When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Products or services may be offered by an affiliated entity. Learn more.
The Company Store Mattress Review: Test Lab Ratings
Sleep Foundation
Why Trust Us
Our mission to create a healthier, more well-rested world demands that our product reviews be best-in-class. You won’t find more expertise on mattresses and sleep products anywhere else.
The Sleep Foundation product testing team uses an industry-leading evaluation process paired with real world consumer feedback to come up with objective recommendations so that you can feel confident in your product decisions.
The Company Store mattress offers a versatile sleep experience with a balanced blend of comfort and support, making it a great choice for various sleeper types. Designed with a hybrid construction, it combines a breathable cover, pressure-relieving memory foam, and a supportive coil system to enhance spinal alignment and minimize motion transfer.
- Superior temperature regulation
- Responsive support from two coil systems
- Above-average ease of movement and edge support
- Lofty price-point
- Coils may produce sound as the mattress ages
- White Glove delivery charge applies to all mattress orders
Founded in 1911 as the La Crosse Garment Manufacturing Co., The Company Store got its start producing down comforters, featherbeds, and winter clothes. Its product line has since expanded to include towels, home decor, sheets, pillows, and mattress toppers. In 2023, the company launched its first mattress model.
The Company Store Mattress is a luxury hybrid model with a medium firm (6) feel. Its comfort system contains layers of polyfoam and natural Talalay latex, while the core uses two coil systems for balanced contouring and responsive support. The design also incorporates several components engineered for temperature regulation.
We’ll highlight which types of sleepers are likely to enjoy The Company Store Mattress, break down how its construction impacted its performance in our tests, and explain the pricing and policies that might influence your purchasing decision.
SMART MATCHING
Is the Company Store Right for You?
Use the filters below to see how well the Company Store lines up with your unique needs. We'll also give you a couple other recommendations based on your answers.
TEST LAB RATINGS
How the Company Store Scored
Motion Isolation6.5/10
Compared to other latex hybrid models we’ve tested, The Company Store Mattress isolates motion moderately well. Its two polyfoam layers absorb many surface vibrations and the latex also dampens movement, though some vibrations may travel because of the latter material’s responsiveness.
Our team members detected minimal movement when a testing partner changed positions on the opposite side of the bed. When we dropped a kettlebell on the surface, our vibrational sensors detected a moderate spread of movement. We don’t expect this motion transfer to disrupt most sleepers, but those who awaken easily and share their bed with a very active partner might notice.
Pressure Relief7.5/10
The Company Store Mattress contours to a sleeper’s body to reduce pressure accumulation. This level of pressure relief is on par with many hybrid models with a medium firm feel.
Two layers of quilted polyfoam cushion the surface, while the Talalay latex underneath adds responsive contouring. By dispersing the sleeper’s weight, there’s less force around pressure-prone areas, such as the hips and shoulders. The microcoil system adds to this effect by adjusting quickly to the sleeper’s shape and movements.
In our tests, team members of all weights and sleep positions felt they experienced enough pressure relief to rest comfortably on the bed. Our pressure mapping also showed that the mattress spread out their weight fairly evenly, limiting pressure buildup.
Temperature Control9.5/10
Thanks to its breathable design, The Company Store Mattress excels at temperature control. While we expect most latex hybrids to perform well in this category, The Company Store Mattress stands out among its peers.
The cover uses a temperature-regulating, moisture-wicking blend of silk, wool, and cashmere. Underneath, copper, silver, and gel fibers are designed to combat microbial growth while transferring away heat. The gel in both polyfoam layers is also intended to reduce heat buildup, while airflow through the Talalay latex layer and two coil systems effectively cools the surface.
Our temperature readings showed that very little heat lingered on The Company Store Mattress after our testers moved. Team members also reported maintaining a neutral temperature throughout the testing process. Because of its exceptional breathability, we recommend The Company Store Mattress for hot sleepers.
Edge Support8.5/10
The Company Store Mattress has solid edge support, which is aligned with most similarly constructed models. Talalay latex compresses over a wider area than polyfoam or memory foam, meaning sleepers are unlikely to feel like the mattress is sagging under their weight if they get close to the edge. The coil systems also provide significant pushback, supporting sleepers well when they approach the perimeter.
Across weight groups and sleep positions, our team members could comfortably sit or lie along the edge without feeling like they might slide off. While those over 230 pounds didn’t feel quite as secure as other testers, no team members reported feeling the need to gravitate toward the center of the bed.
Ease of Movement8.5/10
Because of its responsive materials, The Company Store Mattress is easy to move on. This is consistent with other latex hybrid models we’ve tested in our sleep lab.
While the quilted polyfoam layers conform to the body, they do not maintain a lasting impression when the sleeper moves. Talalay latex also adjusts to the shape of the sleeper, but its natural buoyancy gives a lifting sensation that facilitates movement. The two coil layers add to the mattress’ springy, responsive feel.
Our testers could change positions with little effort, so this mattress might be a good fit for combination sleepers and active sleepers who want to be able to move easily.
Durability8.5/10
The Company Store Mattress combines both foam and natural latex in its comfort system. The latex helps reduce the chances of permanent body impressions. Meanwhile, the support core has a dual-coil design that evenly spreads out body weight and helps prolong the life of the mattress before it starts to sag. We expect this mattress to perform in line with other latex hybrids in terms of durability, lasting seven to eight years at least.
Who it Fits
Fit by Sleep Position and Body Weight
Sizes, dimensions and weights
Side Sleepers
The Company Store Mattress gently conforms to a side sleeper’s shape, reducing pressure around their hips and shoulders. Two quilted polyfoam layers soften the surface to ease pressure points, while buoyant Talalay latex contours to spread the sleeper’s weight out more evenly. Microcoils in the support core deepen the cradling, allowing heavier sections of the body to sink in farther.
During our testing, the mattress worked well for side sleepers of all weights, with those between 130 and 230 pounds reporting a nearly optimal combination of pressure relief and spinal support. A few testers under 130 pounds noted that they prefer a bit more give, while some over 230 pounds said they need slightly sturdier support.
Back Sleepers
Like any of the best mattresses for back sleepers, The Company Store Mattress gently contours to a back sleeper’s body while preventing excessive sagging. Its polyfoam layers let the hips sink in just a little while molding to the lumbar region, thereby adjusting to the spine’s natural curvature. Meanwhile, the Talalay latex spreads the compression over a wider area to redistribute pressure without letting sleepers sink in too deeply.
Across the board, our back sleepers were enthused about this model. They reported feeling lifted yet cradled, helping them maintain good sleep posture. Testers between 130 and 230 pounds were particularly impressed by the balanced support.
Stomach Sleepers
The Company Store Mattress’ notable cushioning and support make it a good fit for many stomach sleepers. The buoyant lifting sensation of the Talalay latex reduces the likelihood of a stomach sleeper’s midsection sagging into the mattress and pulling their spine into an unnatural curve.
Because of its medium firm feel, The Company Store Mattress was better suited for our stomach sleepers between 130 and 230 pounds. Most team members in this weight group noted that the mattress kept their spine on a fairly even plane. Conversely, some testers under 130 pounds said they prefer slightly more cushioning, while some over 230 pounds cited inadequate midsection support.
Construction
Inside the Company Store Mattress
Cover
Silk, wool, and cashmere blend
Comfort Layer
Copper/silver/gel fibers, gel-infused polyfoam (two layers), Talalay latex
Support Core
Microcoils, cotton, pocketed coils
Other Beds You Might Like
Tuft & Needle Original
8.6/108.6/10 · $521 – $1,009
Foam · Medium (5)
Turmerry Certified Organic Latex Hybrid Mattress
8.6/108.6/10 · $1,199 – $2,399
Latex Hybrid · Medium (5)
Avocado Latex Mattress
9.1/109.1/10 · $2,609 – $4,049
Latex · Firm (7)
Spindle Organic Latex Mattress
8.8/108.8/10 · $1,200 – $2,000
Latex · Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)
Back Science Series 2 Mattress
8.5/108.5/10 · $2,399 – $5,732
Hybrid · Firm (7)
Buying It
Trial, Warranty, and Delivery
Availability
The Company Store Mattress ships within the contiguous U.S. You can buy this model directly from The Company Store website.
Shipping
The mattress is delivered within the contiguous U.S. via Pilot Freight Services, the company’s third-party shipping partner. This service includes delivery to your room of choice, unpacking, setup, and the removal of the packaging materials and your old mattress.
Most new mattresses arrive six to eight weeks after the order is placed.
Additional Services
The Company Store Mattress ships exclusively via White Glove delivery for a $199 fee. Old mattress removal and disposal are included.
Sleep Trial
The Company Store Mattress comes with a 100-night sleep trial. After a 30-night break-in period, owners can contact customer support for the remainder of the trial window if they wish to return the mattress.
Warranty
A 15-year limited warranty covers defects in materials and workmanship, though the policy doesn’t apply to fabrics.
Mary is a product-content marketer who applies a pedigree in journalism, human-centered design, and cultural trends to inform strategy. Prior to Sleep Doctor, Mary led editorial and creative at ESPN and Rad Power Bikes. She likes to build and grow things, and break and fix things, and only sometimes in that order.