DreamCloud vs. Puffy Mattress Comparison

Quick Look

We’ve worked hard to show you which mattresses are the best fit for you. Check out our full mattress guides listed below!

Sizing Options

When purchasing a new mattress, some shoppers choose to upgrade to a larger mattress size. Others downsize to better fit their living spaces. When selecting a mattress size, shoppers should keep in mind the size and layout of the bedroom and double-check dimensions. Most mattresses are available in six standard sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king.

In addition to the length and width of the mattress, weight is an essential consideration. Most online mattress companies ship the bed compressed and vacuum-sealed, which is commonly referred to as a mattress in a box. The compressed mattress is easier to maneuver into the bedroom than a fully expanded mattress would be, but it may still be heavy. Those who move regularly may want to look for a lighter mattress. Additionally, a heavy mattress will be difficult to adjust or rotate without assistance.

The height of the mattress determines how easy it is to get in and out of bed. A bed that is too high or too low can be difficult for those with achy joints. Most mattresses have a 10- to 12-inch profile. Mattresses with a profile higher than 12 inches often require deep pocket fitted sheets.

Puffy and DreamCloud stock all six standard mattress sizes for each model. Puffy also offers a split king size. DreamCloud offers two hybrid mattresses, while Puffy has three all-foam models and two hybrids to choose from.

Most mattress companies offer a range of sizes and models to accommodate every shopper. This includes those shopping for themselves, as part of a couple, or as part of a family with kids. The range of sizes ensures there is an option for big and small spaces.

Additionally, shoppers may want a low- or high-profile mattress. The DreamCloud, DreamCloud Premier and Puffy Royal Hybrid are best suited to those who want a high-profile bed. The Puffy and Puffy Lux Hybrid are considered standard height.

Shoppers should also keep in mind that both DreamCloud models weigh 85-106 pounds in a queen size. The Puffy Lux Hybrid and Puffy Royal Hybrid weigh a bit less but still fall in the range of 85-95 pounds in a queen size. Those who want a lighter mattress should consider Puffy’s all-foam model.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Understanding what a mattress is made of and how those materials impact the quality of the mattress is an essential part of mattress shopping. Often, mattresses are made with a foam, latex, or hybrid construction.

Foam mattresses incorporate multiple layers of memory foam and/or polyfoam. Memory foam conforms closely for strong pressure relief. On the other hand, memory foam tends to retain heat, though certain varieties are designed to offset this with gel, copper, or graphite infused into the foam. The density of the foam used often directly affects its durability. Low-density foam is susceptible to deep impressions over time, while high-density foam often holds up better.

Latex mattresses use natural, synthetic, or blended latex. Natural latex is harvested from rubber trees and processed using the Dunlop or Talalay method. Both are breathable and durable. Latex is known for its long lifespan and consistent support.

Hybrid mattresses combine elements of foam or latex mattresses with a pocketed coil support core. This ensures a combination of conforming pressure relief and full-body support. The durability of a hybrid mattress is often determined by the density and composition of the comfort layers.

We’ll break down the constructions of the DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid, DreamCloud Premier, the Puffy, the Puffy Lux, the Puffy Lux Hybrid, the Puffy Royal, and the Puffy Royal Hybrid.

DreamCloud

DreamCloud’s lineup currently includes two models, the flagship DreamCloud mattress and the newer DreamCloud Premier. While they share similar designs, there are a couple of important differences to take into account.

DreamCloud

The DreamCloud is a hybrid mattress with a medium firm feel, which rates as a 6 on the 1-10 firmness scale. The hybrid construction of this mattress ensures moderate contouring and pressure relief, with ample bounce for ease of movement. Most sleepers who weigh 130 pounds or more benefit from a firmer feel, but those who weigh less will probably find the mattress too firm.

The DreamCloud features a Euro-top layer padded with 1.5 inches of gel-infused memory foam, followed by a memory foam comfort layer. These layers contour to the body to relieve pressure points, especially around the shoulders and hips.

A polyfoam transitional layer rests beneath the comfort layer. This component provides extra reinforcement for the sleeper’s body and prevents them from sinking too deeply into their mattress.

The DreamCloud’s support core consists of individually pocketed coils reinforced with a layer of high-density base foam. The coils add bounce to the mattress, making it easier for sleepers to move across the surface and change sleep positions during the night. The coils also promote airflow throughout the mattress to dissipate body heat.

The DreamCloud also includes a hand-tufted cover made from a cashmere blend. This material wicks away moisture and helps to regulate body temperature. Altogether, the DreamCloud measures 14 inches thick.

DreamCloud Premier

The DreamCloud Premier is also a hybrid model. Like the DreamCloud, this model offers a medium firm (6) feel.

The DreamCloud Premier’s Euro-top contains an additional inch of memory foam padding, resulting in a plusher surface with more cushioning for sleepers who prefer deeper contouring and body-hugging.

Apart from this difference, the DreamCloud Premier shares the same components as the DreamCloud, including a gel-infused memory foam comfort layer, polyfoam transitional layer, and pocketed coil support core. As a result, both mattresses perform well in the same categories, including pressure relief, motion isolation, temperature neutrality, and ease of movement.

Puffy

Puffy includes proprietary foam blends in each of its mattress models. The Puffy lineup includes three all-foam mattresses – the original Puffy, the Puffy Lux, and the Puffy Royal – as well as the Lux Hybrid and Royal Hybrid. Each mattress has a stain-resistant “Zip-n-Wash” cover that can be removed for cleaning.

The Puffy

The original Puffy mattress has a 10-inch profile and medium (5) rating. It is the most affordable option of the three Puffy mattresses.

Beneath the stain-resistant polyester cover is a 2-inch comfort layer of gel-infused memory foam. This “CloudComfort” layer draws heat away from the body. It contours deeply for pressure relief and provides the body-hugging feel that is commonly expected from memory foam. This layer helps prevent motion transfer.

The transitional layer of the Puffy is 2 inches of “ClimateComfort” polyfoam. This layer stabilizes temperature. While some foam contracts and expands with temperature fluctuations, the ClimateComfort foam stays more consistent. This layer also keeps sleepers from sinking into the support core.

The base of the Puffy is six inches of firm core support foam, ensuring full-body support to help keep the spine aligned.

The Puffy Lux Hybrid

The Puffy Lux Hybrid is a 12-inch foam mattress with a medium (5) firmness. This is the mid-level price-point model in Puffy’s lineup.

The comfort system of the Puffy Lux Hybrid starts with 1.5 inches of gel-infused CloudComfort foam. This thermal conductive layer helps prevent heat buildup in the mattress. Like the original Puffy, this mattress conforms closely for pressure relief and motion isolation.

Unique to the Puffy Lux Hybrid is a 1.5-inch Plush Dual Cloud polyfoam layer, which reduces pressure points and offers additional contouring.

The Puffy Lux Hybrid has a 2-inch transition layer of ClimateComfort polyfoam for temperature regulation. This layer helps keep the mattress cool in warmer climates and warm in colder temperatures.

The support core of the Lux Hybrid features 6-inch pocketed coils over a 1-inch base layer of high-density polyfoam.

The Puffy Royal Hybrid

The Puffy Royal Hybrid is the company’s most expensive all-foam model. It has a 14-inch profile that will likely require deep pocket fitted sheets. Like the original Puffy and the Lux Hybrid, the Royal Hybrid has a medium (5) firmness and multiple foam layers.

The comfort layer of the Puffy Royal Hybrid is 1.5 inches of foam infused with cooling gel beads. The beads help dissipate excess heat in order to prevent sleeping hot.

Also exclusive to the Royal Hybrid is a 2-inch layer of polyfoam for ample pressure relief and close contouring. The third layer is temperature-regulating polyfoam with cooling properties. This layer provides added airflow throughout the mattress.

The fourth layer of foam offers zoned support and tailored cushioning. This transitional layer is softer at the head, neck, shoulders, and feet, and firmer to support the back. The zoning helps keep the spine aligned while relieving pressure points.

A pocketed coil system and high-density foam base layer in the support core add durability to the mattress.

In-Depth Ratings

The following aspects are especially important to consider when shopping for a new mattress. A mattress is an investment, and shoppers will want to be sure it provides comfort and support for years to come.

Each shopper has unique needs and factors to consider. Some may share the bed and need a mattress that isolates motion. Those who sleep hot may find their main priority is a breathable mattress that regulates temperature. Understanding the following mattress features and prioritizing them will help shoppers narrow down their choices.

• Durability: Durability indicates how long the mattress will provide even, consistent support for sleepers. This often depends on the quality and composition of materials used, in addition to the overall construction of the mattress. Low-density, synthetic foam can have a shorter lifespan than high-density foam. Natural materials like wool and latex tend to be long-lasting. While the average mattress has a lifespan of six to eight years, a durable mattress can last longer. Shoppers who do not want to replace their mattresses every few years will want to look for one highly rated in durability.
• Motion Isolation: How well the mattress absorbs movements and prevents them from being felt in other areas of the bed is referred to as motion isolation. Memory foam especially stands out in this category, as it responds to pressure and returns to its original shape slowly. Mattresses with more bounce tend to transfer movements. Motion isolation helps prevent sleep disturbances, making it an essential feature for couples and those who share the bed with children or pets.
• Sex: A mattress with plenty of bounce makes it easy to change positions during sex. Softer, more conforming mattresses can inhibit movement and result in users feeling stuck in the mattress. Sturdy edge support allows couples to comfortably use the entire mattress during amorous activity. Couples who want a discreet option may choose to go with a foam mattress, as these are typically silent when bearing weight.
• Temperature Neutrality: A mattress that regulates temperature will often provide additional comfort for sleepers. Some materials, like memory foam, tend to retain heat and conform closely, restricting airflow around the body. To offset heat retention, some foams are infused with thermally conductive materials like graphite or gel. Latex and coils can help air circulate throughout the mattress to dissipate heat. Hot sleepers and those who live in warm climates may want to look for a mattress with cooling properties.
• Pressure Relief: How well a mattress reduces tension and pressure throughout the body is often determined by its firmness and comfort layers. Memory foam conforms closely for pressure relief, cushioning the shoulders, hips, and back where pressure is likely to build. If a mattress is too firm, it can cause pressure points to develop in these areas. That said, a mattress that is too soft may not properly support the spine. Side sleepers and those with sharp pressure points will especially want to look for a mattress that offers close contouring for pressure relief.
• Off-gassing: Most mattresses have an initial odor when first unboxed. This odor typically dissipates as the mattress airs out. Mattresses made with foam are likely to off-gas, meaning they release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) when opened. This is not considered harmful, but it could bother those who are sensitive to smells. Mattresses composed of natural materials are less likely to off-gas, but may still have an initial odor.
• Ease of Movement: How much bounce a mattress has will often determine how well it facilitates movement. Plush comfort systems of conforming foam can inhibit movement and make sleepers feel restricted if they sink in too deeply. This makes it difficult to change positions. Latex tends to be more buoyant, and sleepers are less likely to feel trapped in the mattress. Coils add plenty of bounce to a mattress, and the springiness of this type of support core makes it easy to shift positions as needed. This is an essential consideration for combination sleepers who change their sleeping position throughout the night.
• Edge Support: The perimeter of the mattress can offer support for sleeping or sitting on the edge of the bed. A mattress with sturdy edge support often has a reinforced perimeter. This not only makes it easier to get in and out of bed, but it also increases the supportive surface area of the mattress for those who share the bed. A mattress that lacks edge support may sag along the perimeter over time.

DreamCloud

Puffy

In-Depth Pricing

Shoppers who have not purchased a mattress in some time may be uncertain of what to expect in terms of pricing. Prices range from budget to luxury, with many mattresses falling somewhere in between.

The price of a mattress can be indicative of the quality of materials, complexity of construction, and add-on features. High-quality materials are often more expensive, as are mattresses with multiple layers. Some have unique features, like adjustable firmness levels and cooling properties, that can also increase the price of the mattress. That said, customers do not have to buy the most expensive option to get a mattress that suits their needs.

As so many mattress companies offer their products exclusively online and ship directly to consumers, they are often able to offer lower prices. There is less of a retail markup for these companies since they have reduced overhead costs. Additionally, sales and promotions are frequently available. It is rare for consumers to have to pay full price for a mattress.

Prices and Sizing

DreamCloud

Puffy

Both DreamCloud and Puffy ship directly to consumers to reduce overhead costs. The companies also both offer frequent discounts and promotions to entice shoppers. Their flagship models are not significantly different in price.

DreamCloud offers two mattresses at reasonable price-points. The DreamCloud costs considerably less than the average hybrid, whereas the DreamCloud Premier’s price is on par with many competing hybrids. Both of these mattresses feature details that make them feel luxurious, including cashmere-blend covers, hand-tufted Euro-tops, and thick memory foam layers. Either mattress is a good option for value-minded shoppers looking for durable hybrids. Additionally, DreamCloud offers bundle discounts for shoppers purchasing more than one item.

The original Puffy mattress is the brand’s entry-level option, while the Lux Hybrid and Royal Hybrid are considered luxury models. The company uses proprietary foam layers in each mattress that are designed to regulate temperature, relieve pressure points, and isolate motion.

Trial, Warranty, and Delivery

Shipping

When purchasing a mattress online, shoppers should consider processing and transit time. Delivery can often take one to two weeks once the order is placed. Additional time may be needed for White Glove delivery or international shipping.

Most companies offer free standard shipping, typically within the contiguous United States. Companies that ship to Alaska, Hawaii, and/or international locations often charge for shipping to these destinations. White Glove delivery and old mattress removal, when offered, are often an additional charge as well.

Mattress in a box beds are compressed, sealed in plastic wrap, and shipped in a box. This allows shipping companies to deliver the mattress to the doorstep. White Glove delivery includes a delivery team that sets up the mattress for the customer, and may remove the old mattress. Freight shipping is typically offered for orders shipped to Hawaii and Alaska.

DreamCloud Shipping

DreamCloud offers free standard shipping within the contiguous United States. Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii incur a $150 shipping charge. White Glove delivery is $149, with the option to add old mattress removal to this service for $20. International shipping is not currently available. Orders are shipped within five to seven business days. The mattress is compressed and vacuum-sealed.

Puffy Shipping

Puffy ships throughout all 50 states for free. White Glove delivery and international shipping options are not currently available. The bed is compressed and shipped as a mattress in a box, typically within two to five business days.

Returns

Mattress returns are often free, though some companies charge a transportation or restocking fee. Most include a sleep trial that allows customers to try out the mattress in their own homes before making a decision. If the customer decides to return the mattress, the company typically helps coordinate the pickup and return, donation, or recycling of the mattress. Mattress in a box beds cannot be compressed again once they have expanded, so customers should not need to save the original packaging.

DreamCloud Returns

DreamCloud offers a 365-night trial, which begins 30 days after the mattress is delivered. This 30-day break-in period encourages purchasers to adjust to the new mattress before a return can be initiated. Returns are free. DreamCloud coordinates pickup of the mattress and donates or disposes of it. The customer is issued a full refund.

Puffy Returns

Puffy mattresses come with a 101-night sleep trial, which includes a 14-night adjustment period before a return can be initiated. The company offers free returns and coordinates the donation or recycling of the mattress. The customer is issued a full refund.

Warranties

A mattress warranty provides repair or replacement of a mattress in the event of a defect. Warranties typically cover defects in materials and manufacturing, including deep impressions, splits or cracks in the mattress, and other flaws not caused by improper use. Normal wear and tear is not usually covered.

When comparing warranty coverage, shoppers should look at the length of the warranty, eligibility requirements, and the claims process. Most mattress warranties offer coverage for ten years or more. Some offer limited or prorated coverage, and the customer may be responsible for transportation costs.

DreamCloud Warranty

DreamCloud offers a lifetime warranty for both mattresses. For the first ten years, DreamCloud will replace a defective mattress at no charge to the customer. After the first ten years, the company will repair and recover or replace the mattress. The customer is responsible for a $50 shipping charge each way, which is waived if a defect is confirmed.

The DreamCloud warranty covers indentations greater than 1.5 inches, physical flaws, and defects in the cover. The mattress must be used on a firm, solid surface to ensure eligibility.

Puffy Warranty

Puffy also offers a lifetime warranty. The company will replace the mattress at any time if a defect arises. There are no costs to the customer, and replacement models also come with lifetime warranties.

The warranty covers indentations greater than 1.5 inches, flaws in the zipper, and tearing or unraveling of the fabric cover. The mattress must be used on an appropriate foundation.