Anyone who has slept on a lumpy sofa bed or a sagging old mattress can tell you the same thing: comfort matters. Not only can a comfortable mattress help provide a more restful night’s sleep, but it can also relieve pressure points, align the spine, and help you wake up feeling refreshed rather than achy.
While all sleepers can benefit from a mattress that is comfortable for them, not everyone shares the same idea of what makes a mattress comfortable. Factors like an individual’s weight and favored sleep position play a role in what feels comfortable for them, but personal preference also comes into play.
We’ll share our picks for the most comfortable mattresses. While they might not be ideal for all individuals, we think that these mattresses will feel comfortable for the majority of sleepers. We’ll also explain factors that may influence which mattress feels most comfortable to you.
The Layla Hybrid combines the pressure relief of memory foam with the support of pocketed coils, while the bed’s flippable nature gives it a great degree of versatility.
The Layla Hybrid pairs Layla’s copper-infused memory foam and high-density polyfoam with a support core of pocketed coils. The mattress is flippable, with rather different firmness ratings on each side. The resulting combination excels at pressure relief and motion isolation, while also sleeping cool and staying appropriately supportive for a wide variety of sleepers.
One side of the mattress has a medium feel that rates at a 5 on the 10-point firmness scale, while the other side has a firm (7) feel to it. The medium side has a 2.5-inch comfort layer of copper-infused memory foam. The memory foam contours to the body to a moderate extent to provide strong pressure relief, while the copper infusion helps to combat heat retention.
The memory foam rests on a transition layer of 2 inches of zoned polyfoam that provides different degrees of support to different areas of the body. By contrast, the firm side has a thinner comfort layer of 1 inch of memory foam over 1.5 inches of the zoned polyfoam. The mattress is encased in a breathable cover made of polyester, viscose, and spandex with vinyl handles on the sides for easier flippability.
The support core consists of a 6-inch layer of pocketed coils between the layers of foam. The springs reinforce the edges rather well and contribute to a bouncy feel as you move around on top of the mattress. Although the bed uses memory foam in its comfort layers, air is able to flow through the coils, helping the mattress sleep cool. The coil core is supported by the layers of foam on the side that is currently not in use.
The Layla Hybrid’s dual firmness construction captures the two ends of the preferred range of mattress firmnesses, making it a great option for nearly any kind of sleeper. The medium side is best suited to sleepers who weigh less than 130 pounds, while the firm side is likely a better option for sleepers in any position who weigh more than 130 pounds.
The Layla Hybrid comes with a 120-night sleep trial and is backed by a 10-year warranty.
The Midnight model from Helix uses memory foam to cushion side sleeper’s pressure points and promote proper spinal alignment.
The Midnight is a memory foam hybrid model from Helix sleep that offers a balance of conforming and support. It has a medium feel that appeals to side sleepers across all weight groups. The mattress is also available in a ‘Luxe’ version that adds a plush pillowtop and another 2 inches to the overall height of the mattress.
The Midnight is constructed with a layer of gel-infused memory foam that contours closely to the body in order to relieve pressure points. This is followed by a transitional layer of polyfoam that prevents the sleeper from sinking too far down into the bed. Beneath that is a substantial pocketed coil support core, providing significant support and allowing for airflow throughout the mattress. The support core also features a reinforced perimeter, which gives the bed strong edge support.
The Midnight’s combination of pocketed coils and memory foam isolates motion well, sleeps cool, and comes at a below-average price point for a hybrid, making it an attractive option for hot sleepers, those who share a bed, and shoppers on a budget.
Helix ships free to all 50 U.S. states. Plus, they offer a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty.
The WinkBed comes in four firmness options, which should be able to give most sleepers the right combination of contouring and support for their weight group and sleep position.
The WinkBed is a hybrid model with four firmness options. When combined with the WinkBed’s solid pressure relief, temperature neutrality, edge support, and bounce, these four firmness options should be able to accommodate the comfort needs and preferences of most sleepers.
All versions of the WinkBed Mattress use a Tencel cover, which is soft to the touch and wicks heat away from the body. They also use a foam enhancement in the lumbar region to prevent the lower back from sagging and promote better spinal alignment. This reinforcement is coupled with a zoned coil layer that provides extra support around the sleeper’s midsection. The coils are pocketed, so each coil can move independently and air can flow freely between them. Added edge support in the coil layer creates a sturdy perimeter.
The medium-soft, medium-firm, and firm versions of the WinkBed have a gel-infused foam Euro-pillow top that cushions the body while pulling away excessive heat. A layer of microcoils allows airflow while responding quickly to position changes.
The Plus version of the mattress uses a high-density polyfoam top layer to contour to the body while resisting impressions. Instead of microcoils, the Plus version uses a layer of latex for additional support and durability. The coils in the support system of the Plus option are individually pocketed and then banded together in groups of four for extra support.
The WinkBed Mattress comes in four firmness settings: medium-soft (4), medium-firm (6), firm (7-8), and Plus (7-8). Sleepers under 130 pounds will likely find the medium-soft most comfortable. Those who weigh between 130 and 230 pounds may prefer the medium-firm or firm options. Individuals who weigh over 230 pounds might appreciate the extra support of the Plus mattress.
WinkBeds provides a lifetime warranty and a 120-night sleep trial on the WinkBed Mattress.
Designed to alleviate pressure while providing strong support, the flippable Idle Hybrid allows offers a customizable firmness on both sides of your mattress.
The Idle Hybrid is a flippable mattress, meaning you can sleep on the top and bottom surfaces. Idle Sleep offers two firmness levels for this model: medium firm (6) and firm (8). The company lets you choose the same feel for each surface, allowing you to periodically rotate the mattress to protect it from sagging and body impressions. Alternatively, you can select a different firmness level for each surface if you aren’t sure about your ideal feel or you prefer to switch between medium firm or firm levels.
Regardless of which firmness configuration you choose, the Idle Hybrid is constructed with three foam layers on each side and a shared support core of pocketed coils. The top foam layers are adaptive and will contour to your body. The medium firm feel results in deeper conforming and cushioning, which may be beneficial to side sleepers, while the supportive firm feel sinks less and is better suited to back and stomach sleepers – particularly those who weigh at least 130 pounds.
The support core delivers sturdy support and also makes the surface of the bed feel somewhat responsive. The coils are also zoned to be thicker along the edges, which prevents excessive sinkage when people sit along the perimeter. Another major strength of the Idle Hybrid is temperature control. The coils promote steady airflow to keep you and the rest of the mattress cool and comfortable.
Idle Sleep’s 18-month sleep trial is one of the longest in the mattress industry, so you should have plenty of time to test out the bed and decide whether it’s right for you. The Idle Hybrid also comes with a lifetime warranty that protects the mattress for as long as you own it. Standard ground shipping is free for all customers in the contiguous U.S.
The Leesa Hybrid’s coil system gives the mattress sturdy edge support and bounce, and its hole-punched comfort layer relieves pressure without trapping much heat.
The Leesa Hybrid pairs multiple layers of foam with a support core of pocketed coils. The foam layers give the Leesa Hybrid the pressure-relieving hug of memory foam, which many sleepers find comfortable. The coil layer adds additional comfort features, including edge support and bounce.
The Leesa Hybrid’s comfort system is constructed of two layers. The top layer uses high-density polyfoam, which is durable and conforming. Holes punched throughout the layer allow heat to dissipate to prevent the Leesa Hybrid from retaining excessive heat. Next, a layer of memory foam contours to relieve pressure points.
A transition layer of polyfoam prevents sleepers from sinking in against the coil system. The support core is a layer of pocketed coils. These coils contour more deeply and provide added edge support. Air flows through this layer for good temperature regulation. The coils can also move independently of each other, reducing the spread of motion between individual coils.
The Leesa Hybrid rates at a 6 on the firmness scale, giving it a medium-firm feel. While the Leesa Hybrid is supportive and should be able to give a comfortable night’s sleep for most sleepers regardless of weight, it offers the best balance of support and cradling for sleepers who weigh less than 230 pounds.
Leesa has a 100-night trial and a 10-year limited warranty for the Leesa Hybrid.
The Nolah Original’s medium firmness and use of cradling polyfoam allow it to cup the body and relieve major pressure points without trapping excessive heat.
The Nolah Original is an all-foam bed that combines multiple layers of polyfoam to provide significant pressure relief at an affordable price-point. The mattress starts with a 2-inch comfort layer of polyfoam that is engineered to shape more closely to the body than traditional polyfoam, effectively spreading out body weight and helping to take pressure off of key areas. It also does not hug as closely as memory foam, allowing sleepers to feel comfortably cradled without the feeling of being “trapped” in the bed.
A second layer of polyfoam contributes additional cushioning and acts as a buffer between the surface of the bed and its core. The Nolah’s support core consists of a 7-inch base of high-density polyfoam that provides stability and support for its top layers, while also allowing a solid amount of airflow through the mattress. The entire bed is wrapped in a stretchy, breathable cover made of moisture-wicking viscose.
The Nolah Original has a “medium” firmness, rating at a 5 on the 10-point firmness scale. The bed’s medium feel and all-foam construction lend itself well to the needs of side sleepers, lighter sleepers, and those who are looking for more active pressure relief from their beds. While the Original has a balanced firmness and dense support core, it may not be firm enough for most stomach sleepers and those who weigh more than 230 pounds.
Nolah ships free to the contiguous U.S. The Original is backed by a 120-night sleep trial with a 30-night break-in period. The mattress is further covered by a 15-year limited warranty.
The Birch Mattress is a breathable, supportive hybrid crafted from organic and sustainable materials including a wool batting and layers of ventilated latex.
If you find responsive beds comfortable, then we recommend the Birch Natural Mattress. This hybrid model is constructed with a top layer of natural and organic wool batting, followed by a layer of ventilated Talalay latex. Latex is a naturally springy material. It conforms to the body like memory foam, but does not cradle the body or sink too deeply. The mattress also contains a support core of pocketed coils reinforced with wool batting. The coils provide exceptional stability and plenty of reinforcement along the perimeter, so you shouldn’t sink too much when moving across the surface of getting in and out of bed.
Temperature control is another highlight of this mattress. The wool offers natural breathability and moisture-wicking properties, the ventilated latex circulates air near the surface, and the coils promote airflow throughout the interior to help the mattress maintain a comfortable core temperature. Due to its medium firm (6) feel, the mattress is best suited to people who weigh between 130 and 230 pounds. If you think this mattress might be too firm, Birch also offers a latex topper that creates a softer surface feel.
Birch provides free ground shipping to all 50 states, as well as a 100-night sleep trial. The mattress comes with a 25-year warranty that protects against deep body impressions and physical flaws in the bed’s assembly. For an added fee, you can also purchase accidental damage protection that covers other defects not included in the original warranty, such as stains.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora is a comfortable luxury hybrid mattress available in three different firmness options.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora is a luxury hybrid bed known for it’s all-around high performance and versatility. This bed comes in three firmness options: medium soft (4), medium firm (6), and firm (8), and features a range of different materials that each serve a specific purpose.
The cover of the Aurora is woven with phase change material, which absorbs body heat from the sleeper and disperses it away from the mattress. Under this are two polyfoam layers, the top one copper-infused for additional cooling, and the bottom of varying firmnesses depending on which model you choose. Next is a layer of gel infused memory foam, which adds additional conforming and pressure relief. The support core consists of an 8-inch pocketed coil system, which provides substantial support and breathability.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora tested well in every single performance category, including temperature control, ease of movement, edge support, pressure relief, and motion isolation. Since it comes in three different firmness options, sleepers of all weights and positions should be comfortable on this mattress.
The Aurora is sold for an above-average price, but this is to be expected from a luxury hybrid mattress. Brooklyn Bedding offers a 120-night sleep trial and a 12-year warranty. They ship for free to the contiguous US.
The Puffy’s all-foam construction and soft comfort layers provide excellent pressure relief while limiting motion transfer.
The Puffy Mattress is an all-foam model that offers close cushioning and body-contouring. Sleepers who like the hug of memory foam may find the Puffy’s close conforming exceptionally comfortable, but its strong motion isolation and lack of noise also make it a good choice for some couples.
The Puffy is constructed of three layers of foam. The comfort layer uses gel memory foam engineered to contour to the body without trapping heat. A transition layer of temperature-regulating polyfoam prevents the sleeper from sinking into the core. The polyfoam support core stabilizes the top layers while adjusting to support the sleeper’s body, regardless of their sleep position. The Puffy Mattress is encased in a removable cover. This cover is stain-resistant and washable for easy cleaning.
With a rating of 5 on the 10-point firmness scale, the Puffy has a medium feel. Because this is slightly softer than the average firmness most sleepers prefer, the Puffy has a plusher feel than many mattresses. Side sleepers who weigh under 230 pounds are likely to find the Puffy Mattress exceptionally comfortable since it is soft enough to cradle their pressure points without letting them sink in too deeply.
Puffy is one of the few mattresses on the market with a lifetime warranty. It also comes with a 101-night sleep trial.
The GhostBed Flex Mattress combines motion isolation, temperature neutrality, pressure relief, and bounce, making it exceptionally well suited for sleepers looking for balanced features.
The GhostBed Flex uses a hybrid design that pairs several layers of foam with a layer of pocketed coils. With multiple temperature-regulating features, the GhostBed Flex sleeps cooler than many models while also relieving pressure points and isolating motion. Many sleepers will likely find the GhostBed Flex’s combination of benefits extremely comfortable.
A quilted cover is crafted to feel soft and cool to the touch. A layer of fiber and a layer of gel memory foam are quilted into the cover for contouring and cooling. Next, another layer of gel memory foam cradles the sleeper for pressure relief and proper spinal alignment, while the gel infusion wicks heat away from their body. A layer of transitional polyfoam is engineered to be responsive like latex while contouring like memory foam to balance bounce and pressure relief.
A layer of pocketed coils acts as the bed’s support core. Airflow through this layer helps keep the bed cool. The coils give the mattress more bounce, while the pocketing reduces motion transfer between coils. This layer also includes reinforced coils near the perimeter of the bed to create a strong edge. Finally, a polyfoam base supports the spring layer.
The GhostBed Flex is a medium-firm model, rating around 6 on the firmness scale. While sleepers from any weight group may find this setting comfortable, it is perhaps the best fit for sleepers over 130 pounds. Sleepers in this group should be able to sink in enough to experience contouring and pressure relief.
GhostBed provides a 25-year warranty and a 101-night sleep trial for the GhostBed Flex.
Individual mattress models vary due to differences in their materials, quality, and construction. These differences can affect how comfortable a mattress feels. Certain types of mattresses tend to share some characteristics. There is still plenty of variation between individual models, but understanding these commonalities may make it easier to decide what type of mattress will feel most comfortable to you.
Definition: As the name suggests, hybrid mattresses combine construction features from two or more types of mattresses. Most often, this includes a memory foam or polyfoam comfort layer and a coil support core. However, there are also hybrid mattresses with latex, wool, and/or microcoil comfort layers paired with coil support cores.
Blend of Multiple Benefits. Hybrid mattresses usually have comfort layers that contour to the sleeper to provide pressure relief while isolating motion well. The coil support core usually gives the mattress bounce and edge support. Because hybrid models pair aspects of two or more types of mattresses, many people find they provide the benefits of each mattress type without the associated drawbacks, making them an exceptionally comfortable choice.
Definition: Innerspring models consist primarily of a coil support system. They may also have a comfort layer to provide some cushioning, but the comfort layer is usually not substantial.
Temperature Neutrality. People who tend to sleep hot may find innerspring models quite comfortable. Air circulation through the coil layer helps cool the sleep surface, and the thin comfort layers usually do not trap a significant amount of heat.
Definition: Latex models are traditionally constructed of multiple layers of latex foam. This material may be natural, synthetic, or a blend. Talalay latex is a springier, lighter material frequently used in mattress comfort layers, while Dunlop latex is a denser, more durable material that may be used in either the comfort or support layer.
Contouring Without Hug. While memory foam and polyfoam usually compress directly under the weight of the sleeper, latex spreads out the force across a wider surface area. This provides pressure relief without the hug of memory foam. Sleepers who prefer sleeping “on” a mattress to sleeping “in” a mattress may find latex models comfortable.
Definition: Airbeds use a support system of air chambers. These chambers can be emptied or filled by using a remote, app, or manual pump depending on the mattress model. Many airbeds also have thin comfort layers, which may consist of memory foam, polyfoam, and/or latex.
Adjustability. The firmness of an airbed can be adjusted by emptying for filling the air chambers. This may be particularly comfortable for people whose firmness preferences tend to change. Additionally, some models allow each side of the mattress to be adjusted separately, which may make an airbed a comfortable option for couples with different firmness preferences.
Definition: Foam mattresses are usually constructed primarily of memory foam and/or polyfoam, though they may also contain wool, latex, and other materials. All-foam mattresses are usually constructed of multiple layers of foam to achieve the desired balance between contouring and support.
Close Conforming. Foam mattresses tend to shape closely to the sleeper’s body. This relieves pressure points while providing a hugging sensation that many sleepers find comfortable.
As you shop for mattresses, you may notice that they are frequently assigned numerical firmness ratings. These ratings make it easier to see how firm a mattress is and how it compares to other models. In the standard 10-point firmness scale, 1 is the softest mattress possible, while 10 is the firmest.
Most sleepers favor a mattress between medium and firm, ranging from around 5 to 7. However, several factors beyond the numerical rating can contribute to the mattress’s feel.
One key factor is a sleeper’s weight. Sleepers who weigh under 130 pounds do not put as much force on a mattress, so they usually favor a softer model that allows them to sink in more. Individuals who weigh over 230 pounds put more force on a mattress, so they often require a firmer model to support them and prevent them from sinking in too deeply. Taking your body weight into account can help steer you towards the best mattress firmness for you.
The mattress type can also contribute to how firm it feels. Foam mattresses usually compress directly under a sleeper’s weight, which can make them feel softer than innerspring or latex models with a similar numerical rating.
A mattress that is too soft may allow a sleeper’s midsection to sink in too far, putting a strain on the spine. However, a mattress that is too firm could create pressure points and put the spine out of alignment, particularly for side sleepers.
While the ideal mattress firmness is subjective, understanding the factors at play can help you find your ideal firmness setting.
The right mattress is an important component of putting together a comfortable sleep environment, but it isn’t the only factor. Sleep accessories can help modify your sleep surface to promote a more comfortable night’s sleep. Pillows and mattress toppers may put the final touches on your sleep space.
While your mattress supports your body, your pillow supports your head and neck. The wrong pillow can put your spine out of alignment and strain your neck, leading to back and neck pain.
As is the case with mattresses, pillow comfort is subjective. However, an individual’s preferred sleep position can influence how thick of a pillow will feel best to them. A pillow should lift your head enough to straighten your neck and promote proper alignment.
Side sleepers’ heads usually lift the farthest off their mattress due to the breadth of their shoulders, so they frequently favor pillows with a medium or a high loft to fill the gap between the mattress and their heads and necks. Back sleepers have less space to fill, so they often prefer medium loft pillows. Stomach sleepers often sleep without a pillow or with a low loft pillow since a pillow could force their heads backward.
|Sleeping Position||Pillow Loft Recommended|
|Side||Medium or High|
Additional pillows may also make the sleep surface more comfortable. Some sleepers enjoy wedge pillows to prop up their legs or upper bodies. Knee pillows can help a side sleeper maintain proper spinal alignment while preventing the sleeper’s knees from rubbing together. Body pillows can allow the sleeper to prop up their body or separate their knees, providing flexible options for changing comfort preferences.
If your mattress isn’t as comfortable as you’d like, a mattress topper may help adjust the feel to better meet your needs and preferences. A mattress topper is an extra layer that you place on top of your existing mattress. Toppers are generally less expensive than replacing a mattress, making them a popular option for sleepers who want to try out a different feel.
Mattress toppers are available in a wide array of materials, including memory foam, polyfoam, latex, down, and down alternative. For sleepers who have wondered if they might like the hug of memory foam or the responsiveness of latex, a mattress topper can offer an opportunity to try the material without committing to a full mattress.
Thinner mattress toppers usually add some cushioning to the sleep surface, while thicker toppers modify the surface more significantly. A thicker mattress topper may provide similar contouring and pressure relief to that of a mattress with the same material in its comfort layer.
While a mattress topper may make a sleep surface more comfortable, it does not offer the same advantages of a new mattress and cannot fix a mattress that isn’t in good condition. Mattress toppers can give cushioning, contouring, and pressure relief, but they generally don’t provide support. If your mattress is sagging or lacks support, a mattress topper probably won’t affect the comfort significantly.
When purchasing a mattress, several factors may affect how comfortable it feels to an individual. While some mattress companies may advertise that their mattresses are comfortable for everyone, comfort is highly subject. Focusing on the most important details may make it easier to determine whether a mattress will be comfortable for you.
Black Friday coupons and discounts are still live! Check out dozens of exclusive deals from top mattress and bedding brands!