is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here


Written by

Daniel Noyed is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Best Comforters of 2020

If you are giving your bedroom a makeover, a new comforter can be a stylish and functional addition to your bed. Bedding plays an essential role in sleep quality, as it can affect temperature regulation and overall comfort. The weight and fill of a comforter will determine if it is lightweight and breathable or heavy and warm.

Comforters vary greatly in design and price, and they can be made with a variety of different materials like down, polyester, or eucalyptus, which all perform differently. Shoppers should keep their bedroom environment in mind when selecting a comforter, as room temperature, climate, and personal preferences will determine which comforter is the best fit. Also, while a comforter may seem like an expensive investment, many are designed to last for a long time.

We’ll cover our top picks for the best comforters, including down and down alternative options. By breaking down the construction and performance of the best comforters on the market, we’ll help shoppers know what to look for when purchasing a comforter. Lastly, we’ll talk about the pros and cons of using a comforter, how it differs from a duvet, and how to maintain a comforter’s plush, lofty feel.

Product Details

Riley Home White Goose Down Comforter

Best Overall

Who it's best for:
  • Shoppers looking for luxury bedding
  • Those who want a breathable down comforter
  • Shoppers who would like their choice of warmth levels
Riley Home White Goose Down Comforter

The Riley Home White Goose Down Comforter is produced in two warmth options, so it caters to sleepers with different needs and preferences. The down fill is certified by the Responsible Down Standard and shoppers can rest assured that it is humanely sourced.

This is a luxury option with a price-point to match, but shoppers can expect the comforter to last a long time with proper care. The 400 thread count cotton sateen weave cover has subtle stripes and is made with 100% premium long-staple cotton for a smooth hand feel. The baffle box construction helps keep the down fill in place. Sewn-in loops allow purchasers to attach the comforter to duvet cover ties if desired.

The white goose down fill acts as natural insulation, keeping sleepers warm and cozy with a soft, plush feel. There are two density options to choose from, which differ in fill power. The all-season density is designed to be used year-round, with 700 fill power down. The extra warmth option is overfilled with 750 fill power down for a warmer, heavier feel that is better for cold sleepers and winter months.

The Riley Home White Goose Down Comforter can be washed in a front-loading, commercial washing machine with cold water and mild detergent. An additional cold rinse cycle is recommended to remove any soap residue. The comforter can then be tumbled dry with low heat and clean dryer balls to fluff the down clusters.

Shoppers can choose between twin, full/queen, and king sizes. Riley Home allows returns of new or gently used bedding with the original packaging within 100 days. The White Goose Down Comforter is covered by a 5-year warranty.

Feathered Friends Bavarian 700 Down Comforter

Best Down

Who it's best for:
  • Shoppers with larger budgets
  • Those looking for a down comforter to use year-round
  • Shoppers who want their choice of a light, medium, or heavy comforter
Feathered Friends Bavarian 700 Down Comforter

The Feathered Friends Bavarian 700 Down Comforter is a strong down comforter option, constructed with high-quality cotton and ethically sourced down. While shoppers are often cautious about down fill, Feathered Friends has a trackable supply chain and only uses down fill that adheres to the Responsible Down Standard (RDS).

The 400 thread count, single-ply cambric cotton cover is tightly woven to keep the down fill in. A double-stitched, piped edge reinforces the perimeter of the comforter. Loops for duvet cover ties are sewn in, so purchasers can pair the comforter with a duvet cover to prevent wear and tear and extend time between cleanings.

The comforter is filled with 700+ fill power European goose down. Since the down fill is RDS certified, the geese are not subjected to live plucking, force feeding, or other unnecessary suffering. The comforter is certified hypoallergenic.

The Feathered Friends Bavarian 700 Down Comforter has a pillowy feel with a high loft. Shoppers can choose between three weights, including light, medium, and arctic, to ensure the comforter meets their needs. All three options are breathable and help regulate temperature, but some sleepers may find that goose down sleeps a little warm. Available sizes include twin, full, queen, king, and California king.

Feathered Friends includes detailed washing instructions on its website, but the company also offers a cleaning service for purchasers for an additional charge. The Feathered Friends return policy allows returns of new, unused merchandise within 30 days of purchase. The comforter comes with a lifetime warranty, which covers defects in materials and manufacturing, but purchasers must use the comforter inside of a duvet cover to maintain warranty coverage.

Sleep Restoration Down Alternative Comforter

Best Down Alternative

Who it's best for:
  • Value seekers
  • Allergy sufferers
  • Animal-conscious shoppers
  • Shoppers who want a variety of color options
Sleep Restoration Down Alternative Comforter

Since many comforters are designed to be compatible with duvet covers, they tend to only be available in white or neutral colors. The Sleep Restoration Down Alternative Comforter is available in more than 10 colors, including light, dark, and neutral options. It’s a great choice for a down alternative comforter, since it has an affordable price-point and high-quality construction.

Down alternative is beneficial for shoppers with down allergies or those who want to avoid purchasing bedding that incorporates animal products. The Sleep Restoration Down Alternative Comforter has a warm polyester shell, with high-quality down alternative fibers that mimic the feel of natural down. Baffle box stitching helps keep the insulating fill in place. The comforter resists allergens like dust mites, mold, and mildew.

The Down Alternative Comforter can be machine washed on a gentle cycle with cold water, and dried in the sun or with low heat. It is essential for purchasers to follow the manufacturer’s care instructions in order to prevent premature wear and tear.

The fluffy, warm feel of the Sleep Restoration comforter is ideal for cold sleepers and those who live in cooler climates. Shoppers have their choice between twin/twin XL, full/queen, and king/California king sizes. Sleep Restoration offers a 30-day satisfaction guarantee.

Buffy Breeze

Best Cooling

Who it's best for:
  • Hot sleepers
  • Eco-conscious and vegan shoppers
  • Shoppers with pets and kids
Buffy Breeze

The Buffy Breeze is a standout cooling comforter, with a light and breathable construction that is ideal for hot sleepers and those who live in warm climates. This plant-based comforter features a eucalyptus fiber fabrication that has a cool to the touch feel.

The 300 single-ply thread count shell is made of 100 percent eucalyptus fiber for a soft, silky feel and ample airflow throughout the comforter. Loops in every corner allow purchasers to pair the Buffy Breeze with a duvet cover, which is recommended to prevent wear and tear. Wave stitching with recycled thread adds a design element to the comforter while keeping the fill secured.

The Buffy Breeze is filled entirely with eucalyptus fiber that is fluffy and lightweight. All of the eucalyptus used is grown in renewable forests with a waste-free production process. Eucalyptus takes less water to produce, and the Buffy Breeze is OEKO-TEX certified, vegan, and cruelty-free. It’s a good choice for eco-conscious shoppers and those who want to reduce their environmental footprints.

The production process eliminates any essential oils, and the Buffy Breeze is safe for pets and kids. It naturally resists allergens like dust mites, mold, and mildew. The comforter is available in twin/twin XL, full/queen, and king/California king sizes, and is only produced in white. The Buffy Breeze is dry clean only.

Buffy offers a 7-night free trial for the Buffy Breeze, and the company places a hold on your credit card at the time of purchase but does not charge you until the 7 days are up. Additionally, the company offers a 30-day return policy.

Comma Home Eucalyptus Comforter

Best Eco-Friendly

Who it's best for:
  • Eco-conscious shoppers
  • Sleepers with allergies
  • Those who live in warm climates or tend to sleep hot
  • Shoppers with queen or king size beds
Comma Home Eucalyptus Comforter

Shoppers looking for an eco-friendly comforter will find the Comma Eucalyptus Comforter is a good fit, as it is made with natural and recycled materials.

The cover is made with 80 percent Lyocell, a eucalyptus based fabric, and 20 percent polyester from recycled water bottles. Both components reduce waste, as eucalyptus takes less water to produce and recycling water bottles keeps them out of landfills. Including polyester in the fabrication has an antimicrobial effect. Eucalyptus is highly breathable, allowing air to circulate throughout the comforter for a cooling feel. There are eight duvet loops that can be used to secure the Eucalyptus Comforter to a duvet cover.

The inside fill of the Comma Eucalyptus Comforter is air-fluffed polyfill, constructed as a single sheet to prevent bunching up or shifting within the eucalyptus shell. The result is a breathable, lightweight comforter that feels soft and fluffy. Sleepers can cozy up with the lofty comforter with a lower chance of overheating.

Since the Comma Eucalyptus Comforter is hypoallergenic, it is a good fit for sleepers with allergies. The fabrication resists common allergens like mold, mildew, and dust mites. The Comma Eucalyptus Comforter can be machine washed as needed.

The Eucalyptus Comforter is available in white in a queen or king size. Comma allows returns of new and unused bedding within 30 days. Customers are responsible for return packaging and shipping charges.

Ella Jayne All Season White Down Comforter

Best All-Season

Who it's best for:
  • Shoppers who want to use a down comforter year-round
  • Those who want a machine washable down comforter
  • Shoppers with larger budgets
Ella Jayne All Season White Down Comforter

For shoppers who want to use a down comforter year-round, the Ella Jayne All Season White Down Comforter is our pick for the best all-season comforter. The comforter has a lofty feel and is fluffy and cozy, but still regulates temperature well to suit a variety of climates.

The 100 percent cotton shell keeps the fill secured, preventing down clusters from poking through. Baffle box stitching helps prevent the fill from shifting or clumping together. Cotton is naturally breathable and lightweight, so it wicks away heat and moisture for a comfortable feel.

The Ella Jayne All Season White Down Comforter is filled with 550 fill power white goose down fill that is Responsible Down Standard certified. The down fill regulates temperature and acts as natural insulation, so the comforter feels lightweight and breathable in the summer and warm and cozy in the winter. The comforter is hypoallergenic and machine washable.

The Ella Jayne All Season White Down Comforter is a luxury option, so it’s a great fit for shoppers with larger budgets. The comforter is produced in twin, full/queen, and king/California king sizes, and is only available in white. The 30-day return policy allows returns of new and unused bedding.

Brooklinen Down Comforter

Best Lightweight

Who it's best for:
  • Shoppers who are looking for a lightweight down comforter
  • Those who want a generous sleep trial and warranty
  • Hot sleepers
Brooklinen Down Comforter

The Brooklinen Down Comforter is available in three weight options, lightweight all-season, and ultra-warm, to meet different needs and preferences. The 100 percent cotton sateen shell is light and breathable, so air can flow throughout the comforter. This helps regulate temperature and prevents overheating, even with the insulating down fill.

The down cluster fill varies depending on the weight option and is ethically sourced from Hutterite Farms in Canada, as well as from Europe. The all-season option uses 700 fill power down, while the lightweight option is constructed with 650 fill power down. The ultra-warm is made using 750 fill power down. The baffle box construction helps keep the down fill from shifting or clumping. There are corner loops sewn on, so the Brooklinen Down Comforter can be used with a duvet cover to protect the comforter and extend the time between cleanings.

When needed, the comforter can be aired out in the sun or air fluffed in the dryer on low heat. It can be spot cleaned as needed, or dry cleaned in the event of large stains. That said, dry cleaning can cause the down clusters to break down over time, so this option should be used sparingly. The Brooklinen Down Comforter is treated with antimicrobials to help reduce the amount of washing needed.

Shoppers can choose between twin/twin xl, full/queen, and king/California king sizes. The comforter is only available in white. Brooklinen offers a generous 365-day return policy, in addition to a quality guarantee and lifetime warranty.

In-Depth Comforter Guides

For more personalized comforter guides, check out the following pages:

How to Choose a Comforter

A comforter is a necessary piece of bedding for many people. Shoppers should consider their bedroom aesthetic and environment, in addition to specific needs like temperature regulation. We’ll break down what to consider when shopping for a comforter here.

What to Consider When Purchasing a Comforter

The following are the top factors to consider when shopping for a new comforter. These will help you determine the quality of the comforter and how well it meets your specific needs. They’ll also help filter out some of the noise of marketing terms and buzzwords used by companies, as certain features are less important than companies may have you believe.

Quality Materials
Quality materials extend the lifespan of a comforter and affect how it feels. The quality of the comforter’s shell, fill, and construction should all be considered. This includes the type of stitching used to keep the fill in place. A breathable shell can encourage temperature regulation, but the fabric should also prevent fill from escaping.

For down comforters, shoppers will want to consider any relevant certifications, such as the Responsible Down Standard, that indicate the comforter is filled with high-quality down.

Lastly, since price can be affected by quality, shoppers should be aware that a high-quality comforter may cost more upfront but should provide a better return on investment.

Comforters can come in standard bed sizes, like queen or king, or they may be produced in sizes that accommodate two different bed sizes, such as full/queen and king/California king. The comforter should be matched to the purchaser’s bed size. Some comforters are oversized to allow for more overhang on the bed sides.

Because there is such variation within comforter sizing, shoppers should check the product details from the manufacturer to confirm the length and width of the comforter. This is especially important if the comforter will be paired with a duvet cover.

The weight of a comforter can range from lightweight to heavy, and shoppers will want to consider whether or not they sleep hot, what temperature they keep their bedrooms, and if they plan to use the comforter year-round.

Hot sleepers and those in warm climates will benefit more from a lightweight comforter. The midweight or all-season comforters are better for year-round use, as they regulate temperature and keep sleepers from feeling too hot or too cold depending on the season. Heavyweight comforters are best for cold sleepers, winter months, and those who live in cold areas. The shell and fill material impact the weight of the comforter.

Comforters are often white or neutral in color, as they last a long time but can also be paired with a duvet cover. Some have a wider variety of designs available, including solid colors or prints, though these options may be more limited.

The stitching on a comforter adds an element of design while also keeping the fill in place. Comforters that are designed to be used with a duvet cover often incorporate corner loops for cover ties.

There is a wide price range for comforters, from budget to luxury options. Price is not the only marker of quality, but more expensive comforters are often made with higher quality fabrics and fill. This is most noticeable with down comforters, as ethically sourced materials can be more expensive. Setting a budget beforehand can help shoppers narrow down their options.

Temperature Regulation
The breathability of a comforter is determined by the shell and fill, both of which can either retain heat or help dissipate it. Down can act as natural insulation to regulate temperature, though it may still sleep warm for some. Polyester down alternative can also retain heat, though some down alternatives are designed to be breathable and lightweight. Natural fibers like cotton and eucalyptus are breathable and moisture-wicking.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Comforters?

There are several pros and cons to comforters that shoppers should consider before making a purchase. One of the main pros of using a comforter is that it adds an insulating layer to the bed, which is ideal for colder seasons or sleeping with the air conditioning on.

A main downside to using a comforter is the maintenance involved. When used without a cover or a top sheet, a comforter will need to be washed regularly, adding to the expense of the comforter while shortening its lifespan. They can also be difficult to clean at home, since most are too large for a residential washer and dryer to efficiently clean.

Pros Cons
  • Comfort: Comforters add a layer of warmth to the bed.
  • Simplicity: They can be used as a single piece, and do not require a cover.
  • Design: Comforters add style to the bedroom.
  • Price: The various price-points available mean there is an option for nearly every budget.
  • Maintenance: Even machine washable comforters can be difficult to clean, due to the size and fabrication.
  • Limited Color Options: Many comforters are only available in white or neutral colors, and prints and bright color options may be limited.
  • Use with a top sheet: To extend time between cleanings, the comforter should be used with a top sheet.
  • Added Costs: Luxury bedding can be expensive, and come with the added costs of professional or dry cleaning.
    Scroll L - R for more details

    What Types of Comforters are Available?

    When selecting a comforter, the quality of the materials used will be more important than the material itself. That said, there are certain materials that are likely to be used in comforters and it is helpful for shoppers to understand the different types of comforters available. This is determined by the shell and fill materials used, which we will break down here. Some materials are considered to be more luxury, while others lend themselves more to affordability.

    Shell Materials

    Cotton: Cotton is light and breathable, and it is often used to form the shell of a comforter. This fiber naturally wicks away moisture while increasing airflow throughout the comforter. It can also be easy to keep clean. Long-staple cotton tends to be softer, while short-staple cotton is used to make fabrics like flannel.

    Silk: Silk is often used in luxury bedding as it has a smooth, lightweight hand feel. Silk can help regulate temperature, but it is a delicate material that requires additional care. It can drive up the price-point of the comforter.

    Wool: Wool is a warmer natural fiber that regulates temperature and wicks away moisture. It is often used in heavier comforters.

    Eucalyptus: Eucalyptus fibers are soft and breathable. Fabric made from eucalyptus tends to be environmentally friendly, as eucalyptus requires less water to produce than plants like cotton.

    Fill Materials

    Down: Down is the soft plumage found underneath the feathers of birds. Down comforters are typically filled with duck down or goose down, which differ in cluster size and warmth. Duck down is made of smaller clusters for a soft and fluffy feel that is still insulating. Goose down tends to have larger clusters for a higher fill power and added warmth. This also gives the comforter more loft. Down can be expensive and shoppers will want to look for traceable supply chains and certifications that indicate the down was responsibly sourced.

    Down Alternative: Down alternative is synthetic fiber fill, typically made with polyester, that mimics the feel of down. This alternative is beneficial for sleepers with allergies, or those who want vegan bedding. Down alternative comforters are often more affordable, but not all down alternative fills are created equally. The quality of the down alternative fill determines how long the comforter lasts without getting lumpy, in addition to how well it regulates temperature.

    Eucalyptus: Plant-based fibers are becoming more popular, and some comforters are filled with eucalyptus fibers. This fiber fill resists allergens and wicks away heat and moisture. It also has less of an environmental footprint, as eucalyptus is a renewable resource.

    Cotton: Cotton is a breathable, natural fiber that feels soft and lightweight. It is less insulating than down, so it is often used in lighter comforters intended for summer use. Organic cotton is more expensive, but some shoppers may prefer it as it is grown and processed without harsh chemicals.

    Wool: Wool, which is sheared from sheep, is another fill option for comforters. Wool acts as natural insulation, so it stays warm in colder climates, and cooler in warm environments. This makes it ideal for all-season comforters.

    In addition to materials, construction is important. Shoppers should consider the stitching used to secure the fill, in addition to the weave used for the fabric shell. These can prevent shifting and clumping, in addition to fill poking through. Quality materials and durable construction methods will ensure the comforter lasts for many years.

    Frequently Asked Questions About Comforters

    How much do comforters cost?

    On average, shoppers can expect to spend at least $75 to $150 on a new comforter. This is the entry-level price range, and there are budget and luxury options available. Less expensive comforters will likely be made with synthetic materials and have limited features. Luxury options cost upwards of $250 or more, but these tend to be made with high-quality materials and workmanship. Setting a budget beforehand can help shoppers find the best fit.

    How do I clean a comforter?

    Always follow the guidelines set forth by the manufacturer when cleaning a comforter. Some may require professional cleaning or dry cleaning, especially if delicate fabrics or natural down are used. Some comforters are machine washable, but may be too large to fit comfortably in standard washing machines and dryers. A duvet cover used over the comforter can prevent damage to the comforter, and make it easier to keep the comforter clean.

    Where can I buy a comforter?

    Comforters can be purchased online and in stores. Many mattress companies have expanded product lines that include bedding and other sleep accessories. Department and home goods stores also carry comforters and bedding. Comforters are sometimes sold in sets with shams, pillowcases, and other bedding.

    How long do comforters last?

    A high-quality comforter can last 10 to 15 years or longer with proper care, but the lifespan of a comforter is determined by the construction, materials, and usage. Low-quality materials are more likely to deteriorate sooner, and can be prone to flattening or clumping up over time. Taking proper care of your comforter extends its lifespan.

    Which size comforter is right for me?

    Select a comforter size that matches the size of your mattress. Double-checking measurements can let you know what to expect, and a thicker mattress allows for additional fabric to hang over the edges of the bed. Most comforters are sized either for single sizes such as twin, twin XL, full, queen, and king, while others combine similar sizes, such as twin/twin XL or full/queen, in order to accommodate both sizes.

    How do I put a comforter on?

    When used along, a comforter can simply be placed on top of sheets. When paired with a duvet cover, turn the duvet cover inside out and connect the top corner ties to the comforter loops, if present. Then you can turn the duvet cover right side out over the comforter, secure the bottom corner ties and loops, and zip or button the duvet before placing it on the bed.