More and more people are deciding to skip the mattress showroom and instead shop online for a mattress that ships straight to their front door. Offering excellent selection, convenience, and value, a mattress in a box is a compelling option when looking for a new mattress.
- Our top choice—the Helix Midnight Luxe—is a medium firm hybrid that has layers specifically designed to fit most sleeping positions and body types.
- When choosing a mattress online, you want to be sure it’s a bed that will work for you. Don’t just take our word for it, check out a summary of the online reviews in the product details.
- If you just want a quick overview, our 1-minute video reviews are a great place to start. Give them a a watch to start your search.
Our Top Picks
-
Best Overall Mattress in a Box – Helix Midnight Luxe
View Details
-
Most Comfortable Mattress – WinkBed
View Details
-
Best Value Mattress – DreamCloud Mattress
View Details
-
Best Mattress for Side Sleepers – Nolah Evolution 15
View Details
-
Best Mattress for Back Pain – Bear Elite Hybrid
View Details
-
Best Mattress for Couples – Leesa Sapira Hybrid
View Details
-
Best Luxury Mattress – Helix Midnight Elite
View Details
-
Best Extra Firm Mattress – Plank Firm Luxe
View Details
-
Best Mattress for Hot Sleepers – Layla Hybrid
View Details
Swipe for more
Best Overall Mattress in a Box
Helix Midnight Luxe
9.7 /10
Test Lab Score
27% off sitewide + 2 free Dream Pillows with a mattress purchase. Code: SF27
27% off sitewide + 2 free Dream Pillows with a mattress purchase. Code: SF27
The Helix Midnight Luxe wins “Best Overall” because of its versatility. It’s well-suited for a wide variety of sleep positions, isolates motion well, and strikes a good balance between comfort and support. It also has cooling properties and is easy to assemble.



Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,899
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period
100 nights (30-night requirement)
Our Verdict
Who It’s Best For
Side sleepers, stomach sleepers, and back sleepers alike found the Midnight Luxe comfortable, but it tested best with side and back sleepers weighing up to 230 pounds. Given its strong ability to isolate motion, the mattress is also good for couples.
Feel
The Midnight Luxe has a medium firm feel and a good balance between comfort and support, thanks to the combination of memory foam and polyfoam comfort layers layers and zoned coils in the support core. Memory foam on the surface conforms to your body to provide a hugging sensation.
What It’s Made Of
The Midnight is a hybrid mattress with two memory foam comfort layers, followed by transitional polyfoam, while the support core contains zoned pocketed coils with a reinforced perimeter and dense base foam.
What We Don’t Like
Despite its versatility, the Helix Midnight Luxe might not give enough support to sleepers weighing more than 230 pounds. The foam layers may also give off a strong “off-gassing” smell when you first unbox the bed.
Scoring & Reviews
- Comfort and Support: Many reviewers express that the mattress provides exceptional comfort and support, especially noting its ability to alleviate back, hip, and shoulder pain.
- Sleep Quality Improvement: The mattress is frequently described as transformative for those who previously struggled with sleep disturbances.
- Temperature Regulation: Positive remarks are made about the cooling properties of the mattress. Users find the cooling aspect effective, helping to maintain a comfortable sleeping temperature throughout the night.
- Customer Service: Experiences with customer service are predominantly positive, with buyers appreciating the responsive and helpful nature of the support team. Issues are resolved satisfactorily, contributing to a positive overall customer experience.
- Durability Concerns: A few reviewers express concerns about the mattress showing signs of wear or sagging prematurely. These concerns are not widespread but are significant enough to be noted by potential buyers.
- Mixed Reviews on Firmness: While many find the mattress perfectly balanced, there are mixed reviews regarding its firmness. Some users find it softer than expected given its firmness level. While the ‘medium firm’ rating is appropriate by our measurements, the bed does have a ‘cushy’ foam feel that makes for a fairly soft surface feel.
Full Details
Construction Breakdown
The mattress begins with two comfort layers of memory foam that conform closely to your body, followed by a transitional polyfoam layer that provides additional contouring but also pushes back against your weight. Individually pocketed coils reinforced with high-density polyfoam make up the support core. Different “zones” for the coils ensure extra reinforcement for your midsection. The reinforced perimeter coils create pushback when you sleep near the edges of the mattress or get in and out of bed. A breathable Tencel cover encases the entire mattress.
Trial, Shipping, & Warranty
Helix Sleep offers free ground delivery throughout the contiguous U.S. You’ll receive a 100-night sleep trial that includes free return shipping. If you decide to keep the Midnight Luxe, you’ll also receive a 15-year manufacturer’s warranty.
Most Comfortable Mattress
WinkBed
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
Get $300 off all mattresses at Winkbeds
Get $300 off all mattresses at Winkbeds
The WinkBed snags our top spot for back pain because it’s firm enough to provide excellent support and spinal alignment while still balancing exceptional comfort for many different body types. It also holds up incredibly well and maintains its shape and foundational support over time.



Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,499
Mattress Type
Innerspring
Firmness Options
Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7), Firm (8)
Trial Period
120 nights (30 night requirement)
Our Verdict
Who It’s Best For
The WinkBed is a true crowd pleaser. With a firmness level to fit any body type and sleeping position, people struggling with back pain vouch for this bed’s ability to provide comfort, relief, and improved sleep quality.
Feel
The WinkBed embodies all the feelings of a hybrid: A responsive give and take when you sit and lay on it coupled with a plushness in the top layers to give you balanced support and comfort for your back, hips, and shoulders.
What It’s Made Of
Zoned pocketed coils with thicker springs around the edge of the bed to protect the perimeter from sinkage. Most models feature an adaptive polyfoam surface layer, followed by a layer of denser foam to support your body weight. The Plus models feature zoned latex, ensuring heavier bodies won’t sink in too deeply.
What We Don’t Like
Some sleepers with back pain have thought the bed was too firm for their body weight. It’s also a very thick mattress, which means it’s heavier and can be difficult both to move and to find sheets that won’t pop off during the night.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 8573 validated customer reviews of the Winkbed. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Pain Relief and Support: A significant number of users report alleviation of back, hip, and shoulder pain, attributing this to the mattress’s supportive design. Individuals with chronic back issues have noted substantial improvements in sleep quality.
- Comfort Across Sleep Positions: Reviewers from various sleep positions—side, back, and stomach—find the mattress comfortable. The availability of different firmness levels allows users to select options that best suit their sleeping style.
- Temperature Regulation: Many customers appreciate the mattress’s ability to stay cool, enhancing overall comfort throughout the night.
- Edge Support: Users frequently mention the robust edge support, which provides a stable and usable sleeping surface across the entire mattress.
- Firmness Options: Customers appreciate the variety of firmness options available, finding the right balance for their personal preferences.
- Durability and Craftsmanship: The mattress is often praised for its high-quality construction and materials, with users expressing confidence in its longevity. The lifetime warranty further reinforces trust in the product’s durability.
- Customer Service and Trial Experience: Customers value the 120-night risk-free trial and responsive customer service, noting that these factors contribute to a positive purchasing experience.
Full Details
Construction Breakdown
The Euro-top is quilted with gel-infused polyfoam, which cushioned sharp pressure points during our lab tests. The cooling gel infusions are designed to absorb and dissipate excess body heat. Next is a layer of SupportCell polyfoam that kept our testers’ body weights evenly distributed across the mattress surface. The medium soft model has an extra transitional layer made from polyfoam for added plushness, and the Plus model features latex in lieu of foam for enhanced support. The zoned, pocketed coil support core helped maintain spinal alignment for our testers, and the Tencel fabric cover kept the surface cool and breathable.
Trial, Shipping, & Warranty
The WinkBed ships for free to states within the contiguous U.S. and includes a 120-night sleep trial. If you aren’t satisfied with your initial firmness selection, you may exchange the mattress for a softer or firmer model at no extra cost, and the replacement comes with its own 60-night trial. All models are backed by lifetime warranties.
Best Value Mattress
DreamCloud Mattress
8.5 /10
Test Lab Score
Up to 50% off mattresses & up to 66% off bundles
Up to 50% off mattresses & up to 66% off bundles
With a starting price of $665 (hybrid queen), the DreamCloud mattress performs similarly to competitors that have a much higher price point. It has a focus on pressure relief, solid support, and temperature control.


Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$665
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period
365 nights (30-night requirement)
Our Verdict
Who It’s Best For
The DreamCloud mattress is best for side sleepers who weigh more than 230 pounds, but it’s also a good option for back sleepers.
Feel
Those who weigh more than 230 pounds will appreciate the deep contouring and lack of sinkage. Side sleepers will enjoy the combination of cushioning and support.
What It’s Made Of
The DreamCloud cover comes quilted with polyfoam for a plush feel and its comfort layers get progressively denser to help your body settle without sinking too much. Pocketed coils (hybrid model) and high-density base foam provide a sturdy support system to keep your back aligned through the night.
What We Don’t Like
Despite coming in either an all-foam or hybrid version, the base model only has one firmness option, which may not be quite firm enough for heavier sleepers.
Scoring & Reviews
- Comfort and Firmness: Many users describe the mattress as having a medium-firm feel that balances support and plushness, catering to various sleep positions.
- Motion Isolation: Couples appreciate the mattress’s ability to minimize motion transfer, allowing for undisturbed sleep even when sharing the bed with a partner. This quality is essential for those sensitive to movement during sleep.
- Pain Relief: Numerous customers report significant relief from back and joint pain, attributing this to the mattress’s supportive structure and pressure-relieving memory foam layers. This is consistent with expert recommendations for mattresses that promote spinal alignment.
- Temperature Regulation: The mattress’s cooling technology is frequently praised, with users noting a comfortable sleep temperature throughout the night. This feature is particularly beneficial for hot sleepers seeking a cooler sleep environment.
- Edge Support: Users mention strong edge support, providing confidence when sitting or sleeping near the mattress’s perimeter. This feature maximizes the usable sleep surface and enhances overall stability.
- Durability and Quality: Customers commend the high-quality materials and construction, expressing satisfaction with the mattress’s durability and longevity. The lifetime warranty further reinforces confidence in the product’s endurance.
- Customer Service and Trial Period: The 365-night trial period and responsive customer service are highlighted as significant advantages, providing peace of mind and flexibility during the purchasing process.
Full Details
Construction Breakdown
The DreamCloud’s cover is made of a cashmere poly-blend fabric quilted with a polyfoam layer. Our test team found the surface very breathable and plush, and the gel-infused memory foam under the quilted cover offered excellent pressure relief. Beneath is a transition layer of polyfoam and a support core containing individually wrapped coils.
Trial, Shipping, & Warranty
For a luxury mattress, the DreamCloud is fairly affordable, coming in at an average price-point for a standard hybrid bed. DreamCloud stands behind the mattress with excellent guarantees, which include a 1-year sleep trial and a lifetime limited warranty.
Best Mattress for Side Sleepers
Nolah Evolution 15
9.2 /10
Test Lab Score
35% off sitewide + $150 off BedJet & 2 free pillows with mattress purchase
35% off sitewide + $150 off BedJet & 2 free pillows with mattress purchase
The Evolution 15 is Nolah’s top-of-the-line mattress. It’s a hybrid mattress that focuses on zoned support to relieve high-pressure areas for side sleepers.

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,624
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night requirement), $99 return pickup fee
Our Verdict
Who It’s Best For
Side sleepers with back pain and people who experience painful buildup at night welcome the contouring features of the foam layers with the strong support of a coil system.
Feel
The Nolah Evolution feels plush when sinking in to it due to all the foam layers but still feels relatively easy to move around on the surface of the mattress due to its responsive support core.
What It’s Made Of
The Nolah Evolution 15 features a Euro-top cover quilted with foam, a proprietary AirFoam comfort layer (for cooling), followed by polyfoam for contouring. The support core consists of an 8 inch pocketed coil system for targeted body support.
What We Don’t Like
This is a super thick mattress, so finding deep pocket sheets to fit may be a problem. Nolah also charges a $99 return fee, so if you’re not sure this mattress is the choice for you, it may be best to skip it.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 897 validated customer reviews of the Nolah Evolution 15. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Motion Isolation: Couples note the excellent motion isolation, which minimizes disruptions from partner movements during the night.
- Edge Support: The edge support of the mattress is frequently highlighted, with many finding it adequate for sitting or sleeping near the edge without feeling like they will roll off.
- Softness: Many reviewers discuss the softness of the mattress. Some find it too soft, causing discomfort, especially for heavier individuals, while others appreciate the plushness.
- Pressure Relief and Support: Reviewers frequently highlight relief from back and shoulder pain, attributing this to the supportive foam layers and zoned coil system.
- Heat Retention: A few reviewers note that the mattress retains heat, making it uncomfortable for some, particularly in warmer climates or for those who sleep hot.
- Durability and Quality: Users often comment on the high quality and durability of the mattress, noting that it maintains its shape and comfort over time.
Full Details
Construction Breakdown
The Evolution 15 features 2 inches of adaptive foam quilted into the Euro-top, followed by a proprietary AirBreath border gusset designed to maximize airflow and reduce heat buildup. Next is a second comfort layer of AirFoamICE, an open-cell foam infused with graphite for added cooling. Two layers of denser foam provided transitional support that kept our testers on an even plane.
In the support core, thicker coils are used in the midsection to provide extra reinforcement and pushback in the area where most people carry a disproportionate amount of weight. Sturdier coils along the perimeter reduced sinkage when our testers got on and off the mattress. The foundational layer is composed of plant-based fiber. A cover made of breathable ArcticTex fabric encases the mattress, and each side is equipped with handles to aid you with lifting and moving.
The Evolution comes in seven sizes, including a split king.
Trial, Shipping, & Warranty
Nolah provides free ground delivery for all orders in the contiguous U.S. The company also offers a 120-night sleep trial, but customers can forgo the trial period and reduce their up-front cost by up to $150. The Evolution 15 is also backed by a lifetime warranty against structural defects.
Best Mattress for Pressure Relief
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid
8.4 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide. Code: PRESDAY25
25% off sitewide. Code: PRESDAY25
With its balance of cushioning and support, The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is the safest choice for all sleep positions. The three available firmness levels make it one of the most versatile options on the market.


Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$932
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night requirement)
Our Verdict
Who It’s Best For
The Signature Hybrid is a top pick for all sleep positions, but the sub-130 pound crowd is best suited for the softest option. Those over 230 pounds should choose the firm design, and those between 130-230 should opt for the medium-firm.
Feel
The three firmness options will have different feels, but they all provide solid pressure relief, responsiveness, and reduce motion transfer.
What It’s Made Of
While thickness varies depending on the firmness option, the top is made of cotton quilted with polyfoam padding, the comfort layer is in TitanFlex polyfoam followed by transitional polyfoam, and pocketed coils and base polyfoam make up the support core.
What We Don’t Like
Some customers report off-gassing after unboxing, while others have said that the firmness level did not match what they were expecting.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 10000 validated customer reviews of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and support: Many reviewers mention that the mattress is very comfortable and provides good support for various sleeping positions.
- Improvement in sleep quality: Several users report a significant improvement in sleep quality, including better rest and reduced pain.
- Firmness options: People appreciate the availability of different firmness levels, and some discuss their experiences with medium, firm, or pillow-top options.
- RV suitability: A number of reviews specifically mention using the mattress in RVs, noting it as a substantial upgrade from typical RV mattresses.
- Initial odor/smell: Some reviewers note a mild odor upon unpacking, but it typically dissipates quickly.
- Edge support: The mattress is often noted for having good edge support, which is particularly valued by those who sit on the edge of the bed.
- Price and value: Many reviewers feel the mattress is well-priced for the quality and comfort it provides.
- Durability concerns: A few reviewers express concerns about how the mattress will hold up over time, although these comments are not widespread.
Full Details
Construction Breakdown
Specific designs for the Signature Hybrid vary by firmness, but all three contain comfort systems with two polyfoam layers. The topmost layer is infused with cooling gel intended to reduce heat buildup on the surface, while the second layer is fairly dense and acts as a buffer between your body and the support core. Pocketed coils and base foam stabilize the mattress well and create a noticeable bounce when you get into bed.
You can choose from 14 different sizes for the mattress. In addition to standard mattress dimensions, these include a split California king for couples with adjustable beds and several RV sizes.
Trial, Shipping, & Warranty
Brooklyn Bedding offers free ground shipping throughout the contiguous U.S. The company’s sleep trial runs for 120 nights, and those who keep the mattress also receive a 10-year warranty against workmanship defects.
Best Mattress for Back Pain
Bear Elite Hybrid
8.5 /10
Test Lab Score
35% off + free pillows with code: SF35
35% off + free pillows with code: SF35
The strength of this versatile hybrid lies in its strong temperature regulation, thanks to a cover made of Celliant-blend fabric. In addition, a zoned transitional layer provides enhanced reinforcement for the midsection. Three firmness option cater to different preferences and sleep positions.


Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,499
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night break-in period)
Our Verdict
Who It’s Best For
Hot sleepers praise the Bear Elite’s cooling properties, while also speaking favorably of its balance between firmness and cushioning at their desired firmness level. The Luxury Firm model is the most versatile one when accommodating different sleep positions among people weighing between 130 and 230 pounds.
Feel
This bed has a taller profile than many hybrids, a slight bounce, and a plush top layer that is super comfortable. The thick foam layers that help isolate motion don’t retain too much heat thanks to the Celliant-blend cover, and the coil core promotes airflow.
What It’s Made Of
The Bear Elite has one polyfoam and one memory foam layer that is infused with copper to keep it cool. The coils in the support core are thicker around the edges so you can sit and sleep around the edges of the bed without sinking in too much.
What We Don’t Like
This is not the best option for stomach sleepers, especially if they also have back pain.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 3703 validated customer reviews of the Bear Elite Hybrid. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and Support: Many reviewers highlight the mattress’s balance of comfort and support, often mentioning relief from back pain and improved sleep quality.
- Firmness Options: Customers appreciate the various firmness options, with some opting for firmer versions after experiencing discomfort with medium firmness.
- Temperature Regulation: Several reviews note the mattress’s ability to stay cool, which enhances sleep quality, especially in hot weather.
- Size and Upgrade Options: Customers are pleased with the availability of different sizes and the option to upgrade, which provides flexibility for different needs and preferences.
- Quality of Additional Products: Positive remarks on the quality of accompanying products like pillows and sheets, which are often included as free additions.
- Motion Isolation: Many reviewers highlight the mattress’s excellent motion isolation, making it ideal for shared sleeping arrangements.
Full Details
Construction Breakdown
With several firmness options available, the mattress appeals to sleepers with various body types and sleep preferences. Underneath the Euro-top cover is adaptive memory foam, which cushions the body and gently relieves pressure. This layer features a copper infusion designed to help regulate temperature. Next is a layer of polyfoam that further promotes contouring but also has a responsiveness to prevent excessive sinkage. Beneath is a pocketed coil support core, which reinforces the mattress and delivers sturdy but responsive support. The coils rest on a base layer of polyfoam for stability.
Seven sizes are available for the Elite Hybrid, including a split king for couples who share adjustable beds.
Trial, Shipping, & Warranty
If you and your partner have differing firmness preferences, you can order a split king with a different feel on each side. Bear offers a 120-night sleep trial with the Elite Hybrid, as well as a lifetime warranty. Shipping is free within the contiguous U.S.
Best Mattress for Couples
Leesa Sapira Hybrid
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
20% off + 2 free pillows with mattress purchase
20% off + 2 free pillows with mattress purchase
Comfortable is subjective, but most couples find the Leesa Sapira provides great pressure relief in the back and hip areas and is supportive enough to maintain spinal alignment. Since it’s a medium firm hybrid that’s designed to sleep cool, it has just enough foam to provide ample cushioning for a wide range of sleeper types.

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,599
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period
100 nights (30 night requirement)
Our Verdict
Who It’s Best For
The Leesa Sapira Hybrid has strong motion isolation and edge support, so it’s a solid choice for those who are easily bothered by their partner’s movements or sometimes find themselves at the edge of the bed. It’s best suited for side and back sleepers weighing less than 230 pounds.
Feel
The Leesa has a bouncy feel which makes it easier to move around during the night. It’s super soft and plush and gives you the “hug” feeling of the memory foam without sinking in too much to feel stuck.
What It’s Made Of
While thickness varies depending on the firmness option, the top is made of cotton quilted with polyfoam padding, the comfort layer is in TitanFlex polyfoam followed by transitional polyfoam, and pocketed coils and base polyfoam make up the support core.
What We Don’t Like
Some customers report off-gassing after unboxing, while others have said that the firmness level did not match what they were expecting.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 2257 validated customer reviews of the Leesa Sapira Hybrid. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and Support: Many reviewers mention the mattress’s blend of comfort and support, often highlighting its suitability for side and back sleepers, and its ability to alleviate or prevent pain (back, hip, or shoulder).
- Temperature Regulation: Customers note the breathable construction helps regulate temperature, ensuring a cooler sleep experience.
- Durability and Longevity: Positive comments on how the mattress maintains its shape and comfort over several years without sagging or indentations.
- Motion Isolation: The mattress performs well in minimizing motion transfer, making it an excellent choice for couples.
- Odor and Off-gassing: Some mention initial off-gassing smells upon unpacking, but most report that the odor dissipates quickly.
- Edge Support: Good reviews on the edge support of the mattress, which is important for those who sit on the edge of the bed or sleep near the edge.
- Value for Money: Many users feel that the mattress provides good value for the price, especially given its comfort and durability features.
Full Details
Construction Breakdown
The Sapira Hybrid’s comfort system consists of three individual layers, beginning with 1.5 inches of adaptive polyfoam. This layer is aerated to promote air circulation and help the surface stay cool. Memory foam and transitional polyfoam provide additional cushioning. Pocketed coils and dense base foam make up the support system. Thicker coils line the perimeter to stabilize the edges when you get in and out of bed. A breathable knit cover encases the mattress.
Trial, Shipping, & Warranty
Competitive pricing and free shipping to all 50 states make the Sapira Hybrid a solid pick for budget-conscious shoppers, and each order includes two Leesa pillows at no extra charge. Your sleep trial runs for 100 nights. If you decide to keep the mattress after the return period ends, your purchase is further backed by a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty.
Best Luxury Mattress
Helix Midnight Elite
9.8 /10
Test Lab Score
27% off sitewide + 2 free Dream Pillows with a mattress purchase. Code: SF27
27% off sitewide + 2 free Dream Pillows with a mattress purchase. Code: SF27
With its luxury design and high-end construction, the Helix Midnight Elite is the best luxury mattress in the “Best In a Box” category. The only caveat is its price tag, which is hefty.

Price
$2,811
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period
100 nights (30-night requirement)
Our Verdict
Who It’s Best For
Side sleepers praise the pressure relief provided by the Midnight Elite, but it also garnered favorable reviews among stomach and back sleepers weighing up to 230 pounds.
Feel
“Sleeping on a cloud” and “Just the right softness” are a few choice phrases used by customers to describe the experience of sleeping on the Helix Midnight Elite.
What It’s Made Of
As part of Helix’s most luxurious line, the Midnight Elite has five foam layers in its comfort system, plus two layers of zoned microcoils and a reinforced perimeter for stability and durability.
What We Don’t Like
Its pricing is above average for a hybrid model, and it’s 16 inches tall, so sheets are a watch-out.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 110 validated customer reviews of the Helix Midnight Elite. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and support: Many reviewers mention that the mattress provides good support and comfort, especially highlighting its benefits for side sleepers and those with back pain.
- Temperature regulation: Several reviews discuss the cooling features of the mattress, though opinions vary on its effectiveness, with some finding it cool and others still experiencing heat. We found that it performed better than the average hybrid, but with thick foam laters, the bed is inevitably going to trap some body heat.
- Pain relief: A significant number of users report relief from pain, particularly in the back, neck, and shoulders, after sleeping on the mattress.
- Price and value: The cost of the mattress is often mentioned, while the vast majority of users liked the bed, some questioned whether it is worth the relatively lofty investment.
- Durability concerns: A few reviewers express concerns about the long-term durability of the mattress, mentioning issues like sagging or the formation of indentations after short periods of use.
Full Details
Construction Breakdown
The Midnight Elite’s comfort system intersperses memory foam and microcoils to make the surface feel plush, adaptive, and somewhat bouncy. Two polyfoam transitional layers form a buffer between you and the support core to keep your body on an even plane. All of these components are encased in a luxe Euro-top.
The pocketed coils are divided into three firmness zones for extra support beneath your midsection and a gentler feel elsewhere. Extra reinforcement along the perimeter provides stability and reduces compression when you sit or sleep along the edges. A cover made of cooling GlacioTex fabric helps ensure a comfortable sleep temperature. At 16 inches tall, the Midnight Elite is quite thick and requires a deep-pocket fitted sheet.
Trial, Shipping, & Warranty
The sticker price is fairly high, even by luxury hybrid standards, but delivery is free to customers in the contiguous U.S. and each order is backed by a 100-night trial period. If you aren’t satisfied with the mattress, you’ll receive a full refund and Helix covers the return shipping costs. Those who keep their Midnight Elite receive a 15-year manufacturer’s warranty.
Best Extra Firm Mattress
Plank Firm Luxe
7.8 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide. Code: PRESDAY25
25% off sitewide. Code: PRESDAY25
Support without a hug: the Plank Firm Luxe is a flippable mattress featuring one firm and one firmer side. Those weighing more than 230 pounds will notice that the foam on the surface will conform to their body. For others, the rigidity of the Firm Luxe will make you say goodbye to back pain.

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,149
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Firm (7), Extra Firm (9)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night requirement)
Our Verdict
Who It’s Best For
This model is best for those who weigh more than 230 pounds, sleep on their stomach or back, or just happen to prefer a firmer feel. If a softer mattress has caused you back pain in the past, the Firm Luxe is a solid option for spinal alignment.
Feel
True to its name, the Plank has a firm surface that will make you feel like you’re sleeping on it rather than in it. That’s not to say it’s not comfortable, however — the thick foams offer gentle support for high pressure areas.
What It’s Made Of
The Plank has two sides: a firm and an extra firm side. The firm side has layers of proprietary TitanFlex foam that is similar to latex and high-density polyfoam. The extra firm side lacks the TitanFlex foam and has a thinner layer of polyfoam. The two sides share the support core layer, which is made of pocketed coils.
What We Don’t Like
Firm mattresses are not everyone’s cup of tea. Side sleepers and those with severe pressure points should opt for something a little softer.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 1748 validated customer reviews of the Plank Firm Luxe. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and firmness: Many reviewers discuss the comfort level of the mattress, often highlighting its firm feel. While all of those bought the mattress for its firmness, a few people still found the bed too firm.
- Cooling features: Several reviewers mention the cooling features of the mattress, specifically the Glaciotex Cooling Cover, which is appreciated for providing a cooler sleep experience.
- Pain relief: A recurring theme is the relief from back and joint pain, with many users noting improvements in their sleep quality and reduction in pain. Many users report improved spinal alignment, especially those who prefer firmer mattresses.
- Dual firmness options: The mattress’s ability to be flipped for different firmness levels (firm and extra firm) is frequently mentioned and appreciated by those who have different firmness preferences.
- Edge support: A lot of reviewers mention the strong edge support of the Plank Firm Luxe.
- Off-gassing: A few reviewers note the presence of off-gassing when the mattress is new, but it typically dissipates after a few days.
- Customer service: Experiences with customer service are generally positive, with reviewers appreciating the responsive and helpful support team. The 120-night trial period and responsive customer service are frequently noted as key advantages.
Full Details
Construction Breakdown
The firm side of the Plank Firm Luxe features adaptive foam quilted into the cover, followed by a comfort layer of TitanFlex polyfoam and a transitional layer of high-density polyfoam. Our testers noticed that this side combines the contouring of memory foam with the responsiveness of latex. The extra firm side has less foam quilted into the cover and does not include a TitanFlex layer, which our testers found distinctly firmer than the opposite surface. A shared support core of pocketed coils stabilizes both sides of the mattress.
You can choose to add a GlacioTex cover featuring panel of phase change material, which is sewn to the fabric on both sides. This cooling component is engineered to capture and release heat, which helps maintain a comfortable surface temperature. The panel increases the mattress’ price by $100 to $200, depending on which size you select.
Trial, Shipping, & Warranty
Shipping is free of charge for all customers in the contiguous U.S. The Plank Firm Luxe is backed by a 120-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty.
Best Mattress for Hot Sleepers
Layla Hybrid
8.5 /10
Test Lab Score
Up to $200 off mattresses + 2 free pillows
Up to $200 off mattresses + 2 free pillows
With one medium soft (4) and one firm (7) side, The Layla Hybrid has strong cushioning to alleviates painful pressure buildup. It combines cooling technology with steady airflow through its coil system, making it a solid choice when it comes to temperature control.



Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,499
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Reversible: Medium Soft (4), Firm (7)
Trial Period
120 nights
Our Verdict
Who It’s Best For
The Layla Hybrid mattress is best those who prioritize pressure relief. In fact, its flippable design offers a choice between firmness levels, catering to various sleeping preferences and body types.The soft side is a soild option for people under 130 pounds, while the firm side is comfortable for all sleepers from 130 pounds and up, provided they enjoy a bit firmer surface.
Feel
The soft side offers exceptional motion isolation and pressure relief, and both sides have temperature regulation, but the firmer side is stronger in the cooling department since it has less foam.
What It’s Made Of
The 13 inch Layla Hybrid has a flippable construction with five layers. The comfort layers on the soft side has 2.5 inches of copper-infused memory foam that facilitates cooling and 2 inches of polyfoam. The firm side has 1 inch of copper-infused memory foam and 1.5 inches of polyfoam. The shared support core contains pocketed coils.
What We Don’t Like
Some side sleepers report a lack of support from the softer side. And while a flippable design is definitely a perk of the Layla Hybrid, flipping it is not the easiest feat, as it’s on the heavier side.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 1121 validated customer reviews of the Layla Hybrid. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and Support: Many reviewers mention the mattress provides excellent support and comfort, particularly noting improvements in back and shoulder pain.
- Dual Firmness: The dual-sided design, offering both soft and firm options, is frequently praised for its versatility.
- Motion Isolation: Reviewers mention excellent motion isolation, which minimizes disruptions from partner movements.
- Temperature Regulation: Some reviewers appreciate the mattress’s cooling properties, though a few mention it sleeps warm. Mant say the copper-infused foam layers effectively regulate temperature, keeping the sleep surface cool.
- Shipping and Delivery: Fast and efficient shipping is often noted, although a few had issues with delivery services.
- Weight and Maneuverability: The mattress is noted to be heavy, making it difficult to move or flip without assistance.
- Smell and Off-gassing: A few reviewers mention an initial off-gassing smell that dissipates over time.
- Edge Support: Mixed reviews on edge support, with some noting it could be improved.
Full Details
Construction Breakdown
The Layla Hybrid’s medium soft side contains 2.5 inches of copper-infused memory foam, followed by 2 inches of transitional polyfoam. The latter is zoned to provide extra reinforcement for your midsection and gentler cradling elsewhere. The firm side also features these components, but the layers are thinner to minimize cushioning and make this surface feel more supportive. A shared pocketed coil support core is located between the foam layers. The coils are doubled up along the perimeter to reduce sinkage when you lie or sit along the edges.
The copper infusions are meant to reduce heat buildup on the surface, and a breathable polyester-viscose cover encases the entire mattress. You can unzip and machine wash the polyester, rayon, viscose, and poly-lycra blend cover whenever it needs to be cleaned. Comparatively, most mattresses made today feature non-removable covers that can only be spot cleaned.
Trial, Shipping, & Warranty
The Layla Hybrid is competitively priced and shipping is free for all customers in the contiguous U.S. Your order includes a 120-night sleep trial, during which you can return the mattress for free if it doesn’t meet your needs. If you decide to keep the hybrid, Layla backs your purchase with a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty.
Presidents’ Day Mattress Sales Are Here!
Presidents’ Day is a great time to buy a new mattress, with many top brands offering major discounts for shoppers. Visit our full list of Presidents’ Day mattress sales to learn about the best deals.
The Best Deals of The Week
-
Save $199
—
Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Memory Foam
$466 (List Price $665) -
Save $593
—
Helix Midnight Luxe
$1,780 (List Price $2,373) -
Save $2,518
—
Nectar Adjustable Bundle
$1,398 (List Price $3,916) -
Save $300
—
WinkBed
$1,499 (List Price $1,799) -
Save $999
—
DreamCloud Mattress
$665 (List Price $1,664)
Best Overall Mattress in a Box
Helix Midnight Luxe
9.7 /10
Test Lab Score
27% off sitewide + 2 free Dream Pillows with a mattress purchase. Code: SF27
Shop at HelixA medium firm, pressure relieving hybrid that gently contours and provides zones support.
See More Details
Most Comfortable Mattress
WinkBed
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
Get $300 off all mattresses at Winkbeds
Shop at WinkBedsA popular hybrid that’s plush, supportive, and offers a firmness option for every body type.
See More Details
Best Value Mattress
DreamCloud Mattress
8.5 /10
Test Lab Score
Up to 50% off mattresses & up to 66% off bundles
Shop at DreamCloudThis mattress combines top-notch contouring and support at a budget-friendly price point.
See More Details
Best for Side Sleepers
Nolah Evolution 15
9.2 /10
Test Lab Score
35% off sitewide + $150 off BedJet & 2 free pillows with mattress purchase
Shop at NolahA hybrid mattress with zoned support where you need it most.
See More Details
Best for Pressure Relief
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid
8.4 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide. Code: PRESDAY25
Shop at Brooklyn BeddingA budget-friendly hybrid that’s comfortable across all sleep positions.
See More Details
Best for Back Pain
Bear Elite Hybrid
8.5 /10
Test Lab Score
35% off + free pillows with code: SF35
Shop at BearA high-end mattress with zoned support and a cooling design.
See More Details
Best for Couples
Leesa Sapira Hybrid
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
20% off + 2 free pillows with mattress purchase
Shop at LeesaA responsive foam hybrid with moderate contouring for back pain and pressure relief.
See More Details
Best Luxury Mattress
Helix Midnight Elite
9.8 /10
Test Lab Score
27% off sitewide + 2 free Dream Pillows with a mattress purchase. Code: SF27
Shop at HelixA luxury hybrid made with premium materials, a plush pillow-top, and zoned support where you need it most. `
See More Details

Best Extra Firm Mattress
Plank Firm Luxe
7.8 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide. Code: PRESDAY25
Shop at PlankA firm, flippable hybrid mattress with two levels of firmness for extra support all night long.
See More Details

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Best for Hot Sleepers
Layla Hybrid
8.5 /10
Test Lab Score
$220 off + free pillows with code: Sleepy20
Shop at LaylaA flippable hybrid mattress for those who want dual-firmness options.
See More Details
Compare the Best Mattresses in a Box
Select up to 3 products to compare
Rating
|
Product |
Price |
|
---|---|---|---|
/10 |
$1,899 ![]() |
||
/10 |
$1,499 ![]() |
||
/10 |
$665 ![]() |
||
/10 |
$1,624 ![]() |
||
/10 |
$932 ![]() |
||
/10 |
$1,499 ![]() |
||
/10 |
$1,599 ![]() |
||
/10 |
$2,811 ![]() |
||
/10 |
$1,149 ![]() |
||
/10 |
$1,499 ![]() |
Compare Mattresses
Go back to select different products
Price
$1,899
$1,499
$665
$1,624
$932
$1,499
$1,599
$2,811
$1,149
$1,499
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Innerspring
Hybrid
Hybrid
Hybrid
Hybrid
Hybrid
Hybrid
Hybrid
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7), Firm (8)
Medium Firm (6)
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Medium Firm (6)
Medium Firm (6)
Firm (7), Extra Firm (9)
Reversible: Medium Soft (4), Firm (7)
Customer Rating
9.0/10
9.6/10
9.2/10
9.8/10
9.4/10
9.4/10
8.8/10
9.1/10
9.4/10
9.0/10
Side Sleepers (Under 130 lbs.)
8.5/10
8.0/10
7.0/10
8.0/10
7.5/10
7.5/10
8.0/10
8.5/10
4.5/10
7.5/10
Side Sleepers (130-230 lbs.)
10.0/10
9.5/10
8.0/10
9.5/10
9.0/10
9.0/10
9.5/10
10.0/10
6.5/10
9.0/10
Side Sleepers (Above 230 lbs.)
8.5/10
8.0/10
7.0/10
8.0/10
7.5/10
7.5/10
8.0/10
8.5/10
8.0/10
7.5/10
Back Sleepers (Under 130 lbs.)
8.0/10
7.5/10
8.0/10
7.5/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
7.5/10
8.0/10
4.5/10
7.0/10
Back Sleepers (130-230 lbs.)
9.5/10
9.0/10
7.0/10
9.0/10
8.5/10
8.5/10
9.0/10
9.5/10
6.5/10
8.5/10
Back Sleepers (Above 230 lbs.)
9.5/10
9.0/10
7.0/10
9.0/10
8.5/10
8.5/10
9.0/10
9.5/10
6.5/10
8.5/10
Stomach Sleepers (Under 130 lbs.)
6.5/10
6.0/10
7.5/10
6.0/10
5.5/10
5.5/10
6.0/10
6.5/10
5.0/10
5.5/10
Stomach Sleepers (130-230 lbs.)
8.0/10
7.5/10
6.0/10
7.5/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
7.5/10
8.0/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
Stomach Sleepers (Above 230 lbs.)
6.5/10
6.0/10
5.5/10
6.0/10
5.5/10
5.5/10
6.0/10
6.5/10
8.5/10
5.5/10
Motion Isolation
8.5/10
6.0/10
7.5/10
8.0/10
6.5/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
8.5/10
6.0/10
7.5/10
Edge Support
9.5/10
9.0/10
7.5/10
9.0/10
7.5/10
7.5/10
6.5/10
9.5/10
8.0/10
6.0/10
Temperature Control
8.0/10
8.5/10
7.0/10
7.5/10
7.5/10
7.0/10
8.0/10
9.0/10
8.0/10
7.0/10
Ease of Movement
7.5/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
6.5/10
6.5/10
7.0/10
7.5/10
8.0/10
6.5/10
Off-gassing
8.0/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
7.5/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
8.0/10
7.0/10
7.0/10
Pressure Relief
9.5/10
7.5/10
8.0/10
9.0/10
7.0/10
8.0/10
8.5/10
9.5/10
6.0/10
8.5/10
Product Review
Video: We Tested the Best Mattresses in a Box – Here Are Our Favorites
Watch our video below to learn more about our lab’s top picks for mattresses in a box.
Below you’ll find in-depth looks at each of our top picks, but keep scrolling to check out our guide to buying mattresses in a box. The guide offers all sorts of helpful information about the mattress delivery process, pros and cons about different mattress types, and answers to common questions about mattresses-in-a-box.
What Is the Best Mattress in a Box For You?
With so many mattresses in a box to choose from, it’s hard to know where to start searching for a new bed. Here’s a quick look at the main mattress types to help you decide which is the best for you.
What It Is | Who It’s Best For | Who It’s Not For | |
---|---|---|---|
All-Foam Mattresses | Foam beds contain one or more foam layers that contour closely to your body. The deep cushioning eases pressure off sensitive joints and absorbs motion to prevent it from moving across the surface. | • Sleepers with painful pressure points • Side sleepers • Co-sleepers who wake each other up with movement | • People who overheat easily during sleep • Sleepers who don’t like feeling hugged by their mattress • Shoppers who prioritize longevity, since foam has a shorter lifespan than other mattress types |
Hybrid Mattresses | Hybrid beds are made with sturdy coils on the bottom and cushioning layers on top, typically foam or latex. Hybrids have a nice mix of support and plushness so they’re popular with many sleepers, but each model differs in materials and design so it’s important to research the best fit. | • Most side and back sleepers and some stomach sleepers • People who prefer beds with some bounce • Hot sleepers | • People who are easily awoken by a co-sleeper • Sleepers who need deep contouring • Shoppers on a very low budget |
Latex Mattresses | Latex mattresses can be entirely latex or latex hybrid, but both are very responsive and known for durability and excellent cooling properties. These models are usually made with natural and organically sourced materials, which is great for eco-conscious shoppers. | • Sleepers who prefer beds with some bounce • Back and stomach sleepers • People who sleep hot • Eco-conscious shoppers | • Side sleepers with pressure buildup in the shoulders and hips • People with a latex allergy • Shoppers on a budget |
Innerspring Mattresses | Innerspring beds have a thick layer of coils, similar to hybrids. But unlike hybrids, innersprings have thinner layers of cushioning on top. Some of the biggest benefits of innerspring beds are bounce, cooling, and price. | • Sleepers who like bouncy beds • Hot sleepers • Budget-minded shoppers | • People who need deep cushioning • Sleepers who wake easily when a partner moves |
Airbed Mattresses | The defining trait of airbed mattresses are the air chambers in the core: you can adjust these chambers until the firmness feels just right. Foam or latex layers on the surface add cushioning and contouring for your body. Just be prepared to pay a bit more for these models. | • Sleepers who want to try out different firmness levels • Co-sleepers needing a different firmness on each half of the bed • People with painful pressure points | • Shoppers on a tight budget • Sleepers who want a low maintenance bed, since airbed components may need repair over time |
Why Should You Buy a Mattress in a Box?
Getting a mattress in a box can make buying a new mattress much simpler.
After a mattress is made, it can be compressed, rolled up, sealed in plastic, and placed in a box for easy shipping. After bringing the mattress in a box into your bedroom and removing the packaging, the mattress regains its normal size.
A mattress in a box is best if you prioritize value and convenience (and you want to avoid lugging a bulky mattress into your home). It can also be a great option if you would rather shop online than go to a mattress store.
- Easier to transport: Because it’s compressed, a mattress in a box is much easier to ship. While the box can be heavy, it can comfortably fit through doorways and be carried up staircases to a bedroom without a ton of trouble.
- Less expensive: It’s usually less expensive to buy a mattress in a box than a standard mattress. The wide selection of options online creates competitive pricing, and the lack of installation costs means you save when buying a mattress in a box.
- Convenient shopping: When you shop online for a mattress in a box, you can avoid the inconvenience of going to a mattress store. Buying online puts a huge selection of mattresses at your fingertips and gives you access to tons of product information that can guide your purchase. You’ll have to do a bit more research, but you can shop at your own convenience.
- Sleep trials and free shipping: Boxed beds usually ship for free to your front door. Since you’re not trying them in store, these mattresses typically come with a sleep trial to test out the bed with the option to get a full refund. Not all mattress in a box options come with a trial or free shipping, though, so make sure you always check the shipping and return policies.
What Should You Look for in a Boxed Bed?
I recommend thinking about five key points when you’re choosing a mattress in a box. These include the mattress type and quality, your sleeping position and body weight, your firmness and support needs, off-gassing from the mattress, and the right mattress size for your bedroom.
When thinking about these topics, I’ve found that it can be helpful to jot down a few notes to help you know what to look for when you’re comparing the different mattress options.
Mattress Type and Quality
The materials used in a mattress determine the mattress type. Most mattresses in a box are either all-foam or hybrid options.
In a foam mattress, all of the layers are foam, and it’s normal for multiple types of foams to be used. All-foam beds are generally lighter, cushier, and are more likely to hug your body.
In a hybrid mattress, the core is made with innerspring coils. On top of those coils you’ll find one or more layers of foam, latex, or other materials. Hybrids usually weigh more, they’re easier to move on, and the edges of the bed are much more supportive.
For both foam and hybrid mattresses, look for quality materials and thoughtful design. A well-built mattress will hold up better over time, improving your sleep and allowing you to get more value out of your mattress. At the end of the day, your options are up to your budget, but something I always tell people is to think of a mattress as an investment. You might save money up front by going for a cheaper bed, but they’ll typically wear out a few years sooner than a bed that’s built better.
Sleeping Position and Body Weight
Ever wonder why there are so many mattress options? A big reason is that there’s no one mattress that works for everyone. Everyone has different needs and preferences, and a lot of people aren’t even sure what theirs are. How you sleep and your body weight are two of the biggest factors that affect your mattress needs.
Sleeping on your side presses your shoulders and hips into the bed, so side sleepers usually need something a bit softer, with more contouring or “hug.” Back and stomach sleepers tend to need a firmer mattress to support their lower backs and keep their spines aligned.
If you weigh under 130 pounds, you are less likely to press into the cushioning of a mattress, so you’ll usually need a softer bed to get comfort and pressure relief. If you weigh over 230 pounds, you’ll probably sink deeper into the top layers, making it better to have a firmer mattress with a strong support system.
Firmness and Support
You’ve probably heard of firmness, which is how hard or soft a mattress feels. If you have a strong firmness preference, such as for an extra plush or firm sleep surface, make sure to account for that when shopping.
Support is how well a mattress cushions the body to promote spinal alignment. It’s a combination of cushion from the top layers and pushback from the bed’s core. Proper support can help keep you from waking up sore in the morning. Like with firmness, support needs vary from person to person.
Mattress firmness, contouring, sturdiness, and bounce can all influence support. Your sleep position and body weight can also affect your support needs and where you need the most cushioning.
We use a 10-point system to rate mattresses and give them firmnesses, with 1 being incredibly soft and 10 being close to sleeping on a hard, flat surface. Most beds out there are somewhere in the 4 (medium soft) to 7 (firm) range.
In my experience, a medium (5) or medium firm (6) mattress with moderate contouring works best for most sleepers. A lot of mattress in a box options out there match this description, but there are also plenty of choices if your needs are different.
I’ve put together a quick reference of firmness preferences based on body weight and sleeping position. These are based off of our team’s testing and research, so use these as a starting point to help guide you if you’re not sure what firmness you need:
Weight | Side Sleepers | Back Sleepers | Stomach Sleepers |
---|---|---|---|
Less than 130 lbs. | Soft (3) to Medium (5) | Soft (3) to Medium (5) | Medium Soft (4) to Medium Firm (6) |
130 to 230 lbs. | Medium Soft (4) to Medium (5) | Medium (5) to Firm (7) | Medium (5) to Firm (7) |
More than 230 lbs. | Medium Firm (6) to Firm (7) | Firm (7, 8) to Extra Firm (9) | Firm (7, 8) to Extra Firm (9) |
Off-Gassing
When a mattress comes off the assembly line, its brand new materials can emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that collect in the sealed packaging of a mattress in a box.
Off-gassing of VOCs can cause an odor when your mattress is unboxed, and it tends to be worse with foam mattresses. The smell can be annoying, but it goes away pretty quickly. Make sure your bedroom has good ventilation, open windows and doors if you can, maybe even try a fan to help speed up the process. We find the smell typically disappears within a few days.
Size
After unboxing, a mattress in a box will grow in size, so you need to make sure in advance that you choose a mattress size that works for you, your bed partner if you share a bed, and the space in your bedroom.
If you’re not sure about the right size, measure the space in your bedroom. I’ve found that drawing my bedroom layout on paper helps me see how to strike a balance between open space and space for my mattress and other furniture.
How to Shop for a Mattress in a Box
Since a new bed can be a serious investment, I’ll give you a few more of my pro tips to help you prepare for the process and find the best value when shopping for a mattress in a box.
Do Your Research
Doing your research makes the whole bed-shopping process less stressful. While the number of options can be overwhelming, I recommend trying to narrow down your options as quickly as you can. Focus on your needs and your budget first, and keep notes about brands or models that fit you best. There are lots of beds out there with fun bells and whistles and impressive-sounding features, but before all that, you need to make sure it’ll be comfortable for you.
Taking notes helps you compare the construction, features, shipping policies, and sleep trial for different mattress options. Your research can also help you compare prices and find discounts to get the best deal.
Keep an Eye Out for Sales, Discounts, and Bundles
You can usually find a great deal on a mattress in a box thanks to seasonal sales, promo codes, and product bundles.
Deals are typically best around most major holidays and Black Friday. You can check directly on a mattress company’s website at any time for mattress sales and offers. You may also get a little something extra if you go for a bundle with a mattress, bed frame, pillows, bedding, or other accessories.
Pick Your Delivery and Setup Options
Depending on the company, you may have multiple delivery and setup options. Standard shipping of a mattress in a box to your front door is usually included in the price of the bed, and honestly, I’ve found that this works just fine for most people. Mattresses in a box can be a bit heavy, but they’re not too bad to move with two to three people or a furniture dolly.
If you want or need the added convenience of new mattress setup or removal of an old mattress, you can often pay extra for those services. Full White Glove delivery generally involves a team coming to your home to install your new mattress, dispose of all the packaging, and haul away your old bed.
Use Trials and Warranties to Your Advantage
I always tell people buying a mattress in a box to remember that they are protected by a sleep trial and a warranty.
With most mattress in a box options, a sleep trial lets you return the bed for a full refund if you’re unhappy with it for any reason. The bed doesn’t have to be defective – if you don’t like the way it feels and you’re still in the trial period, you can send it back. I definitely recommend putting a note on your calendar near the end of the sleep trial as a reminder to make your final decision about the mattress. New beds take a little time to break in, so if you can, make sure to try out your new bed for at least a month before returning it so you’re giving the bed a fair try.
Another tip is to read the return policy in advance. This will tell you how long the sleep trial lasts and whether there are any fees for returns.
Over the longer-term, a warranty can protect your purchase. Although it won’t cover normal wear-and-tear, it will cover you if your mattress breaks down prematurely.
How to Unbox a Mattress
You should always follow the unboxing guidelines from the manufacturer, but these are the typical steps in the process:
- Bring the box with the mattress into your bedroom
- Set the box flat on the ground
- Gently remove packing tape and open the box
- Slide the mattress out of the box
- Carefully cut open the plastic packaging, taking care not to puncture the mattress
- Place the mattress in its proper position in your bedroom
- Open a window or turn on a fan to allow for ventilation to reduce off-gassing
- Wait a few hours before sleeping on the mattress
- Remember that it may take a day or two for the mattress to reach its normal size
How We Test: Rigor, Data, and Sleeper Feedback
Our industry-leading product testing team cares deeply about improving your sleep. Having a holistic understanding of a mattress’s role as part of a sleep system is paramount to our testing process. Since a bed’s comfort and feel depend largely on body weight and sleeping position, our testing team represents a wide range of body types, sleep positions, and comfort preferences.In our Seattle-based Test Lab, we use an objective, hands-on process to evaluate mattresses across performance categories. The following are the key guidelines that inform our performance ratings. Our ultimate goal is to ensure you have all the information you need to make the best purchase decision for you.
Construction analysis: We begin testing each mattress by analyzing its design and making note firmness, height, individual layer composition, and sticker price. This allows us to evaluate qualities like support, durability, and value.
Product testing: Firsthand testing is crucial to our evaluation and ratings system. We use a wide range of tools and technology to test mattresses in six performance categories: motion isolation, pressure relief, temperature control, ease of movement, edge support, and odor potential.
Field testing: In addition to lab-based tests, we base our ratings on feedback from field testers who use the mattresses in their own homes. They spend several weeks collecting data — this gives us insights into how the mattress performs night after night for an extended period.
User testing: We curate feedback verified owners have provided in surveys, sleep stories, and product reviews. This helps us evaluate our initial findings and, if needed, tweak our ratings to reflect real-world experiences.
How We Determine Our Overall Scores


To determine a mattress’s overall score, we assign weighted percentages to performance categories based on how important they are to the individual sleep experience. For instance, areas like pressure relief and temperature control tend to matter more to people than something like off-gassing, and because more people sleep on their side and back than on their stomach, we weigh those positions more heavily
Performance Categories
Motion Isolation
This criteria alludes to the amount of motion a mattress absorbs when a sleeper moves on the surface. We use two testers lying side by side to evaluate motion isolation, who each feel for transfer while the other person moves on the mattress.
Temperature Control
To determine how well a mattress regulates temperature, we perform temperature tests and look closely at its materials and construction. Many mattresses are designed with cooling components meant to reduce heat retention.
Pressure Relief
A bed with strong pressure relief excels at preventing pressure from building up in areas like the shoulders and hips. Beds with even contouring and weight distribution are top performers when it comes to pressure relief.
Off-Gassing
A mattress in a box may release unpleasant chemical odors for a short period after you’ve unboxed it. The initial smell may be strong but typically fades within 2 or 3 days.
Ease of Movement
This criteria reflects how easily a sleeper can move across a bed’s surface. Responsive surfaces made of latex typically perform better than foam surfaces, which can inhibit movement.
Edge Support
We perform sit tests along a bed’s perimeter to measure how well the edges push back against weight. Mattresses with strong edge support have minimal sagging when sleepers sit on or lie close to the perimeter.
Dive Deeper – More Mattress Guides
In your research process, you may want to zero in on mattresses that offer standout performance in certain categories. These guides can help you find the top picks that match your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
It usually takes less than 15 minutes to fully unbox a mattress. While the process is quick, I advise against rushing through the steps. Taking your time helps make sure that you get the mattress positioned properly and you don’t cause any accidental damage to your mattress or to other items in your bedroom.
The best way to know whether to trust an online mattress company is to check with reliable sources. A recommendation from a person or site that you know well can be a strong vote of confidence.
You can also check a company’s grade with the Better Business Bureau and look at customer reviews on external sites like Trustpilot and Yelp. While these sites won’t perfectly reflect how trustworthy a company is, they may alert you to potential concerns.
A mattress in a box will usually last between five and nine years, or about as long as a standard mattress bought from a retail showroom. All-foam and hybrid mattresses have an average lifespan of six to seven years, while heavier all-latex mattresses tend to last from seven to nine years.
Foam, hybrid, and all-latex mattresses are available as a mattress in a box. Foam and hybrid beds are the most common and popular choices for mattresses in a box.
A mattress in a box can give off a “foamy” smell when it’s first unpackaged because of the release of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) generated during the manufacturing process. Although it’s common with boxed mattresses, the odor typically fades away within a few hours or days.
Still have questions? Ask our community!
Join our Sleep Care Community — a trusted hub of product specialists, sleep health professionals, and people just like you. Whether you’re searching for the perfect mattress or need expert sleep advice, we’ve got you covered. Get personalized guidance from the experts who know sleep best.