Tuft & Needle vs. Loom & Leaf Mattress Comparison

Tuft & Needle and Loom & Leaf are on the forefront of the online revolution that has swept the mattress industry in the last several years. Both brands offer a range of mattresses as well as bed frames, pillows, and other sleep accessories.

Tuft & Needle was one of the earliest companies to make and sell mattress-in-a-box style beds online. Founded in 2012, this company offers three competitively priced mattress models. The Tuft & Needle Original is a low-profile, simply designed, and budget friendly all-foam mattress. The Mint is an upgraded version of the Original, featuring an extra layer of the company’s proprietary Adaptive Foam and a machine-washable cover. The Hybrid contains Tuft & Needle’s Adaptive Foam with the resilient feel of innerspring coils.

Loom & Leaf was developed by Saatva, a mattress company known for its wide range of beds and accessories. The Loom & Leaf, available in a Firm and Relaxed Firm, is a durable all-foam mattress made from high-quality materials. Unique among online mattress retailers, Loom & Leaf does not compress its beds for shipping and offers complimentary in-home set up with every mattress purchase.

If you’re on the market for a new mattress, each of these brands has something unique to offer. Here we’ll take a deep dive comparing and contrasting the most important features and performance categories you need to consider when evaluating Loom & Leaf vs. Tuft & Needle.

Quick Look

We’ve worked hard to show you which mattresses are the best fit for you. Check out our full mattress guides listed below!

Sizing and Weight Options

When buying a new mattress, one of the first practical decisions you’ll need to make is the size. This includes traditional mattress sizing options as well as the weight and height of your new mattress.

Most mattress retailers offer the full range of sizes from twin up to California king. The size you choose will depend entirely on your personal needs, including how much space you have available, how many people will be sharing the mattress, and how much sleep surface you need for a restful night’s sleep.

While mattress sizing is becoming more standardized across manufacturers, the height and weight of a mattress may differ from model to model. Thicker mattresses will sit taller when placed in your bed frame. This can make getting in and out of bed more effortless but will also require deep pocket fitted sheets.

Heavier mattresses can be more difficult to move. If you plan to move frequently or have limited mobility, you may want to choose a lighter mattress for easy lifting and transport.

Both Tuft & Needle and Loom & Leaf offer the full range of mattress size options for each of their models including twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king.

If you’re looking for a lower profile mattress, Tuft & Needle is the better choice with options for both 10-inch and 12-inch mattress heights. In contrast, both the Loom & Leaf Firm and Relaxed Firm come in a 12-inch height.

The Tuft & Needle Hybrid mattress is the heaviest of these two brands at 112 pounds for the queen size. Due to their incorporation of metal innersprings, hybrids tend to be heavier, but for some the comfort is worth the extra weight.

The Loom & Leaf Firm and Relaxed Firm mattresses offer a lighter option at 93 pounds for a queen size. However, if you’re looking for the lightest mattress choice, the Tuft & Needle Original mattress weighs just 72 pounds for a queen size.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Mattress construction and materials are perhaps the most important aspects to consider when buying a new mattress. That’s because the type of materials used and how they are layered will have the largest impact on mattress comfort, overall performance, and durability.

Most mattresses on the market today are made from foam, latex, innerspring coils, or some combination of the three. These materials are layered within the interior of the mattress to create a support core and a comfort layer. The support core makes up the bottom layer of your mattress and provides a sturdy foundation. It’s usually made from high-density foam or latex or a layer of innerspring coils.

The comfort layer sits on top of the support core and offers a soft, plush surface for the sleeper. It’s most often made from foam or latex. As the layer you contact while sleeping, the comfort system can have a significant influence on the overall feeling and performance of your mattress. Here we’ll review the unique construction of Loom & Leaf vs. Tuft & Needle.

Tuft & Needle

Every Tuft & Needle mattress comes with a cover made with a micro polyamide and polyester blend. This material provides a protective, breathable layer that is soft against your skin.

Each Tuft & Needle mattress also contains the company’s proprietary Adaptive Foam. This specially blended polyfoam offers several benefits usually only found in memory foam and latex mattresses.

Tuft & Needle Adaptive Foam offers excellent pressure relief and body-contouring comfort, while still maintaining above average responsiveness and ease of movement. The Adaptive Foam is also infused with cooling gel and graphite to make the sleep surface more breathable and temperature-neutral than a traditional memory foam mattress.

Now let’s take a closer look at how each Tuft & Needle mattress is constructed.

Original Tuft & Needle
The Original Tuft & Needle is an all-foam mattress with simple construction:

• 3 inches of Adaptive Foam
• 7 inches of high-density polyfoam

Although lightweight and low-profile, the Tuft & Needle Original offers a supportive, medium-firm sleep surface with broad appeal.

Tuft & Needle Mint
The Tuft & Needle Mint expands upon the simplicity of the company’s original model, adding an additional layer of Adaptive Foam:

• 3 inches of Adaptive Foam
• 2 inches of Adaptive Foam
• 7 inches of high-density polyfoam

This creates a higher profile mattress while maintaining the medium-firm sleep surface of the Tuft & Needle Original. The Mint also features an antimicrobial protectant embedded into the fabric of the cover. The top half of the cover can be zipped off and machine washed, allowing you to keep your sleep surface hygienic.

Tuft & Needle Hybrid
The Tuft & Needle Hybrid combines the foam construction of the Original and Mint models with two layers of innerspring coils:

• Adaptive Foam
• Micro-coils
• Transitional polyfoam
• Pocketed innerspring coils

The pocketed coil-based support core and comfort layer give this mattress a more responsive bouncy feel. The hybrid construction also provides superior edge support, a common shortcoming of all-foam mattresses. The Tuft & Needle Hybrid offers a slightly softer sleep surface that’s rated a medium on our firmness scale.

Loom & Leaf

Loom & Leaf’s flagship model comes two comfort options: Relaxed Firm and Firm. These options correspond to medium firm (6) and firm (8) on our firmness scale. While the Relaxed Firm option will suit the needs of most sleepers, the Loom & Leaf Firm is a good choice for those who enjoy a more supportive sleep surface.

Both Loom & Leaf options are made with all-foam construction:

• 3 inches of two combined memory foam layers, gel-infused
• 2 inches of transition foam
• 6-inch high-density polyfoam support core

Both Loom & Leaf mattress options come with a quilted organic cotton cover that is cushioned with 5/8 inch of foam for a plush feel. They also share a top layer of aerated and gel-infused memory foam, designed to hold more cooling gel in the center to the mattress. This keeps the sleeper cool while providing additional lumbar support and targeted pressure relief.

The second layer of memory foam determines the mattress firmness. Each model offers contouring pressure relief. However, the more supportive Loom & Leaf Firm mattress offers a better surface for sex as well as superior temperature neutrality.

Average Customer Ratings

Customer ratings and reviews can help give you a more unbiased look at the best and worst features of a particular mattress brand and model. Here are some questions to ask yourself as you read customer ratings:

• Who is the reviewer? Look for reviews from actual customers, not someone who received a free mattress or compensation in exchange for a review. Also note whether the reviewer’s sleep style and comfort preferences match your own.
• What’s the average review score? The overall rating, often on a scale of 1-5, can give you a snapshot of how well a mattress performs for most customers.
• How many reviews are there? The more reviews the better. More reviews means it’s less likely that a mattress’s rating is affected by a handful of positive or negative outliers.
• What do the reviews actually say? Aside from the scores, take a look at what individual reviewers have to say, especially if there are a large number of reviews. It’s important to look at customer reviews as a whole and not give too much weight to any single review. Look for consistent trends and themes, both good and bad.

Below you’ll find a summary of the average customer ratings for Tuft & Needle vs. Loom & Leaf.

In-Depth Ratings

With so many mattresses on the market today, especially from online retailers, it can be hard to figure out which one is right for you. Everyone has their own preferences when it comes to mattress comfort and features.

To get a better sense of how well a mattress will fit your unique needs, it’s important to assess a mattress from every angle. Here we evaluate Loom & Leaf vs. Tuft & Needle looking at the most important categories that are key to mattress performance.

Durability
This category refers to how long you can expect your mattress to resist wear and tear and perform comfortably. When a mattress has reached the end of its lifespan, it begins to sag and loses its ability to comfortably support your weight and promote proper spinal alignment. Most mattresses will last between 6-8 years with some models lasting over a decade. The mattress materials as well as sleeper weight can affect the lifespan of your mattress.

Motion Isolation
If you share a bed with a partner or loved one, you know how someone tossing and turning can keep you up at night. Motion isolation helps dampen the transfer of motion across the surface of the mattress. Memory foam mattresses typically have the best motion isolation.

Sex
For couples looking to do more than sleep on their bed, it’s important to consider how well a mattress performs during sexual activity. Mattresses that are more responsive provide a greater bounce that can make movement easier. Latex and hybrid mattresses tend to have the most responsiveness. However, all-foam mattresses provide superior traction. Take into account what features are most important to you and your partner.

Temperature Neutrality
If you tend to sleep hot or live in a warm climate, you’ll want to find a mattress that stays temperature neutral throughout the night. Softer mattresses that are highly contouring and hug your body can reduce airflow between your skin and the mattress. Additionally, some mattresses are more likely to absorb and retain your body heat, becoming warmer as the night goes on.

Pressure Relief
A mattress should provide support along the length of your body. Areas that are heavier, such as your shoulders, lower back, and hips require ample support as well as enough cushioning to prevent the development of aches and pains. Mattresses with a moderate amount of body contouring will help support proper spinal alignment while providing relief to key pressure point areas.

Off-gassing
Many mattress manufacturing processes create volatile organic compounds (VOCs) as a byproduct. VOCs aren’t toxic, but they can create an unpleasant odor when you first unpack a mattress-in-a-box from its vacuum-sealed packaging. The smell typically dissipates within a few hours though some mattresses can take up to a few days to fully off-gas. This is an important consideration if you’re sensitive to strong odors.

Ease of Movement
While a moderate level of body contouring is important for comfort and pressure point relief, most sleepers don’t want to feel as if they’re sinking into their mattress. A mattress with some resilience—how quickly a material retakes its original shape once weight is removed—makes movement easier. This is important for couples who use their mattress for sexual activity as well as people with reduced mobility who may have trouble getting in and out of bed.

Edge Support
This category refers to how well a mattress can support your bodyweight at its edge. Mattresses with poor edge support sag along their perimeter when you apply weight. Significant edge support will increase the usable surface area of your mattress, an important feature if you plan to share your mattress with a partner or loved one. Edge support will also make it more comfortable to sit on the edge of your bed.

Tuft & Needle

Loom & Leaf

Prices and Sizing

If you’ve already done some research on your own, you likely noticed that prices can vary widely between different mattress brands and models. While this can be confusing for new mattress shoppers, the good news is that there’s a mattress out there that fits into your budget.

Several factors influence the price of a mattress including:

• Materials: certain materials cost more to produce than others. All-foam mattresses tend to be on the lower end of the price scale while mattresses that use natural latex or organic materials are often more expensive.
• Thickness: higher profile mattresses require more materials and are going to be pricier than thinner mattresses made from similar materials.
• Construction: mattresses with complex construction such as a high number of layers and a wide variety of proprietary materials are going to be more costly.
• Country of Origin: while many online retailers use U.S. manufacturing, it can add to the price tag of your mattress.
• Other Perks: don’t forget to consider the value of free shipping, sleep trial policies, and warranties when evaluating the price of a mattress.

Here we’ve compiled a table to show you the current prices of every mattress model made by Tuft & Needle vs. Loom & Leaf.

Tuft & Needle

Loom & Leaf

If you’re looking for a new mattress on a tight budget, the Tuft & Needle Original is your best option. This low-profile, all-foam mattress has a simple design but still offers a comfortable night’s sleep at a low price point

Loom & Leaf doesn’t offer a similar budget option, but the company’s Relaxed Firm and Firm mattresses are comparable to Tuft & Needle’s Mint model. These 12-inch all-foam mattresses are similarly constructed with three distinct foam layers. However, the Loom & Leaf options are noticeably more expensive than the Tuft & Needle Mint.

When considering Tuft & Needle, remember that a lower price point doesn’t necessarily mean lower quality. Even Tuft & Needle’s Hybrid, a mattress style that usually demands a higher price tag, costs less than Loom & Leaf’s all-foam design.

Overall, Loom & Leaf’s price point is above-average for an all-foam mattress. But unlike other mattress retailers, Loom & Leaf’s purchase price includes in-home set up as well as optional removal of your old mattress. Loom & Leaf mattresses also come with a longer sleep trial period and warranty compared to Tuft & Needle.

It’s also important to note that customers rarely pay full price for a new mattress. Online retailers have frequent promotions and sales that reduce the cost so be patient and keep your eye out for discounts.

Trials, Warranty, and Delivery

Aside from their competitive pricing and variety of sleep options, online mattress retailers like Tuft & Needle and Loom & Leaf have been successful due to their excellent customer service. This includes shipping, return, sleep trial, and warranty policies that give you, the consumer, a great deal of freedom when choosing a new mattress.

If you’ve never purchased a mattress online before, we’ll help you understand what to expect when it comes to the logistics of ordering a mattress through the web.

Shipping

Mattresses are bulky items and difficult to ship. That’s why mattress retailers have traditionally been constrained to brick and mortar stores. However, online mattress brands have figured out a way to make mattress shipping low-cost and convenient.

When you order a mattress online, you have two options: mattress-in-a-box shipping or White Glove delivery.

Mattress-in-a-Box Shipping
Mattress-in-a-box represents that standard shipping option for the majority of online mattress retailers including Tuft & Needle. The company will compress, vacuum seal your mattress, and place it in a large box that can be shipped with UPS or FedEx.

Once your order is shipped, your mattress will arrive within a few days with standard ground shipping. Mattress-in-a-box delivery is usually free, however, it may take up to two people to move the box and set up the mattress.

Tuft & Needle offers free mattress-in-a-box delivery in the United States. The company uses FedEx Ground service to coordinate its mattress deliveries which typically take between 3-7 business days to arrive. Same-day shipping is also available for a fee.

The Loom & Leaf is not compressed and is therefore not subject to the standard mattress-in-a-box shipping protocol.

White Glove Delivery
White Glove delivery is a special service offered by many online mattress retailers. Each mattress company may offer a slightly different set of services with their White Glove option. However, White Glove delivery typically includes in-home mattress set-up and old mattress removal.

Tuft & Needle offers White Glove delivery for an additional charge. The service includes in-home setup and old mattress removal.

Because Loom & Leaf does not use mattress-in-a-box shipping methods, every Loom & Leaf mattress comes with free White Glove delivery. This includes in-home set up and a free option for old mattress removal that you can select during checkout. Loom & Leaf does not offer expedited shipping, unless a customer cancels their order for an already-made mattress.

Shipping Outside the Contiguous United States
Shipping policies will often differ for customers living outside the contiguous United States in Alaska, Hawaii, or international locations.

Tuft & Needle only offers free mattress-in-a-box shipping and the option for White Glove delivery to customers in the contiguous United States.

Loom & Leaf ships to the contiguous United States, Ontario and parts of Western Canada. Customers living in Alaska or Hawaii can make arrangements with a third-party freight forwarding service if they wish to purchase a Loom & Leaf mattress.

Returns

Online mattress retailers usually offer forgiving return policies in the form of extended sleep trials. A sleep trial allows you to order a new mattress and try it out for a set number of nights. If you’re not satisfied with the mattress for any reason, you can return it for a refund.

Every company’s sleep trial policy differs in its length (how long you can try out your new mattress), return fees (some companies charge a transportation fee), and mandatory break-in period (how long you must keep your mattress before you can request a refund).

Tuft & Needle and Loom & Leaf offer a 100-night and 365-night sleep trial, respectively, with free returns and no mandatory break-in periods. If you decide to return your mattress, each company will work with you to coordinate either a pickup or donation of the mattress.

Warranties

A warranty protects customers against defective materials in the construction of their mattress. Almost all online mattress companies offer a long term warranty at no extra charge with the purchase of a mattress.

Warranties usually cover your mattress for 10 years at a minimum and may be prorated. This means the customer will be responsible for an increasing percentage of the repair cost the longer they’ve owned their mattress.

Tuft & Needle offers a completely non-prorated 10-year warranty covering defects in materials or manufacturing. During those 10 years, Tuft & Needle will repair or replace the mattress.

Loom & Leaf offers a lifetime warranty. While warranty repairs and replacements are free, customers are responsible for a transportation fee after the first 2 years. The company also offers a Fairness Replacement Option, where customers can keep their defective mattress and purchase a new mattress at a prorated discount and a transportation fee.