Leesa vs. Casper Mattress Comparison

Both Casper and Leesa offer a range of mattress models to choose from. Casper offers more options, with five total compared to Leesa’s three. Both companies have several options to suit the widest variety of sleepers. 

Casper offers both foam and hybrid versions of both of their main products, The Casper and The Wave. This allows customers to choose the mattress version they like, and then decide if they prefer a hybrid or an all-foam model (all-foam is less expensive, but hybrids tend to last longer). Casper also offers the Casper Essential, which is the most budget-friendly of any mattress in this comparison. 

Leesa offers a more streamlined portfolio of mattresses. Their flagship model, the Leesa Original, is a versatile all-foam bed with a crowd-pleasing price point. The Leesa Hybrid is a mid-range hybrid, while the Leesa Legend is a high-end luxury mattress.

There are a lot of factors to consider when choosing between Casper and Leesa, let alone between each individual model. We’ll go for a deeper dive into the details of each mattress. 

Construction and Materials Comparison

The composition and materials used in each bed significantly contribute to their comfort, support, and durability. Below we will compare the construction of each model from both Casper and Leesa. 

First off, it’s helpful to understand the differences between two of the most common categories of mattresses: foam beds and hybrid beds.

All-Foam Mattresses are typically made up of several layers of foam of varying density. A blend of foam types is often used to achieve the desired firmness and support. All-foam mattresses are more common, and more affordable.

Hybrid Mattresses combine foam and innerspring coils to create a versatile and durable mattress. They generally consist of an underlying support layer made up of metal coils, as well as one or more layers of foam for comfort. Hybrids are typically more expensive, but they offer an excellent balance of support, comfort, and durability. 

Next, let’s examine the specific composition and materials of each of these mattresses:

Leesa

Leesa offers three different mattresses, one all-foam along with two hybrids. The compositions and constructions of each Leesa mattress are described below:

The Leesa Original is an all-foam mattress made with:

• 6” polyfoam support core
• 2” polyfoam comfort layer 
• 2” memory foam pressure-relief layer
• Polyester blend cover

The Leesa Original is the flagship product from Leesa, and the most popular. It’s designed to be well suited to a variety of people, regardless of sleep position and other preferences. The Original is offered at an accessible price point, yet still has many of the features of more luxury mattresses. The materials used in the Original offer great pressure relief, superior comfort, and adequate cooling for those hot summer nights. The Leesa is made in the USA.

The Leesa Hybrid is a hybrid mattress made with:

• 6” pocketed metal coils
• 1” polyfoam transition layer
• 1.5” perforated polyfoam layer for breathability
• 1.5” memory foam pressure relief layer
• 1” polyfoam transition layer

The Leesa Hybrid builds on the success of the original Leesa mattress and adds additional support from 6” of pocketed coils. As a hybrid mattress, this model is priced higher than the all-foam version, but it offers some distinct benefits including better edge support and improved durability. The Leesa Hybrid provides a great middle-ground in terms of features and price; it’s a definite upgrade from the all-foam version, but it costs only a bit more. 

The Leesa Legend is a luxury hybrid mattress made with:

• 6” pocketed metal coil support layer
• 1.5” micro pocketed coils for targeted pressure relief in hips and shoulders
• 1” support foam transition layer
• 1” high-density support foam
• 1” ventilated poly foam cooling layer
• 1” memory foam pressure relief layer
• Cover made of blended polyester, recycled PES, cotton, merino wool, rayon, and spandex

The Leesa Legend is a unique mattress that has two distinct layers of pocketed coils. The standard 6” coil layer provides the underlying form and support for the bed, while the 1.5” of micro coils offer targeted support to the hips and shoulders. The Leesa Legend is the first mattress of its kind to combine two distinct layers of pocketed coils; the result is a highly supportive and comfortable mattress with great cooling. Environmentally-minded shoppers will also appreciate Leesa’s use of sustainable and recycled materials, including merino wool, organic cotton and recycled PES material derived from plastic bottles. The Leesa Legend mattress is a luxury bed, and as such, it is priced significantly higher than other models from Leesa. 

Casper

Casper offers three different mattress lines, two of which have hybrid and all-foam versions available. In total, there are five different Casper models to choose from. The compositions and constructions of each version are described below:

The Casper is an all-foam mattress made with:

• 7.5” polyfoam support core
• 1.5” open-cell polyfoam 
• 1.5” memory foam
• 1.5” zoned transition polyfoam
• 100% Polyester cover

The Casper (sometimes called the Casper Original) is the flagship model from Casper, and the most popular. It features a well-balanced composition and is designed to be a crowd-pleaser, suiting a wide variety of sleepers. Despite its moderate price tag, it does offer a few advanced materials and features. Open-cell polyfoam helps increase airflow, which keeps the bed cooler on hot nights. A zoned transition layer provides more support where it’s needed most, which helps improve conforming around the hips, shoulders, and neck. 

The Casper Hybrid utilizes the same three 1.5” foam layers as the original Casper, but it replaces the polyfoam support core with 6” of pocketed coils that are encased in polyfoam, along with a 1” polyfoam transition layer.

The Casper Wave is a luxury foam and latex mattress made with:

• Polyfoam support core
• Open-cell polyfoam 
• Open-cell latex 
• Memory foam 
• Polyfoam with targeted gel pods
• Polyester/wool/rayon blend cover

The Casper Wave is a more luxurious model in the Casper lineup. It features a unique ergonomic system utilizing targeted gel pods and pressure-relieving foam layers for ultimate support. It’s a great option for those with aches and pains, and those who prefer a more luxurious, supportive feel. The Wave is also highly breathable, thanks to its perforated design. This helps it sleep cooler, even in hot climates. 

The Casper Wave Hybrid utilizes the same foam materials, except it replaces the polyfoam support core with a layer of pocketed coils and a thinner layer of polyfoam. 

The Casper Essential is a budget-friendly all-foam mattress made with:

• 7.5” polyfoam support core
• 2” polyfoam support layer
• 1.5” memory foam comfort layer
• 100% polyester cover

The Casper Essential is a more basic model. This mattress removes some of the advanced features of other Casper models to offer a very budget-friendly option. The Essential does not have the zoned support layer for targeted support, nor does it have the open-cell polyfoam for better cooling. Nonetheless, it’s still a very comfortable and supportive mattress that offers excellent value. There is no hybrid version of the Casper Essential. 

In-Depth Pricing

Buying a mattress is a major purchase. You can expect to spend anywhere from $500 to over $3,000 on a quality bed, depending on the type of mattress and the size you choose. 

Various factors can influence the price of a new mattress. All-foam beds are typically more affordable, while hybrid models are priced higher due to higher manufacturing costs. Likewise, higher quality foams will add to the cost of a bed, but will also potentially help to increase its lifespan. The country of manufacture can also influence the price tag; USA-made beds like Leesa tend to be a bit more expensive, due to higher labor costs. 

While cost is always a factor, it’s best to not think of it as the biggest consideration in your mattress purchase. You will spend approximately 1/3rd of your time sleeping on your new bed for years to come, so it’s important to think of it as an investment. It’s also wise to remember that higher quality mattresses will tend to last longer than cheap beds, so in the long run, it may make more financial sense to focus on quality first. 

Even within the product lines of Leesa and Casper, there are significant price differences. The table below lays out the pricing details of each model from both companies.

Overall, pricing between Leesa and Casper is fairly similar, particularly when it comes to the flagship models. For larger sizes, Casper tends to be a bit more expensive, while prices are nearly identical on Twin, Twin XL, and Full mattress sizes. 

Casper does offer a broader range of price points, with models like the Essential offering very budget-friendly prices. For mid-range and high-end models, both Casper and Leesa offer great options. 

Another notable benefit of Casper is that they offer a budget-friendly hybrid mattress. The Casper Hybrid is priced significantly lower than the Leesa Hybrid, and offers many similar features. For shoppers looking for an affordably priced hybrid model, Casper is a good option. 

At the higher end of the price spectrum, Casper and Leesa are similar. The Wave Hybrid and Leesa Legend are comparably priced, and both seek to target the same market segment of luxury shoppers. Each model differs in features and construction, yet they are in a similar tier in terms of overall quality. 

To sum up: Casper comes out ahead in the budget-friendly category, as well as the budget hybrid category. Otherwise, prices are similar across the board. 

Leesa Policies

Shipping – Leesa’s policies make it easy for customers to get their mattress in a timely manner, without needing to pay extra. Within the USA, ground shipping is free on all mattress orders. Shipments will arrive approximately 3-6 business days after purchase. Leesa mattresses can also ship internationally, but additional fees apply. Additional fees may also apply for deliveries in Hawaii or Alaska.

Leesa delivers their mattresses compressed in boxes, using standard shipping services. From there, customers simply unroll the mattress and allow it to expand before setup. There is also an optional White Glove delivery service available, for an additional $150 charge, which can be used to have a team set up your new bed in-home, and even remove your old mattress. 

Returns – Leesa offers easy returns within the first 100 days after delivery. The company asks that customers keep the bed for at least 30 days, to allow adequate time to evaluate the bed and determine if it’s a good fit or not. After the first 30 days, and before the 100-day return period closes, Leesa mattresses can be returned for a full refund. A $100 return fee will apply on orders to Alaska and Hawaii.

Wherever possible, Leesa will arrange for local pickup of your return at your own home. The bed is then donated to a local charity. 

Warranty – All Leesa mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty. The warranty covers qualified defects, including manufacturer defects but excluding normal wear-and-tear. Under the warranty terms, Leesa will repair or replace damaged beds for free. However, the customer is responsible for any transportation or shipping costs associated with the warranty claim.

Casper Policies

Shipping – Casper ships their mattresses for free to all US destinations, excluding Alaska and Hawaii, where additional fees apply. International shipping is available to select destinations, at an additional cost. Domestic orders typically arrive in approximately 2-5 business days. In select destinations, same-day delivery may be available for an additional cost.

All Casper mattresses ship compressed in boxes, through normal delivery services including FedEx and UPS. Customers can also opt for a white-glove delivery and setup service, for an additional fee. Mattresses delivered via White Glove will not be compressed.

Returns – Casper offers easy returns within the first 100 days after delivery. Customers who are not satisfied with their new beds can return their Casper mattress for a full refund. Returns are free, with no fee and no minimum trial period.

Should a customer choose to return their mattress, Casper attempts to connect with local providers to pick up the return and donate it to a local charity. 

Warranty – All Casper mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty. This coverage provides repair or replacement for any damage caused by manufacturer defects. However, it does not cover normal wear-and-tear, stains and spills, burns, and the like. There are no fees or shipping costs associated with warranty claims.