Home / Best Mattress of 2021 / Best Custom Mattress

Best Custom Mattress

Sleepfoundation.org is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Written by

Austin Meadows

author

People buying a new bed have thousands of options to choose from, but there’s still a place for custom mattresses and countless reasons why someone might choose one. Whether you are looking for a bed in a nonstandard shape or size, need greater control over firmness or materials, or want someone to create the bed you haven’t been able to find, a custom mattress offers the flexibility and control you need.

That said, more control over the final product can mean a more stressful buying experience. People looking for a custom bed must first decide on a manufacturer, which often requires an in-depth understanding of mattress construction as well as their own needs. They are then faced with the customization process, which can sometimes be time-consuming and overwhelming.

To help shoppers create the best custom mattress for their needs, we’ll highlight a few of our favorite custom mattress manufacturers. We’ll also break down the different types of custom mattresses and all the information you need to confidently design your custom bed.

The Best Custom Mattresses

Product Details

Brooklyn Bedding Custom

Best Overall

Brooklyn Bedding Custom

Brooklyn Bedding Custom
Mattress Type: Hybrid
Firmness: Soft (3), Medium (5), Firm (7)
Trial length: 120 nights (30-night requirement)
Trial length: 120 nights (30-night requirement)
Warranty: 10 Year, Limited
Warranty: 10 Year, Limited
Sizes: Queen, King, California King
Who it's best for:
  • Couples with different firmness preferences
  • Hot sleepers
  • People who sleep close to the edges of their mattress
Highlights:
  • Customizable firmness, comfort layer composition, and cover material
  • All models feature sturdy, 8-inch pocketed coils
  • Dual-firmness options for king and Cali king sizes
Brooklyn Bedding Custom

Save 20% on a Brooklyn Bedding mattress with this code: sleepfoundation20

Brooklyn Bedding is one of the only online mattress brands to offer a customizable mattress model. All versions of the Brooklyn Custom are hybrid models with pocketed coil support cores, but customers choose from a selection of firmness levels, comfort layer components, and cover fabrics based on their needs and preferences.

The mattress is available in three firmness levels: soft (3), medium (5), and firm (7). You can order a mattress with a uniform feel across the entire surface, or a dual-firmness model if you and your partner don’t share the same preferences. You can also choose from three options for the comfort layer composition. TitanFlex polyfoam is a dense and responsive material, the gel-infused memory foam contours closely without trapping heat, and the ventilated latex conforms gently and promotes airflow near the surface.

Additionally, customers pick from three cover fabrics, all of which have cooling properties. The organic cotton cover has a soft feel and also wicks away moisture from your body on humid nights. The circular-knit polyester feels cool to the touch and has a sleek texture. Lastly, the Recovery Upcycle material absorbs heat and converts it into infrared energy – a process thought to help the body recover during sleep. This fabric is quite breathable, as well.

The Brooklyn Custom has a price-point that falls in line with other customizable models and the price remains the same regardless of specific settings you choose. Shipping is also free for all orders within the contiguous U.S. The mattress is subject to the same 120-night sleep trial and 10-year warranty offered with other Brooklyn Bedding mattresses. The company offers ongoing discounts to military personnel, first responders, medical providers, educators, and college students.

Tochta

Best Luxury

Tochta

Tochta
Mattress Type: Foam
Who it's best for:
  • Couples with different firmness needs
  • Sleepers whose firmness needs vary over time
  • Anyone who prefers the feel of a foam mattress
Highlights:
  • Choice of three customizable mattresses
  • Divini model can be adjusted at home to customize feel over time
  • All models have a 10-year limited warranty
Tochta

Use this SleepFoundation.org link for the most current discount on Tochta mattresses

American mattress manufacturer Tochta offers a range of three customizable mattresses, direct from their South Carolina factory. The company has been in operation for 25 years, with a user-friendly design process that allows streamlined customization without overwhelming the shopper.

Each of Tochta’s three mattresses have an all-foam construction. All three are available in standard sizes, but shoppers can also customize the dimensions and corner shapes.

Tochta’s budget-friendly option, the Journey, has a gel memory foam comfort layer and a balanced, medium firm feel that should appeal to most sleepers above 130 pounds regardless of their preferred sleep position. Tochta’s most popular mattress, the Utopia, combines gel memory foam and latex comfort layers for a responsive medium firm feel that has more bounce than most all-foam beds. Like the Journey, the Utopia should be suitable for most sleepers over 130 pounds.

The Divini is Tochta’s most customizable mattress. Its dual-zone construction allows customers to choose a firmness level for each side of the bed, ranging from ultra-soft to ultra-firm. Should your firmness needs change over time, you can take the Divini apart to rearrange the high-density polyfoam support layers under the gel memory foam comfort layer to change the overall feel. The support core has a raised perimeter that keeps each layer in place while providing above-average edge support. Customers also have the option of an 8-inch or 10-inch profile.

Tochta currently ships for free within the contiguous states. Additional charges apply for mattresses shipped to Alaska and Hawaii. The company provides a 100-night sleep trial, during which time customers can return their undamaged mattress for a full refund. All mattresses have a 10-year limited warranty that covers manufacturing defects, including lingering impressions greater than 1.5 inches.

Mattress Insider

Best Selection

Mattress Insider

Mattress Insider
Mattress Type: Foam, Latex, Innerspring
Who it's best for:
  • Customers looking for start-to-finish customization
  • Sleepers who prefer the feel of specific mattress types, like innerspring, that are less commonly customizable
  • Anyone who needs their custom mattress within a short time frame
Highlights:
  • Fully custom mattress from start to finish
  • Choose preferred firmness level, materials, mattress style and more
  • 10-year warranty
Mattress Insider

Use this SleepFoundation.org link for the most current discount on Mattress Insider mattresses

Mattress Insider is a Colorado-based mattress manufacturer that offers both unusually sized mattresses — such as truck/RV and oversized mattresses — and start-to-finish customization services.

Customers who order through Mattress Insider have full control over their mattress design. This begins with the type of mattress, and the company offers common varieties like foam, innerspring, and latex. Mattresses can be purchased in any custom dimensions a customer requires, including beveling and overall shape. Given that many custom manufacturers only allow for length and width customization, this in-depth control is likely to make Mattress Insider an attractive choice for those buying a mattress to fit antique furniture or any unusually shaped space.

Along with mattress type and dimensions, customers can choose their preferred firmness level for comfort and support. They can also choose among MattressInsider’s three cover options: organic cotton, moisture-wicking polyester, and bamboo-derived rayon.

Mattress Insider also sells custom mattresses for hospital beds, rollaway beds, cots, sofa beds, and other nonstandard frames. Not all customization details may be available for all frames, but the company provides a greater range of options than many of its competitors.

Most custom mattress orders are completed within 5 to 7 business days, though more complex creations may take longer to manufacture. Free shipping through FedEx is available within all 50 states, and Canadian shipping is available for an additional shipping and handling fee. Most U.S. customers receive their mattress 2 to 5 days after it has shipped, depending on the destination. Mattress Insider does not provide a sleep trial for its custom orders, but each mattress is backed by a 10-year warranty.

Custom Mattress Makers

Best Value

Custom Mattress Makers

Custom Mattress Makers
Mattress Type: Hybrid
Who it's best for:
  • Customers who only want to customize mattress size
  • Sleepers of all weights
  • Shoppers interested in a high- or low-profile mattress
Highlights:
  • Range of five mattress styles
  • Custom length and width options
  • Budget-friendly
Custom Mattress Makers

Use this SleepFoundation.org link for the most current discount on Custom Mattress Makers mattresses

Massachusetts-based manufacturer Custom Mattress Makers sells Yankee mattresses and custom beds. Their range of five mattresses can be purchased in standard sizes, or custom-made to your preferred length and width. For customers interested in custom sizing without other features, these handmade mattresses may offer an appealing balance between value and quality.

Three of the five models are variations of the Cocoa design. All three models have a hybrid construction with 8 inches of pocketed steel coils. The three models have different firmness levels to appeal to most sleepers, regardless of their weight or preferred sleep position.

Customers looking for a firm hybrid mattress may be interested in the Daytona, which has a 2.5-inch thick gel memory foam comfort system and an 8-inch pocketed coil support core. The company also offers the Cape, which fits a quilted foam comfort system and pocketed coil core into a 6-inch profile.

Custom Mattress Makers only allows shoppers to customize the length and width of the mattress to the closest inch, though they do take requests for angled corners. Customers who only need this level of control are likely to appreciate the streamlined purchasing experience, as well as the lower prices, when compared to manufacturers with more in-depth customization. However, anyone with more complex customization needs — such as firmness, height, or corner shape — may want to look elsewhere.

Most mattresses take 2 to 3 weeks to manufacture and package. Custom Mattress Makers currently ships for free within the contiguous U.S. states, with most mattresses arriving at their new home within 4 to 5 business days once shipped. All custom mattresses come with a 100-night guarantee, as well a 10-year limited warranty that covers impressions deeper than 1.5 inches and some manufacturing defects.

What is a Custom Mattress?


A custom mattress can mean different things depending on the manufacturer. For many, the term refers to mattresses available in an exceptionally wide range of sizes. These are often used for specific purposes, such as RV or truck beds and nonstandard bed frames, as well as unusually shaped rooms.

The next tier of customization usually involves personalizing a bed’s firmness. While many standard mattresses are available in a range of firmness options, a customized bed often allows customers to choose their desired firmness without restriction. This can be applied to the whole sleep surface or split sides of the bed, depending on the manufacturer. The mattress itself can usually be bought in standard or custom sizes.

An entirely custom bed allows start-to-finish customization. Customers are given a choice of materials, firmness, shape, and other important options. This type of bed is particularly suitable for people with unique requests, like heart-shaped beds, or beds intended to fit snugly in antique frames, boat holds, or other uncommon places.

Custom vs. Customizable

Custom mattresses differ from the customizable mattresses shoppers might find on the market. Customizable mattresses provide buyers with a selection of predetermined options to choose from, including toppers, firmness options, height, and design. While these beds provide a greater range of choices for shoppers in search of the perfect bed, they are not considered custom-made.

How to Choose a Custom Mattress

Custom mattresses are unique by nature, but there are still common factors that all potential buyers should consider. Choosing the best custom-made mattress requires an understanding of what to look for in a mattress. We’ll walk you through some of the most important considerations, and how these factors may differ between custom and standard mattresses. We’ll also explain the different kinds of custom mattresses on the market to give you a broad overview of your options

What to Look For in a Custom Mattress

Mattress manufacturers are in the business of marketing their products, and many use marketing terms that are often unhelpful or misleading. While many companies will market their products as universally comfortable, every sleeper has different needs. What is comfortable for one person may cause a restless night for another sleeper.

Rather than relying on marketing, consider your unique needs and preferences, in addition to price, quality, and other factors, to find the best custom mattress for your needs.

Price
Custom mattresses are generally more expensive than the average standard or customizable mattresses, but value-priced custom models can still come in well below the cost of a luxury bed. Price tends to be dependent on the level of customization, as custom-sized beds are usually less expensive than those with firmness or corner customizations. Start-to-finish customization can range in price widely depending on your choices. Most manufacturers offer quotes to give you a better idea of what your custom bed may cost.

Quality Materials
A custom bed is an investment, and most shoppers will want to be sure the mattress isn’t going to start showing wear and tear within a short period of time. While the average mattress has a lifespan of 6 to 8 years, you can get the most out of your custom mattress by ensuring it is made with high-quality materials. Most manufacturers will provide detailed information regarding the various materials they use, but buyers should consider doing their own research before making a decision.

Firmness Level
While many people love the idea of a soft, pillowy bed, the ideal firmness for a mattress is closely tied to the sleeper’s body weight and sleep position.

Back sleepers and those who weigh between 130 and 230 pounds often prefer a medium to medium firm mattress. Side sleepers and those under 130 pounds tend to select softer options, while stomach sleepers and those above 230 pounds find firmer models to be more supportive. These differences are due to both the need for support and the subjective nature of mattress firmness.

Depending on the mattress manufacturer, shoppers may choose between predetermined firmness levels or they may be able to fully customize the way the bed feels.

Size
In addition to the six standard mattress sizes, there are a number of nonstandard sizes available. These include oversized beds like Alaska king and Texas king, as well as mattresses meant to fit RVs, pickup truck beds, and semi-truck bunks. If none of these options works for your situation, a custom-size mattress may be well worth the investment.

Shape
Many people turn to custom mattresses to fit an unusually shaped bed frame or sleeping area. Shape customization can vary widely, from beveled or angled corners to custom geometric shapes or beds for boats. Corner customization is more widely available, while specific shapes usually require a company experienced in start-to-finish customization.

Pressure Relief
While most beds offer some degree of pressure relief, the type of mattress and materials you choose will have the greatest impact on your bed’s performance. Pressure relief is particularly important for side and stomach sleeping, as these positions can create pressure points that may cause next-day or long-term aches and pains. If this feature is important to you, consider your custom options carefully and work with the manufacturer directly to decide what may be best for your needs.

Edge Support
Sitting on the side of a bed with poor edge support will cause it to sag, and its perimeter will offer less support for sleepers than the center of the mattress. Edge support is largely dependent on a bed’s construction. Foam beds tend to perform poorly in this category, while innerspring and hybrid options often rank quite well. Features like perimeter reinforcement can provide both foam and hybrid models with excellent edge support.

Contouring
Many people associate contouring — the feeling of sleeping in, rather than on, a mattress — with improved pressure relief. Memory foam tends to hug the body for exceptional pressure relief. That said, less-contouring materials like latex can still offer top-notch pressure relief. How much contouring your mattress should provide is primarily a matter of personal preference.

Temperature Regulation
How well a mattress regulates temperature tends to depend on its construction. Support cores and comfort layers with better airflow make for a more temperature-neutral sleeping environment, while materials that restrict airflow or retain body heat tend to be quite warm. Contouring also affects temperature regulation, since a closely contouring mattress may prevent airflow around the body.

What Kinds of Custom Mattresses are Available?

There are multiple types of custom mattresses available. Some are designed for specific purposes, while others are built precisely to the customer’s specifications. While RV, boat, and sofa bed mattresses are common, fully customizable options allow shoppers to get more creative when it comes to different modifications and builds.

RV Mattresses and Campers: While standard sized mattresses rarely fit in RVs and campers, there are non-custom options on the market. However, these models may offer limited options that may not work for your sleep needs. Custom sizing is usually the only option required for this category.

Boat Mattresses: Some sleeping areas on boats allow for a standard sized mattress, but many require a custom creation. Depending on your boat, you may need anything from a custom-sized mattress, to one with beveled corners, to an entirely custom-made bed. Before assuming custom sizing is all you need, be sure to examine the sleeping area for awkward angles or other complications.

Sofa Beds: Replacement mattresses for sofa beds are available, but construction and size options are usually limited. Custom beds can be an excellent option, particularly for people who use theirs often, but not all custom mattress manufacturers work with this style. If you’re looking for a custom sofa bed mattress, you may be best served by a manufacturer specializing in start-to-finish custom work.

Oversized Mattresses: Oversized mattresses can adhere to standardized sizes, such as Alaska king and Texas king, or they can be custom-made. Standard oversized mattresses are easier to find accessories for, but custom options offer greater control. Some custom manufacturers can also add features like hinges, making it easier to fit an extra-large mattress into a small space.

Odd Shapes, Sizes, and Edges: Many custom mattress manufacturers are able to accommodate features like angled or beveled edges. More complex requests, like a heart-shaped bed, may require a start-to-finish custom job. While some mattresses in this category can be considered novelty beds, others are mattresses made to fit tight or unusually shaped spaces, or antique bed frames that require custom dimensions.

Types of Custom Mattresses

Custom mattress buyers have many decisions to make, but one of the most crucial is the type of mattress. Despite the wide range of standard and custom mattresses available on the market, most can be classified into one of four common types: foam, hybrid, innerspring, or latex.

Each type has its own benefits and drawbacks, and there can be a great deal of difference between models within one type of mattress when it comes to quality and construction. For example, foam beds tend to have poor edge support, but this is often remedied in models with reinforced perimeters.

While these four varieties are the most common choices for a custom mattress, a start-to-finish custom manufacturer will likely be able to work with you should you want a more unusual mattress construction, though it may be more expensive.

Foam

All-foam mattresses are one of the most popular options on the market for both standard and custom mattresses. Usually built from a support core of high-density polyfoam, with polyfoam or memory foam comfort layers, foam mattresses generally offer balanced support and pressure relief at a budget-friendly price.

Foam beds offer a number of other benefits, including motion isolation and contouring around the body. Potential drawbacks may include poor temperature regulation, edge support, and suitability for sex, but manufacturers often seek to counteract these drawbacks by using different designs or varieties of foam.

Hybrid

Hybrid mattresses often combine the best traits of foam or latex models with those of a traditional innerspring, with the added benefit of pocketed coils. Individually encased coils form a hybrid’s support core, allowing for better support, temperature regulation, and responsiveness than a foam core. A hybrid’s comfort system is usually made from polyfoam, memory foam, or latex, allowing for significant pressure relief and moderate contouring. There are few downsides to a hybrid mattress, but they can be expensive.

Innerspring

Traditional innerspring mattresses may be less popular than they once were, but modern versions are often an inexpensive choice that still offers durable support. Due to their interconnected coils, innerspring mattresses have less motion isolation and contouring than foam or hybrid beds. However, their temperature regulation is often some of the best on the market. They also have excellent responsiveness, making them particularly suitable for sex.

Latex

Natural latex is made from rubber tree sap, making it a popular choice among eco-minded shoppers. It offers pressure relief with gentle contouring, which is ideal for sleepers who prefer the feeling of sleeping on their bed rather than sinking into it. Latex is naturally responsive for ease of movement, and the breathable construction helps it remain temperature neutral.

All-latex beds are available, but tend to be both heavy and expensive. Some mattresses pair latex comfort layers with a support core made of pocketed coils or high-density polyfoam. Synthetic latex exists, but it lacks many of the qualities of natural latex.

Last Things to Consider With a Custom Mattress

There are several additional considerations to keep in mind when purchasing a custom mattress. As options vary between companies and available models, most custom mattress manufacturers will be happy to answer your inquiries and walk you through what you need to know before making a purchase.

How do I find bedding for custom mattresses?

Custom-sized mattresses are difficult to purchase bedding for, but owners do have two options. The first is to utilize bedding made for standard or oversized mattresses, which is usually easy to find and affordable. Flat sheets and duvets can be bought in a size that hangs over the edges of your bed, while fitted sheets are more difficult and must be altered or pinned to fit properly. If you prefer a more polished look, or have a bed that is too large or awkwardly shaped for premade bedding, you may prefer to have your bedding custom-made as well.

Do I need a custom mattress?

For mattresses that are made for specific purposes, such as use in RVs, there are generally a few standard sizes available. Depending on the size or shape of the intended space, you may be able to purchase a standard size instead of a custom mattress.

In more unique circumstances, like a bed frame with an unusual shape or special dimensions, a custom mattress will likely be necessary to ensure a proper fit.

Will a custom mattress fit in my space?

If you measure accurately, your custom mattress should fit in its intended space. Accuracy is key, so consult your manufacturer for measurement advice if you are unsure. Many mattress manufacturers only allow for customization to the nearest inch, so customers may need to round down in the case of fractions of an inch.

It is also important to check whether your mattress can be moved into its intended location, as oversized mattresses or cramped spaces can make this difficult. If necessary, some manufacturers are able to make custom mattresses that fold for ease of transport.

Can I customize a mattress myself?

While it may seem tempting to cut a standard mattress to fit, particularly if the alteration seems small, doing so damages the integrity of the mattress, voids the warranty, and ensures a less supportive bed with a much shorter lifespan. However, owners can customize their existing mattress’ firmness, support, and overall feel with mattress toppers and other accessories.

  • Was this article helpful?
  • YesNo

About Our Editorial Team

author
Austin Meadows

Sleep Product Tester

Austin is a professional writer and researcher who has covered sleep science and sleep products for over a decade.

About Our Editorial Team

author
Austin Meadows

Sleep Product Tester

Austin is a professional writer and researcher who has covered sleep science and sleep products for over a decade.