Sleepfoundation.org is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

author

Written by

Daniel Noyed

Sleepfoundation.org is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

If you’re here, it’s likely because you’re ready to purchase a new mattress. Maybe you’ve already scoped out many mattress options and narrowed down your choices. You might be wondering, which is better, the DreamCloud or the Casper?

DreamCloud sells two mattresses, the DreamCloud and DreamCloud Premier. Both of these models are hybrids constructed with memory foam comfort layers and pocketed coil support cores. Both mattresses are considered medium-firm, or a 6 on the 1-10 firmness scale, but the DreamCloud Premier offers more cushioning and a slightly thicker profile.

Casper sells three mattress options: the Casper Original, the Casper Nova Hybrid, and the Casper Wave Hybrid. The Casper Original is available in all-foam and hybrid options. The Nova Hybrid and Wave Hybrid are both foam and coil hybrids. The Casper Original and Wave Hybrid measure medium in firmness, and the Nova Hybrid rates medium-soft.

This guide will help you decide whether Casper or DreamCloud is best for you. We evaluate both brands’ mattresses according to many factors, such as how well they relieve pressure, how cool they sleep, how much motion they transfer, and more.

In this guide, we share information from customer reviews in addition to results from our own mattress testing. Finally, we compare Casper vs. DreamCloud in terms of their policies, such as their sleep trial, return policy, shipping practices, and warranty terms.

Quick Look

Price Range (Queen)

$1,099-1,399

Price Range (Queen)

$595-2,595

Firmness Options

Medium Firm (6)

Firmness Options

Medium Soft (4), Medium (5)

Standout Features

  • Sleeps cool
  • Excels at relieving pressure

Standout Features

  • Available in a wide range of price-points
  • Excels at relieving pressure
  • Contains zoned support

Models

Models

Sleep Trial & Warranty

365-night sleep trial
Lifetime limited warranty

Sleep Trial & Warranty

100-night sleep trial
10-year limited warranty

Customer Service

NR

Customer Service

A+

DreamCloud

SleepFoundation readers get $200 off a DreamCloud Mattress.

Casper

Take $100 off a Casper Original Mattress. Use Code: SLEEPFOUNDATION

Sizing and Weight Options

Mattresses are sold in a variety of sizes, generally ranging from twin to king. Different sizes work best for different people’s needs. Generally, larger sizes cost and weigh more than smaller sizes do.

For most people, the amount of space needed is the biggest factor in choosing a mattress size. If you share a bed with a partner, children, or pets, you likely require a larger mattress than those who don’t.

Some people prefer larger beds because they have larger bodies. Others prefer larger beds because they tend to roll over during the night or like to sleep spread out.

A mattress’s height and weight might also factor into your decision-making. If you’ll be setting up your own bed, or if you plan to move in the future, you want to make sure you can lift the mattress.

DreamCloud

Height Size Options
14" Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Height Size Options
15" Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Casper

Height Size Options
11" Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Height Size Options
11" Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Height Size Options
12" Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Height Size Options
13" Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

There are clear differences between the DreamCloud and Casper mattresses. Casper offers more options, but the DreamCloud also offers features that meet certain customers’ needs. Your unique body type and preferences, along with your budget, will determine which bed is best for you.

The DreamCloud and DreamCloud Premier are the firmest mattresses covered in this review, both considered medium firm and rating 6 out of 10. People who weigh more than 230 pounds will probably feel more comfortable on these mattresses than any of the Casper models due to their strong support systems.

The Casper Nova Hybrid is the softest mattress of the group, rating 4 out of 10. As a result, it rates highest with sleepers weighing less than 130 pounds. Heavier weight individuals tend to find that the Casper Nova Hybrid doesn’t offer the support they require.

All of the beds covered in this review contain memory foam and relieve pressure well. Sleepers wanting the greatest amount of “hug” should opt for the softer Casper Nova Hybrid or the all-foam Casper Original.

For many shoppers, price will impact which mattress works for them. The Casper Original is the least expensive and therefore the best for people on a budget. However, the DreamCloud and DreamCloud Premier both come with a lifetime warranty, and this could save you money in the long run.

DreamCloud

SleepFoundation readers get $200 off a DreamCloud Mattress.

Casper

Take $100 off a Casper Original Mattress. Use Code: SLEEPFOUNDATION

Construction and Materials Comparison

The majority of the beds covered in this review are hybrids, but the Casper Original comes in an all-foam model. These two construction types result in different feels and often sell for different prices.

All-foam mattresses contain comfort layers and a support core made of foam, as their name implies. The support core is generally high-density polyfoam, while the comfort layers often contain memory foam. All-foam beds can have anywhere from two to several layers.

Hybrid mattresses use coils as a support core and other materials such as foam for their comfort layers. Hybrid mattresses generally cost more than all-foam beds, but last longer. They usually don’t conform to the body as much, but they tend to sleep cooler.

Now, let’s dig into the construction and material specifics of the DreamCloud and Casper mattresses.

DreamCloud

DreamCloud offers two mattresses. The DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid, also known as the DreamCloud, is made with the following materials:

  • Euro-top cashmere blend cover quilted with 1.5 inches of memory foam
  • Gel-infused memory foam comfort layer
  • Polyfoam transitional layer
  • Individually encased pocketed pocketed coil support core
  • High-density polyfoam base layer

Due to its medium firm feel, the DreamCloud performs well with sleepers who weigh more than 230 pounds, as well as those in the range of 130 to 230 pounds. The memory foam layers provide some body-conforming to support the spine and alleviate pressure, but the coil system delivers sturdy support and people in these weight groups shouldn’t sink too much. People who weigh less than 130 pounds, on the other hand, may find the DreamCloud too firm.

The hybrid construction of the DreamCloud promotes temperature neutrality. Air flows through the pocketed coil layer, allowing sleepers to remain cool throughout the night. Gel infused into the second comfort layer is also intended to counteract the heat-trapping properties of memory foam.

The DreamCloud Premier is made with the following materials:

  • Euro-top cashmere blend cover quilted with 2.5 inches of memory foam
  • Gel-infused memory foam comfort layer
  • Polyfoam transitional layer
  • Individually encased pocketed coil support core
  • High-density polyfoam base layer

As you can see, the DreamCloud Premier has a design that is very similar to the DreamCloud’s. As a result, both mattresses provide comparable medium firm feels. However, the DreamCloud Premier contains an extra inch of memory foam padding quilted into the cover. This offers a plusher surface feel and extra cushioning for sleepers who prefer more of a “hug” from their mattress.

Like the DreamCloud, the DreamCloud Premier also excels at temperature neutrality thanks to steady airflow through its coil system. The breathable cashmere cover also helps the mattress keep cool. Edge support is another strength of the DreamCloud Premier. Owners shouldn’t sink too much when getting in and out of bed, and most people will feel secure sleeping along the edges.

Casper

Casper sells three mattress models, and one of those comes with two construction options. This section contains details about the materials and construction in each of these four beds.

The Casper Original is made with:

  • 1.5″ Airscape open-cell polyfoam comfort layer
  • 2″ 3-zone memory foam comfort layer
  • 7″ polyfoam support core

The Casper Original is an all-foam mattress that measures 11 inches in thickness. It is the brand’s flagship mattress and often referred to simply as “The Casper.” This mattress rates medium, or 5 out of 10, in terms of firmness.

The Casper Original is the brand’s least expensive mattress, though it comes with some advanced features. A zoned memory foam comfort layer provides additional support to the areas of the body that need it most. As a result, sleepers experience spinal alignment and pressure relief.

The Casper Original Hybrid is made with:

  • 1.5″ Airscape open-cell polyfoam comfort layer
  • 2″ 3-zone memory foam comfort layer
  • 7″ pocketed coils support core

The Casper Original Hybrid, also called the Casper Hybrid, is constructed exactly like the Casper Original except for its support core. It also measures 11 inches thick and rates medium in terms of firmness. Instead of high-density polyfoam, the Hybrid contains pocketed coils.

The two Casper Original beds feel similar, but swapping polyfoam for pocketed coils does change the bed. The Casper Original Hybrid sleeps cooler due to airflow through the coil layer. Also, the firm coils increase the bed’s edge support, which can increase the bed’s usable surface area.

The Casper Nova Hybrid is made with:

  • 1″ Airscape open-cell polyfoam comfort layer
  • 1.5″ 3-zone Airscape open-cell polyfoam comfort layer
  • 2″ 7-zone transitional memory foam
  • 7″ pocketed coils support core

The Casper Nova Hybrid shares similarities with the Casper Original Hybrid. The 7-inch pocketed coil support core and uppermost comfort layer are the same in both beds.

The Casper Nova Hybrid contains an additional comfort layer, however. This layer brings the bed’s firmness level down to medium-soft, or 4 out of 10. The Nova Hybrid is softer than the Casper Original, which has a 5 out of 10 firmness rating. As a result, the Nova Hybrid performs better with lighter weight individuals, but is too soft for people over 230 pounds.

Also, the zoned memory foam transitional layers in the two mattresses differ. The Nova Hybrid’s transitional layer has seven zones, compared to three zones in the Casper Original’s transitional layer. These additional zones, along with higher quality materials, make the Nova Hybrid rate higher among sleepers.

The Casper Wave Hybrid is made with:

  • 1″ Airscape open-cell polyfoam comfort layer
  • 1.5″ Airscape open-cell latex comfort layer
  • 1.5″ Airscape 3-zone memory foam
  • 1.5″ zoned polyfoam with targeted gel pods
  • 7″ pocketed coils support core

The Casper Wave Hybrid is the most luxurious mattress offered by Casper. As a result, it comes with a much higher price tag. Like the Casper Original Hybrid and Casper Nova Hybrid, this bed has a 7-inch pocketed coil support core and perforated AirScape comfort layers.

Unlike the other Casper hybrids, the Wave features two, not one, zoned layers to relieve pressure. Also, ta layer of AirScape latex. These additions help the Wave remain temperature neutral, so sleepers stay cool overnight.

Average Customer Ratings

Although professional mattress tests provide the most unbiased information on mattress performance, customer reviews are also useful. Detailed customer reviews can help you determine what features people like or don’t like about a mattress.

We recommend visiting the DreamCloud and Casper websites to read a sampling of customer reviews rather than only viewing each mattress’s total star rating. Viewing what verified buyers are saying about the beds shows you whether or not the mattresses perform the way the companies claim they do.

Of course, you want to take all customer reviews with a grain of salt. Generally, unhappy customers feel more motivated to go online and leave a review. If the reviews are overwhelmingly positive, however, it’s likely that customers tend to like the product.

Try to seek out detailed reviews written by people similar to you. Mattress reviewers often mention their body weight, sleep position preferences, and if they share a bed with a partner. Finding reviews from people most similar to you can help you make your buying decision.

Model Average Rating
DreamCloud Mattress 4.6/5
DreamCloud Premier 4.6/5
Model Average Rating
Casper 4.5/5
Casper Hybrid 4.6/5
Casper Nova Hybrid 4.5/5
Casper Wave Hybrid 4.5/5

In-Depth Ratings

There are many factors you should take into consideration before buying a mattress. Don’t make the mistake of only considering price and firmness level. A mattress can be affordable and the right firmness for you but still not meet your needs.

Instead, evaluate each mattress according to multiple factors, such as durability, motion isolation, temperature neutrality, pressure relief, and more. In this section we explain these factors, so you know exactly what to look for when mattress shopping.

  • Durability: Durability refers to how long a mattress lasts and how well it performs over time. The quality of construction and the types of materials used generally determine a mattress’s durability. An average mattress lasts about 6 years, but some can last for decades. Durable mattresses tend to be more expensive, but can save you money in the long-run since you don’t have to replace them as frequently.
  • Motion Isolation: When a mattress isolates motion well, movement doesn’t travel across the surface of the mattress in response to weight or motion. Motion isolation is most important to people who share a bed with a partner, child, or animal. When a mattress doesn’t isolate motion well, sleepers might be disturbed by the movements of whomever they share a bed with. Of all mattress materials, high-quality memory foam tends to isolate motion the best.
  • Sex: A mattress’s construction can affect the ease with which people can have sex on the mattress. People tend to sink into beds that are highly conforming, which can inhibit movement during sex. A springy, more responsive mattress promotes movement. Edge support also factors into how well a mattress performs in terms of sex. When a bed has strong edges, people can use the entire surface of the bed without much risk of rolling off.
  • Temperature Neutrality: A bed that maintains temperature neutrality doesn’t trap heat, leading to sweaty awakenings during the night. Beds that allow for a lot of airflow, such as those that contain pocketed coil or innerspring layers, tend to remain the most temperature neutral. Of all mattress materials, memory foam traps the most heat. Manufacturers often attempt to counteract this tendency by adding holes and cooling gel to foam comfort layers.
  • Pressure Relief: When a bed is good at relieving pressure, it evenly distributes your weight, so you don’t develop pressure points in any single spot. Pressure relief is especially important for people who grapple with pain or tend to experience discomfort in bed. Transitional layers and zoned layers help relieve pressure by providing more support to the heavier areas of the body that need it most. Generally, the neck, shoulders, and hips are the areas most likely to experience pressure points.
  • Off-gassing: Off-gassing refers to volatile organic compounds (VOCs) releasing from manufactured products. When mattresses off-gas, they emit a chemical odor. Sometimes it takes a few days after unboxing a new mattress for the odor to completely dissipate. The off-gassing odor isn’t a problem for most people, but some find that they are sensitive to it. All-foam mattresses tend to off-gas the most, and innerspring mattresses tend to off-gas the least.
  • Ease of Movement: Moving across the surface of a mattress feels more or less difficult depending on the mattress’s materials and construction. Highly conforming memory foam “hugs” the body. While this conforming property can feel good and relieve pressure, it also inhibits movement. Springier, more responsive mattresses tend to promote movement. Ease of movement can affect your ability to roll over, get out of bed, or have sex on the mattress.
  • Edge Support: Edge support refers to the strength or weakness of the perimeter of a mattress. When a mattress has strong edges, it provides support even when a person lies near or sits on the edge of the bed. When a mattress has weak edges, the sides of the bed tend to fold and buckle under weight. Strong edges allow for full use of the surface of the mattress without a risk of rolling off.

DreamCloud

DreamCloud DreamCloud Mattress DreamCloud Premier
Firmness Medium Firm (6) Medium Firm (6)
Durability 3/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 3/5
Sex 4/5 4/5
Sleeps Cool 4/5 4/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 5/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 4/5 4/5
Edge Support 3/5 3/5
Scroll L - R for more details

Casper

Casper Casper Casper Hybrid Casper Nova Hybrid Casper Wave Hybrid
Firmness Medium (5) Medium (5) Medium Soft (4) Medium (5)
Durability 3/5 3/5 4/5 4/5
Motion Isolation 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Sex 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Sleeps Cool 3/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Off-Gassing 2/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Edge Support 2/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Scroll L - R for more details

Prices and Sizing

When mattress shopping, you can expect to find beds priced as low as $500 as well as those costing over $3,000. You might wonder, why do the costs vary so much?

Generally, the price of a mattress is most heavily influenced by its materials and construction. All-foam beds tend to be the most affordable. Hybrid beds that contain both foam and pocketed coils usually cost more than all-foam beds, on average. Latex mattresses cost the most of all mattress types.

Also, direct-to-consumer beds sold online tend to cost less than those manufactured by traditional mattress companies and sold in brick-and-mortar mattress and department stores. Online mattress retailers are able to cut costs by not having to pay showroom rents or hire in-person sales teams. They then pass those savings onto you.

When shopping for a mattress, keep in mind that you will spend several hours on your bed each day for years to come. Finding a mattress that’s comfortable to you and supports your body well is more important than saving money.

There are significant differences in price across the mattresses sold by DreamCloud and Casper. Understanding what causes these differences can help you determine which mattress is best for you.

DreamCloud

DreamCloud DreamCloud Mattress DreamCloud Premier
Twin $799 $899
Twin XL $899 $1,099
Full $999 $1,299
Queen $1099 $1,399
King $1299 $1,599
California King $1299 $1,599
Scroll L - R for more details
DreamCloud

SleepFoundation readers get $200 off a DreamCloud Mattress.

Casper

Casper Casper Casper Hybrid Casper Nova Hybrid Casper Wave Hybrid
Twin $595 $695 $1095 $1495
Twin XL $695 $795 $1245 $1695
Full $995 $1195 $1795 $2395
Queen $1095 $1295 $1995 $2595
King $1295 $1495 $2295 $2995
California King $1295 $1495 $2295 $2995
Scroll L - R for more details
Casper

Take $100 off a Casper Original Mattress. Use Code: SLEEPFOUNDATION

DreamCloud offers two mattresses, the DreamCloud and DreamCloud Premier. The latter costs more but both models are reasonably priced compared to the average hybrid. Of the Casper beds, the Casper Original Hybrid is constructed and priced most similarly to the DreamCloud. The Casper Hybrid does cost a little less than the DreamCloud, however.

Most people deciding between these two mattresses should allow firmness level to guide their choice, rather than cost. The Casper Hybrid doesn’t perform well with people who weigh more than 230 pounds, but does excel at supporting individuals weighing under 230 pounds. The DreamCloud and DreamCloud Premier are both medium firm, so they are better suited to people who weigh more than 230 pounds.

Among the Casper mattresses, the Casper Original is the least expensive because it’s an all-foam bed. Budget shoppers who enjoy a conforming foam mattress are generally satisfied with this one.

The Casper Nova Hybrid and Casper Wave Hybrid are both luxury hybrid options that contain more sophisticated zoned technology. The Wave Hybrid costs significantly more due to its construction. Shoppers should keep in mind that these beds have different firmness levels, however. The Nova Hybrid is preferred for those who want a softer bed.

Trials, Warranty, and Delivery

Warranty Shipping
Lifetime warranty Free shipping to contiguous US
Warranty Shipping
10 Year, Limited Free

DreamCloud’s Policies

Shipping

DreamCloud ships their mattress for free within the contiguous U.S. They charge a $150 fee for shipping to Alaska or Hawaii. They do not ship internationally at this time.

For $149, customers may purchase White Glove delivery. With White Glove delivery, DreamCloud will have someone deliver your mattress and set it up for you. For an additional $20, they will also remove your old mattress. These services are non-refundable.

Trial

DreamCloud offers a 365-night trial period that begins 30 days after the mattress is delivered. Customers may not return the mattress within the first 30 days because that’s the required break-in period.

Returns

Returns of open DreamCloud mattresses may be initiated 30 days after delivery and within the 365-night trial period. Unopened mattresses may be sent back immediately.

Returns are free, except for in areas that require a recycling fee. Customers who purchased white glove delivery and old mattress removal cannot have those services refunded, however.

DreamCloud does not sell returned opened mattresses. They will make arrangements for your mattress based on where you live. Some mattresses are returned to the company, while others are donated or disposed of locally.

Customers may initiate a return via phone call or email. DreamCloud will not accept returns of mattresses that are dirty or damaged. Any mattress that wasn’t opened within 90 days of delivery is considered damaged and isn’t eligible for a return.

Warranties

DreamCloud offers a limited lifetime warranty. The warranty only applies to the person who originally purchased the mattress. If the mattress wasn’t used on an appropriate base, the warranty may be void. If the mattress was burned, dirtied, or damaged, the warranty may be void.

Within the first 10 years, DreamCloud will replace a defective mattress with a brand new one. After 10 years, DreamCloud will repair and recover the mattress as necessary if it is deemed defective. Body impressions that measure less than 1.5 inches in depth are not considered defects.

Casper’s Policies

Shipping

Casper ships their mattresses for free to the contiguous U.S. and most of Canada. They charge a fee to ship to Alaska, Hawaii, and Northern Canada (Yukon, Northwest, and Nunavut territories). Their standard shipping is done by UPS.

For a fee, Casper will have your mattress delivered and set up for you. Casper doesn’t state what this fee is on their site. With delivery and set-up, they will remove one mattress for each delivered, and one box spring for each box spring delivered.They will not remove bed frames.

Trial

Casper offers a 100-night sleep trial that begins the day your mattress is delivered. Within 100 nights, you may return the mattress for free.

Returns

Casper mattress returns are free. Customers may initiate a return through the Casper website or by calling the company.

Casper will send a courier to pick up the returned mattress. They try to recycle them wherever possible.

Warranties

Casper offers a 10-year limited warranty on their mattresses. The warranty is only valid for the original mattress purchaser. The warranty is only valid to people living in the U.S. and Canada. The warranty can be void if the mattress is used on anything other than a solid bed base.

The Casper warranty covers any defects in the mattress, such as any splits, cracks, or broken zippers. The warranty doesn’t cover body impressions that measure less than 1 inch deep. The warranty also doesn’t cover anything considered abuse, burns, liquid damage, stains, and more.