Puffy vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison

Quick Look

We’ve worked hard to show you which mattresses are the best fit for you. Check out our full mattress guides listed below!

Sizing Options

Size should be one of your first considerations as a mattress shopper. Most mattresses sold today are available in six standard sizes. These include the twin, twin XL, and full for single sleepers, as well as the queen, king, and California king designed for two or more people. You should be able to find a matching base, foundation, or other support system for your mattress size. We don’t recommend using a mattress and support system that correspond to different sizes.

Additionally, some mattresses (including Tempur-Pedic models) are available in “split” sizes for couples who use an adjustable bed base; with a split down the middle of the bed, each sleeper can customize the angle of their side of the bed.

Mattress weight is another important factor since some bases and foundations can bear more weight than others. Weight is especially crucial if you order a mattress-in-a-box model that you’ll need to carry into your house.

Mattress size and weight information for Puffy and Tempur-Pedic is listed in the table below. Please note that Puffy’s “twin XL” size matches the dimensions of Tempur-Pedic’s “twin long” size.

As you can see from the tables, the mattress size and thickness selection from Puffy and Tempur-Pedic are fairly similar. Both brands offer multiple height options for medium-profile and high-profile beds. The mattress weights are also comparable.

Puffy offers a split king size, and Tempur-Pedic offers split king and split California king sizes. This means Tempur-Pedic provides mattresses for couples who use adjustable bed bases. On the other hand, many of Tempur-Pedic’s models are not sold in a twin size; all Puffy models are available in the twin size, so this may be your best option if you’re specifically looking for a twin.

While Tempur-Pedic mattresses are generally heavier than Puffy’s, customers will receive free White Glove delivery for every model except the Cloud. Puffy does not provide any type of White Glove delivery, meaning you’ll need to carry the mattress to the room of your choice and set it up yourself.

Construction and Materials Comparison

The materials used to construct a mattress will affect how it feels and how well it performs in different sleeper categories. Mattresses sold today are generally designed with three core components. The comfort layer provides surface-level cushioning and contouring, the transitional layer reinforces the comfort layer and prevents sleepers from sinking too deeply, and the support core base layer provides stability for the entire bed.

Since each of these components serves a distinct purpose, the use of different materials will produce varying results. For instance, a mattress with a high-density foam support core will feel distinct from a mattress with a steel-coil support core – even if these two beds include comparable comfort and transitional layer materials.

Below, you’ll find a detailed construction breakdown for each Puffy and Tempur-Pedic mattress.

Puffy

Puffy Mattress

The flagship Puffy Mattress is constructed with a gel-infused memory foam comfort layer, followed by a transitional polyfoam layer. The mattress has a medium feel that corresponds to a 5 on the 1-10 firmness scale, so you’ll feel a close body contour as the foam responds and adapts to your body – especially if you weigh more than 230 pounds. This model also contains a support core of high-density polyfoam. Altogether, the Puffy Mattress measures 10 inches thick and is considered a medium-profile bed.

Puffy Lux Hybrid

The Puffy Lux Hybrid model contains comfort layers of gel-infused memory foam and soft polyfoam, along with a polyfoam transitional layer and pocketed coil support core. As a result, the Lux Hybrid is 2 inches thicker than the flagship Puffy model, making it a high-profile 12-inch model. The Lux also has a plusher surface feel than the Puffy Mattress, making it better suited to people who weigh less than 130 pounds but most likely too soft for anyone who weighs more than 230 pounds.

Puffy Royal Hybrid

The Puffy Royal Hybrid is Puffy’s thickest mattress, measuring 14 inches thick and considered a high-profile model. This mattress is also very plush and adaptive thanks to a top comfort layer of gel-infused memory foam, followed by two polyfoam comfort layers, the second of which consists of convoluted (egg-crate) polyfoam that promotes airflow to keep the mattress cool.

The Royal Hybrid also features a transitional polyfoam layer divided into different firmness zones. This ensures enhanced support for your torso and waist – where most people carry a disproportionate amount of weight – and gentle cradling for the head, neck, shoulders, and legs. The mattress contains a pocketed coil support core.

All Puffy mattresses share the same general firmness level of medium (5). If you prefer mattresses that feel softer or firmer than a medium, then you may not be satisfied with any Puffy mattress. That said, Puffy mattresses are generally more affordable than Tempur-Pedic models. So if you have a tight shopping budget, you may want to opt for Puffy over Tempur-Pedic.

Tempur-Pedic

Tempur-Cloud

The Cloud is Tempur-Pedic’s only mattress-in-a-box model, meaning it is compressed for shipping. This mattress is built with two layers of proprietary TEMPUR memory foam, along with a high-density polyfoam base. Like the Puffy Mattress, the Cloud measures 10 inches thick and is considered medium (5), so both beds will feel very similar to one another and provide comparable levels of body-contouring.

Tempur-Adapt

The Adapt measures 11 inches thick, but its medium (5) feel is quite similar to the Cloud’s. This mattress is constructed with a layer of adaptive TEMPUR-ES memory foam over a denser transitional layer of TEMPUR memory foam. The all-foam Adapt contains a high-density support core, whereas the hybrid has a base layer of individually pocketed coils. The hybrid Adapt is more responsive and supportive by comparison, but you’ll still feel a deep, pressure-relieving cradle for your body.

Tempur-ProAdapt

The ProAdapt is one of Tempur-Pedic’s most versatile mattresses. You can select a soft (3), medium (5), or firm (7) feel for the all-foam ProAdapt, or a hybrid model with a medium (5) feel. These models are constructed with TEMPUR memory foam comfort layers and TEMPUR-APR transitional layers. The support core of the all-foam ProAdapt is made from convoluted polyfoam, which helps to circulate air throughout the interior and keep the mattress relatively cool. The hybrid contains pocketed coils instead, which also regulate the bed’s temperature by promoting consistent airflow. The ProAdapt measures 12 inches thick as a hybrid or all-foam model, making it a high-profile mattress.

Tempur-LuxeAdapt

The LuxeAdapt is an all-foam model. The soft (3) LuxeAdapt features a comfort layer of TEMPUR-ES memory foam, while the firm (7) model’s comfort layer is original TEMPUR memory foam; both models also include a transitional layer of TEMPUR-APR memory foam and a convoluted polyfoam base layer. We recommend the LuxeAdapt for anyone who wants a traditional memory foam feel but does not feel comfortable on beds with medium feels. At 13 inches thick, the LuxeAdapt is tied for Tempur-Pedic’s thickest mattress.

Tempur-Breeze

The breeze° models feature covers infused with phase change material (PCM), which absorbs heat from your body until the surface reaches a certain temperature and then maintains that temperature throughout the night, regardless of how hot you feel. The PRObreeze°, which is intended to decrease the surface temperature by 3 degrees, is offered as a medium-feel (5) all-foam or hybrid model. The LUXEbreeze°, which can decrease its surface temperature by as much as 8 degrees, is available as a soft (3) or firm (7) all-foam mattress. All breeze° models contain two memory foam layers over a support core of convoluted, high-density polyfoam.

In-Depth Ratings

Every mattress has distinct pros and cons based on how soft or firm it feels, how much it costs, and which materials are used to construct its individual layers. There are dozens of metrics you can use to evaluate a mattress. We consider the following performance categories most important when comparing different brands and models. You’ll find our ratings for each Puffy and Tempur-Pedic mattress below, but first, we’ll explain what each category means and how we evaluate a mattress for it.

Durability
The average mattress will perform for six to eight years before you’ll need to replace it. Over time, the comfort, transitional, and support materials will soften and lose shape. This can make the mattress feel uneven and less supportive. Certain materials are associated with above-average longevity, such as high-density memory foam, organic latex, and steel coil systems. Regardless of which materials are used, you should rotate your mattress head-to-foot every three to six months to preserve its surface from deep sagging and body impressions.

Motion Isolation
Some mattresses are constructed with materials that absorb movement when you get in and out of bed and prevent this motion from transferring across the surface, where it might disturb your partner’s sleep. Polyfoam and memory foam are particularly effective at preventing or eliminating this transfer. If the mattress features more responsive materials, such as latex layers or coil systems, then you and your partner will probably feel more motion when the other person moves around in bed.

Sex
For sex, most couples prefer a mattress that offers good responsiveness and gentle conforming. A bit of bounciness on the surface allows you and your partner to move around freely, while some contouring ensures good traction when you want to maintain one position for a while. Edge support is also important for sex because mattresses that sink along the perimeter may confine you to the middle of the mattress, whereas reinforced mattresses allow you and your partner to use the entire surface.

Temperature Neutrality
If a mattress is constructed with materials that absorb and trap body heat, then you may notice excessive warmth on the surface that can affect how comfortable you feel. Some beds offer consistent temperature neutrality thanks to certain components, such as ventilated comfort layers, coil systems that promote steady internal airflow, and covers made from breathable fabrics. High-density memory foam tends to sleep warmer than other mattress materials.

Pressure Relief
Many people feel pressure points in certain areas of the body, such as the neck and shoulders, lower back, and hips. For any sleeper, the best mattress for pressure relief will support the body on an even plane, promote good spinal alignment, and prevent excessive sinkage around that person’s heavier areas. For this reason, you should take your body type and sleep position into account when selecting a mattress based on firmness.

Off-gassing
Most mattresses emit off-gassing odor when new, but beds with foam layers typically produce the strongest and most persistent smells. The good news is that off-gassing odors typically dissipate within a week or less, but some models are known to retain these smells for a bit longer. You can place the mattress in a well-ventilated room for a few days before sleeping on it to flush out unwanted smells. However, those who are particularly sensitive to smells may want to avoid beds with above-average odor potential.

Ease of Movement
If a mattress tends to sink deeply, then you may have a more difficult time getting in and out of bed. This can also affect the ease of which you change sleep positions if you are a combination side, back, or stomach sleeper. A mattress with a responsive surface and a sturdy support system will be easier for most people to move across, particularly those who weigh more than 230 pounds.

Edge Support
On any given mattress, you’ll probably sink at least a little when seated along the edges. However, models with thick and supportive base layers provide more bounce-back. If a mattress feels weak around the perimeter, then you may have a hard time getting in and out of bed and may not feel secure sleeping near the edges – especially if you weigh more than 230 pounds.

Puffy

Tempur-Pedic

In-Depth Pricing

The price of a mattress often depends on the materials used to construct its individual layers. For example, the average all-foam mattress costs between $900 and $1,200 in a queen size, while the average hybrid costs $1,600 to $2,200 in the same size. Size is also a factor. Not surprisingly, you’ll pay more for a queen, king, or California king than you would for a smaller size. Certain features or add-ons can drive up the price-point, such as pillow-tops for extra cushioning and dual-firmness for couples. Lastly, you’ll probably pay more for a mattress in a brick-and-mortar store; online mattress brands can sell their beds for less because they don’t face the same overhead costs.

Below, you’ll find current prices for each Puffy and Tempur-Pedic mattress in every available size.

Puffy

Tempur-Pedic

As you can see from these tables, Puffy models cost considerably less than Tempur-Pedic models in most cases. That said, the Lux Hybrid and Royal Hybrid are considered more expensive than average. Only the flagship Puffy Mattress has a price-point that would be considered below average.

Although you’ll be able to find more affordable memory foam mattresses from competing brands, keep in mind that Puffy and Tempur-Pedic offer additional perks for customers. Every Puffy mattress model comes with a non-prorated lifetime warranty, so you may qualify for a free replacement if your Puffy mattress develops excessive sagging at any point. Tempur-Pedic, on the other hand, offers free White Glove delivery anywhere in the contiguous U.S. for every mattress model except the Cloud, which is compressed in a box and ships for free to your doorstep.

Trial, Warranty, and Delivery

Shipping

Puffy – like most mattress-in-a-box brands – provides free ground shipping anywhere in the 50 states. The mattress will be compressed, vacuum-sealed, and shipped in a small box that is delivered directly to your doorstep. You won’t need to be at home to sign for the mattress when it arrives.

Tempur-Pedic ships the Cloud in a box for free, as well, but delivery is limited to the contiguous U.S. at this time. All other Tempur-Pedic mattresses qualify for free White Glove delivery in the contiguous U.S. This service includes scheduled delivery date and time, in-home assembly, and old mattress removal upon request. Mattresses are not compressed for White Glove delivery.

Returns

Most online brands offer sleep trials so that customers can test out the bed for a certain length of time before committing to it. Sleep trials usually span 90 nights or more.

Puffy offers a 101-night sleep trial for all mattress models. This trial includes a mandatory 14-night break-in period, so you won’t be able to initiate a return until at least two weeks after the mattress arrives. In the event of a return, Puffy will issue a full product refund, though shipping costs for Alaska and Hawaii customers are not refundable.

Tempur-Pedic offers a 90-night sleep trial for all mattresses, and this trial includes a mandatory break-in period of 30 nights. Tempur-Pedic may also deduct up to $175 in return shipping charges from your total product refund.

Both companies will arrange for couriers to pick up the mattress at your residence and transport the bed for charitable donation or recycling.

Warranties

A warranty is a written agreement between the manufacturer of a certain product and the customer who purchases said product. The warranty essentially states that manufacturers are responsible for defective items, and will repair or replace the product as needed. The vast majority of mattresses sold today come with some sort of warranty that spans 10 years or longer.

Puffy backs each mattress with a lifetime warranty. This warranty is non-prorated, meaning the company covers all repair and replacement costs if your mattress develops a defect at any point of its lifespan; the replacement mattress is also covered under a lifetime warranty. However, the mattress must be used with a suitable foundation or support system and cannot show any signs of physical damage in order for you to replace it. Under this warranty, defects include sagging or body impressions measuring 1.5 inches or deeper, physical flaws with the mattress that cause materials to deteriorate prematurely, and manufacturing defects associated with the mattress cover.

Tempur-Pedic’s mattress warranty spans 10 years in length, and is also completely non-prorated. You won’t pay anything to have a defective mattress repaired or replaced apart from some minor shipping and transportation fees. This warranty considers sagging and body impressions defects if they measure three-fourths of an inch or deeper.

These warranties are non-transferable, so only you will qualify for warranty coverage – even if you sell or gift the mattress to someone else before the warranty expires.