SF readers get the best price at Brooklinen
Sleepfoundation.org is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
A comforter can add warmth and coziness to a bed and a down comforter is often sought after for its insulating feel. Having high-quality bedding is beneficial for sleepers, as it can help create a relaxing bedroom environment and regulate temperature at night.
A down comforter is filled with the soft clusters found underneath the feathers of ducks and geese that provide insulation. Down is durable, warm, and ideal for a range of climates and sleeping preferences. But there is a wide variety of down comforters on the market today and it can be easy to become overwhelmed as a shopper.
In addition to the different types of down comforters there are, shoppers may also want to consider the ethical nature of down and how it is sourced. There are ways to ensure a down comforter is made with high-quality construction methods and responsibly sourced down, which we’ll break down later on.
We’ll help shoppers select a down comforter that suits their needs with reviews of our top picks on the market today. We’ll include detailed information on the pricing and performance of the best down comforters, in addition to a buyer’s guide that breaks down the pros and cons of down comforters. Lastly, we’ll answer frequently asked questions about down comforters, including how to care for them.
SF readers get the best price at Brooklinen
The Brooklinen Down Comforter is lightweight and can be used year-round instead of switching it out each season. Shoppers have their choice of lightweight, which is better for hot sleepers and warmer climates, all-season, which is slightly warmer but still breathable, and ultra-warm, which is designed for extra weight and coziness.
The 100% cotton shell has a sateen weave with a light sheen. Cotton is highly breathable and encourages air circulation throughout the comforter, which helps dissipate heat and keep sleepers comfortable.
The down cluster fill varies depending on the comforter’s weight, and is ethically sourced from Europe as well as Hutterite Farms in Canada. The lightweight Brooklinen Down Comforter is filled with 650 fill power down, while the all-season version is filled with 700 fill power down, and the ultra-warm version has 750 fill power down. The baffle box construction keeps the down fill evenly distributed and prevents the shifting or clumping of the down clusters.
Additional maintenance is required to keep the Brooklinen Down Comforter looking its best, and airing it outside can help the down clusters maintain their loft. Purchasers can also fluff the comforter in the dryer with no heat. Any small spills or stains should be spot cleaned. Larger stains will require professional dry cleaning, which can reduce the lifespan of the down comforter. A duvet cover is recommended to protect the comforter and the Brooklinen Down Comforter is designed with corner loops that help keep the comforter in place inside of the cover.
The Brooklinen Down Comforter is produced in sizes twin/twin XL, full/queen, and king/California king. Brooklinen offers a 365-day sleep trial, so purchasers can put the Down Comforter to the test for all four seasons. The comforter is covered by a lifetime warranty.
Use this SleepFoundation.org link for the most current discount on Quince bedding
A common complaint about down comforters is that they sleep excessively hot. This can be attributed to down’s natural insulating properties, as this plumage keeps the birds warm in colder temperatures. The All-Season Premium Down Comforter from Quince is an exception to this trend. The high-quality down fill makes the comforter feel very lofty and cozy during colder times of the year, but a breathable cotton sateen shell also helps you stay cool when temperatures spike.
The fill consists of 650-fill power white down that has received certification from the Responsible Down Standard, ensuring humane treatment to put animal lovers at ease. Each of the shell’s baffles is sewn through to distribute the fill evenly across the comforter and prevent the down from escaping.
Each corner is equipped with loops to tie the comforter in place when a duvet cover is used. Twin, full/queen, and king/California king sizes are available. The comforter can be washed and dried in any household machine, though you may also opt for dry cleaning.
The sticker price for this item is on par with the average down comforter. Quince provides free ground shipping for all orders. The company also allows you to return the comforter within 365 days of your original purchase, even if you’ve used or cleaned it. This sleep trial is much longer than average.
Use this SleepFoundation.org link for the most current discount on Tempur-Pedic bedding
Tempur-Pedic has enjoyed a reputation for luxurious, well-made sleep products for nearly 30 years. The Down Comforter is a relatively new addition to the brand’s extensive lineup. Composed of 650 fill power American white down and a cotton-sateen shell, the comforter provides a balance of loftiness and breathability. The cotton prevents excessive overheating but the mid-weight design and plush fill ensure optimal insulation during chillier times of the year.
Thick piping lines the perimeter to prevent rips that can lead to fill escaping while tight baffle boxes evenly distribute the down, so you shouldn’t need to fluff the comforter too often. The cotton’s smooth hand-feel should also be comfortable for people with sensitive skin. King and queen sizes are available, both with high-end price-points that reflect the comforter’s quality of design and materials.
All customers in the contiguous U.S. qualify for free ground shipping. Tempur-Pedic does not permit returns for the comforter, but all customers receive a 1-year warranty against structural defects.
Use this SleepFoundation.org link for the most current discount on The Company Store bedding
Lightweight down comforters are usually best suited for warm or humid weather, while heavier comforters provide much-needed insulation in chillier climates. On the other hand, an all-season comforter offers a balance of loft and airflow to help you sleep soundly throughout the calendar year. The medium-weight LaCrosse Down Comforter from The Company Store is a prime example. The comforter weighs 35 ounces in a queen size, so it won’t feel too light during colder times of the year, but a breathable cotton cover prevents you from overheating when the temperatures rise.
If you’re in the market for a different style of comforter, you can choose from three additional weights. The “light” option – 27 ounces in a queen size – offers minimal insulation and sleeps quite cool. This may be the best option for people who reside in hot places or sweat in their sleep. The “extra” and “ultra” weights provide the most loft and warmth. Either of these weights should keep you sufficiently cozy in frigid conditions.
All versions of the comforter are constructed with 75/25 down and feather fill encased in a shell of cotton twill. A certification from the Responsible Down Standard ensures the ducks are treated humanely during each step of the plumage extraction process. The shell fabric is fairly durable compared to other cotton weaves like percale or sateen, and its smooth hand-feel should feel comfortable for people with sensitive skin. Perimeter piping and sewn-through baffle boxes keep the fill evenly distributed and help prevent it from escaping.
The entire comforter can be washed and dried in household machines, though The Company Store recommends using a front-loading washer to avoid damaging both the comforter and the machine. Five sizes are available, all of which correspond with standard mattress dimensions. You can also choose from more than 20 different colors, ranging from whites and neutrals to earth tones and bright shades.
The LaCrosse Down Comforter’s price depends on which weight and size you select. The Company Store offers free ground shipping for all orders in the contiguous U.S. of $50 or more, including all versions of the comforter. Each purchase is backed by a 90-night trial period and a lifetime guarantee.
Save 15% sitewide on Tuft & Needle products
The Tuft & Needle Down Duvet Insert is available in lightweight and mid-weight designs, but all fall within the range of 7 to 12 pounds. The duvet is filled with a 650 fill power down that retains enough heat to keep you cozy during colder times of the year, while a breathable cotton shell prevents overheating when the temperatures rise. For more insulation, choose the mid-weight option, but the lightweight duvet works best as a summer covering.
The fill has certification from the Responsible Down Standard, ensuring all geese are humanely treated and properly cared for during every step of production. A Standard 100 by OEKO-TEX certification also indicates the duvet has been rigorously tested for the absence of known toxic chemicals.
Although the duvet can be dry cleaned, you may also wash and dry it in household machines for quicker and more cost-effective care. Tuft & Needle recommends laundering the item every 6 to 12 months. Twin/twin XL, full/queen, and king/California king sizes are available.
Tuft & Needle offers free ground delivery throughout the contiguous U.S. The Down Duvet Insert comes with a 100-night sleep trial that includes free return shipping. You’ll also receive a 2-year manufacturer’s warranty.
Save 10% off your cart with code SF10
The purpose of down is to trap and store heat to keep geese warm – so naturally, down comforters can sleep excessively hot for some people. The Casper Humidity Fighting Duvet mitigates this issue with a thin layer of merino wool located between the shell and the fill. Merino wool regulates temperature well and wicks away moisture from your body. The shell is composed of pure cotton for extra breathability, but 650 fill power loft also ensures plenty of coziness and insulation when you need it most.
The duvet is available in two weights. A lightweight option should be suitable for people who live in areas where hot or humid nighttime conditions are common. The mid-weight option may be better for people who reside in more temperate locales where different insulation levels are needed throughout the year.
Each baffle box is sewn-through. This limits shifting and evenly distributes the fill, so you shouldn’t need to fluff too often. The down has been ethically sourced, so the duvet may appeal to consumers who take animal welfare into consideration when making purchases.
The duvet insert is available in twin/twin XL, full/queen, and king/California King sizes. Casper offers free ground shipping throughout the contiguous U.S. and provincial Canada, and every order comes with a 30-night sleep trial. If you choose to keep the duvet, it comes with a 1-year warranty.
Use this SleepFoundation.org link for the most current discount on Pacific Coast bedding
Pacific Coast has produced down comforters and other down bedding since 1884, using a mix of traditional European methods and modern practices. The Classic Down Comforter features a 100% cotton cover and 550 fill power down, making it suitable for year-round use.
The Classic Down Comforter’s HyperClean down fill has been washed and rinsed a minimum of eight times, which is above the industry standard. This process is intended to filter out the dust and dirt that commonly irritates those who suffer from allergies. Additionally, Pacific Coast backs the comforter with an allergy-free warranty, which allows sleepers to return the comforter for a refund within 30 days if it causes any irritation.
The cover of the Classic Down Comforter is constructed using a 240 thread count, down-proof weave that prevents the fill from poking through the fabric. The comforter also has a diamond box design to keep the down from shifting or clumping throughout the night.
Pacific Coast recommends dry cleaning or professionally laundering the comforter. The comforter is designed with corner loops to be used with a duvet cover, which can help extend the amount of time between cleanings.
The Classic Down Comforter is available in twin, full/queen, and king sizes. Pacific Coast offers free ground shipping within the contiguous U.S, and the comforter is backed by a 3-year limited warranty. Pacific Coast products also come with a 30-night sleep trial, during which buyers can return the product for a refund, excluding any shipping costs.
Best Goose Down
Use this SleepFoundation.org link for the most current discount on Royal Egyptian Bedding bedding
Royal Egyptian Bedding produces the Goose Down Comforter in several variations, each of which is reasonably priced and well-constructed. While goose down can be pricey, the Royal Egyptian Bedding Goose Down Comforter offers great value for shoppers.
The 100 percent Egyptian cotton shell is breathable and soft, due to the long-staple cotton fibers used. The smooth weave allows air to flow throughout the comforter, while preventing down fill from escaping.
Royal Egyptian Bedding offers its Goose Down Comforter in multiple fill power levels, including 600, 650, 700, and 750. The higher the fill power, the more warm and insulating the comforter will be. The lower fill power options are more suitable for use in the summer months, or year-round in moderate climates.
The white goose down clusters used as fill are cleaned to remove allergens, dust, and bacteria. The Goose Down Comforter should only be professionally dry cleaned as needed.
Purchasers have 30 days to try out the Royal Egyptian Bedding Goose Down Comforter, and the company encourages purchasers to give the comforter several hours to fluff up completely and reach its maximum loft once it has been removed from its packaging. The comforter is available in twin/twin XL, full/queen, and king/California king sizes, with each being slightly oversized to hang more over the edges of the mattress. There are multiple color options for shoppers.
There are various construction methods used for down comforters, which we will break down in depth later on. In addition to the type of down used, shoppers should also consider the fill power, construction, and design of the down comforter.
Down comforters differ from down alternative and other comforters when it comes to price, warmth, and quality. Down comforters are typically made with natural materials and tend to be more expensive than other options. Down alternative comforters are filled with synthetic fiber fill to imitate the feel of down at a more affordable price-point.
We’ll help shoppers know what to look for when choosing a down comforter, in addition to the pros and cons that should be considered before making a purchase.
A down comforter feels cozy and soft while adding warmth to the bed, but how do you know you are picking the right one? The quality of materials and construction are important to consider, in addition to price. We’ll break down essential considerations for shoppers here.
Purchasing a down comforter can feel overwhelming, especially with so many options to choose from. Understanding what to look for can help shoppers narrow down their choices and pick a down comforter that suits their needs.
Many companies label their bedding as luxury, which can be misleading. The luxury label can cause inflated prices and confusion for shoppers, so we encourage shoppers to look beyond labels and product marketing and focus on the following instead.
These features, which we’ll break down below, determine how the down comforter will perform in terms of durability, temperature regulation, and overall comfort. A high-quality down comforter is an investment, and shoppers want to feel confident they are choosing one that is designed to last. A well-constructed down comforter will last for many years, especially with proper care.
Down comforters are often sought after for their durability and quality construction. When considering the quality of materials, shoppers should look at the shell, fill, and design. The shell material will likely be made with cotton, as it is breathable and soft, but some comforters are made with wool, silk, or synthetic fabrics. To determine the quality of the down fill, shoppers can consider the type of down and its fill power, in addition to the supply chain and any relevant certifications. The stitching should keep the fill in place. Extended warranty coverage can also speak to the quality of the comforter.
The size of the down comforter should correspond to the mattress size, though some are designed to fit two similar sizes, such as a full/queen size. Shoppers should decide how much of the comforter they want to hang over the edges of the bed and double-check the manufacturer’s measurements before purchasing. There are variations in sizing between manufacturers, which will be important if shoppers plan to use the comforter inside of a duvet cover.
The weight of a down comforter is often measured in ounces, indicating how much down fill is used. In addition to weight, shoppers should factor in fill power, which measures how much room one ounce of down fill takes up. Higher fill power means more warmth, as do heavier weights. Shoppers may want to consider what season or climate they plan to use the comforter in, and whether or not they tend to sleep hot.
A down comforter can be paired with a duvet cover, so the down comforter itself is often simple in terms of design and color. That said, many down comforters are woven with subtle stripes or patterns or available in more than one color. The stitching used to keep the down fill from shifting also creates a design, which can include box, diamond, or channel patterns.
A down comforter can be expensive, but it is also a valuable investment due to its durability. Shoppers should expect to pay more than they would for a down alternative comforter, but the price range can vary widely. Setting a budget before shopping is helpful, as is keeping an eye out for sales and promotions.
Down is naturally insulating, so it provides plenty of warmth but is still breathable. Different fill powers determine how well the down comforter regulates temperature. Hot sleepers and those who live in warmer climates may want to look for a lightweight down comforter with a fill power of 600 to 700, while those who want added warmth may opt for 700 to 850 fill power.
There are several pros and cons of down comforters, which shoppers will want to keep in mind before making a purchase. One of the main benefits of a down comforter is its durability. The natural down clusters provide warmth and comfort for many years, especially if the comforter has a high-quality construction.
The drawback to the durability of a down comforter is that it comes with a higher price tag. While a down comforter can provide a valuable return on your investment, it is more expensive upfront than other comforter types.
When selecting a down comforter, the quality of the materials used will matter more than the materials themselves. That said, there are different types of down comforters available, and it is helpful for shoppers to understand their options before deciding on a down comforter.
Duck Down vs. Goose Down
Down comforters will be filled with either duck down or goose down. Both act as insulation, providing warmth for sleepers while promoting breathability.
It is essential for shoppers to compare comforters beyond duck vs. goose down, since both types of down have similar durability and insulating properties. Fill power indicates how warm the comforter will be, in addition to the size and quality of the down. Common fill powers range from below 400 to 800 and above.
The cover material of the down comforter impacts temperature regulation and price.
The stitching on a down comforter serves a functional purpose, as well as adding design interest. There are several stitching types that are commonly used.
How much do down comforters cost?
Down comforters can be expensive, but there are a range of price-points available. Shoppers can expect to spend at least $150 on a down comforter that is made with high-quality construction and a higher fill power. Budget-friendly down comforters may include a percentage of feather fill for added structure and lower costs.
Price is not the only way to tell if a down comforter is high-quality, but certain types of down fill and shell materials will be more expensive. Shoppers should compare comforters to get an idea of different price-points and construction methods.
How do I clean a down comforter?
When cleaning a down comforter, it is crucial to follow the guidelines provided by the manufacturer. Some down comforters can be machine washed, while others require professional cleaning. When machine washing a down comforter, mild detergent and cold water is often recommended. The comforter should be air dried or tumble dried with low heat, and purchasers should make sure the comforter is completely dry before placing it back on the bed or storing it.
Use caution when dry cleaning a down comforter, as this cleaning process can strip the down clusters of natural oils and cause them to break down more quickly. A duvet cover helps protect the down comforter and extend the time needed between cleanings.
Where can I buy a down comforter?
Down comforters are popular and widely available, and they can be purchased online and in stores. Those who want to shop for a down comforter at a physical location can look at department stores and home goods retailers. Bedding and mattress companies that operate online tend to have down comforter options available, and some offer generous sleep trials or return policies that allow the purchaser to test out the comforters in their homes. When shopping online, customers should look for return policy requirements and warranty coverage.
How long do down comforters last?
Down comforters are durable and can last 10 to 15 years or longer with proper care and maintenance. Down is a natural material that needs to be fluffed regularly to maintain its loft and it should be carefully cleaned when needed. A duvet cover can extend the lifespan of a down comforter by preventing normal wear and tear.
Which size comforter is right for me?
When selecting a comforter size, shoppers should consider their mattress size and how much coverage they want. Down comforters are available in standard sizes that correspond to mattress sizes. Confirm the sizing and measurements provided by the manufacturer to ensure compatibility, as dimensions can vary slightly between brands. Some down comforters are oversized to hang more over the edges of the bed.
Is buying down ethical?
Down is an animal byproduct that can be sourced sustainably and ethically. Responsibly sourced down is harvested without causing undue harm. While there is a history of unethical treatment within the down industry, including live-plucking and force-feeding, there has been closer scrutiny that has led companies to seek out ethical suppliers. Shoppers can look for certain certifications, such as the Responsible Down Standard, that indicate a traceable supply chain and humane treatment of the ducks and geese from which the down is sourced.
The Sleep Foundation editorial team is dedicated to providing content that meets the highest standards for accuracy and objectivity. Our editors and medical experts rigorously evaluate every article and guide to ensure the information is factual, up-to-date, and free of bias.
The Sleep Foundation fact-checking guidelines are as follows: