When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Products or services may be offered by an affiliated entity. Learn more.

Whether you prefer the contouring qualities of memory foam or the responsive bounce of innersprings, a well-designed pillow-top mattress can enhance your sleep experience. In general, you have two options: A traditional pillow-top gives the appearance of an additional layer sitting on top of the mattress, while a Euro-top lines up flush with the edge of the layers beneath. Our list below includes both. Plus, we’ll share some tips for buying a new pillow-top or Euro-top mattress.

How We Tested the Best Pillow-Top Mattresses

Testing Criteria

Let’s review what makes a good pillow-top mattress. The top layer should feel plush, but the rest of the mattress should be built firmly enough to provide ample support. Besides construction, we looked at a few other factors to determine the best of the bunch:

Pillow-top material: Depending on the bed type, a good pillow-top should contain high-quality foam or latex, or fibrous materials like cotton, wool, or down and feathers. Choosing which material comes down to personal preference, sleep position, and body type.

Firmness level: Because the pillow-top layer adds extra softness, the rest of the mattress should be firm enough to support the body’s pressure points, like the back, hips, and shoulders. Top-tier pressure relief means that your spine will be supported, regardless of how soft or firm the bed is.

Edge support: Since pillow-tops have extra cushioning, firm edges can keep the mattress from looking and feeling saggy and offer stability when getting in and out.

Motion isolation: Because they have extra padding, pillow-tops should do a good job of containing movement (especially when made of foam), which generally does a better job of keeping sleepers in place than fiberfill.

How We Evaluated

To select the best pillow-top mattress, we started by searching our database of over 1,000 mattresses and reviewed the highest-rated models. From there, we zeroed in on several dozen, then had them sent to our Seattle test lab for evaluation. In addition to our testing criteria, we considered the following:

  • Overall comfort
  • Sleep position and body size
  • High-quality materials
  • Perimeter reinforcement, which can look like firmer coils that reduce sinkage when you sit (or sleep) closer to the edge

Our testing group includes sleepers of all sleep positions and body sizes, which helped them compile our list of the best pillow-top mattresses. After trying each bed out, they provided scores for our top performance categories and assigned superlatives to each option.

These are their top picks to match a diverse range of sleep needs.

Our Testing Team

Logan Foley

Logan Foley

Editorial Director

Full Bio

Mary Fenton

Mary Fenton

Head of Product Content

Full Bio

Jeremy Klein

Jeremy Klein

Senior Product Testing Manager

Full Bio

Brad Nehring

Brad Nehring

Senior Product Analyst

Full Bio

Colin Simpson

Colin Simpson

Product Research Manager

Full Bio

Best Mattress Deals for Presidents’ Day

Best Mattress Overall: Leesa Sapira Chill Hybrid

Best Overall Mattress

9.0/10Test Lab Score

Leesa Sapira Chill Hybrid

A foam hybrid that cushions your body without trapping heat.

30% off sitewide Shop At Leesa
Price: $1,698
Mattress Type: Hybrid
Firmness Options: Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)
Trial Period: 120 nights (30-night requirement)
Key Details
  • Who It’s Best For: Most side and back sleepers across different weight groups, couples, hot sleepers, and people with shoulder, back, or hip pain.
  • Feel: Customers choose from medium (5), medium firm (6), and firm (7) designs.
  • What It’s Made Of: Comfort layers of gel-infused polyfoam, memory foam, adaptive polyfoam, and transitional foam over three-zoned pocketed coils with perimeter reinforcement and high-density base foam.
  • What We Don’t Like: Initial off-gassing odor can be strong and unpleasant for the first few nights, and you’ll need a deep-pocket fitted sheet because the mattress has a high profile.
Scoring & Reviews

The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.

Side Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

9/10

130-230 lbs

9.5/10

Above 230 lbs

9/10

Back Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8/10

130-230 lbs

7.5/10

Above 230 lbs

6.5/10

Stomach Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8/10

130-230 lbs

7/10

Above 230 lbs

6/10

In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.

SELECT AN ICON TO VIEW DETAILS:

Motion Isolation

7.5/10
7.5/10

In our tests, the Sapira Chill Hybrid’s foam-heavy comfort system absorbed most motion with ease. Even when one tester shifted positions or got up, the other hardly noticed — especially on the medium and medium firm models. For couples, this mattress is a standout in motion isolation for a hybrid.

Pressure Relief

8.5/10
8.5/10

Pressure relief was a top-scoring category across the board. Our side sleepers noted significant cushioning in the hips and shoulders, and even our back sleepers experienced a nice balance of support and contouring. The plush top layers adapted closely without making us feel stuck.

Temperature Control

7.5/10
7.5/10

Though it contains multiple foam layers, the Sapira Chill didn’t trap as much heat as we expected. The open-cell construction and airflow from the coil core helped maintain a neutral sleep temperature for most of our testers — particularly on the firmer options where we didn’t sink in as deeply.

Edge Support

7/10
7/10

We were impressed with how well the Sapira Chill held up around the edges. The reinforced perimeter coils gave us a stable feel when sitting or lying near the sides of the bed, which is especially helpful for co-sleepers or anyone who likes to spread out.

Ease of Movement

8/10
8/10

Movement on the Sapira Chill felt smooth, especially for a hybrid with four foam layers. While the softer model had a bit of a “sink-in” feel, the underlying coil support and responsive transition foam made it easy to shift positions or get in and out of bed on all three firmness levels.

Durability

8/10
8/10

The Leesa Sapira Chill Hybrid earns high marks for durability. As a hybrid mattress that uses four distinct foam layers, two of which are high-density polyfoam, sleepers can rely on cradling support without sinkage. Add to that the pocketed coil layer with individually wrapped springs, and the mattress should provide at least eight years of comfort.

Read Our Full Leesa Sapira Chill Hybrid Review

Best Mattress for Back Pain: WinkBed

Best Mattress for Back Pain

9.4/10Test Lab Score

WinkBed

High end hybrid bed providing ample support, cushion, and cool sleep.

30% off all WinkBeds mattresses Shop At WinkBeds
Price: $2,570
Mattress Type: Innerspring
Firmness Options: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7), Firm (8)
Trial Period: 120 nights (30 night requirement)
Key Details
  • Who It’s Best For: Sleepers of any weight and position can find a model that meets their needs.
  • Feel: Depends on firmness level, but all have an inviting pillow-top and zoned support for pressure relief.
  • What It’s Made Of: Tencel cover, cooling gel-infused polyfoam, and a pocketed coil base layer. Depending on the model, additional comfort layers are made of either polyfoam or natural latex.
  • What We Don’t Like: May be too bouncy and transfer motion. Odor can linger up to 72 hours after unboxing.
Scoring & Reviews

The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.

Side Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

9.5/10

130-230 lbs

10/10

Above 230 lbs

9.5/10

Back Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8.5/10

130-230 lbs

8/10

Above 230 lbs

7/10

Stomach Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8.5/10

130-230 lbs

7.5/10

Above 230 lbs

6.5/10

In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.

SELECT AN ICON TO VIEW DETAILS:

Motion Isolation

6.5/10
6.5/10

All four firmness options offer above-average motion isolation compared to other hybrids we’ve tested. The Softer, Luxury Firm, and Firmer models have polyfoam layers that significantly absorb vibrations, preventing motion from traveling across the surface. The Plus features latex, and does not isolate as much motion – though it still received high marks from our team. Although the coil core gives the mattress some bounce, the foam layers are substantial enough to dampen motion transfer.

Motion Isolation

Pressure Relief

8/10
8/10

Like with many hybrid models, the WinkBed’s strong contouring can help relieve painful pressure points. Using pressure-mapping sensors, we found the Softer, Luxury Firm, and Firmer versions of the mattress generously cradle your body and ease pressure off sensitive joints, thanks largely to the multiple foam layers. The Plus version uses polyfoam and latex layers, which offer gentle contouring as well.

Pressure Relief

Temperature Control

9/10
9/10

The WinkBed’s Tencel cover wicks heat and moisture away from the sleeper’s body. In the Softer, Luxury Firm, and Firmer models, polyfoam infused with cooling gel helps to minimize heat retention. The Plus version uses latex, a naturally breathable material that resists heat buildup.The coil core also promotes significant air circulation. All of these components make the WinkBed one of the best cooling mattresses on the market.

Temperature Control

Edge Support

9.5/10
9.5/10

While many hybrid models have sturdy edges, the WinkBed’s perimeter is exceptionally strong . Thanks to extra reinforcement along the edges, our testers noticed minimal compression when sitting along the edge. Most sleepers should feel secure enough to sleep or sit on the full surface of the mattress without worrying about rolling off.The edge of the Softer model may not seem quite as sturdy as the Luxury Firm, Firmer, and Plus versions, due to its plusher design.

Edge Support

Ease of Movement

7.5/10
7.5/10

The three softest versions of the WinkBed Mattress feature polyfoam comfort layers. Polyfoam is more responsive than memory foam, so the WinkBed won’t hug your body as closely as hybrid mattresses made with close-conforming memory foam. The result is strong ease of movement across the surface.The Plus model features a very responsive latex layer, so this option shines when it comes to ease of movement.

Ease of Movement

Durability

8/10
8/10

As a hybrid mattress with a polyfoam comfort layer, the Winkbed should last slightly longer than the average bed. Hybrids tend to be durable because the inner coils last a long time, and polyfoam is more durable than memory foam. That being said, the foam comfort layer isn’t too thick on the Winkbed (2 to 2.5 inches, depending on the firmness you choose), so you might find the bed getting less comfortable after around eight or nine years when impressions and sagging start to set in.

Read Our Full WinkBed Review

Best Value Mattress: Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Memory Foam

Best Value Mattress

8.6/10Test Lab Score

Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Memory Foam

Hugs and soothes pressure points for restful sleep.

30% off sitewide with code: PRESDAY30 Shop At Brooklyn Bedding
Price: $466
Mattress Type: Foam
Firmness Options: Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period: 120 nights (30-night requirement)
Key Details
  • Who It’s Best For: Side and back sleepers who weigh up to 230 pounds, as well as hot sleepers.
  • Feel: Plush and adaptive on the surface, then extra supportive around the midsection as your body settles.
  • What It’s Made Of: Polyfoam and memory foam comfort layers encased in a Euro-top, zoned transitional foam, and dense base foam.
  • What We Don’t Like: Off-gassing can be strong for the first few nights and people over 230 pounds may sink too much.
Scoring & Reviews

The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.

Side Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

7/10

130-230 lbs

9/10

Above 230 lbs

7.5/10

Back Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8/10

130-230 lbs

7/10

Above 230 lbs

6/10

Stomach Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8/10

130-230 lbs

6/10

Above 230 lbs

5.5/10

In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.

SELECT AN ICON TO VIEW DETAILS:

Motion Isolation

8.5/10
8.5/10

The CopperFlex Memory Foam provides great motion isolation, with our testers clocking almost no motion transfer across the bed during movement. This is due to the all-foam construction—with memory foam comfort layers and an all-foam base, there is little means for one side of the bed to affect the other.

Pressure Relief

9/10
9/10

This bed provides excellent pressure relief, which notably reduced pressure on the shoulders and hips compared to other beds. With a thick foam comfort layer and a foam base, the bed conforms close to the body and ‘hugs’ the sleeper quite a bit.

Temperature Control

7/10
7/10

As an all-foam bed, the CopperFlex is inevitable going to trap a decent amount of body heat. Luckily, the top layer of quilted polyfoam isn’t very dense, allowing for some airflow. We don’t find copper-infused foam to make too much of a difference in cooling.

Edge Support

7/10
7/10

Like most all-foam beds, the edge support of the CopperFlex memory foam is mediocre. The high density support core provides a bit of support, but there’s definitely some noticeable sinkage when sitting around the edges. Perhaps not the best choice for those with mobility issues.

Ease of Movement

6.5/10
6.5/10

As an all foam bed with a memory foam comfort layer, it’s no surprise that our testers found the CopperFlex Memory Foam a bit hard to move around on. The foam conforms close to the body, giving you that sinking sensation, and it definitely requires a bit more effort to roll around on the bed, especially for heavier sleepers.

Durability

7/10
7/10

Read Our Full Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Memory Foam Review

Best Luxury Mattress: Saatva Classic

Best Luxury Mattress

9.5/10Test Lab Score

Saatva Classic

Traditional innerspring with a plush euro-top and excellent breathability.

$300 off orders of $1,000 or more Shop At Saatva
Price: $1,795
Mattress Type: Innerspring
Firmness Options: Soft (3), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period: 365 Nights ($99 Return Fee)
Key Details
  • Who It’s Best For: Sleepers of any position and body weight, depending on model.
  • Feel: Luxe but feels sturdy from edge-to-edge, stays cool, and gently cushions your body.
  • What It’s Made Of: Thin layer of microcoils that sit on top of taller pocketed coils. On top, a resilient polyfoam and a comfort-boosting lumbar pad made of memory foam.
  • What We Don’t Like: Above-average sticker price and $99 return fee.
Scoring & Reviews

The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.

Side Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8.5/10

130-230 lbs

9/10

Above 230 lbs

8.5/10

Back Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

9/10

130-230 lbs

8.5/10

Above 230 lbs

7.5/10

Stomach Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

9.5/10

130-230 lbs

8.5/10

Above 230 lbs

7.5/10

In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.

SELECT AN ICON TO VIEW DETAILS:

Motion Isolation

6.5/10
6.5/10

Motion isolation is one of the Saatva Classic’s weaker performance areas. The dual-coil design makes the surface responsive to movement, resulting in a noticeable bounce when you switch sleep positions or get in and out of bed. This can be problematic if you share your bed with a partner, as their movements can disrupt your sleep and vice versa.

Motion Isolation

Pressure Relief

8/10
8/10

While all of the Saatva firmness options have pressure-relieving potential, the amount of pressure relief that an individual experiences on the mattress will vary based partially on their weight and sleep position. Individuals who weigh under 130 pounds will likely experience the most pressure relief on the Plush Soft version of the mattress, while sleepers over 230 pounds will likely get the best balance of contouring and support from the Firm version.

Pressure Relief

Temperature Control

10/10
10/10

While hybrid mattresses tend to sleep cool, the Saatva Classic’s construction may help it sleep even cooler than many other hybrid models. While all the firmness options may help promote a cooler night’s sleep, the Plush Soft version has more conforming that could lead to slightly more heat retention.

Temperature Control

Edge Support

8.5/10
8.5/10

The Saatva Classic has a sturdy enough edge to allow almost all individuals to sit or sleep near the perimeter without excessive sinkage. This reinforcement is excellent even compared to most hybrid models.Because the Plush Soft version of the Saatva allows individuals to sink in more, its edges may not feel quite as secure as those of the Luxury Firm and Firm versions of the mattress.

Edge Support

Ease of Movement

8.5/10
8.5/10

The Saatva Classic’s comfort system consists of polyfoam and minicoils. While these materials conform to your body, they regain their shape more quickly than memory foam. This prevents sleepers from feeling “trapped” in the bed.All three designs are relatively easy for sleepers to move across and change positions on. However, most individuals will probably find the firmer versions of the mattress easier to move on, since they conform less than the Plush Soft version.

Ease of Movement

Durability

8/10
8/10

The Saatva Classic is stacked with features that help ensure durability. It’s constructed with both pocketed and support coils, plus polyfoam and memory foam comfort layers for additional comfort and support. Shoppers have a choice of thickness and firmness levels, and in general, going with thicker and firmer options can help add to the longevity. With its thick, 13-gauge coils in the bottom layer providing a sturdy base, this mattress should easily make it to the 10-year mark.

Read Our Full Saatva Classic Review

Best Mattress for Pressure Relief: Bear Elite Hybrid

Best Mattress for Pressure Relief

8.5/10Test Lab Score

Bear Elite Hybrid

A close-conforming memory foam hybrid offering great pressure relief.

40% sitewide with code: SF40 Shop At Bear
Price: $1,499
Mattress Type: Hybrid
Firmness Options: Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period: 120 nights (30-night break-in period)
Key Details
  • Who It’s Best For: People with persistent shoulder, back, or hip pain, as well as couples and people who run hot in bed.
  • Feel: Sold in medium (5), medium firm (6), and firm (8) designs.
  • What It’s Made Of: Adaptive memory foam and five-zone transitional polyfoam, followed by pocketed coils with a reinforced perimeter and dense base foam.
  • What We Don’t Like: The foam layers may hinder movement when you move on the surface.
Scoring & Reviews

The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.

Side Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8.5/10

130-230 lbs

9/10

Above 230 lbs

8.5/10

Back Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

7.5/10

130-230 lbs

7/10

Above 230 lbs

6/10

Stomach Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

7.5/10

130-230 lbs

6.5/10

Above 230 lbs

5.5/10

In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.

SELECT AN ICON TO VIEW DETAILS:

Motion Isolation

7/10
7/10

The Bear Elite Hybrid shows considerable ability to prevent vibrations from traveling across the surface of the mattress. Its memory foam layer only reacts where weight is directly applied, which helps keep movement from causing ripple effects that spread to the other side of the bed.However, the bounce of the coils can cause some motion transfer, especially on the firm model that has a reduced amount of contouring.

Pressure Relief

8/10
8/10

The Bear Elite Hybrid offers excellent pressure relief that stems from its comfort system and the zoned, pocketed coils in its support core. In our testing, it was side and back sleepers who tended to get the best pressure relief and support. That said, stomach sleepers liked the firm (8) model that maintained a flat, stable surface with just enough cushioning for the midsection.

Temperature Control

7/10
7/10

This mattress doesn’t feel overwhelmingly hot, but it also probably shouldn’t be the top choice for hot sleepers. The copper-infused foam makes it slightly cooler than some other memory foam mattresses, but heat can still collect in and around the foam. The risk of overheating is highest on the Luxury Plush model because it has the closest contouring around the skin, which may make it harder for heat around the body to dissipate during the night.

Edge Support

7.5/10
7.5/10

Reinforced edges in the support core help give this mattress a solid rating for edge support. While you’ll notice foam compression around the perimeter, it’s not so significant that you’ll feel like the mattress is giving out beneath you.Of the three different firmness options, edge support is clearly strongest in the firm (8) model and weakest in the one with a firmness level of medium (5).

Ease of Movement

6.5/10
6.5/10

When you need to switch your sleeping position or adjust your body’s alignment on the mattress, you generally won’t encounter much resistance. Sleepers over 230 pounds may find that there’s less ease of movement, especially on the softer models. But in most cases, the springiness from the thick layer of pocketed coils enables relatively easy movement on the surface of the Bear Elite Hybrid.

Durability

7.5/10
7.5/10

The Bear Elite Hybrid Mattress scores above average for durability thanks to its pocketed coils, reinforced perimeter, and memory foam and polyfoam layers. The mattress comes in three firmness levels, and going firmer will typically extend the life of the mattress a bit more. Overall, you should expect around seven to eight years of use.

Read Our Full Bear Elite Hybrid Review

Best Mattress for Side Sleepers: Helix Midnight Luxe

Best Mattress for Side Sleepers

9.7/10Test Lab Score

Helix Midnight Luxe

A premium quality, hybrid mattress created with side sleepers in mind.

27% off sitewide with code: SF27 Shop At Helix
Price: $1,799
Mattress Type: Hybrid
Firmness Options: Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period: 120 nights (30-night requirement)
Key Details
  • Who It’s Best For: Side sleepers up to 230 pounds. Many back sleepers under 230 pounds.
  • Feel: Medium firm (6). Softens impact around the hips and shoulders but keeps you supported and prevents unwanted sagging.
  • What It’s Made Of: Memory foam and adaptive polyfoam layers and a smooth Tencel cover. Add-on options include ergonomic lumbar support in the top layer and cooling fabric in the cover. Support core is tall coils and base polyfoam.
  • What We Don’t Like: Add-on features raise the total cost. Often a “new mattress smell” for up to a couple of days after unboxing.
Scoring & Reviews

The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.

Side Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

9.5/10

130-230 lbs

10/10

Above 230 lbs

9.5/10

Back Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8.5/10

130-230 lbs

8/10

Above 230 lbs

7/10

Stomach Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8.5/10

130-230 lbs

7.5/10

Above 230 lbs

6.5/10

In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.

SELECT AN ICON TO VIEW DETAILS:

Motion Isolation

8.5/10
8.5/10

As a medium firm mattress with thick foam comfort layers, it’s no surprise that the Midnight Luxe tested very well for motion isolation. Our testers could barely feel any movement across the surface of the mattress when fellow testers rolled around on it.

Motion Isolation

Pressure Relief

9.5/10
9.5/10

All of the Helix Luxe models have thick foam comfort layers and conform fairly close to the body. Consequently, they’ve all performed well in our pressure mapping tests, with notably less pressure in the hips and shoulders than many hybrids. With it’s 6 out of 10 firmness, The Midnight Luxe in particular performs average among other Helix Luxe beds.

Pressure Relief

Temperature Control

8/10
8/10

The Helix mattresses perform about average for hybrids when it comes to sleeping cool. Memory foam is well-known for its tendency to sleep hot, as it often traps and retains heat through the night, but the coil cores of these beds promote airflow to help balance out heat retention.

Temperature Control

Edge Support

9.5/10
9.5/10

All Helix mattresses feature a reinforced perimeter, meaning the coils on the edges are thicker than the coils in the middle of the bed. When putting this to the test, we found significantly less sinkage on the edge than the middle while applying weight.

Edge Support

Ease of Movement

7.5/10
7.5/10

Helix Luxe mattresses tend to be somewhat responsive and bouncy, and all tested pretty well for ease of movement. The Midnight Luxe in particular had a middle-of-the-road performance in our tests, as the medium firm surface conforms a bit to the body, but doesn’t fully provide that ‘stuck’ feeling and inhibit motion.

Ease of Movement

Durability

8.5/10
8.5/10

The Helix Luxe collection of hybrid mattresses is built for durability, and the firmer options will likely extend the life even further. Each model is 14 inches thick and features three layers of foam (memory and poly), plus has 1,000 individually wrapped coils, including zone and perimeter support. It’s likely that you’ll be able to enjoy this mattress for close to a decade.

Read Our Full Helix Midnight Luxe Review

Most Comfortable Mattress: Nolah Evolution 15

Most Comfortable Mattress

8.7/10Test Lab Score

Nolah Evolution 15

A cloud-like experience with a plush euro-top in multiple firmnes options.

30% off sitewide + extra $50 off with code: SF50 Shop At Nolah Sleep
Price: $1,480
Mattress Type: Hybrid
Firmness Options: Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period: 120 nights (30-night requirement), $99 return pickup fee
Key Details
  • Who It’s Best For: Most side and back sleepers, as well as couples and hot sleepers.
  • Feel: Medium (5), medium firm (6), and firm (8). Supportive with some bounce and plenty of cushioning. Allows for easy movement and resists heat buildup.
  • What It’s Made Of: A layer of adaptive polyfoam and three other polyfoam layers. Durable pocketed coils, zoned for ergonomic support.
  • What We Don’t Like: Standard fitted sheets may not be deep enough. Return fee of $99.
Scoring & Reviews

The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.

Side Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8.5/10

130-230 lbs

9/10

Above 230 lbs

8.5/10

Back Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

7.5/10

130-230 lbs

7/10

Above 230 lbs

6/10

Stomach Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

7.5/10

130-230 lbs

6.5/10

Above 230 lbs

5.5/10

In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.

SELECT AN ICON TO VIEW DETAILS:

Motion Isolation

7.5/10
7.5/10

Thanks to its thick polyfoam layers, the Nolah Evolution 15 Hybrid absorbs enough movement to prevent most sleep disruptions. However, there is still some motion transfer because of the bounciness of the coils. You can expect the most motion transfer on the firm (8) model and the least on the plush (5) option. Across the board, though, our testers noticed only light motion transfer across all three firmness levels.

Motion Isolation

Pressure Relief

8.5/10
8.5/10

The combination of zoned coils and multiple polyfoam layers, including zoned AirFoam, enable the Nolah Evolution Hybrid to cushion pain points and provide above-average pressure relief. Choosing the right firmness option can optimize pressure relief. While individual preferences vary, a plush (5) or luxury firm (6) model works best for most side sleepers under 230 pounds, while the luxury firm (6) or firm (8) are better suited to the majority of back and stomach sleepers.

Pressure Relief

Temperature Control

7/10
7/10

Like many hybrids, the Nolah Evolution 15 excels at temperature regulation. Cooling fibers in the cover are engineered to draw heat away from the body, and the aerated polyfoam layers help reduce heat retention. The coil layer also promotes steady ventilation.In our testing, all three models resisted heat retention. That said, compared to the firm (8) model, the plush (5) and luxury firm (6) permit more sink and allow slightly less cooling airflow around the skin.

Temperature Control

Edge Support

8.5/10
8.5/10

The sturdy 8-inch coils gives the Nolah Evolution Hybrid a reliable level of edge support. While there can be some sink from the foam layers, resilient polyfoam prevents instability around the perimeter of the bed.Edge support does vary based on the firmness level. Our team noticed a reduction in edge support between the firm (8) and the luxury firm (6) and plush (5) models. Even on the softer models, though, you get solid edge support from this mattress.

Edge Support

Ease of Movement

6.5/10
6.5/10

The Nolah Evolution 15’s foam layers don’t sink or hug excessively, and the bounce of the coils facilitates movement on the surface. This makes this mattress a solid fit for combination sleepers or anyone who hates feeling stuck in place when lying in bed. With its softer surface, the plush (5) model restricts movement a bit more than the other two. The firm (8) model provided standout ease of movement to all of our sleepers.

Ease of Movement

Durability

7.5/10
7.5/10

With a stunning 15-inch profile, seven inches of which are polyfoam found in the comfort layer, the Nolah Evolution 15 is a highly durable mattress. Beneath that are 8-inch coils to give the bed more support. If longevity is your main concern, going with the firmer of the three options may extend the life a bit more. Otherwise, you can generally expect around eight or nine years of comfort.

Read Our Full Nolah Evolution 15 Review

Best Temperature Regulating Mattress: Birch Luxe

Best Temperature Regulating Mattress

9.3/10Test Lab Score

Birch Luxe

Luxury latex hybrid with a medium firm feel.

27% off sitewide with code: SF27 Shop At Birch
Price: $1,968
Mattress Type: Latex Hybrid
Firmness Options: Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period: 120 nights (30-night requirement)
Key Details
  • Who It’s Best For: Hot sleepers, side and back sleepers under 230 pounds, and lighter-weight stomach sleepers.
  • Feel: Bouncy but with moderate contouring around heavier areas. Stays cool.
  • What It’s Made Of: Organic cotton and wool cover includes pillow-top stuffed with organic wool and organic latex. Core of pocketed coils keeps the mattress ventilated.
  • What We Don’t Like: Bouncy materials can cause motion transfer.
Scoring & Reviews

The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.

Side Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8/10

130-230 lbs

8.5/10

Above 230 lbs

8/10

Back Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

9.5/10

130-230 lbs

9/10

Above 230 lbs

8/10

Stomach Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

9.5/10

130-230 lbs

8.5/10

Above 230 lbs

7.5/10

In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.

SELECT AN ICON TO VIEW DETAILS:

Motion Isolation

6.5/10
6.5/10

Any mattress with springs inevitably transfers some motion, which is why all-foam models typically outperform hybrids in this category. Latex is bouncier than foam, so the Birch Luxe Mattress isn’t as effective at curbing movement when compared to hybrids with foam comfort systems.

Pressure Relief

7/10
7/10

The Birch Luxe offers a moderate amount of pressure relief. The latex contours somewhat, but the mattress is firm enough to help evenly distribute body weight and encourage a straighter spine. Side sleepers and those who weigh less than 130 pounds might prefer a softer model with more cushioning. People over 130 pounds of any sleep position should experience notable contouring and adequate support.

Temperature Control

9/10
9/10

Hybrids are typically better at regulating temperature than all-foam mattresses, as foam tends to trap heat. The Birch Luxe regulates temperature exceptionally well. The cover and comfort system use naturally breathable materials, including cotton and wool, to help draw heat and moisture away from the body. When compared to memory foam, natural latex has an airier structure that resists heat buildup. Plus, the pocketed spring support core also offers space for air to circulate.

Edge Support

9/10
9/10

The Birch Luxe features a hefty coil core that’s designed to minimize sagging throughout the mattress. Heavier gauge coils along the perimeter provide extra reinforcement, delivering above-average edge support.

Ease of Movement

9/10
9/10

The Birch Luxe’s construction makes it easy for sleepers to move around on its surface. Latex is notable for its responsiveness, which is helpful when changing sleeping positions. The coil support system also makes getting in and out of bed easier. The medium firm (6) feel of the bed doesn’t compress significantly, preventing the feeling of being trapped in the bed.

Durability

8.5/10
8.5/10

Thanks to its use of natural, durable materials, the Birch Luxe should perform for at least nine to 10 years, which is considerably longer than the average bed. Unlike foam, latex resists impressions and sagging, and the wool and cotton used throughout the construction should prove sturdy, too. Coils are generally more durable than polyfoam for support and should maintain their performance over time.

Read Our Full Birch Luxe Review

Best Mattress for Heavy Sleepers: Saatva HD

Best Mattress for Heavy Sleepers

9.2/10Test Lab Score

Saatva HD

A high-end innerspring mattress with an emphasis on craftsmanship.

$300 off orders of $1,000 or more Shop At Saatva
Price: $2,945
Mattress Type: Innerspring
Firmness Options: Firm (7)
Trial Period: 365 Nights ($99 Return Fee)
Key Details
  • Who It’s Best For: Sleepers who weigh between 230 and 500 pounds, regardless of sleeping position.
  • Feel: Firm (7) and supportive. Provides notable pressure relief while staying stable and even.
  • What It’s Made Of: Euro-top filled with fabric and foam bolstered by polyfoam, natural latex, and memory foam. Coils in the support core are thick and encased in dense foam.
  • What We Don’t Like: Too firm for people under 230 pounds. Not compatible with all bed frames and foundations.
Scoring & Reviews

The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.

Side Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8/10

130-230 lbs

9/10

Above 230 lbs

10/10

Back Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8/10

130-230 lbs

8.5/10

Above 230 lbs

8/10

Stomach Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8.5/10

130-230 lbs

8.5/10

Above 230 lbs

7.5/10

In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.

SELECT AN ICON TO VIEW DETAILS:

Motion Isolation

6.5/10
6.5/10

Motion isolation on the Saatva HD is only around average. Its firmness and bounce reduce its ability to keep vibrations from traveling across the mattress surface.While you can detect movement when a bed partner gets in or out of bed, it’s not enough to bother most people. It is mostly a concern for anyone who sleeps lightly and can be easily awoken.

Motion Isolation

Pressure Relief

8.5/10
8.5/10

The Saatva HD provides average to above-average pressure relief to most sleepers. In our testing, it was most supportive for people over 230 pounds who can benefit from its balanced feel without excessive sinkage. Its firmness and zoned design also made it a good option to relieve pressure for people who sleep on their back or stomach.

Pressure Relief

Temperature Control

8/10
8/10

The Saatva HD has excellent temperature regulation. It stays cool thanks to the layers of cotton, latex, and innerspring coils. Cotton is naturally breathable, and latex retains minimal heat. Air can flow through the coils so that warmth doesn’t build up in the support core.All of these elements make the Saatva HD compelling for hot sleepers, especially those who have a higher body weight.

Temperature Control

Edge Support

8/10
8/10

Multiple components contribute to above-average edge support on the Saatva HD. Extra-thick coils with a high-density polyfoam encasement create a sturdy base around the perimeter. The responsive and firm latex also holds up well around the edges.This strong edge support is a refreshing change of pace for sleepers over 230 pounds who often find mattresses to be too soft around the perimeter.

Edge Support

Ease of Movement

7.5/10
7.5/10

The Saatva HD’s bounce makes ease of movement a strength of this mattress. Both latex and coil layers create a springiness that lets you easily turn over or switch your sleeping position.

Ease of Movement

Durability

8.5/10
8.5/10

The Saatva HD mattress is likely to last close to 10 years thanks to its multiple layers of polyfoam, latex, and innerspring coils. As a hybrid, it’s a step above all-foam models. But Saatva went with more durable materials for this mattress, which is marketed to heavier people. Specifically, its 14-gauge tempered steel coils that are 25% stronger than industry standard and the latex and polyfoam components in the comfort layer, which add durability.

Read Our Full Saatva HD Review

Best Mattress for Couples: Naturepedic EOS Pillow Top

Best Mattress for Couples

8.7/10Test Lab Score

Naturepedic EOS Pillow Top

A durable latex hybrid chock-full of organic and natural materials.

15% off with code: SF15 Shop At Naturepedic
Price: $4,799
Mattress Type: Latex Hybrid
Firmness Options: Soft (3), Medium Soft (4), Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)
Trial Period: 90 nights (30-night requirement)
Key Details
  • Who It’s Best For: Couples with different firmness preferences.
  • Feel: Depends on firmness level. But all models support the body and encourage ease of movement.
  • What It’s Made Of: Organic cotton cover along with organic wool, plant-based fiber fill, and multiple layers of organic latex. An 8-inch layer of individually wrapped coils as a base.
  • What We Don’t Like: Expensive and some assembly required.
Scoring & Reviews

The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.

Side Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8.5/10

130-230 lbs

8/10

Above 230 lbs

7/10

Back Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

8.5/10

130-230 lbs

7.5/10

Above 230 lbs

7/10

Stomach Sleepers

Under 130 lbs

7/10

130-230 lbs

6.5/10

Above 230 lbs

6/10

In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.

SELECT AN ICON TO VIEW DETAILS:

Motion Isolation

7/10
7/10

Motion isolation is not a major strength of the EOS Pillow Top because the latex and coils both respond to movement with a light bounce. This can send ripples of motion transfer across the surface when someone changes positions or gets up during the night, so couples face a higher potential for nighttime sleep disruptions. That said, the softer designs absorb more movement than the firmer ones.

Pressure Relief

7.5/10
7.5/10

The EOS Pillow Top has proven to be a durable, well-made mattress – but the firmness you choose makes a difference. You may notice indentations and impressions in the surface sooner if your mattress is on the softer side, whereas the firmer models won’t develop wear ad tear as quickly.

Temperature Control

8.5/10
8.5/10

Temperature control is one of the EOS Pillow Top’s major strengths. Breathable materials directly below the surface, ventilated latex that doesn’t retain too much heat, coils that promote internal airflow, and a moisture-wicking cover all contribute to the bed’s superior cooling abilities.

Edge Support

7/10
7/10

Edge support for the Naturepedic EOS Pillow Top varies by firmness level. Softer models dip a bt along the perimeter when weight is applied, while the firmer designs withstand compression better and won’t sink as much. This consideration is especially important for people with mobility issues who have a hard time getting in and out of bed.

Ease of Movement

8.5/10
8.5/10

The EOS Pillow Top has a responsive, bouncy surface that most people can move across with relative ease. You shouldn’t feel stuck or trapped as you might moving on memory foam, as the latex springs back into place as soon as weight is removed. However, heavier individuals may still struggle to move across softer versions of the EOS Pillow Top.

Durability

8.5/10
8.5/10

The EOS Pillow Top has proven to be a durable, well-made mattress – but the firmness you choose makes a difference. You may notice indentations and impressions in the surface sooner if your mattress is on the softer side, whereas the firmer models won’t develop wear and tear as quickly.

What Is a Pillow-Top Mattress?

Pillow-top mattresses feature an extra top layer designed to enhance cushioning or responsiveness on the surface. The layer is typically composed of foam, latex, wool, or various fibers, and usually measures 2 to 4 inches. The edge of the pillow-top layer is not attached to the edge of the layer beneath, which gives it a cloud-like feel.

ProsCons
  • Plush comfort with a soft, luxe feelContouring properties for pressure reliefAbsorb motion to minimize sleep disruptions for co-sleepers
  • Traps heat (though some add cooling features to offset this)Prone to sagging along the edges

Pillow-Top vs. Euro-Top

While pillow-tops and Euro-tops both feature a soft 2- to 4-inch layer sewn to the top of the mattress, there are several important differences between the two models. On a pillow-top, the perimeter of the surface layer is not attached to the mattress layers beneath. 

By contrast, the perimeter of the Euro-top surface layer is sewn onto the rest of the bed, creating a seamless appearance. Euro-tops also sometimes use denser materials that make the top layer feel more integrated with the mattress.

Euro-tops are often available in a wider range of firmness levels and can accommodate more types of sleepers. They also offer stronger edge support and better durability than traditional pillow-tops. As a result, Euro-tops generally carry a higher price-point. That said, they don’t always offer the immediately plush sensation that sleepers expect from a pillow-top.

Who Should (and Should Not) Sleep on a Pillow-Top Mattress?

Pillow-Top Mattresses Are Best For

Side Sleepers

  • In general, side sleepers appreciate the extra padding and contouring of pillow-tops.
“Side sleepers may experience pain or discomfort in the shoulders or hips due to the uneven distribution of body weight, particularly those with increased sensitivity or arthritis. The added cushioning of a pillow-top mattress may help mitigate the impact on pressure points and ensure a more restful sleep.”
Pranshu Adavadkar, MD
Pranshu Adavadkar, MD
Sleep Medicine Physician

Those Who Like a Plush Surface

  • If you want a supportive mattress but don’t love a firm feel, a pillow-top can provide that cloud-like feel without compromising support.

Couples

  • Pillow-top mattresses tend to absorb motion well so they can be a good fit for couples who don’t want to disturb each other when shifting positions during the night.

Pillow-Top Mattresses Are Less Than Ideal For

Sleepers Over 230 Pounds

  • Pillow-top mattresses don’t always have strong enough support for those over 230 pounds and might allow these sleepers to sink too far into the mattress.
“Our spine has natural curves that must be maintained during sleep. A mattress without proper support can lead to excessive sagging, putting undue strain on the lower back leading to pain, discomfort, and restless sleep.”
Pranshu Adavadkar, MD
Pranshu Adavadkar, MD
Sleep Medicine Physician

Those Who Like a Firm Feel

  • If you like to sleep on a flat, even surface, the plush quality of a pillow-top won’t be to your taste.

How to Choose the Best Pillow-Top Mattress

There are a number of factors to consider when choosing a mattress, whether it’s a pillow-top or not. We’ll walk you through some of the main considerations and explain how they vary according to a sleeper’s individual needs and preferences. 

“Sleeping on a pillow-top mattress gives you that luxury, hotel-bed feeling. The plush surface gives you a super soft and high-end feel, providing extra comfort and support. I always describe it as ‘sleeping on a cloud,’ which you hear often when talking about pillow-top and Euro-top mattresses.”
Logan Foley
Logan Foley
Editorial Director

Materials 

Materials determine the quality and feel of the entire mattress, including the pillow-top layer. Common materials used in pillow-tops include foam, latex, wool, and fiberfill. Natural fibers tend to be more durable than synthetic fiberfill, which varies in quality and may break down faster. 

Foam often provides deeper contouring than other materials but ranges widely in quality. In general, low-density foam is less durable than high-density foam. Those who want a more responsive pillow-top layer may prefer latex. The bouncy feel provides strong ease of movement, but this also means it will not hug the body as closely as foam. Latex is a natural material and more durable than foam.

The comfort layers and pillow-top rest above a layer of coils. Many hybrid models feature pocketed coils, but there are several other types of coil — offset, continuous wire, and Bonnell — which play a role in the overall feel and durability of the mattress.

Firmness

Pillow-top mattresses tend to feel less firm than traditional hybrid or innerspring mattresses, but keep in mind that mattress firmness is subjective. How a mattress feels depends largely on the sleeper’s body weight and sleeping position. For example, a person who weighs over 230 pounds may find a medium firm mattress too soft and prone to sinking, while a sleeper who weighs 130 pounds might find the same mattress too firm. The best firmness level for you is one that provides a comfortable balance of pressure relief and support. 

While pillow-tops usually suit sleepers who prefer softer beds, pillow-top and Euro-top mattresses are available in a range of firmness levels.

Feel and Support

Pillow-top mattresses are designed for sleepers who like a soft feel to their sleeping surface. The quilted surface layer cradles the body, while coils beneath push back. The balance of cushioning and support is important to maintaining healthy sleep posture. A mattress that promotes spinal alignment will offer enough cradling for the shoulders, hips, and spine while maintaining support for areas like the lower back. 

Pillow-tops are usually meant to feel soft and luxurious, but the rest of the mattress should still provide ample support. “As a sleep specialist, I emphasize that softness alone isn’t enough—support is key,” says sleep medicine physician Pranshu Adavadkar, M.D. “A pillow-top mattress should cushion pressure points but also provide a firm foundation to keep the lower back and spine properly aligned.”

Thickness

Because of the extra layer quilted on top, both pillow-top and Euro-top mattresses tend to have a taller profile than the average mattress. Standard mattress thickness is generally 10 to 12 inches. For a pillow-top, expect a range of 13 to 15 inches. You may need to purchase deep pocket sheets in order to fit the higher profile. 

Price

Shoppers looking for a cheap mattress with pressure relief sometimes opt for a pillow-top innerspring model, which tends to have a lower price-point. These models are typically less durable, but they cost as little as a few hundred dollars. 

Euro-top and pillow-top hybrid models usually carry a steeper price-point because of their higher quality materials and more complex construction. They may cost anywhere from $700 to over $3,000 for a queen size. You can usually find a quality Euro-top or pillow-top hybrid for between $1,000 and $2,000.

Many online mattress companies include free shipping. Some also provide services like old mattress disposal and White Glove delivery. Keep in mind that since pillow-top mattresses often have taller profiles, you may need to invest in deep pocket sheets.

Temperature Regulation

The thick comfort layer that pillow-tops provide can sometimes come with heat retention because the materials conform to the body, though this depends on the specific materials used. Memory foam conforms closely and can trap heat, while latex provides more gentle contouring. It’s also worth noting that pillow-tops are always found on coil mattresses, and coil support cores are great at encouraging airflow.

Edge Support

Edge support refers to a mattress’ ability to stand up to weight along its perimeter. Because a traditional pillow-top isn’t fully connected to the rest of the mattress, it is prone to sagging along the edge. Euro-tops, by contrast, have better edge support because the top is sewn to the rest of the bed, and Euro-tops often incorporate denser materials.

“For older adults or those with mobility issues, firm edge support offers added stability,” Dr. Adavadkar says. “It helps them sit comfortably on the side of the bed without sinking in, provides a stable surface to push off from when getting out of bed, and helps prevent the feeling of rolling off.”

Motion Isolation

The added plushness of a pillow-top helps absorb motion so it doesn’t travel across the surface of the bed. A pillow-top’s ability to isolate motion does depend on its materials. Foam absorbs motion better than fiberfill, for example. All-foam beds also take the prize when it comes to motion isolation as there is always some movement transfer in a coil bed.

Ease of Movement

The softness of a pillow-top can make it slightly more difficult to switch positions than a bed with a more even surface. That said, the coil layer offers push back, so pillow-tops tend to have better ease of movement than all-foam beds.

Which Mattress Types Feature a Pillow-Top?

Pillow-tops are usually found on hybrid and innerspring mattresses, since they’re typically meant to balance the coils with extra cushioning and contouring. Foam mattresses already offer strong conforming, so it’s rare to find a foam model with a pillow-top.

Hybrid

Definition: Hybrid mattresses combine sturdy coils with comfort layers made of foam, latex, or other conforming materials.

Highlight: These mattresses are intended to provide a balance of cradling and support with the combination of coils at the base and contouring materials on top. Adding a pillow-top boosts the cushioning even more.

Innerspring

Definition: The most simple, traditional mattress design, these beds consist of supportive coils encased in a cover.

Highlight: A pillow-top adds cushioning and pressure relief to the otherwise firm design.

How We Test: Your Comfort Is Our Science

Our industry-leading product testing team cares deeply about improving your sleep. Having a holistic understanding of a mattress’s role as part of a sleep system is paramount to our testing process. Since a bed’s comfort and feel depend largely on body weight and sleeping position, our testing team represents a wide range of body types, sleep positions, and comfort preferences.

In our Seattle-based Test Lab, we use an objective, hands-on process to evaluate mattresses across performance categories. The following are the key guidelines that inform our performance ratings. Our ultimate goal is to ensure you have all the information you need to make the best purchase decision for you.

Construction analysis: Mattress construction plays a major role in our ratings system. We begin our testing with a top-to-bottom analysis of each mattress, making note of its materials, firmness, thickness, and other physical attributes. Price-point is another major factor as we assess quality of materials and overall value.

Quantitative product testing: For hands-on testing, our team members take turns lying and moving on each mattress. This immersive process helps us evaluate beds for performance categories like motion isolation, pressure relief, ease of movement, and temperature control.

Field testing: Once we’re finished testing a mattress in our lab, one of our team members takes it home and sleeps on it in their own bedroom for two to three weeks. Field testing helps us understand how each mattress performs in the long term.

User feedback: In addition to our team’s testing data, we draw from customer surveys and product reviews to calculate our final ratings. This helps us ensure our findings are consistent with real-world experiences.

How We Determine Our Overall Scores

Performance Categories

Motion Isolation

This refers to the amount of motion a mattress absorbs when a sleeper moves on the surface. To evaluate motion isolation, we use two testers lying side by side who each feel for transfer while the other person moves on the mattress.

Temperature Control

To determine how well a mattress regulates temperature, we perform temperature tests and look closely at its materials and construction. Many mattresses are designed with cooling components meant to reduce heat retention.

Pressure Relief

A bed with strong pressure relief excels at preventing pressure from building up in areas like the shoulders and hips. Beds with even contouring and weight distribution are top performers when it comes to pressure relief.

Off-Gassing

A mattress in a box may release unpleasant chemical odors for a short period after you’ve unboxed it. The initial smell may be strong but typically fades within 2 or 3 days.

Ease of Movement

This reflects how easily a sleeper can move across a bed’s surface. Responsive surfaces made of latex typically perform better than foam surfaces, which can inhibit movement.

Edge Support

We perform sit tests along a bed’s perimeter to measure how well the edges push back against weight. Mattresses with strong edge support have minimal sagging when sleepers sit on or lie close to the perimeter.

Dive Deeper – Mattress Guides by Type

If you’re still not sure if a pillow-top mattress is the best choice for your specific needs, take a look at our other guides broken down by mattress type.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a pillow-top mattress last?

The lifespan of a pillow-top mattress can range from 3 years to more than 10, depending on the quality of construction and materials. For example, latex generally lasts well over eight years, while low-density foam may start to deteriorate after several years. On average, you can expect a quality pillow-top mattress to last five to seven years.

To prolong the life of your mattress, practice proper cleaning and care, rotate the bed on occasion, and consider investing in a mattress pad or mattress protector.

Are pillow-top mattresses good for back pain?

A pillow-top mattress that offers a combination of support and pressure relief will likely help relieve back pain. However, the ideal balance for each sleeper will vary according to sleeping position and body weight.

“A mattress with good lumbar support can make a significant difference for those with chronic back pain,” Dr. Adavadkar says “A pillow-top mattress with adequate support can offer both cushioning for pressure points and the necessary support to maintain natural spinal alignment. It can be the difference between frequent tossing and turning, waking up with a sore back, and enjoying a comfortable, refreshing sleep.”

How can you prevent a pillow-top mattress from sagging?

While pillow-top mattresses may be prone to sagging over time, you can enhance longevity by ensuring that the mattress has a proper bed frame. You can also opt for a mattress made from more durable materials such as latex.

Still have questions?

Our product experts have extensive experience testing just about every sleep product on the market.

Send an email to AskAnExpert@sleepfoundation.org with your questions and we’ll help you find exactly what you’re looking for.

Learn more about our Editorial Team