When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Products or services may be offered by an affiliated entity. Learn more.
As someone who makes their living testing mattresses, I fully stand behind the online mattress movement. Shopping for a mattress online is fast, easy, and risk-free. I’ll kick back with my phone or laptop, tap or click a few buttons, and then — in a matter of days — a new mattress shows up at my door.
But I realize that not everyone is so enthusiastic about buying a mattress online. That’s why I created this guide. I combed through data from the 2,000+ mattresses in our database and helped our testing team try out the top 50. Then, we settled on our top 10 picks for best online mattress, with options for all types of sleepers.
Our Top Picks
-
Best Overall – Helix Midnight Luxe
View Details
-
Most Comfortable – WinkBed
View Details
-
Best Value – DreamCloud Classic Hybrid
View Details
-
Best for Side Sleepers – Nolah Evolution 15
View Details
-
Best for Back Pain – Saatva Classic
View Details
-
Best Luxury – Leesa Sapira Hybrid
View Details
-
Best Cooling – Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe
View Details
-
Best Extra Firm – Plank Firm Luxe
View Details
-
Best for Pressure Relief – Bear Elite Hybrid
View Details
-
Best for Heavy Sleepers – Titan Plus
View Details
Swipe for more
Best Overall
Helix Midnight Luxe
9.7 /10
Test Lab Score
27% off sitewide + free bedding bundle with code: SF27
27% off sitewide + free bedding bundle with code: SF27
We landed on the Helix Midnight Luxe as the best online mattress because of its all-around performance, competitive price, and broad appeal. Most sleepers can get support from its hybrid design, and it provides above-average cushioning and back support.




Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,780
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period
100 nights (30-night requirement)
Our Verdict
- Who It’s Best For: Side or back sleepers who weigh less than 230 pounds, as well as couples.
- Feel: Medium firm (6) with a light amount of pushback, while still softly cradling heavier areas like the hips, shoulders, and abdomen.
- What It’s Made Of: Three foam layers make up the comfort system: The first two are memory foam and the third with transitional polyfoam. The base is a tall layer of pocketed coils supported by a layer of dense polyfoam.
- What We Don’t Like: Lacks firmness for some people over 230 pounds.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 5876 validated customer reviews of the Helix Midnight Luxe. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and Support: Many reviewers express that the mattress provides exceptional comfort and support, especially noting its ability to alleviate back, hip, and shoulder pain.
- Sleep Quality Improvement: The mattress is frequently described as transformative for those who previously struggled with sleep disturbances.
- Temperature Regulation: Positive remarks are made about the cooling properties of the mattress. Users find the cooling aspect effective, helping to maintain a comfortable sleeping temperature throughout the night.
- Customer Service: Experiences with customer service are predominantly positive, with buyers appreciating the responsive and helpful nature of the support team. Issues are resolved satisfactorily, contributing to a positive overall customer experience.
- Durability Concerns: A few reviewers express concerns about the mattress showing signs of wear or sagging prematurely. These concerns are not widespread but are significant enough to be noted by potential buyers.
- Mixed Reviews on Firmness: While many find the mattress perfectly balanced, there are mixed reviews regarding its firmness. Some users find it softer than expected given its firmness level. While the ‘medium firm’ rating is appropriate by our measurements, the bed does have a ‘cushy’ foam feel that makes for a fairly soft surface feel.
Full Details
The Helix Midnight is a hybrid mattress with multiple layers of foam and a layer of pocketed coils. Our hands-on tests showed that this design offers excellent pressure relief and support for side sleepers. Our testers also found that this construction balanced bounce, contouring, edge support, and temperature neutrality.
How It Performs
Compared to other models we’ve tested, we give the Helix Midnight a 6 on our 10-point firmness scale — which we call a medium firm feel. This falls in the range most sleepers prefer. Sleepers on our team who weighed up to 230 pounds found the combination of cushioning and support very comfortable.
While many of our testers enjoyed the bed, side sleepers in particular enjoyed the balanced feel. They also found the mattress’ thicker comfort layers were excellent at relieving pressure buildup.
Foam layers can often trap too much heat, but we found that the airflow through the coil core reduced this heat retention and kept testers fairly cool. Hot sleepers who often find memory foam too hot may appreciate the Midnight.
Construction Breakdown
A proprietary Soft Touch Design cover is made from stretchy polyester and designed for enhanced breathability. The comfort layer uses memory foam to conform to a sleeper’s body, which is ideal for relieving pressure points. Our testers found the dense polyfoam transition layer to be very supportive and effective at keeping bodies from sinking in.
The support core is made up of responsive pocketed coils. The pocketed design enables coils to respond individually to your weight, reducing the spread of motion and cradling your body more deeply. Reinforced coils around the perimeter support the edge of the bed to make it easier to use the full mattress surface.
Trial, Shipping, and Warranty
Shipping is free for customers in the contiguous U.S. The Helix Midnight Luxe comes with a 100-night sleep trial and a lifetime limited warranty.
Most Comfortable
WinkBed
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
Get $300 off all mattresses at Winkbeds
Get $300 off all mattresses at Winkbeds
Sleeping on the WinkBed can be a positive step toward a comfortable night’s sleep. With a hybrid design, its materials are intelligently layered to give tailored support to the lumbar spine and the right amount of cushioning to keep the spine aligned.

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,499
Mattress Type
Innerspring
Firmness Options
Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7), Firm (8)
Trial Period
120 nights (30 night requirement)
Our Verdict
- Who It’s Best For:Most sleepers, depending on firmness level.
- Feel: Ranges from medium soft (4) to firm (8) — plush, firm, or somewhere in between. All are sturdy and stable, including around the perimeter.
- What It’s Made Of: Top layers are polyfoam, except WinkBed Plus, which uses natural latex as a comfort layer. The support core is thick metal coils that are individually wrapped.
- What We Don’t Like: Can transfer motion.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 8573 validated customer reviews of the Winkbed. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Pain Relief and Support: A significant number of users report alleviation of back, hip, and shoulder pain, attributing this to the mattress’s supportive design. Individuals with chronic back issues have noted substantial improvements in sleep quality.
- Comfort Across Sleep Positions: Reviewers from various sleep positions—side, back, and stomach—find the mattress comfortable. The availability of different firmness levels allows users to select options that best suit their sleeping style.
- Temperature Regulation: Many customers appreciate the mattress’s ability to stay cool, enhancing overall comfort throughout the night.
- Edge Support: Users frequently mention the robust edge support, which provides a stable and usable sleeping surface across the entire mattress.
- Firmness Options: Customers appreciate the variety of firmness options available, finding the right balance for their personal preferences.
- Durability and Craftsmanship: The mattress is often praised for its high-quality construction and materials, with users expressing confidence in its longevity. The lifetime warranty further reinforces trust in the product’s durability.
- Customer Service and Trial Experience: Customers value the 120-night risk-free trial and responsive customer service, noting that these factors contribute to a positive purchasing experience.
Full Details
Thanks to a foam hybrid design, our test lab found that the WinkBed balances pressure relief and spinal alignment for a highly comfortable sleep surface. The WinkBed is the company’s flagship hybrid mattress and is available in four firmness levels: medium soft (4), medium firm (6), firm (7), and firm (8).
How It Performs
Our testing found the WinkBed comfortable across sleeping positions and weight groups thanks to the different firmness options. On our team, side sleepers and testers weighing under 130 pounds appreciated the deeper contouring and pressure point relief from the softer model.
We found the medium firm option was the most versatile, while the firm option appealed to back and side sleepers in our lab. For sleepers over 230 pounds, we recommend the WinkBed Plus, which is specifically made for people in this weight category.
In addition to being generally supportive, the mattress has strong edge support that stood out compared to other beds we’ve tested. This is largely due to higher-gauge coils positioned around the bed’s perimeter. The ventilation through the pocketed coils also helps the bed stay cool, which our hot sleepers appreciated.
The coils are individually wrapped to stop excessive motion transfer. When combined with the thick foam layers, we found this feature helped absorb motion to prevent disturbances from transferring from one side of the bed to the other when more than one tester shared the surface. Couples seeking more motion isolation may prefer the softest model.
Construction Breakdown
At 13.5 inches tall, the WinkBed has a fairly high profile compared to other beds we’ve tested. This is a result of its substantial foam comfort layers and coil support core.
The mattress features a gel-infused polyfoam Euro-top that we found wicks excess moisture while relieving pressure point discomfort. The Euro-top also contains a polyfoam transitional layer that kept us comfortably situated “on” the mattress, rather than “in” it.
The medium soft model features a second polyfoam layer that evenly distributed the weight of our testers across the surface and enhanced cushioning.
Under the comfort system is a pocketed coil support core, which lifts the midsection and shoulders to maintain healthy spinal alignment. These layers are all encased in a Tencel lyocell material, which is known for its breathability and durability. Our testers, even the sleepers who run hot, felt fairly cool while lying on the surface.
Trial, Shipping, and Warranty
Standard deliveries are free in the contiguous U.S. The mattress qualifies for a 120-night sleep trial, as well as a lifetime warranty.
Best Value
DreamCloud Classic Hybrid
8.5 /10
Test Lab Score
Save up to 60% on mattresses
Save up to 60% on mattresses
The DreamCloud Classic is a quintessential hybrid mattress that nicely showcases the foam-over-coils design. Its carefully constructed layers give you the cushioning and pressure relief of foam along with the bounce and stability of pocketed coils.

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$649
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period
365 nights (30-night requirement)
Our Verdict
- Who It’s Best For: Side and back sleepers between 130 and 230 pounds.
- Feel: Medium firm (6) that blends inviting comfort and dependable spinal support. Soft and smooth cashmere cover.
- What It’s Made Of: One layer of memory foam and two made with resilient polyfoam. Base is a tall set of innerspring coils.
- What We Don’t Like: May be too soft for some stomach sleepers and people over 230 pounds. Some customers report signs of wear and tear after a few years of nightly use.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 8729 validated customer reviews of the DreamCloud Mattress. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and Firmness: Many users describe the mattress as having a medium-firm feel that balances support and plushness, catering to various sleep positions.
- Motion Isolation: Couples appreciate the mattress’s ability to minimize motion transfer, allowing for undisturbed sleep even when sharing the bed with a partner. This quality is essential for those sensitive to movement during sleep.
- Pain Relief: Numerous customers report significant relief from back and joint pain, attributing this to the mattress’s supportive structure and pressure-relieving memory foam layers. This is consistent with expert recommendations for mattresses that promote spinal alignment.
- Temperature Regulation: The mattress’s cooling technology is frequently praised, with users noting a comfortable sleep temperature throughout the night. This feature is particularly beneficial for hot sleepers seeking a cooler sleep environment.
- Edge Support: Users mention strong edge support, providing confidence when sitting or sleeping near the mattress’s perimeter. This feature maximizes the usable sleep surface and enhances overall stability.
- Durability and Quality: Customers commend the high-quality materials and construction, expressing satisfaction with the mattress’s durability and longevity. The lifetime warranty further reinforces confidence in the product’s endurance.
- Customer Service and Trial Period: The 365-night trial period and responsive customer service are highlighted as significant advantages, providing peace of mind and flexibility during the purchasing process.
Full Details
The DreamCloud Classic Hybrid’s design features pressure-relieving memory foam and pocketed coils that promote healthy spinal alignment. During testing, we found this design to be very comfortable for most side sleepers, providing a plush feel without excessive sinkage and heat retention.
How It Performs
Side sleepers on our team, as well as those with sensitive pressure points, benefited the most from the DreamCloud Classic Hybrid’s balanced contouring and support. We found the plush surface cushioned our shoulders and hips, while the coils kept our lower backs supported.
Thanks to the individually wrapped coils, we think couples will appreciate the mattress’ ability to limit motion transfer. We noticed that the foam layers also absorbed a good amount of noise, so we didn’t hear each other’s movements when sharing the bed.
We also recommend this mattress for people who enjoy foam surfaces but also tend to overheat on them. The foam comfort layer has a nice plush feel, but the coil support core circulates more air than an all-foam construction.
Construction Breakdown
The DreamCloud Classic Hybrid is encased in a stretch-blend cover that our testers found breathable and soft to the touch. A top layer of memory foam gives the surface a plush, pillowy feel.
A polyfoam transition layer offers a deeper, pressure-relieving contour. It also prevents your body from sinking too deeply into the bed and provides a buffer between you and the support core.
Individually wrapped pocketed coils make up the support core. These coils move independently, so any weight applied to one coil does not affect those surrounding it. The coils provide targeted support to the heavier areas of your body, and the coils allow air to circulate throughout the mattress for enhanced cooling. A high-density polyfoam base completes the design.
Trial, Shipping, and Warranty
DreamCloud ships free to the contiguous U.S. Mattress purchases are backed by a 365-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty.
Best for Side Sleepers
Nolah Evolution 15
9.2 /10
Test Lab Score
30% off + 2 free pillows
30% off + 2 free pillows
When lying on your side, it’s easy for your spine to get drawn out of alignment, which is why a mattress like the Nolah Evolution is so popular with side sleepers. It distributes your body’s weight to relieve pressure on the hips and shoulders, promoting a sleep posture that reduces the risk of aches and pains in the morning.

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,624
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night requirement), $99 return pickup fee
Our Verdict
- Who It’s Best For: Side sleepers between 130 and 230 pounds (luxury firm model). Side sleepers over 230 pounds (firm). Side sleepers under 130 pounds (medium).
- Feel: Supportive comfort. While firmness depends on the model, all versions cushion pressure points while preserving a sleep surface that’s free of excess sinkage.
- What It’s Made Of: Four different foams make up the upper part. The lower section is heavy-duty pocketed coils that are reinforced in select areas.
- What We Don’t Like: Return fee of $99. You may need a new fitted sheet with deeper pockets.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 897 validated customer reviews of the Nolah Evolution 15. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Motion Isolation: Couples note the excellent motion isolation, which minimizes disruptions from partner movements during the night.
- Edge Support: The edge support of the mattress is frequently highlighted, with many finding it adequate for sitting or sleeping near the edge without feeling like they will roll off.
- Softness: Many reviewers discuss the softness of the mattress. Some find it too soft, causing discomfort, especially for heavier individuals, while others appreciate the plushness.
- Pressure Relief and Support: Reviewers frequently highlight relief from back and shoulder pain, attributing this to the supportive foam layers and zoned coil system.
- Heat Retention: A few reviewers note that the mattress retains heat, making it uncomfortable for some, particularly in warmer climates or for those who sleep hot.
- Durability and Quality: Users often comment on the high quality and durability of the mattress, noting that it maintains its shape and comfort over time.
Full Details
The Nolah Evolution 15 is a high-profile foam hybrid with three firmness levels: medium (5), medium firm (6), and firm (8). Based on our battery of performance tests, we found that each model’s zoned coils help create a surface that’s easy to move across, while the foam layers absorb movement transfer.
How It Performs
Each firmness level caters to different sleep needs. Among all our testers, side sleepers up to 230 pounds and back sleepers under 130 pounds enjoyed the deeper contouring from the medium feel. Our testers found the medium firm model’s balanced feel made it the most versatile.
This model was best suited for side sleepers over 230 pounds, back sleepers weighing up to 230 pounds, and stomach sleepers between 130 and 230 pounds. Back sleepers who weighed at least 130 pounds and stomach sleepers over 230 pounds appreciated the firmest option’s even surface.
The Evolution’s performance varied across our testing criteria depending on the firmness chosen. Couples who value motion isolation may opt for the medium feel, whereas those who prioritize sex may appreciate the firmer models.
During testing, the medium firm and firm options also earned higher marks in edge support and temperature regulation. Testers with persistent pressure points found more relief from the softest model.
Construction Breakdown
A quilted cover made from proprietary ArcticTex fiber encases the mattress, which is meant to keep the surface cool to the touch. During testing, we found the Euro-top quilted with polyfoam had a nice plush feel that closely contours to the body to relieve pressure.
A polyfoam comfort layer infused with graphite is designed to reduce heat buildup, and we found this layer helped evenly distribute weight across the mattress surface to promote spinal alignment.
The polyfoam transitional layer adds cushioning between the comfort system and the coils. This layer also prevented our testers from sinking too deeply into the mattress. Zoned pocketed coils make up the support core, and they offer ample pushback to the hips and shoulders to avoid uncomfortable sagging. Extra coils along the perimeter reinforced the edges noticeably.
Trial, Shipping, and Warranty
Nolah ships free to the contiguous U.S. Orders come with a 120-night sleep trial and a 30-night break-in period. If you keep the mattress, it’s covered by a lifetime warranty against structural defects.
Best for Back Pain
Saatva Classic
9.4 /10
Test Lab Score
Save up to $600
Save up to $600
The Saatva Classic is carefully constructed with high-quality materials, and you can pick from three firmness levels to maximize your satisfaction. Its thoughtful construction combines multiple supportive elements. It also comes with free White Glove delivery, an uncommon perk for online mattresses.



Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,795
Mattress Type
Innerspring
Firmness Options
Soft (3), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period
365 Nights ($99 Return Fee)
Our Verdict
- Who It’s Best For: Side and back sleepers less than 230 pounds (luxury firm option). Most other sleepers (plush soft and firm models)
- Feel: Depends on firmness levels. All models have gentle cushioning, notable edge support, and above-average temperature regulation.
- What It’s Made Of: Responsive polyfoam with memory foam on top, and microcoils rest on a tall set of innerspring coils.
- What We Don’t Like: Return fee of $99. May be some motion transfer, especially on firmer models.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 3308 validated customer reviews of the Saatva Classic. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Delivery Service: Positive feedback on the delivery process is common, with customers highlighting the professionalism and efficiency of the delivery teams. The white glove delivery service, including old mattress removal, is frequently praised.
- Comfort and Firmness: Customers appreciate the customizable firmness options, with Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm levels catering to diverse preferences.
- Durability: Long-term users report that the mattress maintains its comfort and support over the years, indicating good durability and quality construction.
- Material Quality: Customers appreciate the safe and high-quality materials used in the mattress, such as the absence of harmful chemicals and the use of organic cotton.
- Temperature Regulation: Some reviewers specifically mention sleeping cooler on the Saatva Classic, highlighting its temperature regulation features that contribute to a more comfortable sleep.
- Adjustability and Customization: The ability to customize the mattress for personal needs, like the split king option with different firmness levels, is a significant plus for many customers.
Full Details
The Saatva Mattress features a luxury hybrid design that combines multiple layers of foam with a dual-coil innerspring system to give the mattress support, bounce, and breathability. Our testers recommend this mattress to shoppers who are willing to spend more on a mattress made with high quality materials.
How It Performs
The Saatva is available in soft (3), medium firm (6), and firm (8), and it comes in 11.5-inch and 14.5-inch versions. With so many options available, most testers on our team found a combination that suited them.
The soft version appealed to testers under 130 pounds, while the medium firm option worked well for testers between 130 and 230 pounds. Testers over 230 pounds preferred the extra support of the firm version.
The foam comfort layers in all three firmness options greatly relieved pressure, and airflow from the coil support core regulated body temperature. The medium firm and firm options ranked exceptionally well for edge support and sex, so we believe couples can confidently use the full area of the bed without slipping off.
Construction Breakdown
A Euro-top cushions the surface of the mattress. This layer consists of an organic cotton cover and a layer of polyfoam. Underneath is a thin layer of memory foam to provide extra support and cushioning near the hips.
The comfort system also includes a layer of pocketed coils. We found that these coils contoured to our bodies and enhanced airflow, while the pocketed design reduced the spread of motion between coils.
The support base consists of durable Bonnell coils made from recycled steel. A foam encasement wraps around the perimeter of the mattress to prevent sagging. Our testers were able to use the full mattress surface thanks to the strong edge support.
Trial, Shipping, and Warranty
Saatva offers free White Glove delivery, a lifetime warranty, and a 365-night sleep trial.
Best Luxury
Leesa Sapira Hybrid
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
30% off select mattresses + free sleep bundle
30% off select mattresses + free sleep bundle
The Leesa Sapira Hybrid is made using high-quality foams that isolate motion well across its surface, limiting the disturbances resulting from each sleeper’s movements. It also has good edge support, which means even the edges of the mattress are sturdy and usable.

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,599
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period
100 nights (30 night requirement)
Our Verdict
- Who It’s Best For: Side sleepers and back and stomach sleepers under 230 pounds.
- Feel: Medium firm (6) with cushioning around common problem areas like the shoulders, hips, and lower back. Soft enough to be comfortable but firm enough to stop you from sinking too deeply.
- What It’s Made Of: Memory foam and polyfoam in the top four layers, followed by thick pocketed coils, which rest on a vibration-absorbing layer of dense polyfoam.
- What We Don’t Like: On the expensive side. Can feel too plush for back and stomach sleepers over 230 pounds.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 2257 validated customer reviews of the Leesa Sapira Hybrid. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and Support: Many reviewers mention the mattress’s blend of comfort and support, often highlighting its suitability for side and back sleepers, and its ability to alleviate or prevent pain (back, hip, or shoulder).
- Temperature Regulation: Customers note the breathable construction helps regulate temperature, ensuring a cooler sleep experience.
- Durability and Longevity: Positive comments on how the mattress maintains its shape and comfort over several years without sagging or indentations.
- Motion Isolation: The mattress performs well in minimizing motion transfer, making it an excellent choice for couples.
- Odor and Off-gassing: Some mention initial off-gassing smells upon unpacking, but most report that the odor dissipates quickly.
- Edge Support: Good reviews on the edge support of the mattress, which is important for those who sit on the edge of the bed or sleep near the edge.
- Value for Money: Many users feel that the mattress provides good value for the price, especially given its comfort and durability features.
Full Details
The Leesa Sapira Hybrid is a thoughtfully constructed bed with multiple foam layers that provide cushioning, along with a coil system that delivers ample support. This balanced feel catered to many of our testers across primary sleeping positions and body types.
How It Performs
The multiple foam layers provided excellent pressure relief for our side and back sleepers who experience sharp pressure points in the shoulders, hips, and spine.
Meanwhile, the polyfoam transitional layer and coil system offered enough support to keep our lower backs from sinking. The mattress is a good match if you weigh up to 230 pounds, but those who exceed this weight range may sink more deeply into the bed and not receive adequate support.
The Sapira Hybrid is somewhat bouncy due to the responsive transitional layer and coil system, and this makes the mattress conducive to sex. Steady airflow through the coils also kept the bed at a comfortable temperature throughout testing. Our heat guns detected minimal heat buildup on the surface.
Construction Breakdown
The Sapira Hybrid has a polyester-blend cover and begins with a layer of memory foam, which contours closely to the body. Beneath is a polyfoam transitional layer that conforms more deeply, allowing the surface to cradle sharp pressure points.
The support core consists of pocketed coils with a reinforced perimeter. The coils give the bed stability and moderate bounce. A layer of high-density base foam completes the hybrid design.
Trial, Shipping, and Warranty
Shipping to all 50 states is free. There’s a 100-night sleep trial with a 30-night break-in period. The Sapira Hybrid also comes with a lifetime warranty.
Best Cooling
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe
9.2 /10
Test Lab Score
Save 30% sitewide with code: MEMORIAL30
Save 30% sitewide with code: MEMORIAL30
With the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe, you can put the days of waking up in a sweat behind you. A combination of materials that dissipate heat and a breathable mattress cover enable this hybrid to cushion your pressure points without sleeping hot.


Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,586
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night requirement)
Our Verdict
- Who It’s Best For: Most sleepers, depending on firmness level, as well as hot sleepers.
- Feel: Soft (4), medium firm (6), or firm (7) options. All have an even, sturdy feel with a cool surface and solid edge support.
- What It’s Made Of: Comfort system with quilted fabric and foam on top of a tall base of pocketed coils.
- What We Don’t Like: Light smell for a short period after unboxing. Return fee of $99.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 3474 validated customer reviews of the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Height and Thickness: Many reviewers mention the mattress being taller or thicker than anticipated, requiring adjustments like new bed sheets.
- Comfort and Support: Consistent mentions of the mattress providing good support and comfort, suitable for various sleeping positions and body types.
- Cooling Features: A significant number of people appreciate the cooling aspect of the mattress, which is particularly beneficial for hot sleepers.
- Firmness Levels: Some reviewers note discrepancies in the expected versus actual firmness levels, with some finding the mattresses softer than anticipated.
- Edge Support: Mixed reviews on edge support, with some finding it adequate and others noting it could be improved. We found it to be relatively average for a hybrid
- Material Quality: Reviews often mention the high quality of materials, though some note issues with sheets slipping off due to the sleekness of the mattress cover.
- Smell and Off-Gassing: Some mention a noticeable smell upon unpacking that dissipates over time.
Full Details
Brooklyn Bedding’s Aurora Luxe comes in three firmness levels — medium soft (4), medium firm (6), and firm (7) — that cater to a wide variety of sleepers. The mattress balances pressure-relieving contouring with responsiveness, with cooling features that help maintain temperature neutrality.
How It Performs
Our testing found the Aurora Luxe suited different sleepers depending on the firmness level you choose. The softest model’s adaptive cushioning performed best among side and back sleepers under 130 pounds.
Side sleepers between 130 and 230 pounds, as well as back and stomach sleepers under 130 pounds enjoyed the medium firm model’s balanced feel.
Back and stomach sleepers who weigh at least 130 pounds enjoyed the firmest model’s even sleep surface and support. If you need deep cushioning, the optional “Cloud” pillow-top is an extra foam layer you can add to the comfort system for a fee.
We recommend the Aurora Luxe for couples who value motion isolation and responsiveness for sex. Those who prioritize the former may opt for the softer model, which absorbs slightly more motion.
Couples seeking a more responsive feel may enjoy the firmest option. All models performed well in our temperature neutrality tests thanks to the use of phase change material and a breathable coil support core.
Construction Breakdown
The three firmness levels differ slightly in their composition, but they all have a top layer made from proprietary CopperFlex foam that adapts to the body to relieve pressure while offering slight bounce.
The foam is infused with copper gel and phase change material intended to enhance cooling. This is followed by a layer of polyfoam with a firmer feel to prevent excessive sinkage, though exact firmness varies depending on the model.
The medium soft and medium firm options feature a gel-infused memory foam transitional layer that adds cushioning between the comfort system and the coil support core. The firmer option uses a VariFlex foam layer that gives the bed firmer support.
Pocketed coils make up the support core. This layer has a zoned configuration with thinner coils that cradle the shoulders and legs, and thicker coils to support the midsection and reinforce the edges. A GlacioTex cooling cover encases the mattress.
Trial, Shipping, and Warranty
Brooklyn Bedding ships free to the contiguous U.S. It offers a 120-night sleep trial with 30-night break-in period, after which you can return. The Aurora Luxe is backed by a lifetime warranty, covering structural defects.
Best Extra Firm
Plank Firm Luxe
7.8 /10
Test Lab Score
Save 30% sitewide with code: MEMORIAL30
Save 30% sitewide with code: MEMORIAL30
The Plank Firm Luxe is our pick in this category because it lets you choose between a firm or extra firm sleep surface. Thanks to its reversible design, you’re not locked into one firmness level and can pick the side that best supports your spinal alignment.


Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,149
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Firm (7), Extra Firm (9)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night requirement)
Our Verdict
- Who It’s Best For: Back and stomach sleepers.
- Feel: One side is firm (7), the other is extra firm (9). Both are firmer than most online mattresses offer substantial pushback.
- What It’s Made Of: Support core is a 6-inch layer of coils. The firm side has a thick layer of quilting and two layers of polyfoam. The extra-firm side has only a thin layer of fabric and a dense slab of polyfoam.
- What We Don’t Like: May be too firm. Return fee of $99 return.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 1748 validated customer reviews of the Plank Firm Luxe. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and firmness: Many reviewers discuss the comfort level of the mattress, often highlighting its firm feel. While all of those bought the mattress for its firmness, a few people still found the bed too firm.
- Cooling features: Several reviewers mention the cooling features of the mattress, specifically the Glaciotex Cooling Cover, which is appreciated for providing a cooler sleep experience.
- Pain relief: A recurring theme is the relief from back and joint pain, with many users noting improvements in their sleep quality and reduction in pain. Many users report improved spinal alignment, especially those who prefer firmer mattresses.
- Dual firmness options: The mattress’s ability to be flipped for different firmness levels (firm and extra firm) is frequently mentioned and appreciated by those who have different firmness preferences.
- Edge support: A lot of reviewers mention the strong edge support of the Plank Firm Luxe.
- Off-gassing: A few reviewers note the presence of off-gassing when the mattress is new, but it typically dissipates after a few days.
- Customer service: Experiences with customer service are generally positive, with reviewers appreciating the responsive and helpful support team. The 120-night trial period and responsive customer service are frequently noted as key advantages.
Full Details
The Plank Firm Luxe is an excellent choice for sleepers who prefer a particularly firm bed. The mattress features a flippable design, each side with a distinct feel.
Our test team gives one side a firm (7) rating and the other side an extra firm (9) rating, but we found both sides provide great support to keep the spine aligned and avoid back pain.
How It Performs
The Plank Firm Luxe performed best among the back and side sleepers on our team, especially those weighing over 230 pounds.
Thanks to the pocketed coil support core, couples should find the mattress has the bounce many prefer for sex. Sleep partners may also appreciate the mattress’ sturdy perimeter, as we found the strong perimeter allowed us to lie closer to the edge.
Hot sleepers may want to opt for the cooling panel for exceptional temperature regulation, but the hot sleepers on our team reported that the standard cover on its own retains very little heat.
Construction Breakdown
The standard cover is made from a breathable cotton-microfiber blend, and you can choose to add a sewn-in cooling panel made with phase change material for an additional fee. This material is designed to absorb and dissipate excess body heat. The quilted cover’s thickness varies depending on the side of the mattress, measuring 1.5 inches on the firm side and .75 inches on the extra firm side.
Both sides feature a 2-inch comfort layer of high-density polyfoam and 6 inches of pocketed coils. Our test team found this design excelled at evenly distributing weight and offering targeted support.
The firm side adds an extra layer of TitanFlex foam to the comfort system to gently cradle the body. Pocketed coils make up the shared support core for stability.
Trial, Shipping, and Warranty
Brooklyn Bedding ships free to the contiguous U.S. Plank Luxe Hybrid purchases are backed by a 120-night trial and a lifetime warranty.
Best for Pressure Relief
Bear Elite Hybrid
8.5 /10
Test Lab Score
35% off + free pillows with code: SF35
35% off + free pillows with code: SF35
If you have sharp pressure points that make it hard to get settled into bed, it’s time to consider the Bear Elite Hybrid. Its interior materials cushion high-impact areas like the joints, and the Celliant fabric in the cover is engineered specifically to contribute to muscle recovery and a cooler night’s sleep.

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,499
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night break-in period)
Our Verdict
- Who It’s Best For: Most sleepers, depending on firmness level. Those who prioritize pressure relief and a cool and inviting sleep surface.
- Feel: Medium (5), medium firm (6), or firm (8). All provide a sense of cushioning comfort.
- What It’s Made Of: Copper-infused memory foam and a zoned polyfoam. Innerspring coils and high-density polyfoam serve as the mattress base. The cover is Celliant fabric.
- What We Don’t Like: A light but noticeable smell for up to a few days after you set it up. You may need a new fitted sheet with deep pockets.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 3703 validated customer reviews of the Bear Elite Hybrid. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and Support: Many reviewers highlight the mattress’s balance of comfort and support, often mentioning relief from back pain and improved sleep quality.
- Firmness Options: Customers appreciate the various firmness options, with some opting for firmer versions after experiencing discomfort with medium firmness.
- Temperature Regulation: Several reviews note the mattress’s ability to stay cool, which enhances sleep quality, especially in hot weather.
- Size and Upgrade Options: Customers are pleased with the availability of different sizes and the option to upgrade, which provides flexibility for different needs and preferences.
- Quality of Additional Products: Positive remarks on the quality of accompanying products like pillows and sheets, which are often included as free additions.
- Motion Isolation: Many reviewers highlight the mattress’s excellent motion isolation, making it ideal for shared sleeping arrangements.
Full Details
All three versions of the Bear Elite Hybrid excelled during our temperature control tests. The mattress’ cooling Celliant-blend cover, gel-infused comfort layer, and coil system all play a role in maintaining a comfortable temperature throughout the night.
How It Performs
Our tests show the Elite Hybrid’s performance varies by firmness. Side and back sleepers on our team weighing less than 130 pounds received adequate cushioning and contouring from the medium (5) model, which is the softest design.
Testers who prefer slightly more support and gentler conforming preferred the medium firm (6) feel. This model is the most balanced of the three and earned favorable ratings from most of our side and back sleepers across all weight groups.
If you need extra reinforcement, we recommend the firm (8) model. Our testers over 230 pounds felt most comfortable on this mattress.
Thick foam layers help ensure good motion isolation for couples, while the reinforced perimeter allows you and your partner to use the entire surface for sleep or sex. If you share the bed with a partner, you should notice fewer sleep disturbances while having a comfortable surface to move across.
Construction Breakdown
The Elite Hybrid’s comfort system consists of gel-infused memory foam over transitional polyfoam. The latter layer features five firmness zones with denser foam pushing back against the torso and hips, resulting in enhanced support for the entire body without excessive stiffness beneath the head and legs.
The support core contains pocketed coils and high-density base foam. Thicker coils line the perimeter to stabilize the edges and prevent sinkage when you get in and out of bed. A cover woven with cooling Celliant fibers encases the mattress. Measuring 14 inches thick, the Elite Hybrid is considered a high-profile model and may require deep-pocket sheets.
Trial, Shipping, and Warranty
Shipping is free within the contiguous U.S., and all orders include two pillows at no cost. Bear offers a 120-night sleep trial. Those who choose to keep the mattress receive a lifetime warranty covering structural and material defects, and they can purchase an additional plan that protects against stains and other types of physical damage for up to 10 years.
Best for Heavy Sleepers
Titan Plus
8.0 /10
Test Lab Score
Save 30% sitewide with code: MEMORIAL30
Save 30% sitewide with code: MEMORIAL30
The Titan Plus Mattress puts the needs of heavier sleepers front and center. Its reinforced hybrid design and firm feel give it the sturdiness and support required by sleepers over 230 pounds.


Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,049
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Firm (8)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night requirement)
Our Verdict
- Who It’s Best For: Sleepers over 230 pounds.
- Feel: Firm (8) with minimal cushioning and considerable bounce. Stable across the surface, including around the edges.
- What It’s Made Of: A layer of resilient polyfoam quilted into the cover. Below that, another layer of bouncy foam. The support core features an 8-inch layer of firm, durable coils. You can add a cooling cover.
- What We Don’t Like: Can transfer motion. Cushioning for pressure points is limited, especially for people under 230 pounds.
Scoring Breakdown
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 2753 validated customer reviews of the Titan Plus. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Firmness Level: The Titan Plus is exceptionally firm – some users appreciate this quality, others say the mattress doesn’t provide enough cushioning.
- Supportive for Plus Size: The mattress was originally designed for plus-size people, and many users who fall into this category enjoy the extra reinforcement and pushback.
- Edge Support Issues: Users are generally satisfied with the mattress’s edge support, with most saying they can sit or sleep along the perimeter without feeling like they’re going to roll out of bed.
- Motion Transfer: Some owners who sleep with a partner report strong motion transfer and, in some case, sleep disruptions resulting from movement.
- Odor: Users say the foam layers emit off-gassing smell for the first 24 to 48 hours, but little to no odor after that.
- Positive Customer Service Experiences: Many highlight Brooklyn Bedding’s convenient, mattress-in-a-box delivery system and hassle-free trial period.
Full Details
The Titan Plus is one of today’s leading mattress designed for people over 230 pounds. A firm (8) feel, dense foam comfort layers, and robust support coils ensure excellent support and minimal sinkage for sleepers in this weight range — even those who have struggled with other foam hybrids in the past.
How It Performs
Since the Titan Plus is intended to accommodate a niche group of sleeper types, our testing team was mixed in their reviews of the mattress.
Testers in the target weight demographic were very pleased with the ultra-supportive design, with some remarking that the Plus met their needs in a way other foam hybrids we’ve evaluated have fallen short. Those who weigh 230 pounds or less were not as enthusiastic.
Most agreed the mattress felt too firm for their bodies, and anticipated pain and pressure buildup on their sensitive areas with long-term use.
In terms of performance, the Titan Plus excelled in areas such as edge support and ease of movement. Both of these strengths can be attributed to the strong coil system.
We also found the mattress slept fairly cool despite some light heat retention in the foam layers. For other testing categories such as motion isolation and pressure relief, the mattress did not perform as well as most of its softer hybrid counterparts.
Construction Breakdown
The Titan Plus’ comfort system contains a top layer of gel-infused memory foam, followed by latex-like TitanFlex polyfoam in the transitional layer. These materials are somewhat adaptive, but don’t expect much contouring. Most of our testers noted little to no sinkage when lying on the mattress.
Pocketed coils and high-density base foam make up the support core. These components stabilize the mattress and give the surface plenty of bounce. A cotton-blend cover encases the Titan Plus.
For an extra charge, you can upgrade your mattress to include a third foam layer covered in heat-dissipating GlacioTex material — this add-on may be necessary if you’re a hot sleeper, or if you want a bit of extra padding.
Trial, Shipping, and Warranty
Standard shipping is free in the contiguous U.S. The sleep trial runs for 120 nights, and those who choose to keep their mattress receive a lifetime warranty against structural and material defects.
- Convenient Shipping and Setup: A good online mattress should have hassle-free delivery, typically arriving compressed and rolled into a box. It should expand quickly and reach full firmness within 24 to 72 hours.
- Generous Sleep Trial and Warranty: A lengthy sleep trial (usually 100 nights or more) and a solid warranty provide peace of mind and risk-free testing.
- Transparent Customer Reviews and Ratings: Reputable online mattress brands feature verified customer reviews and ratings to help shoppers make informed decisions.
How We Evaluated & Reviewed
Meta Analysis: Virtually all of the 2,000+ mattresses in our product database are available for online purchase. We narrowed these down to our top 50 models based on previous testing data, construction analyses, and sleeper reports.
Hands-On Testing: In our Seattle Test Lab, our team thoroughly evaluated each of the top 50 best online mattresses. Using a wide range of tools and technologies, we tested the mattresses for performance metrics such as pressure relief, motion isolation, temperature control, and edge support.
Field Testing: Next, we sent each of the 25 top performers home with a member of our testing team to sleep on for up to two weeks to see how a mattress performs in real-world environment.
User Reviews: Our team collected data from about 39,500 reviews from verified owners of mattresses they purchased online to determine whether our team’s findings match customers’ experiences.
The Best Deals of the Week
-
Save $665
—
Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Memory Foam
$0 (List Price $665) -
Save $474
—
Helix Midnight Luxe
$1,899 (List Price $2,373) -
Save $2,452
—
Nectar Adjustable Bundle
$1,398 (List Price $3,850) -
Save $300
—
WinkBed
$1,499 (List Price $1,799) -
Save $882
—
DreamCloud Classic Hybrid
$649 (List Price $1,531)
Best Overall
Helix Midnight Luxe
9.7 /10
Test Lab Score
27% off sitewide + free bedding bundle with code: SF27
Shop at HelixI recommend this luxurious memory foam hybrid to all my friends and family shopping for a mattress, particularly those who are side and back sleepers.
See More Details
Most Comfortable
WinkBed
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
Get $300 off all mattresses at Winkbeds
Shop at WinkBedsSeveral members of our testing team love this high-end hybrid so much they bought one of their own to sleep on at home.
See More Details
Best Value
DreamCloud Classic Hybrid
8.5 /10
Test Lab Score
Save up to 60% on mattresses
Shop at DreamCloudIn our opinion, you can’t go wrong with this all-around great hybrid mattress at an affordable price point.
See More Details

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Best for Side Sleepers
Nolah Evolution 15
9.2 /10
Test Lab Score
30% off + 2 free pillows
Shop at NolahTo me, lying down on this mattress felt like lounging on a cloud, thanks to its plush Euro-top and ample cushioning.
See More Details
Best for Back Pain
Saatva Classic
9.4 /10
Test Lab Score
Save up to $600
Shop at SaatvaIf you’re looking for a more traditional innerspring mattress with a plush Euro-top and excellent breathability, I recommend this bed.
See More Details
Best Luxury
Leesa Sapira Hybrid
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
30% off select mattresses + free sleep bundle
Shop at LeesaDuring our testing, this memory foam hybrid limited disturbances from across the bed and prevented sinkage on the edges.
See More Details
Best Cooling
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe
9.2 /10
Test Lab Score
Save 30% sitewide with code: MEMORIAL30
Shop at Brooklyn BeddingAs someone who occasionally sleeps hot, I found this luxury, pressure-relieving mattress limited body heat retention for a cool night’s sleep.
See More Details
Best Extra Firm
Plank Firm Luxe
7.8 /10
Test Lab Score
Save 30% sitewide with code: MEMORIAL30
Shop at PlankLooking for versatility? I love that this high-quality flippable mattress is firm on one side and even firmer on the other.
See More Details

Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Best for Pressure Relief
Bear Elite Hybrid
8.5 /10
Test Lab Score
35% off + 2 free pillows. Use code: SF35
Shop at BearOur testers with pain issues agree: This mattress is one of the absolute best for supporting body alignment with balanced pressure relief and targeted support.
See More Details
Best for Heavy Sleepers
Titan Plus
8.0 /10
Test Lab Score
Save 30% sitewide with code: MEMORIAL30
Shop at TitanFew mattresses we’ve tested have been specifically designed with heavier people in mind. But this one was, and as a result, it’s extremely supportive.
See More Details
Video: We Tested the Best Online Mattresses of 2025 – Here Are Our Favorites
Watch our video below to learn more about our lab’s top picks for best online mattress.
Should You Buy a Mattress Online?
If discounts, convenience, and a wide range of mattress options matter to you, buying a mattress online is likely your best choice. But, you want to do your research upfront to ensure you choose the right mattress for you and avoid hidden costs.
Personally, I prefer looking online for mattresses, because shopping from my home feels comfortable, and high-pressure salespeople stress me out. To help you decide for yourself, I’ve put together a list of the pros and cons of online mattress shopping.
Pros | Cons |
---|---|
Convenience: Comparison shopping that would take multiple in-person visits can be done in minutes online. Lower prices: When a manufacturer spends less money on brick-and-mortar stores and salespeople, they pass the savings on to you. Wider selection: Online shopping allows you to browse dozens of sites with a few clicks instead of being limited to options sold by a few retailers. | Can’t try before you buy: The only way to see and feel an online mattress IRL is by buying it. Analysis paralysis: While many people like having a lot of mattress options, the breadth of choices can cause overwhelm and uncertainty. No face-to-face interaction: Some people prefer talking to a salesperson over getting info from product descriptions, online reviews, and FAQs. |
What to Consider When Buying a Mattress Online

If you’re ready to buy a mattress online, there are a few things to keep in mind while shopping. Consider these before clicking “add to cart” to increase the chance that you’ll be happy with the bed you buy.
Mattress Type
When mattress companies first started selling mattresses online, all-foam models were basically the only designs available. That’s because foam was the easiest to compress and roll for the “mattress in a box” shipping method. But, with time, companies have found ways to affordably ship or deliver most mattress types.
I’ve been a fan of hybrid beds for a while, but there’s no single best mattress type that suits everyone. My favorite may not be your favorite. The best mattress type for you depends on how you want your bed to feel when you lie on it.
- Foam mattresses are highly contouring, and the ultra-plush ones feel like they’re hugging you. Because of this, though, they tend to trap body heat.
- Latex models are made with either Dunlop or Talalay latex and are more responsive than foam options.
- Innersprings are made with that classic coil construction you likely slept on as a kid, and they offer a signature bounce.
- Hybrid mattresses contain a mix of coils with foam or latex comfort layers and tend to please a variety of sleepers.
- Airbeds are a high-tech option, and you can adjust their firmness levels using an app or remote control.
Firmness Level
A mattress with the right firmness for you won’t feel too soft or sag. It also won’t be so firm that you feel like you’re sleeping on a wooden board. When your mattress firmness level is dialed in, it’ll feel comfortable and keep your spine aligned throughout the night.
Sometimes people say they prefer a soft or firm mattress, they’re actually referring to the amount of contouring or how responsive they want their bed to feel. Don’t make this mistake! While firmness does affect feel, the ideal firmness for you relates to objective measures, not just personal preference.
In general, the best mattress firmness range for you is fairly predictable, based on your body weight and the sleeping position you find yourself in the most often. While personal preference is subjective, I’ve found these guidelines to be a good starting point for most people. (Note: We measure mattress firmness on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being the softest and 10 being the firmest.)
Weight | Side Sleepers | Back Sleepers | Stomach Sleepers |
---|---|---|---|
Less than 130 lbs. | Soft (3) to Medium (5) | Soft (3) to Medium (5) | Medium Soft (4) to Medium Firm (6) |
130 to 230 lbs. | Medium Soft (4) to Medium (5) | Medium (5) to Firm (7) | Medium (5) to Firm (7) |
More than 230 lbs. | Medium Firm (6) to Firm (7) | Firm (7 or 8) to Extra Firm (9) | Firm (7 or 8) to Extra Firm (9) |
Contouring and Pressure Relief
When I’m looking for a mattress that keeps me comfortable through the night, the balance of contouring and support is at the top of my list.
As a side sleeper, a good mattress should cushion pressure points like my bottom shoulder and hip, while still supporting my spine in a healthy, aligned position. Back sleepers will want more support for their lower back, while stomach sleepers typically need more midsection support.
I’ve learned that the comfort layers — the ones closest to my body — make the biggest difference in how well a mattress molds to my shape and relieves pressure. But the support core underneath matters, too. When all the layers work together, I wake up feeling rested instead of stiff or sore.
Quality and Durability
In my experience, high-quality mattress materials usually result in better sleep. They also tend to be more durable, which means they help the mattress last longer. And yes, high-quality mattresses tend to cost more, but that doesn’t mean that all pricey mattresses are high-quality. (I’ve learned that the hard way.)
There are a couple ways to assess mattress quality and durability when shopping online. Carefully read through how a manufacturer sources materials and creates their mattresses, then compare these descriptions to what their competitors are saying. Also, scan or search online reviews for past customers mentioning how long a specific mattress lasted for them.
Budget and Mattress Size
There are mattresses sold online at nearly every imaginable price point. Knowing your budget in advance can save you time by keeping you from going down a rabbit hole of researching mattresses outside of your ideal price range.
Mattress materials play a big role in a mattress’ price. As I said earlier, high-quality materials add to a higher price tag. Similarly, larger sized mattresses (think: king and California king) cost more than smaller options, because they require more materials to build. Premium features and add-ons, like pillow tops or optional cooling materials, can also increase a mattress’ price.
Off-Gassing
When you first unbox a new mattress, it may release an odor — this is off-gassing. Most online mattresses are compressed and wrapped in plastic before they are shipped. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) produced during the manufacturing process get trapped inside this plastic, then escape when it is opened.
Off-gassing odors usually dissipate and are no longer noticeable within a day or two. Mattresses made with synthetic foams tend to produce more off-gassing odors than other mattress types.
Personally, I’m not bothered by off-gassing. But people who are particularly sensitive to smells may want to opt for mattresses that contain little to no foam or let a new mattress air out for a day or two before sleeping on it.

Tips for Buying a Mattress Online
Shopping for a mattress online can feel like braving the Wild West, but I’ve found that a few simple tips can make the process much easier. From understanding return policies to reading the fine print on warranties, here’s what I keep in mind before clicking “buy.”
Shop the Sales
The mattress industry offers the best deals on a fairly predictable schedule. If you can hold out until the next holiday to make your purchase, you could save hundreds. The biggest mattress sales are tied to Martin Luther King Jr. Day, Presidents Day, Memorial Day, the Fourth of July, Labor Day, and Thanksgiving/Black Friday.
Beware of Scams
There are endless online scams these days, and unfortunately, some of them extend into the mattress space. Follow these tips to ensure the site you’re buying from is legitimate:
- Make sure the url begins with “https” and has a padlock symbol to its left. Both of these things indicate a secure connection that will protect your personal data.
- Check the Better Business Bureau (BBB) website to see how many years a mattress company has been in business and what BBB rating they currently have.
- Look over the company’s website for contact information and clearly outlined policies related to shipping, returns, and warranty.
Review the Sleep Trial, Return Policy, and Warranty
There are three policies you want to pay special attention to before clicking “Place Order.” The sleep trial, return, and warranty policies determine what will happen if you’re unhappy with the mattress you order. Read through each of these policies carefully, so you understand how to make a return if necessary and can avoid hidden fees.
- Sleep trial: A sleep trial is the amount of time a company allows you to try out a mattress to decide if you like it. Sleep trials are commonly around 90 days, but some are shorter and others are longer. I’ve even tested beds with year-long sleep trials!
- Returns: A return policy outlines the process for initiating a return and specifies if returns are free or come at a cost. Usually, you must initiate a return within the sleep trial period to receive a refund. Most companies offer free returns, but some charge a fee or require you to ship the mattress back to them.
- Warranty: The warranty describes what will happen if you decide to keep a mattress beyond the sleep trial, but something goes wrong with it later on. Most warranties cover mattress defects but not damage caused by something you did. Warranties can last anywhere from a few years to a lifetime.
Important note: Many online mattresses must be unboxed within a certain time frame after their delivery, such as 90 days, or else these policies can be void. This is because keeping a mattress compressed for too long can damage it or inhibit its ability to expand.
Choose Your Shipping and Delivery Method
Read through shipping and delivery options before placing your order, so you know what to expect. Many mattress companies offer free shipping, but some charge a fee.
With free shipping, most companies leave your mattress in a box sitting on your front step. But, some companies require you to be home, so they can bring it inside and set it up. This set-up feature is called White Glove Delivery, and it often includes old mattress removal.
How Long Does It Take to Ship?
Shipping times can vary widely, but they should be noted on a company’s website. Some companies have mattresses ready to go and ship them right after you order. Others assemble your mattress specially for you, which means they can’t ship it for several days. Most companies send shipping notifications via email or text, so you know when to expect your mattress.
Unboxing Your New Mattress Step by Step
I’ve personally unboxed dozens if not hundreds of mattresses, and I can assure you that you don’t need to be intimidated by the process. Just follow these steps to ensure it goes smoothly.
1. Prepare Your Space
It might be tempting to unbox your new mattress in your living room or front room and then carry it to the bedroom, but I advise against this. Carrying the mattress while it’s still in the box is easier. Enlist someone to help, so you don’t hurt your back, then carry the boxed mattress together into the bedroom it will stay in.
If there’s an old mattress in the space where the new one will be going, remove it from the room before you unbox the new mattress. Also, clear out any clutter that’s within a few feet of the bed frame or platform, as this might get in the way.
2. Open the Box
Opening the box requires extra care, because you don’t want to accidentally slice into the mattress. If there are instructions on the box telling you how to open it, follow them. Usually, you’ll use scissors or a knife to cut the tape that’s holding the box closed, while being very, very careful to keep the sharp edge away from the mattress inside the box.
3. Remove the Plastic
Once you’ve opened the box, you’ll need to remove the plastic from the mattress. Put the compressed mattress on top of the bed frame or platform before removing the plastic, so you won’t need to move the mattress once it decompresses and is harder to move.
Follow instructions given for removing the plastic. These may be printed on the plastic itself or printed on a piece of paper found inside the box. You may have to use scissors to cut the plastic, or the box may include a special tool to remove the plastic without damaging the mattress.
4. Let the Mattress Expand
Your mattress should immediately unroll and begin decompressing after you remove the plastic from it. If it doesn’t, help it along and position it how you would like it on your bed frame or platform.
If your new mattress looks wrinkled, shriveled, or thinner than you expected at this point, don’t worry! That’s just a side effect of being compressed, and it should expand with time. Check the instructions that came with it to find out how long you should wait before lying down on it. Some manufacturers ask that you don’t lie on the mattress for several hours as it expands.
How We Test: Your Comfort Is Our Science
We test mattresses in our Seattle-based Test Lab using an objective process that we’ve created over several years of consistently testing mattresses. High-tech tools allow us to measure pressure, temperature, and movement across the bed’s surface to determine how well each mattress performs in different areas.
We also have our testers take mattresses home with them to see how they perform in the real world. Because our testing team members have different body weights and sleep position preferences, their opinions resonate with our diverse audience. To put it simply, you can trust that our ratings are relevant for you and your unique needs.
Construction analysis: We begin testing each mattress by analyzing its design and making note firmness, height, individual layer composition, and sticker price. This allows us to evaluate qualities like support, durability, and value.
Product testing: Firsthand testing is crucial to our evaluation and ratings system. We use a wide range of tools and technology to test mattresses in six performance categories: motion isolation, pressure relief, temperature control, ease of movement, edge support, and odor potential.
Field testing: In addition to lab-based tests, we base our ratings on feedback from field testers who use the mattresses in their own homes. They spend several weeks collecting data — this gives us insights into how the mattress performs night after night for an extended period.
User testing: We curate feedback verified owners have provided in surveys, sleep stories, and product reviews. This helps us evaluate our initial findings and, if needed, tweak our ratings to reflect real-world experiences.
How We Determine Our Overall Scores

To calculate an overall mattress score, we compile all of the individual scores given to a mattress model across specific performance categories, like pressure relief and temperature control.
Instead of simply averaging these individual scores, we use a weighted system based on which factors have more of an impact on how well a person sleeps. For example, pressure relief is weighted more heavily than off-gassing, because it influences how comfortable you feel night after night, while off-gassing is usually only relevant shortly after unboxing a mattress.
Performance Categories
Motion Isolation
This is how much vibration a mattress absorbs when someone moves around on it. We measure this with a vibrometer, and the results help determine whether you’ll be woken up when your bed partner rolls over or gets in or out of bed.
Temperature Control
No one wants to wake up clammy and hot, so we perform temperature tests with a heat gun to see how much a mattress heats up and how quickly any built-up heat dissipates.
Pressure Relief
In this guide, I’ve already covered why pressure relief is important. We use pressure mapping technology that shows just how much impact occurs around the heavier parts of the body.
Ease of Movement
This category reflects how easy it is to move around on the bed’s surface. Materials like latex tend to get higher scores for ease of movement. As with testing edge support, we use kettlebells to determine how deeply a mattress compresses and how quickly it bounces back.
Edge Support
Mattresses with strong edge support provide a more dependable sleep surface because that translates to more usable surface area. We perform tests measuring how much the edges sink when you sit or lie down near the perimeter and how long it takes for the edge to return to its original shape.
Off-Gassing
A mattress that has been compressed to ship in a box can release unpleasant chemical odors due to volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Though they’re not harmful, they can be annoying, so we analyze how strong the smell is and how long it takes to fade away.
Dive Deeper: Mattress Guides by Type
If you’d like to narrow down your search for a bed beyond an online mattress, consider our other recommendations below broken down by mattress type.
Best Mattress by Type
- Best Mattress in a Box
- Best RV Mattress
- Best Mattress in Canada
- Best Smart Mattress
- Best Memory Foam Mattress
- Best Flippable Mattress
- Best Airbed Mattress
- Best Mattress for Bunk Beds
- Best Mattress on Amazon
- Best Temporary Air Mattress
- Best Walmart Mattress
- Best Pillow Top Mattress
- Best Crib Mattress
- Best Gel Mattress
Still have questions? Ask our community!
Join our Sleep Care Community — a trusted hub of product specialists, sleep health professionals, and people just like you. Whether you’re searching for the perfect mattress or need expert sleep advice, we’ve got you covered. Get personalized guidance from the experts who know sleep best.