Best Pillow-Top Mattress of 2025
Find your perfect mattress in less than 10 seconds
When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Products or services may be offered by an affiliated entity. Learn more.
Pillow-top mattresses have a layer of extra material sewn on top, typically designed to add a touch of inviting comfort. A traditional pillow-top gives the appearance of an additional layer sitting on top of the mattress, while a Euro-top lines up flush with the edge of the layers beneath. Our list of the best pillow-top mattresses include both types of models. We’ll discuss our top picks in-depth below and share some tips for buying a new pillow-top or Euro-top mattress.
Our Top Picks
-
Best Mattress Overall – WinkBed
View Details
-
Best Luxury Mattress – Saatva Classic
View Details
-
Most Comfortable Mattress – Nolah Evolution 15
View Details
-
Best Mattress for Back Pain – Cloverlane Hybrid
View Details
-
Best Mattress for Heavy Sleepers – Saatva HD
View Details
Swipe for more
Best Mattress Overall
WinkBed
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
Get $300 off all mattresses at Winkbeds
Get $300 off all mattresses at Winkbeds
In the solidly built WinkBed, the comfortable pillow-top is the icing on the cake. It enhances the feel and support of this mattress, which delivers solid across-the-board performance and is offered in four different firmness options.
Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,499
Mattress Type
Innerspring
Firmness Options
Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7), Firm (8)
Trial Period
120 nights (30 night requirement)
At a Glance
- Who It’s Best For: Sleepers of any weight and position can find a model that meets their needs.
- Feel: Depends on firmness level, but all have an inviting pillow-top and zoned support for pressure relief.
- What It’s Made Of: Tencel cover, cooling gel-infused polyfoam, and a pocketed coil base layer. Depending on the model, additional comfort layers are made of either polyfoam or natural latex.
- What We Don’t Like: May be too bouncy and transfer motion. Odor can linger up to 72 hours after unboxing.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 8573 validated customer reviews of the Winkbed. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Pain Relief and Support: A significant number of users report alleviation of back, hip, and shoulder pain, attributing this to the mattress’s supportive design. Individuals with chronic back issues have noted substantial improvements in sleep quality.
- Comfort Across Sleep Positions: Reviewers from various sleep positions—side, back, and stomach—find the mattress comfortable. The availability of different firmness levels allows users to select options that best suit their sleeping style.
- Temperature Regulation: Many customers appreciate the mattress’s ability to stay cool, enhancing overall comfort throughout the night.
- Edge Support: Users frequently mention the robust edge support, which provides a stable and usable sleeping surface across the entire mattress.
- Firmness Options: Customers appreciate the variety of firmness options available, finding the right balance for their personal preferences.
- Durability and Craftsmanship: The mattress is often praised for its high-quality construction and materials, with users expressing confidence in its longevity. The lifetime warranty further reinforces trust in the product’s durability.
- Customer Service and Trial Experience: Customers value the 120-night risk-free trial and responsive customer service, noting that these factors contribute to a positive purchasing experience.
Best Value Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid – Medium
8.4 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide. Code: PRESDAY25
25% off sitewide. Code: PRESDAY25
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is our choice for the best value pillow-top mattress. While the pillow-top doesn’t come standard, as an optional add-on it elevates the already high-quality performance of this hybrid with even better cushioning and temperature regulation.
Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$999
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night requirement)
At a Glance
- Who It’s Best For: Side sleepers. Stomach and back sleepers may also be able to find a firmness level that suits them.
- Feel: Depends on firmness level. Cloud-like pillow-top with extra cradling for shoulders and hips.
- What It’s Made Of: Two adaptive polyfoam layers and a base of thick pocketed coils. The 2-inch cloud pillow-top features additional foam layers and a temperature-regulating fabric.
- What We Don’t Like: Costs more than the standard Signature Hybrid. Return fee of $99.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 11,922 validated customer reviews of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and support: Many reviewers mention that the mattress is very comfortable and provides good support for various sleeping positions.
- Improvement in sleep quality: Several users report a significant improvement in sleep quality, including better rest and reduced pain.
- Firmness options: People appreciate the availability of different firmness levels, and some discuss their experiences with medium, firm, or pillow-top options.
- RV suitability: A number of reviews specifically mention using the mattress in RVs, noting it as a substantial upgrade from typical RV mattresses.
- Initial odor/smell: Some reviewers note a mild odor upon unpacking, but it typically dissipates quickly.
- Edge support: The mattress is often noted for having good edge support, which is particularly valued by those who sit on the edge of the bed.
- Price and value: Many reviewers feel the mattress is well-priced for the quality and comfort it provides.
- Durability concerns: A few reviewers express concerns about how the mattress will hold up over time, although these comments are not widespread.
Best Luxury Mattress
Saatva Classic
9.4 /10
Test Lab Score
$300 off for purchases of $1,000 or more
$300 off for purchases of $1,000 or more
The Saatva Classic’s carefully selected materials and sleek Euro-top make it our choice for the best luxury mattress. Its innovative coil-on-coil design keeps you comfortably supported, and this mattress comes with the luxury perk of free White Glove delivery and installation.
Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,795
Mattress Type
Innerspring
Firmness Options
Soft (3), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period
365 Nights ($99 Return Fee)
At a Glance
- Who It’s Best For: Sleepers of any position and body weight, depending on model.
- Feel: Luxe but feels sturdy from edge-to-edge, stays cool, and gently cushions your body.
- What It’s Made Of: Thin layer of microcoils that sit on top of taller pocketed coils. On top, a resilient polyfoam and a comfort-boosting lumbar pad made of memory foam.
- What We Don’t Like: Return fee of $99.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 3308 validated customer reviews of the Saatva Classic. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Delivery Service: Positive feedback on the delivery process is common, with customers highlighting the professionalism and efficiency of the delivery teams. The white glove delivery service, including old mattress removal, is frequently praised.
- Comfort and Firmness: Customers appreciate the customizable firmness options, with Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm levels catering to diverse preferences.
- Durability: Long-term users report that the mattress maintains its comfort and support over the years, indicating good durability and quality construction.
- Material Quality: Customers appreciate the safe and high-quality materials used in the mattress, such as the absence of harmful chemicals and the use of organic cotton.
- Temperature Regulation: Some reviewers specifically mention sleeping cooler on the Saatva Classic, highlighting its temperature regulation features that contribute to a more comfortable sleep.
- Adjustability and Customization: The ability to customize the mattress for personal needs, like the split king option with different firmness levels, is a significant plus for many customers.
Best Mattress for Side Sleepers
Helix Midnight Luxe
9.7 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide
25% off sitewide
Equipped with a foam-filled Euro-top, the Helix Midnight Luxe takes home the top spot for side sleepers. It helps side sleepers settle into a healthy posture thanks to contouring memory foam and responsive pocketed coils.
Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,899
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period
100 nights (30-night requirement)
At a Glance
- Who It’s Best For: Side sleepers up to 230 pounds. Many back sleepers under 230 pounds.
- Feel: Medium firm (6). Softens impact around the hips and shoulders but keeps you supported and prevents unwanted sagging.
- What It’s Made Of: Memory foam and adaptive polyfoam layers and a smooth Tencel cover. Add-on options include ergonomic lumbar support in the top layer and cooling fabric in the cover. Support core is tall coils and base polyfoam.
- What We Don’t Like: Add-on features raise the total cost. Often a “new mattress smell” for up to a couple of days after unboxing.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 5876 validated customer reviews of the Helix Midnight Luxe. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Comfort and Support: Many reviewers express that the mattress provides exceptional comfort and support, especially noting its ability to alleviate back, hip, and shoulder pain.
- Sleep Quality Improvement: The mattress is frequently described as transformative for those who previously struggled with sleep disturbances.
- Temperature Regulation: Positive remarks are made about the cooling properties of the mattress. Users find the cooling aspect effective, helping to maintain a comfortable sleeping temperature throughout the night.
- Customer Service: Experiences with customer service are predominantly positive, with buyers appreciating the responsive and helpful nature of the support team. Issues are resolved satisfactorily, contributing to a positive overall customer experience.
- Durability Concerns: A few reviewers express concerns about the mattress showing signs of wear or sagging prematurely. These concerns are not widespread but are significant enough to be noted by potential buyers.
- Mixed Reviews on Firmness: While many find the mattress perfectly balanced, there are mixed reviews regarding its firmness. Some users find it softer than expected given its firmness level. While the ‘medium firm’ rating is appropriate by our measurements, the bed does have a ‘cushy’ foam feel that makes for a fairly soft surface feel.
Most Comfortable Mattress
Nolah Evolution 15
9.2 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide. Save an additional $50 with code: SF50
25% off sitewide. Save an additional $50 with code: SF50
If what you want is comfort, the best pillow-top mattress is the Nolah Evolution 15. Its Euro-style pillow-top is extra thick and lightly embraces your body to help ease you into a peaceful night of sleep.
Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$1,624
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Trial Period
120 nights (30-night requirement), $99 return pickup fee
At a Glance
- Who It’s Best For: Most sleepers, depending on firmness option.
- Feel: Medium (5), medium firm (6), and firm (8). Supportive with some bounce and plenty of cushioning. Allows for easy movement and resists heat buildup.
- What It’s Made Of: A layer of adaptive polyfoam and three other polyfoam layers. Durable pocketed coils, zoned for ergonomic support.
- What We Don’t Like: Standard fitted sheets won’t stay in place. Return fee of $99.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 897 validated customer reviews of the Nolah Evolution 15. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Motion Isolation: Couples note the excellent motion isolation, which minimizes disruptions from partner movements during the night.
- Edge Support: The edge support of the mattress is frequently highlighted, with many finding it adequate for sitting or sleeping near the edge without feeling like they will roll off.
- Softness: Many reviewers discuss the softness of the mattress. Some find it too soft, causing discomfort, especially for heavier individuals, while others appreciate the plushness.
- Pressure Relief and Support: Reviewers frequently highlight relief from back and shoulder pain, attributing this to the supportive foam layers and zoned coil system.
- Heat Retention: A few reviewers note that the mattress retains heat, making it uncomfortable for some, particularly in warmer climates or for those who sleep hot.
- Durability and Quality: Users often comment on the high quality and durability of the mattress, noting that it maintains its shape and comfort over time.
Best Temperature Regulating Mattress
Birch Luxe Mattress
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide
25% off sitewide
All layers of the Birch Luxe — from the pillow-top to the base — contribute to cooler sleep, making this our pick for the best temperature-regulating mattress. It’s also made with eco-friendly materials that cushion and support your body for dynamic all-around performance.
Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$2,099
Mattress Type
Latex Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Firm (6)
Trial Period
100 nights (30-night requirement)
At a Glance
- Who It’s Best For: Hot sleepers, side and back sleepers under 230 pounds, and lighter-weight stomach sleepers.
- Feel: Bouncy but with moderate contouring around heavier areas. Stays cool.
- What It’s Made Of
- Organic cotton and wool cover includes pillow-top stuffed with organic wool and organic latex. Core of pocketed coils keeps the mattress ventilated.
- What We Don’t Like: Bouncy materials can cause motion transfer.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 163 validated customer reviews of the Birch Luxe. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Organic and Eco-Friendly: The mattress is appreciated for being made from natural materials, which is a significant plus for environmentally conscious consumers and those sensitive to chemicals.
- Heat Regulation: Several users have noted that the mattress does not retain heat, making for a cooler sleeping experience compared to other brands.
- Motion Isolation: Couples have reported that the mattress does a good job of isolating motion, meaning that partners are not disturbed by each other’s movements during the night.
- Heavy and Difficult to Set Up: Some negative feedback includes the mattress being heavy and difficult to set up, which could be a challenge for some buyers.
- Price: The mattress is more expensive than other options, but many users feel that the quality and comfort justify the cost.
- Customer Service: There are mixed reviews on customer service, with some customers experiencing great service, while others faced challenges, particularly concerning delivery and handling issues.
Best Mattress for Back Pain
Cloverlane Hybrid
8.7 /10
Test Lab Score
Save up to 50% on mattresses
Save up to 50% on mattresses
With three firmness options and a Euro-style pillow-top, the Cloverlane Hybrid can provide the right support for your back with a cushioned and responsive feel. Materials focused on ventilation minimize heat retention, and each order comes with free White Glove delivery.
Price
$1,399
Mattress Type
Hybrid
Firmness Options
Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)
Trial Period
365 nights (30-night requirement)
At a Glance
- Who It’s Best For: Back and stomach sleepers (firm models) and side sleepers under 130 pounds (medium soft).
- Feel: Elegant and regal with pillow-top accommodating pressure points and lower back.
- What It’s Made Of: Responsive polyfoam with extra lumbar support. Other comfort layers include gel-infused memory foam, polyfoam, and latex, and the base is composed of pocketed coils with dense foam around the edges.
- What We Don’t Like: Can trap heat, and stomach sleepers may find it lacks firmness and support.
Scoring Breakdown
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
Best Mattress for Heavy Sleepers
Saatva HD
8.8 /10
Test Lab Score
$300 off for purchases of $1,000 or more
$300 off for purchases of $1,000 or more
The best pillow-top mattress for sleepers with a higher body weight is the Saatva HD. Its sturdy design with high-end materials, including a tall Euro-style pillow-top, makes it a reliable source of support for people over 230 pounds.
Credit: Sleep Foundation Test Lab
Price
$2,945
Mattress Type
Innerspring
Firmness Options
Firm (7)
Trial Period
365 Nights ($99 Return Fee)
At a Glance
- Who It’s Best For: Sleepers who weigh between 230 and 500 pounds, regardless of sleeping position.
- Feel: Firm (7) and supportive. Provides notable pressure relief while staying stable and even.
- What It’s Made Of: Euro-top filled with fabric and foam bolstered by polyfoam, natural latex, and memory foam. Coils in the support core are thick and encased in dense foam.
- What We Don’t Like: Too firm for people under 230 pounds. Not compatible with all bed frames and foundations.
Scoring & Reviews
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
We performed a meta-analysis on 133 validated customer reviews of the Saatva HD. This is what people who bought the mattress had to say:- Quality of Materials: Users frequently comment on the high-quality materials and construction of the mattress, noting its durability and the luxurious feel of the fabrics used.
- Positive Impact: Several reviewers mention significant improvements in sleep quality and reductions in back and joint pain since switching to this mattress.
- Customer Service: The customer service provided by Saatva receives high marks for being helpful, responsive, and accommodating, enhancing the overall purchasing experience.
- Delivery and Setup: The delivery and setup process is often described as efficient and professional, with many appreciating the white glove delivery service that includes setup and old mattress removal.
- Price and Value: Reviewers feel that the mattress represents good value for money, considering its quality and the level of service provided.
- Heavy and Bulky: Some users find the mattress to be quite heavy and difficult to move or adjust, which can make changing sheets or moving the mattress challenging.
Best Mattress for Couples
Naturepedic EOS Pillow Top
8.6 /10
Test Lab Score
15% off with code: SF15
15% off with code: SF15
The EOS Pillow Top is our top choice for couples because you can select a distinct firmness feel for the two sides of the bed. The mattress also uses eco-conscious materials, including responsive organic latex in the supportive pillow-top.
Price
$4,799
Mattress Type
Latex Hybrid
Firmness Options
Soft (3), Medium Soft (4), Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)
Trial Period
90 nights (30-night requirement)
At a Glance
- Who It’s Best For: Couples with different firmness preferences.
- Feel: Depends on firmness level. But all models support the body and encourage ease of movement.
- What It’s Made Of: Organic cotton cover along with organic wool, plant-based fiber fill, and multiple layers of organic latex. An 8-inch layer of individually wrapped coils as a base.
- What We Don’t Like: Expensive and some assembly required.
Scoring Breakdown
The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights. These scores are determined by how well the mattress supports and relieves pressure for each sleeper type.
- Above-average motion isolation: Thanks to the extra padding layer, many pillow-top mattresses absorb and isolate movement better than other innersprings and hybrids.
- Soothing pressure relief: Pillow-top mattresses tend to feel softer and cushier on their surfaces, and this can benefit people who frequently feel pain and pressure points in their shoulders, lower back, and hips.
- Perimeter reinforcement: Many of the best pillow-top mattresses feature thicker coils along their perimeters. This helps push back against your weight and reduce sinkage when you sit or sleep close to the edge of your bed.
How We Evaluated & Reviewed
- Meta Analysis: Of the 2,000+ mattresses in our product database, roughly 150 contain pillow-top or Euro-top layers. Based on historical data and construction analyses, our team chose the top 30 models for in-depth testing to help us determine the best pillow-top mattresses on the market today.
- Test Lab Evaluations: In our Seattle Test Lab, our team thoroughly evaluated each of the top 30 pillow-top mattresses. We used state-of-the-art tools and technology to assess mattresses for pressure relief, motion isolation, edge support, and other important performance metrics. Our team includes testers in different weight and sleep position groups to ensure our findings are inclusive of all sleepers.
- Field Testing: After our hands-on tests had concluded, we sent each pillow-top mattress home with a team member to sleep on in their own bedroom for up to two weeks. Field testing helps us determine how well a mattress performs for a prolonged period of time in a real-world sleep environment.
- User Reviews: We collected data from roughly 31,000 reviews and surveys from verified owners of pillow-top mattresses. This extra step lets us know whether or not our team’s initial findings line up with real-world experiences.
The Best Deals of The Week
-
Save $166
—
Brooklyn Bedding CopperFlex Memory Foam
$499 (List Price $665) -
Save $593
—
Helix Midnight Luxe
$1,780 (List Price $2,373) -
Save $2,518
—
Nectar Adjustable Bundle
$1,398 (List Price $3,916) -
Save $300
—
WinkBed
$1,499 (List Price $1,799) -
Save $965
—
DreamCloud Mattress
$699 (List Price $1,664)
Best Mattress Overall
WinkBed
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
Get $300 off all mattresses at Winkbeds
Shop NowThe WinkBed’s padded pillow-top complements a hybrid with impressive all-around performance.
See More Details
Best Value Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid – Medium
8.4 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide. Code: PRESDAY25
Shop NowAn optional cloud-like pillow-top gives this hybrid excellent performance and value.
See More Details
Best Luxury Mattress
Saatva Classic
9.4 /10
Test Lab Score
$300 off for purchases of $1,000 or more
Shop NowA luxurious pillow-top mattress with the added perk of free White Glove delivery.
See More Details
Best Mattress for Side Sleepers
Helix Midnight Luxe
9.7 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide
Shop NowA pillow-top hybrid with comfortable materials that cradle the heavy joints of side sleepers.
See More Details
Most Comfortable Mattress
Nolah Evolution 15
9.2 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide. Save an additional $50 with code: SF50
Shop NowA hybrid whose pillow-top and responsive foam layers provide comfortable, targeted support.
See More Details
Best Temperature Regulating Mattress
Birch Luxe Mattress
8.9 /10
Test Lab Score
25% off sitewide
Shop NowNatural and sustainable materials power this pillow-top that’s ideal for hot sleepers.
See More Details
Best Mattress for Back Pain
Cloverlane Hybrid
8.7 /10
Test Lab Score
Save up to 50% on mattresses
Shop NowThe Cloverlane Hybrid’s Euro-top with lumbar support is engineered to ward off back pain.
See More Details
Best Mattress for Heavy Sleepers
Saatva HD
8.8 /10
Test Lab Score
$300 off for purchases of $1,000 or more
Shop NowThe Saatva HD has a tall pillow-top that enhances comfort for heavier sleepers.
See More Details
Best Mattress for Couples
Naturepedic EOS Pillow Top
8.6 /10
Test Lab Score
15% off with code: SF15
Shop NowA high-end hybrid with a responsive pillow-top and the option to have a different firmness level on each side.
See More Details
What Is a Pillow-Top Mattress and Who Should Sleep on One?
Pillow-top mattresses feature an extra top layer designed to enhance cushioning or responsiveness on the surface. The layer is typically composed of foam, latex, wool, or various fibers, and usually measures 2 to 4 inches. The edge of the pillow-top layer is not attached to the edge of the layer beneath, which gives it a cloudlike feel.
In general, side and back sleepers appreciate the extra padding of pillow-tops. This mattress type is also ideal for those seeking greater contouring or cushioning than conventional innerspring and hybrid mattresses. It’s also a good match for people who simply prefer a plush sleep surface.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
Who Should Not Sleep on a Pillow-Top Mattress?
In general, pillow-top mattresses are not ideal for sleepers who weigh over 230 pounds or who prefer a firm sleeping surface. Heavier sleepers, especially those who sleep on their back or stomach, need strong support. The cushioning of a pillow-top may cause these sleepers to sink uncomfortably deep.
Pillow-Top vs. Euro-Top
While pillow-tops and Euro-tops both feature a soft 2- to 4-inch layer sewn to the top of the mattress, there are several important differences between the two models. On a pillow-top, the perimeter of the surface layer is not attached to the mattress layers beneath. By contrast, the perimeter of the Euro-top surface layer is sewn onto the rest of the bed, creating a seamless appearance. Euro-tops also sometimes use denser materials that make the top layer feel more integrated with the mattress.
Euro-tops are often available in a wider range of firmness levels and can accommodate more types of sleepers. They also offer stronger edge support and better durability than traditional pillow-tops. As a result, Euro-tops generally carry a higher price-point. That said, they don’t always offer the immediately plush sensation that sleepers expect from a pillow-top.
Which Mattress Types Feature a Pillow-Top?
Pillow-tops are usually found on hybrid and innerspring mattresses, since they’re typically meant to balance the coils with extra cushioning and contouring. Foam mattresses already offer strong conforming, so it’s rare to find a foam model with a pillow-top.
| Mattress Type | Description | How it Performs |
|---|---|---|
| Hybrid | Hybrid mattresses combine sturdy coils with comfort layers made of foam, latex, or other conforming materials. | These mattresses are intended to provide a balance of cradling and support. Adding a pillow-top boosts the cushioning. |
| Innerspring | The most simple, traditional mattress design, these beds consist of supportive coils encased in a cover. | A pillow-top adds cushioning and pressure relief to the otherwise firm design. |
What Should You Look for in a Pillow-Top Mattress?
There are a number of factors to consider when choosing a mattress, whether it’s a pillow-top or not. We’ll walk you through some of the main considerations and explain how they vary according to a sleeper’s individual needs and preferences.
Materials
Materials determine the quality and feel of the entire mattress, including the pillow-top layer. Common materials used in pillow-tops include foam, latex, wool, and fiberfill. Natural fibers tend to be more durable than synthetic fiberfill, which varies in quality and may break down faster.
Foam often provides deeper contouring than other materials but ranges widely in quality. In general, low-density foam is less durable than high-density foam. Those who want a more responsive pillow-top layer may prefer latex. The bouncy feel provides strong ease of movement, but this also means it will not hug the body as closely as foam. Latex is generally a more natural and durable material than foam.
The comfort layers and pillow-top rest above a layer of coils. Many hybrid models feature pocketed coils, but there are several other types of coil — offset, continuous wire, and Bonnell — which play a role in the overall feel and durability of the mattress.
Firmness
Pillow-top mattresses tend to feel less firm than traditional hybrid or innerspring mattresses, but keep in mind that mattress firmness is subjective. How a mattress feels depends largely on the sleeper’s body weight and sleeping position. For example, a person who weighs over 230 pounds may find a medium firm mattress too soft and prone to sinking, while a sleeper who weighs 130 pounds might find the same mattress too firm. The best firmness level for you is one that provides a comfortable balance of pressure relief and support.
While pillow-tops usually suit sleepers who prefer softer beds, pillow-top and Euro-top mattresses are available in a range of firmness levels.
Feel and Support
Pillow-top mattresses are designed for sleepers who like a soft feel to their sleeping surface. The quilted surface layer cradles the body, while coils beneath push back. The balance of cushioning and support is important to maintaining healthy sleep posture. A mattress that promotes spinal alignment will offer enough cradling for the shoulders, hips, and spine while maintaining support for areas like the lower back.
Pillow-tops are usually meant to feel soft and luxurious, but the rest of the mattress should still provide ample support.
Watch Video: Benefits of Pressure Relief
In the video below, we’ll discuss why pressure relief is an important mattress quality, ways to determine how well a mattress alleviates pressure, and which types of mattresses generally perform well for pressure relief.
Thickness
Because of the extra layer quilted on top, both pillow-top and Euro-top mattresses tend to have a taller profile than the average mattress. Standard mattress thickness is generally 10 to 12 inches. For a pillow-top, expect a range of 13 to 15 inches. You may need to purchase deep pocket sheets in order to fit the higher profile.
Price
Shoppers looking for a cheap mattress with pressure relief sometimes opt for a pillow-top innerspring model, which tends to have a lower price-point. These models are typically less durable, but they cost as little as a few hundred dollars.
Euro-top and pillow-top hybrid models usually carry a steeper price-point because of their higher quality materials and more complex construction. They may cost anywhere from $700 to over $3,000 for a queen size. You can usually find a quality Euro-top or pillow-top hybrid for between $1,000 and $2,000.
Many online mattress companies include free shipping. Some also provide services like old mattress disposal and White Glove delivery. Keep in mind that since pillow-top mattresses often have taller profiles, you may need to invest in deep pocket sheets.
How We Test: Your Comfort Is Our Science
Our industry-leading product testing team cares deeply about improving your sleep. Having a holistic understanding of a mattress’s role as part of a sleep system is paramount to our testing process. Since a bed’s comfort and feel depend largely on body weight and sleeping position, our testing team represents a wide range of body types, sleep positions, and comfort preferences.
In our Seattle-based Test Lab, we use an objective, hands-on process to evaluate mattresses across performance categories. The following are the key guidelines that inform our performance ratings. Our ultimate goal is to ensure you have all the information you need to make the best purchase decision for you.
Construction analysis: Our rating system is grounded in construction. Each mattress rating is derived at the intersection of quality, value, and versatility across a range of sleepers. We look at the bed’s price point, materials, firmness options, comfort and support systems, cooling technology, as well as brand reputation, and then we perform a detailed analysis that measures performance across six different categories to arrive at an overall score.
Quantitative product testing: During these hands-on lab tests, our team uses various tools and technology to evaluate a bed’s performance against motion isolation, pressure relief, temperature control, ease of movement, edge support, and potential for odor emissions. We use the outcomes from these tests to calculate a score for each category.
Field testing: Our field testers sleep on mattresses and other sleep products, like pillows, sheets, and mattress toppers, in their own bedrooms. After weeks of at-home testing, each field tester provides a detailed analysis of how the mattress performs, including what they like and dislike about the bed.
User feedback: Observations from mattress owners and users outside our team are invaluable to our research. We draw insight from surveys, sleep stories, and customer reviews to extract themes, fine-tune our ratings, and better understand how each product performs over time in a real-world setting.
How We Determine Our Overall Scores
To determine a mattress’s overall score, we assign weighted percentages to performance categories based on how important they are to the individual sleep experience. For instance, areas like pressure relief and temperature control tend to matter more to people than something like off-gassing, and because more people sleep on their side and back than on their stomach, we weigh those positions more heavily.
Performance Categories
Motion Isolation
This criteria alludes to the amount of motion a mattress absorbs when a sleeper moves on the surface. We use two testers lying side by side to evaluate motion isolation, who each feel for transfer while the other person moves on the mattress.
Temperature Control
To determine how well a mattress regulates temperature, we perform temperature tests and look closely at its materials and construction. Many mattresses are designed with cooling components meant to reduce heat retention.
Pressure Relief
A bed with strong pressure relief excels at preventing pressure from building up in areas like the shoulders and hips. Beds with even contouring and weight distribution are top performers when it comes to pressure relief.
Off-Gassing
A mattress in a box may release unpleasant chemical odors for a short period after you’ve unboxed it. The initial smell may be strong but typically fades within 2 or 3 days.
Ease of Movement
This criteria reflects how easily a sleeper can move across a bed’s surface. Responsive surfaces made of latex typically perform better than foam surfaces, which can inhibit movement.
Edge Support
We perform sit tests along a bed’s perimeter to measure how well the edges push back against weight. Mattresses with strong edge support have minimal sagging when sleepers sit on or lie close to the perimeter.
Dive Deeper – Mattress Guides by Type
If you’re still not sure if a pillow-top mattress is the best choice for your specific needs, take a look at our other guides broken down by mattress type.
Best Mattress by Type
- Best Mattress in a Box
- Best RV Mattress
- Best Mattress in Canada
- Best Smart Mattress
- Best Online Mattress
- Best Flippable Mattress
- Best Airbed Mattress
- Best Mattress for Bunk Beds
- Best Mattress on Amazon
- Best Temporary Air Mattress
- Best Walmart Mattress
- Best Memory Foam Mattress
- Best Crib Mattress
- Best Gel Mattress
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a pillow-top mattress?
A pillow-top mattress has a 2- to 4-inch layer of cushioning sewn directly onto the top to provide a soft, plush sleeping surface. On a standard pillow-top, the edges do not connect to the perimeter of the mattress, while Euro-top mattresses integrate the edges of this top layer into the lower layers of the mattress.
How does it feel to sleep on a pillow-top mattress?
As the name suggests, sleeping on a pillow-top mattress feels somewhat like having a large, plush pillow beneath your body. That said, the specific sleeping experience varies depending on the materials used and the overall firmness of the layers beneath.
How long does a pillow-top mattress last?
The lifespan of a pillow-top mattress can range from three years to more than 10, depending on the quality of construction and materials. For example, latex generally lasts well over eight years, while low-density foam may start to deteriorate after several years. On average, you can expect a quality pillow-top mattress to last five to seven years.
To prolong the life of your mattress, practice proper cleaning and care, rotate the bed on occasion, and consider investing in a mattress pad or mattress protector.
Are pillow-top mattresses good for back pain?
A pillow-top mattress that offers a combination of support and pressure relief will likely help relieve back pain. However, the ideal balance for each sleeper will vary according to sleeping position and body weight.
Is there a difference between a pillow-top and hybrid mattress?
The term pillow-top applies exclusively to mattresses with a soft layer sewn onto the top, but a hybrid mattress is any model that combines a coiled support system with comfort layers made from other materials. While many pillow-top mattresses are also hybrids, not all hybrids have pillow-top designs.
How can you prevent a pillow-top mattress from sagging?
While pillow-top mattresses may be prone to sagging over time, you can enhance longevity by ensuring that the mattress has a proper bed frame. You can also opt for a mattress made from more durable materials such as latex.
Still have questions?
Our product experts have extensive experience testing just about every sleep product on the market.
Send an email to [email protected] with your questions and we’ll help you find exactly what you’re looking for.
Logan is a Certified Sleep Science Coach with a deep understanding of what it means to struggle with sleep. Her years of experience researching and testing sleep products – including mattresses, natural sleep aids, and bedding – are critical to her role helping lead the editorial team. As a chronic insomniac, she aims to bring her findings to anyone struggling with getting adequate rest. Her expertise is in creating informative, trustworthy, and useful health content. When she’s not testing mattresses or researching CBT-I, she enjoys spending time in the sunshine with her husband and her dogs Pepper and Winston.