Sleepfoundation.org is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Home / Bedding Reviews / Brooklinen Comforter Review

Written by

Bill Fish

author
Brooklinen

Use this SleepFoundation.org link for the most current discount on Brooklinen bedding

Founded by Vicki and Rich Fulop in 2014, Brooklinen is a direct-to-consumer online retailer specializing in bedding, bath, and home goods. Inspired by the couple’s search for quality and affordable bedding, Brooklinen uses a streamlined supply chain in an effort to keep prices lower than many of their competitors without sacrificing product quality.

In addition to sheets, pillows, and duvets, Brooklinen makes three different comforter models: Natural Down, Down Alternative, and Weighted. We will be focusing on the Brooklinen Down Comforter, which comes in three weights: Lightweight, All-Season, and Ultra-Warm. Made with down cluster fill and a sateen-weave cotton shell, the Down Comforter is available in three sizes: twin/twin XL, full/queen, king/California king.

We’ll analyze the Brooklinen Down Comforter’s performance, including its materials, construction, and pricing. We’ll also compare this model to the company’s Down Alternative Comforter and Weighted Comforter to help you determine which might be the best fit for you. Finally, we’ll explain cleaning and maintenance as well as other factors to consider when shopping for your next comforter.

Brooklinen Comforter Review Breakdown

A comforter is intended to add warmth and coziness to your sleep experience, but materials and construction can influence the overall performance, durability, and comfort.

Some people avoid down comforters because of allergies, but the Brooklinen Down Comforter is hypoallergenic and has been treated with Ultra-Fresh Antimicrobials. The model is designed to feel soft and lofty thanks to its down cluster fill and sateen-weave cotton shell.

The Brooklinen Down Comforter features a baffle box construction to minimize clumping, as well as loops on the corners to prevent bunching within a duvet cover. Three different weight options are available to suit your unique sleeping and warmth preferences. The Lightweight model may be ideal for hot sleepers, whereas the Ultra-Warm is intended for those who prefer additional warmth and coziness. If you’re seeking the most versatile option, the All-Season comforter is designed for year-round use.

Although we’ll be focusing on the Down Comforter, we’ll also highlight Brooklinen’s other models, the Down Alternative Comforter and the Weighted Comforter.

Materials and Construction

Materials and construction determine a comforter’s overall performance in terms of feel, temperature regulation, and maintenance. Fill and shell material are the two largest factors when it comes to comforter quality, as they impact its loft, softness, and warmth.

The Brooklinen Down Comforter features baffle box construction with down cluster fill. The fill power and type of down varies based on the model to adjust the warmth level. The Lightweight Down Comforter uses 650-fill-power recycled European down, the All-Season Down Comforter contains 700-fill-power Canadian duck down, and the Ultra-Warm Down Comforter consists of 750-fill-power Hutterite goose down.

A 400 thread count cotton shell made with a smooth sateen weave encases the down. Baffle boxes help distribute the fill more evenly while also providing space for the fill to expand, creating a lofty feel. Corner loops on the shell enable owners to attach a duvet cover to protect the comforter.

Many people avoid down products due to concerns about allergies, but the Brooklinen Down Comforter is designed to be hypoallergenic and has been treated with Ultra-Fresh Antimicrobials to inhibit the growth of microorganisms. If you are seeking a vegan-friendly option, however, their Down Alternative Comforter may be a more suitable fit. This model features the same 400 thread count sateen-weave cotton shell, but the fill is made from recycled PET bottles or shaved microfibers intended to mimic the texture of down.

Brooklinen also offers a Weighted Comforter, which has a quilted sateen shell and a glass microbead and down alternative interior. The added weight is intended to reduce stress and facilitate more restful sleep.

Product Weight Options Size Options Fill Material Shell Material
Brooklinen Down Comforter Lightweight, All-Season, Ultra-Warm Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/California King Down Cotton
Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter Lightweight, All-Season, Ultra-Warm Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/California King Down Alternative Cotton
Brooklinen Weighted Comforter 15 lbs., 20 lbs., 30 lbs. Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/California King Glass Microbeads, Down Alternative Cotton
Scroll L – R for more details

Prices and Sizing

Down comforters have a reputation for being pricey because they are sourced from ducks and geese, whereas down alternatives utilize synthetic materials like polyester and rayon. Natural down comforters cost anywhere from $80 to upwards of $850, depending on the craftsmanship and materials. When compared to comparable models, the Brooklinen Down Comforter is competitively priced.

Fill power is the universal rating system used to measure the fluffiness and insulating properties of goose and duck down, and it is a significant factor in determining the price-point. A higher fill power equates to a warmer and loftier comforter. The Ultra-Warm Down Comforter has the highest fill power and is the most expensive of the Brooklinen comforters. If you are sticking to a budget or lead a vegan lifestyle, the Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter is a more economical option.

Brooklinen Comforter Pricing

Sizes Price
Brooklinen Down Comforter Lightweight: $149, $249, $349
All-Season: $249, $349, $449
Ultra-Warm: $399, $499, $599
Brooklinen Down Alternative Comforter Lightweight: $129, $199, $249

All-Season: $199, $249, $299
Ultra-Warm: $299

Brooklinen Weighted Comforter 15 lbs. (Twin/Twin XL): $249
20 lbs. (Full/Queen): $349
30 lbs. (King/California King): $399
Scroll L – R for more details

Comforter Performance Ratings

Comforters can enhance the sleep experience by adding warmth and coziness. Many opt for down comforters, as high-quality models tend to be durable, regulate temperatures well, and provide luxurious plushness.

Fill is the material comprising the interior of a comforter and is typically the most important factor when it comes to overall performance because it determines loft and warmth. The Brooklinen Down Comforter uses down clusters instead of individual feathers, which provide a softer and airier feel without the risk of sharp feather shafts poking through the fabric.

Down clusters are typically better at retaining heat than feathers, and the Ultra-Warm version of Brooklinen’s Down Comforter is very insulating. Even though it has a high fill power, it is still lightweight because it uses down clusters. The All-Season version is also excellent at retaining heat, while the extra breathability of the Lightweight model makes it more appropriate for summer months.

All versions of the Brooklinen Down Comforter feature a 400 thread count long-staple cotton shell with a sateen weave and a soft and supple feel. Baffle box construction helps keep the fill evenly distributed. Corner loops also prevent the comforter from shifting inside a duvet cover.

Durability is another important factor to consider when shopping for a comforter. The Brooklinen Down Comforter’s substantial, baffle box construction helps preserve the quality of the fill without restricting its fluffiness. When cared for properly, Brooklinen’s Down Comforter is very durable, though it may flatten somewhat with time. Fluffing the comforter should help it regain some of its loft.

Brooklinen Down Comforter

Quality of Fill

The Brooklinen Down Comforter’s fill consists of responsibly sourced down clusters that have undergone a five-step sorting and cleaning process. This results in an extremely soft and fluffy fill that maintains its loft well.

Quality of Shell

The comforter’s soft 400 thread count shell is made from cotton woven in a sateen weave that gives the material a subtle sheen. Its sturdy baffle box construction keeps the fill in place, and corner loops prevent the comforter from bunching within a duvet cover.

Softness

The down clusters give the comforter an exceptionally soft and snuggly feel, while the cover has a silky texture that’s gentle on the skin.

Temperature Control

Customers can choose from Lightweight, All-Season, and Ultra-Warm designs, each of which offers a different level of temperature control. The Lightweight provides moderate warmth and is better for summer months or warmer climates, while the All-Season is designed for year-round use. With the highest fill power, the Ultra-Warm is the most insulating version.

Durability

While the down may flatten over time, the comforter is composed of high-quality materials that should hold up quite well. Routinely using a duvet cover may enhance the comforter’s life expectancy.

Care and Cleaning

Comforters are often too bulky and cumbersome to wash on a regular basis. Duvet covers can help protect your comforter and simplify the cleaning process since they are easy to remove and often machine-washable. The Brooklinen Down Comforter has corner loops that make it easy to affix a duvet cover securely.

Brooklinen also provides specific care instructions in order to preserve their comforter’s integrity. The company recommends leaving the Down Comforter outside on a dry day to air out or using the no heat/air fluff setting on a dryer to achieve a similar result. Owners should also shake their comforter out periodically to help fluff it and remove dirt and dust.

Regardless of the model, Brooklinen advises treating spills and lighter stains by hand using a mild soap. The Down Comforter can be dry cleaned for larger stains, but keep in mind that this can affect its durability since the chemicals used could degrade the down clusters. Their Down Alternative Comforter, however, may be dry cleaned freely without notably shortening its lifespan.

Brooklinen’s Weighted Comforter can also be dry cleaned. Owners can remove small stains by spot cleaning with warm water and soap, and they can dry the spot using a hair dryer on low heat.

Discounts and Deals

Brooklinen

Use this SleepFoundation.org link for the most current discount on Brooklinen bedding

Trial, Warranty, and Shipping Policies

  • Availability

    The Brooklinen Down Comforter may be purchased directly through the company website or at their flagship store in Brooklyn, NY. Brooklinen products are also available via Amazon.

  • Shipping

    Brooklinen offers free shipping within the United States via FedEx, UPS, and/or USPS. International shipping is also available for a flat-rate fee based on location, but additional duties and taxes may apply. Shipping fees are nonrefundable.

    Orders usually take 1 to 4 days to process. Shipping time varies based on courier and location, but the average turnaround is 3 to 7 days.

  • Trial

    When purchased directly through the official website, the Brooklinen Down Comforter comes with a 365-day return policy. If you decide the comforter isn’t right for you, you can return it for a full refund of the purchase price or exchange it.

  • Warranty

    Brooklinen backs its Down Comforter with a 1-year warranty. Should there be a quality issue with your comforter, you may file a claim directly with the company.