mattresses, other products we test include pillows, sheets, mattress pads and toppers, adjustable beds, weighted blankets, and comforters. Each product is evaluated against a set of objective criteria to ensure our results are accurate and free of bias. The performance categories we test for vary by product type. For mattresses, these include durability, pressure relief, motion isolation, temperature control, and edge support.

Each member of our testing team brings years of experience and expertise to our sleep product tests. The team also consists of people who fall into different categories based on body type, primary sleep position, and general comfort preferences. This commitment to diversity allows us to make product recommendations that are inclusive of all sleepers.

Keep reading for a detailed overview of our testing process and more information about our testing lab.

Our Product Testing Team

Tom Ryan

Tom Ryan

Head of Product Testing

Keith Cushner

Keith Cushner

Executive Director, Product

Lauren Fountain

Lauren Fountain

Senior Editor

Colin Simpson

Colin Simpson

Product Research Manager

Logan Foley

Logan Foley

Managing Editor, Health & Product

Danny Noyed

Danny Noyed

Senior Editor, Product

Brad Nehring

Brad Nehring

Product Expert

Jeremy Klein

Jeremy Klein

Senior Product Expert

Jackson Lindeke

Jackson Lindeke

Director, Product Experience

About Our Test Lab

Our test lab is located at OneCare Media’s main office in Seattle, Washington. This is where our team conducts hands-on tests of mattresses and other sleep products. We use the results of these tests to generate ratings, which are featured in our product reviews and guides. To ensure our ratings are inclusive of all sleepers, our testing team consists of people who fall into different categories based on body type, sleep position, and personal comfort preferences.

The equipment we use for our tests is state of the art. Key components include pressure-mapping software for our pressure relief tests, a heat gun that measures temperature control, and weights and laser levels to help us determine how well mattresses isolate motion. We evaluate each product individually using the same set of performance criteria based on the type of product we’re testing.

We consistently receive and test mattresses and other products from top sleep brands. These products are usually in excellent condition when our tests are finished, allowing us to donate them to charity.

Sleep Foundation lab testers utlizing lab equipment Sleep Foundation lab testers adjusting test dummy on mattressSleep Foundation sleep testers analyzing mattress pressure Sleep Foundation sleep testers examining products

Why You Can Trust Us

Another layer of our review and testing process is our in-depth knowledge of the sleep product industry. Members of our team have gone through the process of designing and manufacturing mattresses, pillows, and more so we know the ins and the outs of what goes into making these products and what to look for when it comes to value and quality. We’ve toured U.S. manufacturing sites where many major brands source their steel coil systems, latex foams, or have their beds assembled. We’ve spent hours at the biggest textile facilities throughout the world learning about what goes into everything that goes into a bedroom setup. While a lot of what goes into sleep products affects their quality, a lot of the features that are used tend to be just marketing jargon.

Sources/Data Sets: Our information comes from multiple sources to ensure accuracy and mitigate the risk of bias. We pull information from the following sources:

  • In-house product testing
  • Mattress manufacturers and industry experts

Performance Ratings

For mattresses, here is a breakdown along with definitions of all the performance factors we test for and discuss.

We use a scale of 1-5 to rate mattress performance. The scale is as follows:

  • 1: Low
  • 2: Low to Medium
  • 3: Medium
  • 4: Medium to High
  • 5: High

All of the following terms are directly related to the performance of a mattress.


Firmness is measured on a scale of 1 (softest) to 10 (firmest). We refrain from recommending beds that rank below a 2 or above an 8 on this firmness scale, as they aren’t great options for most sleepers. Firmness is provided by the mattress manufacturers and is measured scientifically by applying pressure to the surface of the mattress.

  • Soft: 2-3
  • Medium Soft: 4
  • Medium: 5
  • Medium Firm: 6
  • Firm: 7-8


The average lifespan of a mattress is six to eight years, so our ratings are based on that average. While we don’t hang on to our mattresses that long during testing, this rating is based on the quality of materials used in the construction of the bed.

Motion Isolation

Motion isolation refers to how much you can feel movement from the other side of the bed. For example, a mattress that rates high in this category will do a great job of keeping you asleep if your partner is moving around or getting up before you do.



The more bounce a mattress has, the better it is for sex. If a mattress rates low in this category, it typically means that the bed is not very responsive, which can cause couples to sink into the bed, making sex more difficult.


Sleeps Cool

While some luxury and high-tech beds offer actual cooling features like water that heats/cools the surface of the mattress, this metric is measuring how well the materials inside the mattress stay temperature neutral throughout the night. This is especially important for sleepers who tend to wake up sweating.


Pressure Relief

When you lay down on a mattress, your body has natural pressure points like your hips and shoulders. If a mattress does well in this category, it will conform to your body and allow it to release some of that pressure, reducing pain and promoting restful sleep.



Off-gassing refers to the odor that comes off the mattress after unboxing and/or opening it. This smell is harmless and typically dissipates completely within a few days.


Ease of Movement

Getting in and out of a bed shouldn’t be difficult. If a bed rates low in this category, it generally means that it’s not a good choice for people with chronic pain or people who toss and turn a lot at night.


Edge Support

Many people use their bed as a place to sit when getting ready in the morning, or sleep close to the edge of the bed because of a sleeping partner. Because of this, it’s important that a mattress can hold your weight and won’t collapse around the edges.


Sleeping Positions

The position that you sleep in can affect the type of mattress that best fits your needs and preferences. We rate each mattress we review for all sleeping positions (back, side, and stomach) on a scale of 1-4. If you are a combination sleeper, assume that you need a mattress that scores highly in each position you sleep in.

  • 1: Poor
  • 2: Fair
  • 3: Good
  • 4: Excellent

Sleeper Weight

The amount of weight on top of a mattress affects the pressure put on the comfort layers, therefore affecting how the mattress feels. We have found that most individuals who weigh more than 230 pounds will have similar needs for a mattress in terms of firmness, thickness, and comfort layers. Although we use the term “heavy” across the site for brevity and convenience to describe sleepers, we do not use weight categories such as “average” or “overweight” as they can be misleading and highly dependent on the individual. We use 230 or more pounds as a practical standard of weight when discussing how mattresses interact with sleepers’ bodies.



The prices featured on our product pages are the current manufacturer price, before any discounts. For comparison and product category pages, we list the Queen size price only with the exception of beds for kids where we list Twin size prices. Actual pricing may fluctuate based on deals and sales.

Please check back often as we’ll continue to expand this page to include all of the performance metrics we use for other sleep products including pillows, sheets, weighted blankets, white noise machines, and much more! If you have any questions about our testing process please reach out to us at [email protected].

  • Was this article helpful?
  • YesNo

About Our Editorial Team

Logan Foley

Certified Sleep Coach

Logan has extensive experience testing sleep products and producing sleep content. She is also a Certified Sleep Science Coach.